Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parents think I don’t have enough money in pension

270 replies

Helena1985h · 22/12/2021 20:43

Talking to my mum and dad about pension today. I’m 35 FYI.

They asked me how much I’d put away as were saying they wished they’d focused more on their pensions when young. I logged in and had a look and I have just under 55k.

They seemed to think that was way too small, and they’ve properly freaked me out TBH. Is that really not a lot at my age? I sort of assumed I was doing okay!

OP posts:
CurtainTroubles · 23/12/2021 14:18

This reply has been deleted

Withdrawn at the user's request

VanGoghsDog · 23/12/2021 13:54

@DeepaBeesKit

My dad reckons I should try and put away 7k per year into pension which would be 20% of salary so a lot!

He's not far off. DH works in a related area and he would always recommend half your age as a percentage, rounded up to the nearest whole number. So at 35 he would say you need to be putting in 18%.

I'm 36 and I put 18% in mine, I will add another 2% of AVCs next year.

While it's a good "rule of thumb", the half your age advice relates to when you start paying into a pension, not forever.

If you start at twenty, then ten. But it can stay ten forever, it doesn't need to go up to fifteen when you're thirty, and twenty five when you're fifty.

But most people put in far less so it's a good benchmark.

I never understand why people say "if you want x proportion of your salary" because, to me, what I get in retirement is totally separate to my salary while I'm working. I'd never expect, or need, even 50% of my current salary in retirement.

I think you should decide your financial needs in retirement based on what you want to do, not on how much you earn now. Though appreciate if you earn £100k now and only save enough for a £20k pension it's a big drop.

I earn c£80k, but I'm only working towards having a pension of c£20k plus state pension later. It seems enough to me.

My plan is that when I've got enough in the pension for that to be my drawdown, I'll stop doing such a boring high paid job and do something more useful (but probably terribly badly paid) and not pay into the pension any more.

AuntyBumBum · 23/12/2021 13:50

Lots of people are in for a hella rude awakening. Have you not been seeing the news lately?

Retirement age going up to 67 and even then they already making noises that it needs to go up more.

Most of us aren't good at planning, and recent collective decisions really haven't helped. For example as a country I think we took the view that covid policy just had cost whatever money it needed - discussing the financial consequences was somehow immoral, and in poor taste. That doesn't mean there aren't financial consequences. And most of us will be paying them one way or another for the rest of our lives.

Similar for the long-term financial damage of brexit.

VanGoghsDog · 23/12/2021 13:47

@Imdreamingofapeacefulxmas

Scottish mortgage off loaded it's tesla didn't it?
It might have done now but it definitely contributed to the rise last year.
dundydee · 23/12/2021 13:41

Retirement age going up to 67 and even then they already making noises that it needs to go up more.

The last news I read said it shouldn't go up as the life expectancy gains predicted are not happening.

Imdreamingofapeacefulxmas · 23/12/2021 12:25

Scottish mortgage off loaded it's tesla didn't it?

Spectre8 · 23/12/2021 12:24

Lots of people are in for a hella rude awakening. Have you not been seeing the news lately?

Retirement age going up to 67 and even then they already making noises that it needs to go up more.

Not to mention the recent news putting feelers out about possibly have retirement ages by life expentancy based on regions, where regions with lower life expentancy those people get their state pension earlier than those in regions where life expentacy is higher have to wait even longer. This isn't decided but they are thinking about it.

A very long time ago there was something I read from a credible medai source that talked about whether state pensions would even be around and that the government is going to have trouble funding them around 2035.

So since then I've been paing down my mortage asap and ensuring im maximising my pension contributions on the basis I have enough to have a good retirement without factoring in the state pension.

And young people today really need to start thinking like that. I'm surem any will think there is no way they would get rid of the state pension - well you don't know and they are already moving goalposts such that most won't even make it to get it.

Imdreamingofapeacefulxmas · 23/12/2021 12:24

It's a gamble for me compared to my safe index trackers.

Even though I did my due diligence on it before investing.

DeepaBeesKit · 23/12/2021 12:22

My dad reckons I should try and put away 7k per year into pension which would be 20% of salary so a lot!

He's not far off. DH works in a related area and he would always recommend half your age as a percentage, rounded up to the nearest whole number. So at 35 he would say you need to be putting in 18%.

I'm 36 and I put 18% in mine, I will add another 2% of AVCs next year.

nearly4o · 23/12/2021 12:22

I am 38 and I have a defined benefit scheme from one job that will pay out 9k a year at 65 and then goes up to 13k at state pension age. From new job - I have 15k that took 3 years to accrue . If I work for another 25 years that will have approx 135k in it - enough for maybe 3/4 k per year?

I am not too worried. We have a rental property and my husband has a good military pension of approx 20k per year

VanGoghsDog · 23/12/2021 12:17

@Imdreamingofapeacefulxmas

S and p is tracking same stocks.
Loads of funds track stock market stocks. But the way you worded it you were saying S&P is the US stock exchange, it's not.
VanGoghsDog · 23/12/2021 12:16

@Imdreamingofapeacefulxmas

Van gogh is that Scottish mortgage?

Mine is up that much as well.

It's my gamble fund.
Otherwise I'm invested in index funds.

Yes!

I didn't take it as a "gamble", at the time it was a good addition to my portfolio. It holds a lot of tech stock, and tech is volatile, subject to trends etc, so I don't really want to hold them individually. Also, many are US based and I don't want US stocks due to withholding tax.

So it was a great addition to my types of stocks. Then Covid hit. And the fund holds Facebook, Amazon, Zoom, Tesla .......and Tesla itself is partly influenced by Bitcoin ......and all of that stuff took off during the pandemic. It was a total fluke for me!

Imdreamingofapeacefulxmas · 23/12/2021 12:14

S and p is tracking same stocks.

Imdreamingofapeacefulxmas · 23/12/2021 12:12

Van gogh is that Scottish mortgage?

Mine is up that much as well.

It's my gamble fund.
Otherwise I'm invested in index funds.

VanGoghsDog · 23/12/2021 12:10

@Imdreamingofapeacefulxmas

Many index funds are a little of everything or ones that replicate or follow the ftse 100 or s and p (us stock market) are self cleaning.

It's better than buying individual stocks.
Eg marks and Spencer fails it falls out of the fste and is replaced by anther company.

It's self cleaning and in the US only a couple of companies in index now where there 100 years ago.

Buying a little of everything doesn't give instant huge returns but it's steady and fairly stable.
It would take something like an asteroid hitting the world to wipe out fste or s and p 500.
You buy into innovation and creation, through s and p I have exposure to apple, tesla, alphabet and hundreds of other great companies.
But if one fails... I don't loose money it simply drops out.

Simple path to wealth jl Collins. He suggests just investing in one vanguard fund, the same fund Warren buffet has told his wife to put all their money in, if he dies!

It's a huge fund that has a little of everything.
My investments dropped considerably during covid but that would only be an issue if I had to draw on them.

Which is why we all need cash reserves as well or some bonds to balance it out.

They have been hovering around 25% since its been opened.

S&P (Standard and Poor) isn't the US stock market. It's a benchmark and fund provider. I have a couple of their funds.

The US stock market is NYSE or NASDAQ.

Imdreamingofapeacefulxmas · 23/12/2021 12:06

@Cupcakeschocolate

I'd be looking at opening a vanguard sipp.
Sipp = self, invested, personal pension.

They have life stragety funds depending on age which buy a little of everything but the have more or less bonds depending on your risk.

I've got 100% equity life stragety funds.

When you open up with vanguard a bit like John Lewis partners you also own vanguard. Very low fees, Google jack boggle.

He set up vanguard.

When you add to your sipp the government also tops it up.

However i would simultaneously also set up at socks and shares isa because there are penalties on taking money out of a sipp.

VanGoghsDog · 23/12/2021 12:02

@united4ever

Thanks Van Gogh.

That is great. A massive plus over an annuity if you have kids. I can see why they are popular.

Exactly. I know several people who have both DB and DC schemes and are planning to just live on the DB scheme and "save" the DC scheme for their kids' inheritance.
VanGoghsDog · 23/12/2021 12:00

@Cupcakeschocolate

Does anyone have a private pension who can point me in the right direction.... After reading this I must be clueless. I have one with work. Bit it's not very good. I don't know how to add to it. So must speak to them about it. Or is it better to have a savings account or isa. I'm 29 and it has really opened my eyes. That sounds stupid I know. But I've been concentrating on my kids and didn't think too much about it! Feeling quite a fool now
Noone can tell you what is best for you, there are so many factors.

I've always taken a balanced approach - put some in savings (ISA) as cash, some in stocks, some in pension and use some to pay off mortgage.

First consideration is always to pay off debt and build an emergency fund. And ensure you are maximising employer contributions to your pension (because they might pay more if you do - mine pays 10% if I pay 2% and if I increase that to 3% they pay 15%. I actually pay 35%, so I get 50% of my salary in my pension).

united4ever · 23/12/2021 11:59

Thanks Van Gogh.

That is great. A massive plus over an annuity if you have kids. I can see why they are popular.

VanGoghsDog · 23/12/2021 11:52

@united4ever

Lump sum is the wrong term. So say you have 400k pot and decide to live off 4% so 16k a year (plus state pension). When you die the 400k could be more or less still 400k. This 400k can be passed to kids tax free?
Free of inheritance tax, yes.

However:

"As of April 2015, money left in pensions can be passed on to anyone you like – they do not have to be your spouse or a financial dependant. If you die before your 75th birthday, that money can be passed tax free and if you die after turning 75, income tax only becomes payable when your beneficiaries start to withdraw the money."

www.ii.co.uk/analysis-commentary/why-you-need-will-your-pension-ii512914

Cupcakeschocolate · 23/12/2021 11:51

Does anyone have a private pension who can point me in the right direction.... After reading this I must be clueless. I have one with work. Bit it's not very good. I don't know how to add to it. So must speak to them about it. Or is it better to have a savings account or isa. I'm 29 and it has really opened my eyes. That sounds stupid I know. But I've been concentrating on my kids and didn't think too much about it! Feeling quite a fool now

VanGoghsDog · 23/12/2021 11:49

@Daisydoesnt

Pensions don't earn interest

No they don't earn "interest" as such, as pension investments wouldn't usually be held in cash. Your pension contributions are normally invested into equities (and bonds, and probably a number of other asset classes) in which case they will grow over time. In other words, you might not benefit from compound interest, but you will still benefit from compounding.

Exactly.

But it's a different mathematical concept than the miracle of compound interest, which compounds at the same rate year on year. Investments are bumpy, good years and bad years.

One of my funds I bought in Feb 2020 is up by 130%. Meanwhile, my Shell shares........not doing so great!

united4ever · 23/12/2021 11:49

Lump sum is the wrong term. So say you have 400k pot and decide to live off 4% so 16k a year (plus state pension). When you die the 400k could be more or less still 400k. This 400k can be passed to kids tax free?

VanGoghsDog · 23/12/2021 11:47

[quote EmpressCixi]@VanGoghsDog
Yes technically, by definition the returns are not interest but growth in value and/or dividends. But they are expressed as a +/- % return/loss, in the same way as interest is, and both are a % calculated against the same base. The concept of compound interest is roughly equivalent to the concept of compound earnings.

My point is that you can actually compare a pension fund with a ten year average return of 8% to a savings account with only 0.2% interest and think, hmm..yes there is risk that the fund may have an off year or two with a net loss, but you know what long term my money is definitely going to do much better in the SIPP than in a savings account.

The same applies to thinking about whether to prioritise pension or mortgage pay off. You shouldn’t compare the interest on your mortgage to the interest rate on savings, but the interest on your mortgage to the long term returns from a decent pension fund type.

I understand you are correcting terminology and have no complaint there. I hope I have explained myself better.[/quote]
I don't expect it was only you I was responding to. I agree with what you've said. But loads of people are referring to pension returns as "interest" and it's very misleading for the reasons I gave.

And it's this confusion which prevents people from really understanding money. Or wanting to.

My intelligent sister screeches like a banshee if I mention pensions to her. One sentence and she starts whining "it's all so complicated". It really isn't. I'm not (ostensibly) as intelligent as her, but I've taught myself about investments, pensions, tax. And I'm totally crap at maths, so it's not that!

caringcarer · 23/12/2021 11:30

My Dad worked in a factory all his life. Best not of advise he gave to his 5 dd was to start your pension as soon as you start work and pay in more than you have to. I trained to become a teacher and he told me take put a second stakeholder pension on top of Teachers pension. I did not know anyone else paying 2 pensions but followed that advise and really at the time it was not too hard before I married and had children. I retired early at 56. I am 60 now and get my TP every month but also have my extra pot I can drawdown from when I want to that I have been able to use to help my children with deposits. The earlier you invest the greater the rewards. I have absolutely drilled pensions into my children.