Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not have contacted this friend?

59 replies

nobodysperfectatall · 23/12/2021 11:36

I have a friend I've known for about 10 years, know through DC I'd say we are good friends but not best friends if that makes sense.

Her DH left her 7 years ago and she's basically been heartbroken ever since. She went consider counselling but seems very 'stuck'.

She often doesn't read WhatsApp messages or reply to them. If I make an effort to push past this she will come for a walk or we'll go to the pub for dinner. She always says that me and one other friend are the only ones ones who 'gets what she needs' and she really appreciates it.

So what she means is we are the only ones who tolerate being ignored when it suits her and engaged with when it also suits her.

About two months ago I was quite upset about something in my own life and she did reply but was fairly dismissive by text.

At around that time I took a good long look at all of the friendships in my life and realised that I was the one doing the running in all of them. So I decided to drop the rope and stop initiating contact with the people who don't ever contact me first or who ignore messages when I do. This included this friend.

No big drama or fallouts I just let things drift. I've been really happy and free the last couple of months since I did this and this is about me, my own boundaries and what I consider friendship.

So this friend hasn't been in touch in all that time which I'm fine with as she's as capable of contacting me as I am her. But now I'm worrying a bit about her as I know Christmas is hard for her and she will see herself as having been dumped whereas for me I'm applying boundaries across the board.

AIBU to carry on with this even though its almost Christmas this week or should I put a card through her door?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
GiantHaystacks2021 · 24/12/2021 01:39

Think I can see why the DH left.......
I wouldn't give her another thought.

nobodysperfectatall · 23/12/2021 18:48

Thank you everyone. I'm going to leave things at they are, I appreciate all viewpoints, they really helped me to clarify things.

OP posts:
Crimeismymiddlename · 23/12/2021 16:50

Don’t worry about a card. You sound like a really nice person, and great friend but she hasn’t bothered to contact you, or send you a card to start up contact again. Maybe losing you will make her think about and improve her friendship behaviour, But ultimately she has shown you that she does not think your friendship is worth her putting in the effort-only you, on her terms.

ESGdance · 23/12/2021 16:07

@ResentfulAF that’s a very courageous and honest post. It also echos the guidance of the OPs therapist that rescuing / taking responsibility for all of the emotional heavy lifting in the friendship is inadvertently keeping her friend stuck.

I am also currently sitting on my hands and biting my tongue in an attempt to wait for the ball to be returned from the court of a self absorbed friend. I am technically “last man standing” as my “friend”
has offended/snubbed/not nurtured or respected other friends. It will be interesting to see if / when she notices - although we have been round this loop before many times before - it’s almost like a blinking competition where I lose!

MumDad1958 · 23/12/2021 16:01

Friendship is a two way street. This friend isn't a true friend.

Redglitter · 23/12/2021 16:01

Stick to your guns. One sided friendships are hard work. You've been there for her all these years, wait & see how long it takes her to contact you

It might sound hard but ffs her husband left 7 years ago, she should have moved on by now.

If she needs support that badly she knows how to get hold of you.

I'm going through similar with a friend of mine and I'm absolutely determined that this time I'm not giving in

ResentfulAF · 23/12/2021 15:46

I'm the kind of friend who is awful at contact. I make no excuses for it, I know it's unacceptable but it's a deep anxiety type thing for me. I will think about someone everyday and care about them deeply while completely failing to reply to their messages or initiate contact.
I wouldn't send the card. I think she needs to feel the shame of her actions and feel the consequences. If you keep the friendship ticking over it allows her to believe things aren't that bad and she still has wiggle room to be uncommunicative. It's a comforting lie.
The sting of no contact from you is a reasonable and fair thing for her to feel, and could be a prompt for her to admit her faults and apologise, or make more of an effort. Or she will stay hunkered down and continue not to reach out.
Either way, you can't keep things going all on your own. Give her the chance to a good friend, rather than shouldering that yourself.

Littlepinkpeg · 23/12/2021 15:21

I think you know what you want to do, especially after saying you've had a wonderful few months without this person in your life, that speaks volumes to me.
You've done enough, don't feel guilty.

ESGdance · 23/12/2021 14:48

You have answered all your own questions. Have a read back. You know that this “friendship” is not mutual or reciprocal.

She hasn’t changed in 8 years. This is who she is.

She hasn’t responded to or valued the support you gave her or stepped up when you needed support.

You took the right emotional decision to withdraw because of how you say you felt ….. all that’s happening now is YOU are doubting yourself due to some misapplied loyalty or obligation to another which comes at the expense of your own self worth.

Don’t slip back into this futile and unsatisfactory relationship when you have made so much progress.

Don’t keep “hoping” she will change / get better / be different and be continually disappointed and drained.

Look at the space that this draining “friendship” has created for yourself or to pursue or nurture new more refreshing friendships.

Hold strong.

“I've been really happy and free the last couple of months since I did this and this is about me, my own boundaries and what I consider friendship.”

“I have had a wonderful couple of months with no expectations of people to return or initiate contact and life just feels clearer and happier.”

“I think your friends have shown you who they are.”

“I'd like to keep the friendship if she initiates from time to time but not on these terms, no.”

“But now I'm worrying a bit about her as I know Christmas is hard for her and she will see herself as having been dumped whereas for me I'm applying boundaries across the board.”

“I don't usually send her a card, I don't do them so it would be a form of initiated contact for me to do that today.”

“There is something about this particular friend that makes me feel guilty for doing it, due to her personal circumstances.”

bananaboats · 23/12/2021 14:26

I wouldn't send a card if its not something you usually do. I've been in the exact same situation as you op and I tbh although my circle is smaller now im happier. I haven't fallen out with anyone just haven't initiated and guess what haven't heard from them since! Friendships go both ways.

Dancingonmoonlight · 23/12/2021 14:18

Its a hard one isn't it OP.

I think if you don't usually send cards, I wouldn't send one this year.
However I would drop a Happy New Year text to her.

But if you're happy for her to stay out of your life, then don't as it is potentially opening the door for her.

I lost touch with a friend of many many years this year. We didn't fall out but haven't seen each other since covid due to distance. We stayed in touch via irregular phonecalls but I found myself getting more and more stressed after talking to her and I kept lengthening the time between calls. This thread has made me reflect that perhaps she feels 'ghosted'. I hope not. I have just realised we are very different people, our outlooks on life are very different and I don't 'enjoy' talking to her and I'm sure she feels the same.

CheshireKitten123 · 23/12/2021 14:17

"There is something about this particular friend that makes me feel guilty for doing it, due to her personal circumstances"

This might help OP.

www.baggagereclaim.co.uk/it-will-take-more-than-one-attempt-to-communicate-your-boundaries-keep-going/

AngelinaFibres · 23/12/2021 14:16

@nobodysperfectatall

Thanks all I'm really torn so really appreciate replies.

I spoke to a counsellor friend who suggested I consider that I might be enabling her helplessness by always being the one who 'rescues' her makes contact, chivies her out and that this might be enabling her sense of victimhood rather than helping her move forward.

Your counsellor has hit the nail on the head.
zingally · 23/12/2021 14:11

@CareBear50

Put a card through her door OP. Just say you've been busy but look forward to hearing from her and hope she's doing OK as you know it's a tough time of year for her And see if she gets back to you
This. ^

She's useless, but you already knew that.

This way, you are very clearly putting the ball in her court. No mixed messages, no ghosting. You clearly say something like "I'd love to hear from you when you're up for doing something!" and then walk away.

UnsuitableHat · 23/12/2021 14:02

I’d probably send a card in this situation, but if you’re happy for her to stay out of your life there’s no need to.

TheBestofTimesTheWorstofTimes · 23/12/2021 13:54

I always say it is good to "mirror people". Copy her way of behaving and see if it jolts her out of complacency ans she starts putting in effort, or whether she cba and is not that bothered about you.

Coyoacan - I generally need other people to initiate contact - why? On the face of it this seems so selfish, even though you put that you "repay" their friendship. But why do others have to make the first move towards you?

JoanOgden · 23/12/2021 13:41

I wouldn't send a card myself. You've done your best over the past 7 years... if she cares about your friendship it is very easy for her to initiate contact.

nobodysperfectatall · 23/12/2021 13:38

@Uninterested

Ughh, so sorry, I really hadn’t meant my post to have come across aggressively. Apologies!!!! I was just trying to say that you are overthinking it! There is nothing wrong in whatever option you choose.
Oh thank you, sorry I see what you're saying.
OP posts:
comingintomyown · 23/12/2021 13:38

I’ve had phases of dropping contact with friends where I do all the running and a few have disappeared from my life but there are a few where I’ve stopped judging and accept if I want to see them I initiate it . Many years later I’m really glad I stuck with them, we often meet or chat on the phone they are pleased to see me and readily respond when they hear from me.
I think dropping off a card is a nice light way of keeping the lines of communication open for the future

Uninterested · 23/12/2021 13:34

Ughh, so sorry, I really hadn’t meant my post to have come across aggressively. Apologies!!!!

I was just trying to say that you are overthinking it!

There is nothing wrong in whatever option you choose.

nobodysperfectatall · 23/12/2021 13:32

@Diana8

OP: "I'm applying boundaries across the board".

I have no idea what this piece of jargon means - I see those words on this site all the time - it must be from one of the handful of books people constantly refer to on here.
I wouldn't post a card - you are inviting her back in to basically use you.
You made your decision and it was the right one.

As I said in my OP I am applying the same boundaries to all the friends who never initiate contact and / or don't reply to messages.

There is something about this particular friend that makes me feel guilty for doing it, due to her personal circumstances.

OP posts:
Diana8 · 23/12/2021 13:17

OP: "I'm applying boundaries across the board".

I have no idea what this piece of jargon means - I see those words on this site all the time - it must be from one of the handful of books people constantly refer to on here.
I wouldn't post a card - you are inviting her back in to basically use you.
You made your decision and it was the right one.

DoubleDeckerSwimmer · 23/12/2021 13:15

If it will make you feel better, post a card. Then you don't need to go all the way to their house.

If it will not make you feel better, then leave it. Especially if you are happy for the friendship to fade.

nobodysperfectatall · 23/12/2021 13:11

@larkstar

Go with your intuition, your heart and be flexible - this is the real world, people and situations are complex - no simple set of rules is ever going to be perfect for all situations - drop her a note - it really could arrive at the right time and make a difference - obviously the smart money is that it will be inconsequential but you don't know that - something seems to be telling you to contact her so I'd do that and not get selfishly wrapped up by your rules. I have had to cut contact with peopel in my life because they largely only added problems and stress to my life and it was definitely the right thing to do but equally I shared a few long overdue home truths with a long standing friend of 20 years and he cut contact with me - I continued to message him and slowly, reluctantly he has started to write back - I don't regret it at all - telling him things someone needed to tell him - I didn't want to lose him as a friend - that wasn't my intention - to burn bridges but I was prepared for that to happen - I was still surprised by his reaction and the fact that he has not tried to talk to me about the things I said - I'd still argue my case with him. So - be intelligent - and that includes being intuitive, compassionate, forgiving... all those good qualities.
I've been being intuitive, compassionate and forgiving for 7 years now.
OP posts:
Viviennemary · 23/12/2021 13:10

I would put a card through the door but stop doing all the running.

Swipe left for the next trending thread