Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Taking a job in a tiny business when pregnant

455 replies

Fromageetvino · 23/12/2021 13:13

Ok so I know IABU but venting a little.
I took on my first FT employee in July this year (already have 1 x part timer). Three weeks in she disclosed that she is pregnant and is now off on Mat leave.

It’s an industry where recruiting is super difficult at the moment so getting a mat leave cover is likely to be practically impossible.

I know it’s her right etc, and of course have treated her fairly and she will be returning whenever she chooses to return.

But if I’m honest - it’s absolutely screwed our plans for any growth this year (on top of covid troubles).

While I know it’s “right” would you take on a job in a small business when pregnant?

Am prepared to get flamed here (hence the NC).

OP posts:
UntilYourNextHairBrainedScheme · 24/12/2021 14:53

@MabelsApron wgy exactly do you have the very oddball opinion that taxpayers money shouldn't be spent on maternity leave? Have the majority of taxpayers voted in favour of discriminating against women of childbearing age?

KeranaCosmonauts · 24/12/2021 14:51

@Fromageetvino You were obviously hoping that people would say "no, I wouldn't do that" and agree with you about how terrible it is and how screwed over you've been. Which some people have done, so you got what you wanted.

@CaptSkippy The thing with small businesses is that any Average Joe with a bit of capital can set one up (whether they survive is another story), so there are lot of amateurs out there who don't act professionally or within the law. When I was at uni I had part time jobs at various local small businesses and was shocked at how some of them carried on. The owners and managers behaved in ways that they'd never have got away with in a large company with strict rules around conduct and an HR department. I had to laugh at the OP's description of "kindly shopkeeper". Many of them are anything but.
Large companies aren't perfect either but at least the market has weeded out the amateurs and there's a bit more employee protection.

user290814356289 · 24/12/2021 14:09

Wasn't there a huge post just last year about a woman who was pregnant when offered a job which she accepted, then told them she was pregnant and they took rescinded the offer. She took them to a tribunal and rightly won. Lots of people spoke up to support this woman so I'm surprised to see the support for the business owner on this.

Your employee has every right to have a baby. She also has a legal right not to disclose her pregnancy until 15 weeks before her due date.

As much as it's difficult for your work situation op, this is what happens when you employ someone. It is always a possibility. Fathers also take paternity leave.

I'm shocked at the things I've read about getting rid of her through probationary period loopholes and other illegal practices mentioned on this thread.

Yes she should have applied as it's her decision to apply for a job whenever she wants.

Fromageetvino · 24/12/2021 13:48

@KeranaCosmonauts read my OP, I didn’t ask if employers would discriminate. I asked if women would apply to a job in a very small business when pregnant.

OP posts:
KeranaCosmonauts · 24/12/2021 13:42

@Fromageetvino She probably didn't even think those things though, you've just assumed she did.
She probably saw a job that appealed to her and applied for it, simple as that.
This woman doesn't know you or the ins and out of your finances and recruitment issues and wouldn't have given those things a second though. Neither is she obliged to.
It's not her responsibility and she has done nothing wrong!
You though, are determined to believe she purposely screwed you over. You've gone on a parenting forum with a high percentage of working mothers to moan about pregnant women having the temerity to apply for a job. You're angry that she didn't disclose her pregnancy at interview even though you admit it may have influenced your decision. You're clearly feeling smug about others agreeing with you and saying they too would discriminate.
If you really just wanted to vent about your disappointment then you'd have done so in private, to your family and friends, not gone on a public forum to encourage hundreds of people to slate your employee. Who has done nothing wrong.
So yes, people like you do make it worse for women in the workplace. It's not many times I've been genuinely appalled at a thread on MN but this is one of those times. You really ought to be ashamed of yourself!

Fromageetvino · 24/12/2021 13:31

I feel like with larger employers in general there is just more room to actually be human.

While actually if I ever went back into the workplace I’d never choose a small business, I actually feel the opposite.

Large companies you’re more of a number - restructures etc don’t take into account humans, and HR don’t give a fuck.

That’s not to say either is right or wrong - just more my perception.

OP posts:
Fromageetvino · 24/12/2021 13:25

@IntermittentParps

I answered about whether I’d rather be on ML or taking a temp job. On how I’d like it if you took a percentage of my salary ( which as I say doesn’t apply to me as I’m freelance). And on the morality of advertising a job as temp to possibly permanent (although I cannot properly answer, as I’ve pointed out, because you seem to think you would/could only advertise it as highly likely to go permanent, even though I’ve said that jobs are very usually advertised as temp with a possibility of permanent.)
Yes, rather like a politician you answered a different question to the ones asked. So let’s try again (don’t worry have been a freelancer so will make them freelance friendly, as it seems the ability to translate the word salary to income may be a little tricky).

Would you rather - your client had a little whinge about your on MN. Or promised an annual contract then rescinded two months later?

Would you like to reduce 20% of your for six months?

And if sound prickly? I am. Xmas Grin

OP posts:
CaptSkippy · 24/12/2021 13:22

@KeranaCosmonauts

This thread is utterly depressing. And quite astonishing really, in this day and age. So, at what stage after taking a job is a woman allowed to get pregnant? 6 months, a year, 2 years? There will probably never be a convenient time from the employer's point of view. How will things be any different if she announced she was pregnant a year after being hired, for example? You'd still have to find a temporary replacement or do without her for a bit. If you're going to hire employees then you have to accept they might get pregnant, or sick, or need to take time off for some other reason. If you can't deal with that then you should probably use freelancers or do the work yourself. If you struggle to recruit then you need to offer higher pay. If none of these things are an option then you need to accept you don't have a viable business, or that you can only have a very small business and can't expand any more. As for the question, would I take a job in a small business while pregnant...judging by this thread, I wouldn't take a job with a small business at all.
That last sentence really hit the nail on the head. This whole thread has made me feel wary of considering a small business as a potential employer. I feel like with larger employers in general there is just more room to actually be human.
IntermittentParps · 24/12/2021 13:15

I answered about whether I’d rather be on ML or taking a temp job. On how I’d like it if you took a percentage of my salary ( which as I say doesn’t apply to me as I’m freelance).
And on the morality of advertising a job as temp to possibly permanent (although I cannot properly answer, as I’ve pointed out, because you seem to think you would/could only advertise it as highly likely to go permanent, even though I’ve said that jobs are very usually advertised as temp with a possibility of permanent.)

Fromageetvino · 24/12/2021 13:06

I’ll answer your question Parps when you stop ignoring mine. Have answered all of yours and you’ve swerved every single one of mine.

OP posts:
IntermittentParps · 24/12/2021 13:00

there is a reason that over 70% of people agree with me.
In this very specific case someone chose - completely knowingly themselves over someone else.

I think so many people agree with you because, depressingly, misogyny is still rampant.
And what do you think of the point made earlier that just because someone is pregnant doesn’t necessarily mean they’ll need their ML? God forbid, obviously, your employee doesn’t carry her baby to term; but it is always possible, and it’s one reason why she and other women may apply for a job while pregnant/not disclose pregnancy in the recruitment process.

Fromageetvino · 24/12/2021 12:56

@Blossom987

Anyway it’s been good to chat but I really have to put this thread to bed now. I am procrastinating all my Xmas Eve jobs and this thread is too distracting! It’s a topic I’m clearly passionate about even if you don’t agree with me.

Merry Christmas!

You too x
OP posts:
Blossom987 · 24/12/2021 12:53

Anyway it’s been good to chat but I really have to put this thread to bed now. I am procrastinating all my Xmas Eve jobs and this thread is too distracting! It’s a topic I’m clearly passionate about even if you don’t agree with me.

Merry Christmas!

Fromageetvino · 24/12/2021 12:50

@Blossom987 I’m not saying that at all.
But if you interviewed for let’s say the beautician. Would it not occur to you during the process to think. “Ah she’s talking about these plans etc and actually I’m not telling her that I’m actually going to be off in three months time. I feel a bit bad here. Yes she’s said I’m opening the second salon - but I know that won’t be happening anytime soon as I won’t be there to do it as she expects. Also that part timer who I met who seems lovely and said she was so happy to have me starting as she was nervous about doing eyelashes as it’s not her thing. Ha she’s got another think coming”.

Would you not feel the teeniest twinge no? I would.

OP posts:
Blossom987 · 24/12/2021 12:41

[quote Fromageetvino]@Blossom987 you really can’t see beyond a huge corporation can you?
You’ve said - you’d fuck over the kindly shop keeper and the little beautician. Because they’re “business” and they’re therefore evil.
Very telling tbh.[/quote]
Eh? You are making it sound like I would set out purposely to target a small business owner instead of a large organisation to fuck over. If I was pregnant in need of a job and applied for various roles and the one that suited me best or was the only job offer at the time or whatever happened to be a small business owner, then yeah I’d accept the job. Why wouldn’t I? I would need a job just as much as you would need a business. And I would expect business owners to be able to survive someone going on maternity leave or any other usual costs that go with employing people. Because it could happen not long after starting even if I wasn’t pregnant at the time.

Not sure why you keep repeating the word evil. i’ve not seen a single poster use that word.

Blossom987 · 24/12/2021 12:28

[quote TractorAndHeadphones]@Blossom987 if everyone took the ‘if it’s lawful it’s just business’ line then they could just fire women who had gone on mat leave couldn’t they? As long as they made sure they had all the necessary steps. As a pp have mentioned there’s room for a case when employers don’t cover their arses

This attitude of ‘the law is the law’ helps nobody. I believe that individual PEOPLE have goodwill and there should be consideration. I of course protect myself but ‘businesses’ aren’t a homogenous entity, they are made up of people.

For example my current boss will fight to get me stuff no matter what the rules say. Would I go above and beyond? Yes - for him, not the business.
In the same company my previous boss was a jobsworth and I would absolutely not do anymore than I was paid to sometimes even less.

So I really didn’t care about the company but I cared about the people.
To automatically assume that people are going to screw you over and therefore you should get in first will just end up with everyone being miserable[/quote]
Given the amount of posters on this thread who would quite happily avoid employing all child bearing age women, automatically assuming a woman is going to ‘screw them over’, is it any wonder pregnant women also assume they may need to protect themselves? I’m not suggesting people spend their entire careers doing nothing to help others incase they get screwed over. Just that if they are at risk of discrimination then they should absolutely protect themselves.

Sometimes business owners or employees have to make decisions that prioritise their own needs even if it does have an impact, financially or otherwise, on someone else. what I mean by ‘it’s just business’ is that it’s not personal, and that it’s also lawful. What many posters are suggesting is small businesses should also be unlawful at the same time as putting the business first, by discriminating against someone with a protected characteristic.

Fromageetvino · 24/12/2021 12:21

[quote TractorAndHeadphones]@Blossom987 so it would be great for business to fold and person on mat leave to lose their job anyway right?

A lot of small business aren’t ‘viable’ in the sense of a large one. Whether you think it’s fair or not it’s a simple logic problem.

The business can only afford things if it has work, which generates revenue. Without employees the business cannot generate revenue.

One person going off on mat leave in a 2 person business is in percentage terms HALF the business. Would a major company with 10,000 employees survive having 5,000 temps?

It’s illogical to say that ‘business is business is business full stop and they should all be the same’.

Ultimately if you say that they shouldn’t hire if mat leave causes a problem then nobody will have a job. And nobody will start a business.[/quote]
^this^

Doesn’t matter that I’m not at risk of folding - she couldn’t possibly know that. And common sense would tell you it’s a possibility.

OP posts:
TractorAndHeadphones · 24/12/2021 12:07

@Blossom987 so it would be great for business to fold and person on mat leave to lose their job anyway right?

A lot of small business aren’t ‘viable’ in the sense of a large one. Whether you think it’s fair or not it’s a simple logic problem.

The business can only afford things if it has work, which generates revenue. Without employees the business cannot generate revenue.

One person going off on mat leave in a 2 person business is in percentage terms HALF the business. Would a major company with 10,000 employees survive having 5,000 temps?

It’s illogical to say that ‘business is business is business full stop and they should all be the same’.

Ultimately if you say that they shouldn’t hire if mat leave causes a problem then nobody will have a job. And nobody will start a business.

Fromageetvino · 24/12/2021 12:05

@Blossom987 you really can’t see beyond a huge corporation can you?
You’ve said - you’d fuck over the kindly shop keeper and the little beautician. Because they’re “business” and they’re therefore evil.
Very telling tbh.

OP posts:
Fromageetvino · 24/12/2021 12:02

@TractorAndHeadphones

Also OP I don’t understand why you would agree to her going PT If it doesn’t suit the business - IF she asks. If you hired a full timer you hired a full timer?

Even in my corporate job with lots of part timers you have to prove that it can work… you don’t expect to be given PT.

It’s a bridge I will cross if/when it comes but can probably be accommodated. I’m not going to refuse it just because of how I feel personally

Despite what a few PPs think - I do want people who work for me to have a good work/life balance and enjoy working here. So if requests are made and can reasonably fit - I’ll always try to accept them but with an eye to how this would work at scale as well (as it can be easy to say yes to things when there are three of you, which may cause problems when there are say 12).

OP posts:
Blossom987 · 24/12/2021 12:02

[quote Fromageetvino]@Blossom987 a chronic illness is a totally different thing and without being outing is something that is already part of my business.

But you’ve laid it out - yes push comes to shove - you would look after yourself and the detriment of another individual.

Funnily enough - I actually haven’t. And don’t. But hey I’m an “evil business”.[/quote]
In business yes! Businesses do this ALL the time, why wouldn’t an employee? What good would it do me to be out of work to protect somebody else’s income? I don’t get any money to survive by being a martyr.

I know you haven’t actually been unlawful. But I think it’s only because she didn’t disclose it. You do think she should have put your business before her own employment needs. Why does she owe you that? The only thing either of you owe is covered by employment law. You’re just annoyed it works in her favour as she has a protected characteristic, and it’s not in favour of you.

TractorAndHeadphones · 24/12/2021 11:55

@Blossom987 if everyone took the ‘if it’s lawful it’s just business’ line then they could just fire women who had gone on mat leave couldn’t they? As long as they made sure they had all the necessary steps. As a pp have mentioned there’s room for a case when employers don’t cover their arses

This attitude of ‘the law is the law’ helps nobody. I believe that individual PEOPLE have goodwill and there should be consideration. I of course protect myself but ‘businesses’ aren’t a homogenous entity, they are made up of people.

For example my current boss will fight to get me stuff no matter what the rules say. Would I go above and beyond? Yes - for him, not the business.
In the same company my previous boss was a jobsworth and I would absolutely not do anymore than I was paid to sometimes even less.

So I really didn’t care about the company but I cared about the people.
To automatically assume that people are going to screw you over and therefore you should get in first will just end up with everyone being miserable

Fromageetvino · 24/12/2021 11:50

@Blossom987 a chronic illness is a totally different thing and without being outing is something that is already part of my business.

But you’ve laid it out - yes push comes to shove - you would look after yourself and the detriment of another individual.

Funnily enough - I actually haven’t. And don’t. But hey I’m an “evil business”.

OP posts:
Blossom987 · 24/12/2021 11:48

@TractorAndHeadphones

OP as you said what is right by law is not necessarily morally right. Also a lot of the posters attacking you have ignored a very important point: The financial stability of the business also affects the person on mat leave! If the business struggles there’ll be little for them to come back to. And if folds, nothing.

It’s all very good in saying ‘business should do X Y Z’ but where’s the magic money or contract tree that will make this happen?

I agree it’s a risk to take and probably true for anyone joining a small business. However OP hasn’t suggested her business is at risk of folding. And if a business folds from just one person needing maternity leave then was it really viable? It also wouldn’t survive someone needing long term sick in that case either.
TractorAndHeadphones · 24/12/2021 11:48

Also OP I don’t understand why you would agree to her going PT If it doesn’t suit the business - IF she asks. If you hired a full timer you hired a full timer?

Even in my corporate job with lots of part timers you have to prove that it can work… you don’t expect to be given PT.