Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be horrified? (content warning: sex crimes)

198 replies

Aromatica · 23/12/2021 11:17

I've read about this case where John Ernest Goodier has been charged with bestiality, child pornography, drug possession and not sticking to his sex offenders conditions.

He recently goes by the name Claire. This paper refers to him as a man but many of the others refer to him as a woman.
www.northwichguardian.co.uk/news/19682778.northwich-man-admits-sex-dog/

AIBU to be horrified that this might be reported and recorded as a woman's crime and may serve time in a woman's prison?

(Yes I did post this before but requested it was deleted, so I could post again with a poll. In the interim, the ability to add a poll has gone and I can't see any polls in AIBU. Peculiar 🤔)

OP posts:
rockinghorsebadge · 23/12/2021 21:08

@Lockheart

As an adult, I don't need MN deleting threads in case they offend though? Or do they delete because advertisers would be cross?

MNs talk guidelines say they will delete (among other things) personal attacks, racism, homophobia, transphobia etc.

If that does not suit I suggest that you find a different forum.

Urgh, patronising.
Linguini · 23/12/2021 20:12

www.lifesitenews.com/news/mexican-supreme-court-affirms-right-to-change-birth-certificates-to-reflect-age-identity/

If the UK follow recent identity laws introduced in Mexico, this man would have the right to identify as too young to go to prison.

AlfonsoTheUnrepentant · 23/12/2021 19:53

Not only transgender, but also transage. How cute.

gailforce1 · 23/12/2021 19:30

20 months - wonder how soon he will be on the streets again?

Nowayoutonlydown · 23/12/2021 19:21

I was disgusted when I read the article about this.
This vile human being will be put into a male prison I read about an hour ago. They do not deserve to be around other human beings, they are a vile predator through and through.

Yummychocs19 · 23/12/2021 19:18

Just one other thing in relation to appropriation…men have traditionally dominated women, we had to fight hard for our rights and still aren’t treated equally in all areas of society. That’s why I find this all really unreasonable ….a man decides to do this and we are told to just accept it or if we don’t we are being hateful etc.

Yummychocs19 · 23/12/2021 19:14

Also I’m not even sure if I’m allowed to express my opinion on this anymore?!

Yummychocs19 · 23/12/2021 19:11

Yanbu. People get slated all the time for cultural appropriation yet somehow if you’re born as a biological woman or man it’s okay to appropriate the characteristics of the opposite sex? I don’t get the society we are living in today….I’d have thought statistically more men commit sex offences than women? Why does ‘identifying’ as a woman when you have / had a penis suddenly enable you to be blindly accepted as a woman in society and use our changing facilities and toilets and prisons without any regard for potential risks to biological women?

RobotValkyrie · 23/12/2021 19:03

@Lacedwithgrace

The alternative is she endangers men. Criminals don't get to choose who they feel safest with.
But if they happen to be male sex offenders, then they do get to chose who they will endanger, and get to pick the more physically vulnerable demographic? Makes sense. Sounds fair and all that.
Guavaf1sh · 23/12/2021 18:58

The world is insane now

Linguini · 23/12/2021 18:56

women are anyway capable of horrendous crimes

Women can't use their penis to commit crimes

Outlyingtrout · 23/12/2021 18:55

No the crime has nothing to do with gender preference, women are anyway capable of horrendous crimes, I don't get the whole wishing she does the time in a male prison.

Have you read the thread? And you still don't understand why it's important that men are not imprisoned alongside vulnerable women? Or why it's completely disingenuous to pretend that women commit these offences just the same as men do?

AlfonsoTheUnrepentant · 23/12/2021 18:47

@Strangeways19

No the crime has nothing to do with gender preference, women are anyway capable of horrendous crimes, I don't get the whole wishing she does the time in a male prison.

Without medical & proper professional direction the trans status in the eyes of the law doesn't stand anyway.
Christ though, a dog, what state of mind would you have to be in for that to happen.
Is there a full story somewhere?

The perpetrator is a he, not a she, and therefore belongs in a male prison.

And what is "medical and proper professional direction"? Your post shows a staggering ignorance of the issue.

Strangeways19 · 23/12/2021 18:39

No the crime has nothing to do with gender preference, women are anyway capable of horrendous crimes, I don't get the whole wishing she does the time in a male prison.

Without medical & proper professional direction the trans status in the eyes of the law doesn't stand anyway.
Christ though, a dog, what state of mind would you have to be in for that to happen.
Is there a full story somewhere?

Lacedwithgrace · 23/12/2021 18:37

The alternative is she endangers men. Criminals don't get to choose who they feel safest with.

Blossom987 · 23/12/2021 18:22

Imagine being a woman sent to prison for not paying your tv licence but then this individual gets a suspended sentence - on two separate occasions - for possessing child sexual abuse images. And people say women get lighter sentences than men.

AlfonsoTheUnrepentant · 23/12/2021 18:16

You're welcome, @Waitwhat23!

Waitwhat23 · 23/12/2021 18:15

Second - there is no such thing as "true trans gender individuals". People are trans if they say they are. End of story. And don't complain to me - complain to Stonewall.

@alfonsotheunrepentant thank you Alfonso, this is what I was trying (badly) to say. Stonewall have a huge umbrella of what constitutes trans individuals and because of 'no debate' we can't challenge this without accusations of transphobia.

Linguini · 23/12/2021 18:12

Careful now, it's "they is not a woman"

AlfonsoTheUnrepentant · 23/12/2021 18:10

@Theoldcuriosityshop

I've just read he's being sent to a male prison, because she is not legally a woman.
He is not a woman, legal or otherwise.
Theoldcuriosityshop · 23/12/2021 18:09

He's been jailed for 20 months.

Theoldcuriosityshop · 23/12/2021 18:09

I've just read he's being sent to a male prison, because she is not legally a woman.

AlfonsoTheUnrepentant · 23/12/2021 18:09

@Rina66

Give him the choice, if you really want to identify as a woman, we'll help you by rendering your penis unusable, as a woman you won't need it. If that's not a acceptable and as you've proved children, animals and women aren't safe around you, you're going to a male prison.

This man is abusing the system and it's insulting to true trans gender individuals and all that they've fought so hard for.

Two points: castration, chemical or otherwise, does not stop the desire to be a sex offender. All that it means is that the offender must resort to using objects which can be more dangerous to the victim.

Second - there is no such thing as "true trans gender individuals". People are trans if they say they are. End of story. And don't complain to me - complain to Stonewall.

AThousandEyes · 23/12/2021 18:07

Who decides who's 'a true trans' and who's just playing the system then? Because according to Stonewall and the trans community's own definition, a trans person is anyone who says they are, full stop, hashtag 'no debate'.

I do believe there are some who don't identify as trans and who are just using it to gain an easier sentence or access to vulnerable women (though when women warned that predatory men would use self identification to game the system this way we were told it was nonsense). But I also believe that there will be a significant number who genuinely identify as transwomen (however you define that) who are violent sexual offenders; how could it be otherwise given that transwomen are biologically male and retain male rates of offending? Those attempting to downplay the very real risks to women by saying that no 'true transwoman' is a risk are utterly delusional.

Swipe left for the next trending thread