Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To Think Having ASD Doesn’t Entitle You to This?

313 replies

WheelieBinPrincess · 23/12/2021 12:42

Just moved into our own flat after many many years of renting/saving. Outskirts of London, zone 5, which explains why we’ve bought a flat and not a house, a flat was what we could afford. But it’s a nice place. Not a new build, for context, but not really old either. 70’s I think. We are on the ground floor. Above us live a single mum and her teenage son.

We’ve only been here three nights but have been kept up until 3am or so by what was quite obviously someone using headphones and shouting into a mouthpiece. DH was a gamer so I knew what was going on. Think ‘NOOOOOO!!!’ And ‘FUCCCCKKKKKKKK’ at random intervals. It’s incredibly loud.

We have a 3 month old baby. Sleep is obviously precious enough as it is, he still wakes 2/3 times in a night to feed.

Anyway, this morning we popped upstairs and the mum answers the door-explained that we just moved in, can hear all the shouting, please can it stop because it’s a very unsociable time of night to be dealing with that level of noise, we have a baby, DH has work etc etc. She was very apologetic and said it was her 15 year old son playing Fortnite, and she went to sleep with ear plugs in but that he wakes her up a lot too.

But then she said there wasn’t much she could do because her son has ASD, it’s his hobby and only way of being sociable as he games with others online, he considers these gamers his friends so he won’t be able to stop doing it. She said in time hopefully we’ll ‘filter out’ the noise. He gets carried away and he doesn’t do it on purpose but she said again about his ASD and repeated that that’s the way he is and there is nothing she can do. Then she said we hope we have a lovely Christmas and closed the door Confused

Now, I know this is Mumsnet and I’ve been here a long time. So, before anyone asks-

No, we can’t ‘move bedrooms’
No, we can’t move
No, we can’t afford a detached house.

But surely we shouldn’t just have to put up with it?! They’re having a laugh right?

OP posts:
AlfonsoTheUnrepentant · 23/12/2021 16:58

@Floundery

The mother offered this as a rationale as to why she's not going to challenge his behaviour

If the mother had (for example) “it’s because were black/Muslim/Jewish - it’s our culture and we can’t help it” would the obvious dog-whistle in the title have been clearer to the hard-of-thinking here?

Oh, MN would have shut that down so fast your head would spin. But it's ok to take lumps out of autistic people. This is just the latest example.
AlfonsoTheUnrepentant · 23/12/2021 16:57

But that is true for a range of mental health conditions and associated behaviours.

Autism is not a mental health condition, @Eleganz. It is a developmental condition.

Floundery · 23/12/2021 16:57

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Eleganz · 23/12/2021 16:57

@DoucheCanoe

Not one person on here has said that the OP should just shut up and put up or that it's acceptable behaviour.

Of course it's not, but sometimes we aren't perfect and we let things slip especially when we're going through a tough time for whatever reason.

The OP has spoken with her neighbour and hopefully they'll be able to sort it out soon, if not then of course you follow the route of complaint but you need to give it time.

I suggest you reread OP's first post.

She says her neighbour hopes that "in time" OP will learn to filter out the noise and there is nothing more she can do. The neighbour has made no commitment to try anything to sort it out.

AlfonsoTheUnrepentant · 23/12/2021 16:57

So we should accept any and all behaviour if it is accompanied by a diagnosis of autism then?

We accept it from NTs, @Eleganz. Why should it be different for autistic people?

AlfonsoTheUnrepentant · 23/12/2021 16:55

@Sleepyblueocean

"Such a constructive attitude which I am sure will help the acceptance of autistic young adults in society."

People with autism, wherever they lie on the spectrum, are already part of society.

But not an accepted part of society. After all, we engage in "anti-social behaviour". And it would be funny to cut their Internet cable. And ring their doorbell at 3am.
Eleganz · 23/12/2021 16:54

@cansu

Eleganz It isn't a question of accepting their behaviour. This is a bit like saying 'Should we just accept this person has diabetes then?' Being autistic means that you have a differently functioning brain. The person cannot make themselves behave differently especially those who are profoundly or severely autistic.
But that is true for a range of mental health conditions and associated behaviours. That doesn't mean we accept that someone is behaving anti-socially because they have BPD for example and just allow that behaviour to continue.
AlfonsoTheUnrepentant · 23/12/2021 16:54

OP, by all means - please do complain. Make it official. Complain to the council. After all, you put it it, you should have more "leverage" because you own while your neighbours rent.

And then make sure that you detail your complaints about your neighbours when it comes to selling your house. If you don't, you could be sued (as another poster helpfully pointed out).

DoucheCanoe · 23/12/2021 16:52

Not one person on here has said that the OP should just shut up and put up or that it's acceptable behaviour.

Of course it's not, but sometimes we aren't perfect and we let things slip especially when we're going through a tough time for whatever reason.

The OP has spoken with her neighbour and hopefully they'll be able to sort it out soon, if not then of course you follow the route of complaint but you need to give it time.

Offmyfence · 23/12/2021 16:52

@Floundery

I can't believe in 2020 I'm reading a thread about a teenage boy staying up late gaming and a mum who doesn't like conflict entitled 'to think ASD doesn't entitle you to this?' . Of course this isn't anything to do with being autistic

Have to agree with this. I am sympathetic for the OP but the inflammatory and ablist thread title is fucking awful.

Imagine replacing “ASD” with another protected characteristic in that title. OP would rightly be banned. But it’s just autism and we all agree they’re an awful bunch, so she can crack on… Angry

So how should OP have described the conversation without mentioning ASD? The mother offered this as a rationale as to why she's not going to challenge his behaviour,
Sleepyblueocean · 23/12/2021 16:52

"So we should accept any and all behaviour if it is accompanied by a diagnosis of autism then?"

You really have a thing about autism. I would suggest changing the word autism in your posts to any other group eg women, and see how they read.

TheHateIsNotGood · 23/12/2021 16:52

I'm so sorry OP about this, I could be the mother upstairs, but I'm not. My ds20 with ASD/autism does this too and it's got a lot, lot worse since the covid lockdowns started nearly 2 years ago - not least because all routines were destroyed and now there is nothing to get up for. At this time.

That doesn't help you of course - hopefully things will change soon for the lad upstairs so he'll have something else going on.

Eleganz · 23/12/2021 16:51

@DoucheCanoe

The fact that anyone thinks that Autistic young adults need to be "accepted by society" is exactly the reason that parents of these young people get so fed up and dismissive in the first place.

They are part of society. They shouldn't have to fight for that right!

But people do have to fight for acceptance in society. That is a fact of life. Many marginalised groups, people with health conditions have all had to and continue to fight for acceptance and recognition by wider society. That may not be how it should be, but it is how it is.
cansu · 23/12/2021 16:51

Eleganz
It isn't a question of accepting their behaviour. This is a bit like saying
'Should we just accept this person has diabetes then?'
Being autistic means that you have a differently functioning brain. The person cannot make themselves behave differently especially those who are profoundly or severely autistic.

Floundery · 23/12/2021 16:50

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

joobleydoo · 23/12/2021 16:49

OP, I'm sorry you're dealing with unacceptable noise, you must feel so gutted having just bought your flat.

As a parent of two autistic children I find it very uncomfortable that some (not all by any means) posters have felt it's ok to talk about autism being used as an "excuse". It's a really offensive generalisation and it sweeps my children into a pile of "others".

It's also lazy on the part of those making such comments, given the overwhelming number of parents of autistics who've posted on this thread that such antisocial behaviour is not tolerated.

And, just to be clear, the specific situation that's being commented on here is of a teenage autistic with enough language and comprehension to be able to connect socially with others via gaming - and a parent who is disturbed by the noise herself it wears ear plugs rather than finding a way to tackle the issue. (Ie We are not commenting on a hypothetical situation with a different autistic child with a different needs profile- so please, to any worried parents reading this, don't assume the comments for this situation would also apply to your own, they might not.)

In terms of practical routes forward, I think there are several helpful suggestions on this thread, I would echo:

  1. Knock on the family's door nightly if needs be, ie every time you are woken, wake the mother. Once it becomes her problem directly she may be more motivated to tackle it.
  1. Give her a short timeframe and say if there is still noise past a set time (eg 10pm) you will raise a complaint with the council.
  1. You could suggest applying for funding (as a pp said) for soundproofing her son's room. However I'd suggest that should be a last resort as it still doesn't tackle the root issue.
DoucheCanoe · 23/12/2021 16:47

The fact that anyone thinks that Autistic young adults need to be "accepted by society" is exactly the reason that parents of these young people get so fed up and dismissive in the first place.

They are part of society. They shouldn't have to fight for that right!

Eleganz · 23/12/2021 16:46

@Sleepyblueocean

"Such a constructive attitude which I am sure will help the acceptance of autistic young adults in society."

People with autism, wherever they lie on the spectrum, are already part of society.

So we should accept any and all behaviour if it is accompanied by a diagnosis of autism then?
Eleganz · 23/12/2021 16:45

@alphonsotheunrpentant.

No I didn't. I won't be responding to any more of your posts.

Eleganz · 23/12/2021 16:43

@Floundery

We don’t know she hasn’t *@Eleganz* - a few months after my first parenting course DS got sensory overwhelm and - despite 3 adults in the room, injured another child. Should I string him up and let you throw rotten eggs at him?

We know nothing about this woman apart from what is in the OP.

Neither does OP because her interact with the woman was for her to say there was nothing she could do and shut the door in her face. That does not seems like a reasonable thing to do to a neighbour raising a concern with you.
HotPenguin · 23/12/2021 16:43

I can see both sides here. It isn't acceptable to be shouting and swearing at 3 in the morning. I know someone in the exact same situation, her neighbours son is now in his 20s, he's never worked or gone to college, he just sleeps in the day and games all night.

But your neighbour is perhaps at her wits end and ground down trying to deal with her son, so she's taking the path of least resistance here. I don't think it's fair to say the mum is lazy, her life might be really difficult.

I have two kids with ASD and no way would I allow them to behave like this. I have strict limits on gaming etc because I know it's addictive and I don't want them to detach from the real world and be immersed in gaming.

I think it's possible to have sympathy for the family whilst also taking action to improve the situation such as complaining to the landlord. Comparing the noise with a baby crying is silly, as babies crying cannot be avoided. Likewise if the noise was due to a meltdown.

Sleepyblueocean · 23/12/2021 16:42

"Such a constructive attitude which I am sure will help the acceptance of autistic young adults in society."

People with autism, wherever they lie on the spectrum, are already part of society.

cansu · 23/12/2021 16:41

There is no magic wand for challenging behaviour. Who do you think will come round and help this parent deal with her 15 year old having a meltdown at 11pm because he isn't allowed to use his game system?

It really is not that simple. If it was, I guess the mum would have already done it as it is probably disturbing her too.

I think that the OP will make numerous complaints and will get nowhere. She could well end up in a worse situation.

sadpapercourtesan · 23/12/2021 16:41

@Eleganz my autistic child is at university, is too polite and considerate for his own good, and has considerably better social skills than you so, as evinced by your posts on this thread Grin

No amount of bluster is going to cover the stupidity (and cruelty) of your attitude. The "help and support" you referred to doesn't exist. Parents of autistic kids are not magicians. And the vast majority of us do not allow our children to run riot or upset our neighbours, if it is within our power to prevent it, any more than parents of NT children do.

Floundery · 23/12/2021 16:41

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn