Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To Think Having ASD Doesn’t Entitle You to This?

313 replies

WheelieBinPrincess · 23/12/2021 12:42

Just moved into our own flat after many many years of renting/saving. Outskirts of London, zone 5, which explains why we’ve bought a flat and not a house, a flat was what we could afford. But it’s a nice place. Not a new build, for context, but not really old either. 70’s I think. We are on the ground floor. Above us live a single mum and her teenage son.

We’ve only been here three nights but have been kept up until 3am or so by what was quite obviously someone using headphones and shouting into a mouthpiece. DH was a gamer so I knew what was going on. Think ‘NOOOOOO!!!’ And ‘FUCCCCKKKKKKKK’ at random intervals. It’s incredibly loud.

We have a 3 month old baby. Sleep is obviously precious enough as it is, he still wakes 2/3 times in a night to feed.

Anyway, this morning we popped upstairs and the mum answers the door-explained that we just moved in, can hear all the shouting, please can it stop because it’s a very unsociable time of night to be dealing with that level of noise, we have a baby, DH has work etc etc. She was very apologetic and said it was her 15 year old son playing Fortnite, and she went to sleep with ear plugs in but that he wakes her up a lot too.

But then she said there wasn’t much she could do because her son has ASD, it’s his hobby and only way of being sociable as he games with others online, he considers these gamers his friends so he won’t be able to stop doing it. She said in time hopefully we’ll ‘filter out’ the noise. He gets carried away and he doesn’t do it on purpose but she said again about his ASD and repeated that that’s the way he is and there is nothing she can do. Then she said we hope we have a lovely Christmas and closed the door Confused

Now, I know this is Mumsnet and I’ve been here a long time. So, before anyone asks-

No, we can’t ‘move bedrooms’
No, we can’t move
No, we can’t afford a detached house.

But surely we shouldn’t just have to put up with it?! They’re having a laugh right?

OP posts:
phishy · 23/12/2021 13:37

@Floundery

I can't believe in 2020 I'm reading a thread about a teenage boy staying up late gaming and a mum who doesn't like conflict entitled 'to think ASD doesn't entitle you to this?' . Of course this isn't anything to do with being autistic

Have to agree with this. I am sympathetic for the OP but the inflammatory and ablist thread title is fucking awful.

Imagine replacing “ASD” with another protected characteristic in that title. OP would rightly be banned. But it’s just autism and we all agree they’re an awful bunch, so she can crack on… Angry

Another one ignoring the fact that OP only mentioned the ASD because the woman offered it as the justification for the noise and said there’s nothing she can do.
WheelieBinPrincess · 23/12/2021 13:36

Er, are you off your rocker, @HG107?

The baby actually doesn’t do a lot of crying (I’m not saying that through a bias new mum thing either)

I appreciate that may change.

When he’s a toddler, I will do what I can to mitigate the noise he makes and set boundaries to limit the impact on my neighbours as any good parent would do.

Am I suppose to just accept I won’t sleep again because of someone else’s child Confused

OP posts:
phishy · 23/12/2021 13:36

@Sleepyblueocean

"My DS was 4 years old and my DH took him swimming. There was another boy swimming at the same time who took a dislike to him and when they were in the changing rooms tried to punch my son. The mother didnt say anything bar giving my husband a card which said he suffered from ADHD. Well that's OK then."

When ds was 5 he went to a class (mainstream school) birthday party. He was minding his own business happily flapping. A group of same age children laughed at him and threw things at him. Their parents didn't even notice because they were sitting at the other end of the room chatting and not watching what their kids were doing.

Did either of you say anything to the parents?

I don’t know why people can’t say something, even if just politely.

Floundery · 23/12/2021 13:35

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

TheBestofTimesTheWorstofTimes · 23/12/2021 13:33

It's a shame baby wakes up at 6.30am and HAS to have loud nursery rhymes blasting from the speakers directed at the flat above on a loop isnt it Wink

Arethechildreninbedyet · 23/12/2021 13:33

Sorry OP what a nightmare.

I would start recording it every time it happens, if it’s especially bad start logging it with the police, then start to complain to the council.

The only way she will act is if she starts getting official complaints.

Sleepyblueocean · 23/12/2021 13:33

"My DS was 4 years old and my DH took him swimming. There was another boy swimming at the same time who took a dislike to him and when they were in the changing rooms tried to punch my son. The mother didnt say anything bar giving my husband a card which said he suffered from ADHD. Well that's OK then."

When ds was 5 he went to a class (mainstream school) birthday party. He was minding his own business happily flapping. A group of same age children laughed at him and threw things at him. Their parents didn't even notice because they were sitting at the other end of the room chatting and not watching what their kids were doing.

CatJumperTwat · 23/12/2021 13:31

You're not being unreasonable but, sadly, that doesn't mean there's anything to be done. The mother is ineffectual and the council will do sod all (certainly no "heavy fines"). As you can't move, all you can do is invest in as much soundproofing as you can and save up so you CAN move.

phishy · 23/12/2021 13:30

@HMG107

When you wrote this post you didn't take a few minutes to think about how your post would come across to others (especially those who are autistic) so you aren't always considerate. It's hardly surprising a teenage boy hasn't thought too much about his neighbors who moved in three days ago.

Eh? The neighbour has offered her son's ASD as justification for the noise, so of course OP is going to mention it.

And pp upthread have said their son with ASD is not allowed to speak into mic after 10.30pm and is supportive of OP.

You're expecting OP to be resigned to never getting a full night's sleep again which is not reasonable.

WorraLiberty · 23/12/2021 13:28

@HMG107

I can't believe in 2020 I'm reading a thread about a teenage boy staying up late gaming and a mum who doesn't like conflict entitled 'to think ASD doesn't entitle you to this?' . Of course this isn't anything to do with being autistic.

I have a two-year-old - your child is likely to be waking in the night and making lots of noise throughout the day for years to come. They'll also be regular high pitch crying due to separation anxiety, tantrums etc so this young lad is likely to have to put up with a lot from you and your family. I'm autistic and have ADHD and my child is a sensory nightmare.

When you wrote this post you didn't take a few minutes to think about how your post would come across to others (especially those who are autistic) so you aren't always considerate. It's hardly surprising a teenage boy hasn't thought too much about his neighbors who moved in three days ago.

You tried to speak to mum and it didn't get anywhere all you can really do now is try and keep as calm as possible over the next few weeks and see what happens in term time. If you do end up feeling frustrated again don't forget if you have a newborn your neighbors will also be putting up with a lot of anti-social behavior from yourself so its only fair that there's give and take on both sides.

It's likely you'll get a response if you build a relationship with these neighbors rather than being combative.

That's ridiculous to put a newborn baby's crying in the same category as a teenager shouting and swearing at 3am and you know it Hmm

Gaming is a very deliberate act that doesn't have to be done loudly at 3am.

AlfonsoTheUnrepentant · 23/12/2021 13:25

Some people with autism will never be able to adapt but they also suffer from NT people not adapting for their needs.

Hand on heart, that is the first time I have ever seen anyone say this. We autistic people continually get crap from NTs so I appreciate your kindness and understanding and wish more people shared your compassion.

Fromageetvino · 23/12/2021 13:24

Being purely practical - could you suggest that she looks at the flooring etc in her sons room? For example if it’s wood, any chance of carpet? Or if carpeted can she add a thicker insulating underlay?

HMG107 · 23/12/2021 13:23

I can't believe in 2020 I'm reading a thread about a teenage boy staying up late gaming and a mum who doesn't like conflict entitled 'to think ASD doesn't entitle you to this?' . Of course this isn't anything to do with being autistic.

I have a two-year-old - your child is likely to be waking in the night and making lots of noise throughout the day for years to come. They'll also be regular high pitch crying due to separation anxiety, tantrums etc so this young lad is likely to have to put up with a lot from you and your family. I'm autistic and have ADHD and my child is a sensory nightmare.

When you wrote this post you didn't take a few minutes to think about how your post would come across to others (especially those who are autistic) so you aren't always considerate. It's hardly surprising a teenage boy hasn't thought too much about his neighbors who moved in three days ago.

You tried to speak to mum and it didn't get anywhere all you can really do now is try and keep as calm as possible over the next few weeks and see what happens in term time. If you do end up feeling frustrated again don't forget if you have a newborn your neighbors will also be putting up with a lot of anti-social behavior from yourself so its only fair that there's give and take on both sides.

It's likely you'll get a response if you build a relationship with these neighbors rather than being combative.

thenewduchessoflapland · 23/12/2021 13:23

I wouldn't let a 15 year stay up past 11pm gaming let alone 3am neuro divergent or not.

I have a nearly 13 year with ASD;people comment on how well behaved he is;that's because we parent him and have set rules and boundaries.

Kids with ASD usually thrive on routine and clear boundaries;in this case the issue is the mother not the kid.

The fact she shoves in ear plugs and ignores the situation tells you everything you need to know really.

Franklin12 · 23/12/2021 13:23

What a selfish family. Clearly the Mother isnt planning to do anything about it. Some people just have NO idea what they do to others and I am afraid I agree with a PP who said ADHD, ASD can sometimes be used as an excuse.

My DS was 4 years old and my DH took him swimming. There was another boy swimming at the same time who took a dislike to him and when they were in the changing rooms tried to punch my son. The mother didnt say anything bar giving my husband a card which said he suffered from ADHD. Well that's OK then.

I would make some gentle enquiries with the leaseholder about this.

TheOccupier · 23/12/2021 13:22

YANBU. Sounds like they (or their landlord if they rent) are in breach of their lease. Is there a managing agent for the block?

CovidisaThiefofJoyandcandoone · 23/12/2021 13:22

.... having said that a solicitor's letter might do the trick.

really sorry about this OP.

CovidisaThiefofJoyandcandoone · 23/12/2021 13:21

re "having a case" against the seller, that is not something I as a litigator would recommend to family or friends because

  1. if you think this is stressful it's not half nor quarter of what the stress of funding and fighting litigation would be. We're talking thousands.
  1. the actions you would take to gather evidence for the litigation are not the same as the actions you take to work towards a solution to the problem (in fact they may be the polar opposite and make the mum feel more entrenched).

I know that's easy for me to say but I've been in your position and know what it feels like. The idea of "suing the seller" is something that other people find easy to say but it isn't easy to do.

NdujaWannaDance · 23/12/2021 13:20

Tell her that you understand how difficult it is and you feel for her, however none of that is your problem to put up with - it's her problem to solve. She needs to speak to her son and tell him to stop the shouting. If he will not or cannot stop the shouting she needs to unplug the internet after 10.30pm.

Tell her you will give her until after Christmas and if things haven't improved you will have no choice but to go to the management company and ask them to intervene.

If his ASD is severe and it's impossible to make changes to his behaviour then they will either have to move or take steps to soundproof the room where he games. Walls, floors and ceiling.

If they are tenants they risk being evicted. If they are owner occupiers they risk having their lease revoked and losing their property if they do not abide by the terms of the lease.

Sleepyblueocean · 23/12/2021 13:17

"I think that as a society we really need to look again at this idea that ASD means kids diagnosed with it should be allowed to do whatever they want, because ‘it’s wrong that they should need to adjust to the world’."

Most parents of children with autism do not think like that. Sure there are some that don't think they should help their child to adapt but there are an equal proportion ( at least) of parents of NT children who don't care what their child does.
Some people with autism will never be able to adapt but they also suffer from NT people not adapting for their needs.

WorraLiberty · 23/12/2021 13:17

[quote BusBusBus]@WorraLiberty - i cant see heavy fines being issued. Ive been in a similar situation and went through environmental health which had very little impact.[/quote]
Well fingers crossed for the OP then, I hope she has better luck.

CovidisaThiefofJoyandcandoone · 23/12/2021 13:17

I am sympathetic OP but you made me smile with this

"Now, I know this is Mumsnet and I’ve been here a long time. So, before anyone asks-

No, we can’t ‘move bedrooms’
No, we can’t move
No, we can’t afford a detached house."

BusBusBus · 23/12/2021 13:16

@WorraLiberty - i cant see heavy fines being issued. Ive been in a similar situation and went through environmental health which had very little impact.

needmoreshinys · 23/12/2021 13:16

I agree with keeping a diary, but as someone who is going through a noise dispute it takes a while, so keep in mind school holidays, weekends, maybe inset days, because while he may be quieter on the days he has to be in school, it might work in your favour.

As in when he has to, its quiet.

RonaldosShirt · 23/12/2021 13:15

It's school holidays at the moment, so hopefully it may not be carrying on so late once schools return. Staying up until 3am and then being at school for 8.30ish , hideous. I think I'd write her a formal letter and keep a record of it - 'further to our conversation on xx date you confirm that the noise is unacceptable but won't take action to stop it. I am requesting again, this time in writing, that you set a deadline of XXpm and ensure that the noise ceases'. Something like that. And then see if that kicks her into action. I appreciate it's is way if socialising, but no one needs to socialise for hours on end through the night, every night.

Swipe left for the next trending thread