Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not give free stuff to people who can’t even say please

87 replies

Iwasintoyou · 22/12/2021 15:26

Giving away some free items brand new but thought as it was near christmas I would help people out. Woman commented is this available. I said yes she then said I can pick up tonight. Aibu to not want to give it to her dh thinks I am personally think please doesn’t cost anything and makes a difference.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MidnightMeltdown · 06/01/2022 14:37

It does seem.a bit odd though that there are conditions attached to something that's free amd supposedly first come first served.

I use Trash nothing to advertise fee items, and they encourage people to use their 'fair offer' policy. This means NOT first come first served. You are supposed to wait a while so that people who might not have easy access to computer, internet, or are working etc get a chance to see the advert and reply. You can then decide who you want to give it to.

I think that this is better, otherwise you just get greedy grabby people who check the site constantly and ask for everything.

If someone rude like this woman replied to me then they definitely wouldn't get the item.

NumberTheory · 28/12/2021 00:42

I like “Please.” And “Thank you” but I am much more keen on people who read the listing, accept any terms and will turn up and take it away at my convenience. All the pleases and thank you sin the world don’t make up for wanting a bit of it but not the rest, wanting it delivered, rearranging times for days on end, etc.

So someone who isn’t quibbling and is willing to come round and get it today is, to me, more appreciative in many ways than someone who uses all the right words but still asks me to jump through hoops for them.

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 28/12/2021 00:25

@Flakeymcwakey

You are not giving it away for free, are you OP? The price you have attached is a certain amount of gratitude. Perhaps some difference and an acknowledgement that you are a good person. You should work in the charities sector, you'd fit right in.
Not gratitude. Basic respect for other people. I pity anyone who thinks that's a problem quite frankly.
Flakeymcwakey · 27/12/2021 23:41

Well I think you shouldn't call it free. And you should make clear that you'll only give your stuff to people who you feel have the right attitude.

Snog · 26/12/2021 10:39

Or as a minimum common politeness and not to be messed around?

Snog · 26/12/2021 10:38

Surely gratitude is a wholly appropriate expectation????

Flakeymcwakey · 24/12/2021 13:27

You are not giving it away for free, are you OP? The price you have attached is a certain amount of gratitude. Perhaps some difference and an acknowledgement that you are a good person. You should work in the charities sector, you'd fit right in.

Snog · 24/12/2021 13:25

There are a lot of rude people about and for me it saps the pleasure out of giving away something of value to a stranger.

It's usually a lot easier to put something in the bin than to go to the bother of rehoming it to someone who wants it.

I use the Olio app to rehome things and find most people there to be polite and fewer time wasters than on FB.

Goldilocks99 · 24/12/2021 13:21

I wouldn't take time taken over replies as being rude. Checking with partner whether to commit or when can pick up, being at work, plain missing the message. Plenty of reasons for a later reply.
Seeing rudeness where there is none.

NandorTheRelentless · 24/12/2021 12:57

[quote StarfishDish]@NandorTheRelentless They were rude tbh. 'Ye' isn't really a polite answer is it really?[/quote]
They answered, in the positive
What more did you want?

StarfishDish · 24/12/2021 12:54

@NandorTheRelentless They were rude tbh. 'Ye' isn't really a polite answer is it really?

Noodledoodledoo · 24/12/2021 12:12

Basic manners do make a difference.

I was selling something on marketplace and replied it was still available, no response for 3 days, then I got asked how much it was - on the listing but I replied with the price, then got 'address' after 2 hours, 20 minutes later - what's the address, message got deleted.

Sounds petty, but you don't ignore the reply for 3 daysand then start being demanding with no manners - would rather give the item to the charity shop than deal with people with zero manners.

BorderlineHappy · 24/12/2021 11:49

We have a usually lovely group for the area
A woman put up a post and asked for boys trousers.
I had about 6 pairs with tags still on them and I offered them.
She didn't drive and it was a bit of a trek for her.

So I agreed to drop them down,
She never turned up,never rang me.

Turns you off helping people.

NandorTheRelentless · 24/12/2021 11:22

@StarfishDish

I'm always polite but find some sellers can be rude too! This was a conversation I had...

Hi, is this still available please? 😊
Ye.
Could I have it then, please? 😊
Ye.
What is your address please?
Gave postcode
Are you available at the weekend?
Ye.

I gave up after that and messaged 'I'm really sorry but my husband managed to get one. Sorry to waste your time.' to which they responded 'No worries. Thanks for letting me know.'

🙈

What's wrong with that? They answered your questions
Goldilocks99 · 24/12/2021 11:17

*your.

Goldilocks99 · 24/12/2021 11:16

So many time waster sellers on FB marketplace. They don't get a please till we're past the template stage.
Of you want to teach people a lesson, you have to inform them what you are doing, sellers and buyers flake so often you're message will not be clear.
This endless thankery is pointless, it's embarrassing. There was a thread the other day where a mum was cross that her child's sports coach gave an in person thank you to her child for a thank you present, rather than a note or text.
What's next, a thank you note for a thank you note?
Please realise how unnecessary all the angst is. One thank you suffices. Thank you.

CallMeRachel · 24/12/2021 02:41

I think manners or lack of is a generational thing.
Mid 30’s downwards don’t seem to see the need for any imo.
I choose who I give things to. Rude people don’t get. It should be a life lesson but the Penny never seems to drop…yanbu

Goldilocks99 · 23/12/2021 08:42

@TheVolturi

I hate this too. I usually reply along the lines of, I'm not sure if you are new to the site, but the rules are that when requesting an item you are polite and courteous!
You sound charming. You get a thank you when they come and take it away. Let them eat cake, but also be pointlessly unnaturally polite first. FB marketplace doesn't have a please in the auto message. They set the tone. If you don't like it take it up with them. Oh please can I have your old junk magnanimous radiant lady?
TheVolturi · 23/12/2021 07:52

I hate this too. I usually reply along the lines of, I'm not sure if you are new to the site, but the rules are that when requesting an item you are polite and courteous!

Thwackit · 22/12/2021 23:26

@Cyw2018

Tried to give away a pair of really lovely DrMarten boots that needed resoling but didn't fit me comfortably after pregnancy... This is what followed...

I did manage to eventually give them to someone pleasant and capable of using basic manners.

What the actual…I mean, that’s outrageous!
hibbledibble · 22/12/2021 23:00

Yanbu. Manners should be compulsory, whether something is free or not.

It's rediculous how hard it is sometimes giving away good items for free.

ToffeeNotCoffee · 22/12/2021 22:30

*1) most of the free stuff where I live is obviously people trying to avoid huge haulage costs to get rid of the item (Garden sod, old fences/gates, old sofas, old bed frames etc... worth nothing). If they are helping you out by taking something you need rid of without costing you money they don't need to throw yourself at their feet and beg.

  1. You are lucky enough to be in a position of giving something worth money away because you can afford to as a charity act. If you are doing it for this reason expecting anything back (even just to pick and choose people based on what you decide should be 'suitable' behavior) means your hearts are in the wrong place and you are only doing it to lord your power/privilege over others and make yourself feel better.*

This^

Ohdofuckoffcovid · 22/12/2021 19:42

I hate it when they say, I’ll have that, no please or thank you

KirstenBlest · 22/12/2021 19:39

@coffeetofunction

Manors cost nothing....
If only...
Lokdok · 22/12/2021 19:35

@Whatwouldscullydo

You can give it or not give it to whoever you want.

It does seem.a bit odd though that there are conditions attached to something that's free amd supposedly first come first served.

I mean ultimately its doing u a favour ( you no longer have to have it cluttering up your place or take a trip to the tip) as much as it's doing them a favour.

I mean yeah I'd not be rude to anyone there's no need but then I.work.with the public so if I refused to serve anyone who didn't say please or thank you we'd have alot fewer customers.

I dont think you are unreasonable fir hoping people might be polite.

Sadly you are a little U for expecting strangers to behave in a way you wouod like/expect/impose as an unknown condition

That just doesn't happen unfortunately

Such an odd mentality. Giving things away is a kindness, charity. You are not doing a favour when you take it off their hands! They could sell it for the same amount of hassle, or give it to charity shop or chuck it out which would be easier for them. How horribly ungrateful.