Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU To wish that the media would ask which way people voted in the EU referendum when reporting problems of the farming and fishing industry caused by Brexit?

168 replies

Kendodd · 22/12/2021 11:03

www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-humber-59748581.amp

Because if you voted Leave you are too stupid to be in business and don't deserve my sympathy.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Peregrina · 24/12/2021 18:54

I think a lot of people in the UK would like to see a much more collaborative relationship with the EU, and indeed I suspect that many thought that an EEA type arrangement would be what we ended up with. But at present the Government has zero appetite for a better relationship. They are hell bent on deals literally on the other side of the world, but seem to want to pretend that our neighbours don't exist.

LemonSwan · 24/12/2021 16:08

Funny isn't it how we look at things differently. For me, covid is exactly the time we want as much international cooperation as possible rather an an every man for himself and trample the weak underfoot approach.

It is interesting isn't it! I consider diversity an asset so I like to think our differing views a strength of our society rather than a downfall.

I am sure once things settle down we can move forward collaborating more with the EU on common goals on a voluntary basis. If its beneficial to everyone its only a matter of time. I do not want to lose final autonomy or accountability though. They are very very important to me. But I don't see why we cant have both.

Peregrina · 24/12/2021 16:06

Sure they made mistakes, but its their mistakes and they cant pass the buck to the EU.

But don't worry. This Government always passes the buck - with Covid it's to the general public for not obeying the rules, although with this the Govt have been well and truly rumbled because they don't obey the rules they made either.

KenDodd · 24/12/2021 15:36

Funny isn't it how we look at things differently. For me, covid is exactly the time we want as much international cooperation as possible rather an an every man for himself and trample the weak underfoot approach.

OP posts:
LemonSwan · 24/12/2021 14:01

I am a small business owner who voted leave. I have at times thought my god why did I do that because it does make importing such a painful longer process and it is more expensive.

However then we had the pandemic; and thats exactly the kind of scenario I want a fully autonomous accountable government in. Sure they made mistakes, but its their mistakes and they cant pass the buck to the EU.

Lifes not black and white. Its when you choose your paint colours and theirs a series of greys and off whites which look good under some lights and slightly grim under others. Its hard to get it bang on even with every possible option. Its impossible to be perfect when you have only two colours to choose from.

KenDodd · 24/12/2021 13:49

Some analysts from the BBC

www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-59761292

Again, love to know how people adversely (or positively) effected voted.
I know one poster up thread said her work is booming because of Brexit, didn't say what she did though. I did wonder if her job is assisting business moves from the UK to the Netherlands as I've heard that's a real boom industry.

OP posts:
Pumperthepumper · 23/12/2021 22:35

Oh wait, I’m remembering wrong - it was a poster. An anti-immigrant poster. Such japes!

The bus was the lie about the NHS.

Pumperthepumper · 23/12/2021 22:34

@FrippEnos

Pumperthepumper

Did they care more about NI or stopping immigrants coming in?

I couldn't tell you, I haven't taken a survey of them. Nor would I presume to answer for them. Unlike many remainers here.

Probably the immigrants though. Remember when they put them on the side of the bus? What a laugh that was!
FrippEnos · 23/12/2021 22:00

@Peregrina

Generally speaking the English know precious little of the history of Ireland and care even less.
This is pretty much the truth. but then most will only know of the versions put forward from the 70s.
FrippEnos · 23/12/2021 22:00

Pumperthepumper

Did they care more about NI or stopping immigrants coming in?

I couldn't tell you, I haven't taken a survey of them. Nor would I presume to answer for them. Unlike many remainers here.

Scrowy · 23/12/2021 21:47

The farming vote is estimated to roughly reflect the national vote on brexit. The farming press was heavily promoting remain.

As with anything else Brexit related generally the vocal farming supporters of brexit posted widely on it, put posters up, put up signs in their fields and the remainers.... didn't.

For those farmers like me who farm in upland sheep farming systems brexit is a disaster and we absolutely did not vote for it.

Farmers like me are the 'tributary' at the stream/river of food production. For many years we have provided produce to the next person in the chain below the cost of production because subsidies meant we could afford to.

Subsidies allow Farmers to provide cheap food. Take them away and food becomes more expensive.

Pumperthepumper · 23/12/2021 19:37

@TheHateIsNotGood

Just checked back to thank derxha for providing some info. Look pumper I'm really not too concerned about your definitions, all you want is a 'scrap'.

If my post was deleted for being bile, then the one where you quoted me would have been too.

Please feel free to requote me if you feel that upset by my words, but it upsets some people whose wounds haven't completely healed yet, hence my original post was removed. I accept that and shouldn't you too?

Or just go back and look yourself? It’s the one about murdering the neighbours in NI, I started it ‘I expect this will be deleted’ so you should spot it no bother. Or, don’t be a coward: share your views again.
Peregrina · 23/12/2021 19:10

Generally speaking the English know precious little of the history of Ireland and care even less.

TheHateIsNotGood · 23/12/2021 19:02

Just checked back to thank derxha for providing some info. Look pumper I'm really not too concerned about your definitions, all you want is a 'scrap'.

If my post was deleted for being bile, then the one where you quoted me would have been too.

Please feel free to requote me if you feel that upset by my words, but it upsets some people whose wounds haven't completely healed yet, hence my original post was removed. I accept that and shouldn't you too?

Pumperthepumper · 23/12/2021 18:52

@TheHateIsNotGood

I'll leave you all to it again, I haven't bothered to go back through my posts to see which ones were deleted but i can guess which ones they were - and it wasn't "bile" i just moved into discussing the basics in, what are still. 'sensitive' areas for discussion. And I accept that.

I plan to read all the policy, changes, etc inc the small print in regards to changes to agricultural subsidies in the UK, Over xmas, so it might take me some time. Hopefully others here will do the same before they post before 'knowledge' - I accept that I did.

Ho,ho,ho, and all that kind of thing

It was bile, it’s still there because I quoted it.
Peregrina · 23/12/2021 18:48

Total garbage about NI too, the GFA was always a major part of Brexit discussions.

Absolutely, and for me the thing which swung my vote. It was a huge achievement by Major and Blair, and one I thought impossible.

TheHateIsNotGood · 23/12/2021 18:46

I'll leave you all to it again, I haven't bothered to go back through my posts to see which ones were deleted but i can guess which ones they were - and it wasn't "bile" i just moved into discussing the basics in, what are still. 'sensitive' areas for discussion. And I accept that.

I plan to read all the policy, changes, etc inc the small print in regards to changes to agricultural subsidies in the UK, Over xmas, so it might take me some time. Hopefully others here will do the same before they post before 'knowledge' - I accept that I did.

Ho,ho,ho, and all that kind of thing

Pumperthepumper · 23/12/2021 17:57

@FrippEnos

I doubt it, but them the remain campaign could have made so much more of it, and most of the remainers that I know cared more about their cheap holidays than NI.
Did they care more about NI or stopping immigrants coming in?
FrippEnos · 23/12/2021 17:56

I doubt it, but them the remain campaign could have made so much more of it, and most of the remainers that I know cared more about their cheap holidays than NI.

Pumperthepumper · 23/12/2021 17:52

@FrippEnos

Pumperthepumper

Not everyone who voted leave was a racist but every racist voted leave and all that.

and yet some remainers voted remain for cheap labour not for love of different cultures.

Total garbage about NI too, the GFA was always a major part of Brexit discussions.

You remember it one way I remember it another. But then maybe it was over shadowed by the name calling.

Were there many leave voters concerned with NI do you think?
FrippEnos · 23/12/2021 17:49

Pumperthepumper

Not everyone who voted leave was a racist but every racist voted leave and all that.

and yet some remainers voted remain for cheap labour not for love of different cultures.

Total garbage about NI too, the GFA was always a major part of Brexit discussions.

You remember it one way I remember it another. But then maybe it was over shadowed by the name calling.

Pumperthepumper · 23/12/2021 17:29

@FrippEnos

Eleganz

The referendum was lost due to a well funded misinformation campaign and emotional appeals to latent nationalism as well as rampant entryism into the Tory party (that has only got worse since) as well as an exceptionally poor remain campaign run by people who weren't prepared to truly explain the benefits of EU membership.

For the remain campaign you forgot apathy and general name calling (thick, racist etc.) its always a good way to get people to vote for you. (also that the remain campaign said very little about NI although some now claim otherwise)

Also the mad racism and xenophobia of the leave campaign. Not everyone who voted leave was a racist but every racist voted leave and all that.

Total garbage about NI too, the GFA was always a major part of Brexit discussions. So much so that @TheHateIsNotGood is still getting bile deleted all these years later.

OneRuleForThem · 23/12/2021 17:27

@Eleganz
My anecdotal stories are examples of what people experienced up and down the country following the Brexit referendum. The result emboldened xenophobes to take these actions that did not occur before. The police statistics are clear that there was a spike in hate related incidents following the referendum.

I thought my point was clear but perhaps not. It was that we all have anecdotal stories, we all have our own lives and tribulations, we all have things that happen to us that others don’t (or can’t) understand. My gay friends (and I) up and down the country have faced anti-gay abuse from EU nationals. Some of my non-white friends (and I) up and down the country have faced racist abuse from EU nationals. These incidents have been specifically from mostly citizens hailing from EU countries that doesn’t have an outlook on both of these things that we have here in the UK. I’m sure if we looked into police stats we would also see stats rising in accordance to the number of people from EU countries coming into this one.

And your point appears to be? That all EU citizens are homophobes?

And your point appears to be? That all UK citizens are violent anti-EU xenophobes? It’s easy to level blanket accusations at groups that aren’t truth. No, I’m not saying that all EU citizens are racist homophobes, far from it, but that doesn’t take anything away or make it any less real to what has happened over the many years to me and my friends subject from a certain criteria. It’s not all one side good, one side bad. Far, far from it.

JuergenSchwarzwald · 23/12/2021 17:20

@jcyclops

The UK farming and fishing industries have been constantly complaining before we joined the EEC, during our membership, and since we left.

Plus ça change.

I don't know what it is about fishing, the French never stop moaning about it, either.
derxa · 23/12/2021 17:19

@TheHateIsNotGood

Hi derxa, nearly mentioned you in my post as you're a MNer that knows, even if you post '.'

When you say "farming subsidies are devolved" do you mean, within the UK nations, or as a ref to the NZ method?

Not sure why I'm asking as I should really look it up. There's an idea everybody, we should really look stuff up ourselves and read through all the small fine print before we comment on 'farming' shouldn't we.

Thanks dx of the .

Well I should be better informed about subsidies than I am. Yes farm payments are devolved I get a Single Farm Payment via the Scottish Govt. according to their criteria In the future we will likely have to prove that we are using our land in a more environmentally friendly way so planting more hedges and the like. www.cbd.int/doc/case-studies/inc/cs-inc-newzealand-technical-en.pdf#:~:text=The%20economy%20of%20New%20Zealand%20has%20historically%20been,than%20the%20costs%20of%20producing%20and%20processing%20it. Above is an interesting summary of what happened in New Zealand. Yes people on here use 'farmers' on here for their arguments knowing nothing about us. People like George Monbiot and James O'Brien are worse.