Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It's reasonable to spend just Christmas Day with in laws, right ?

37 replies

toiletbrushlover · 22/12/2021 10:51

We've had our original plans cancelled potentially due to travel difficulties and will be staying home most probably.

The same happened last year.

Usually when in the UK we travel to in-laws house on Christmas Eve and stay until Boxing Day. This was due to the fact of having a little baby and living over an hour away and it was just easier. We were left no choice but to do that last year.

Now we've moved, so we are 10 mins from in laws, so it's absolutely not necessary to stay over.

So I suggested we just go on Christmas Day for lunch and that's it. I also want to start my own traditions with my own family.

The relationship is not the best, well, in fact, it entirely toxic. So the less time spent, the better I think.

They may get upset, but I think it's entirely normal ? If we lived near my parents we would also only go there or have them over for one of the days, rather than the entire period. It's just less stress that way.

What does everyone else do ? Do you have to spend both days with them ? Are we being rude ? I'm afraid it might kick off because of this.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Mischance · 22/12/2021 16:25

I live 20 minutes from my DD, and at Christmas I do stay over on Christmas Eve and on Christmas Day. This is because I am not mad about driving at night and they are entirely happy for me to stay, indeed insist that I should - partly, I think, because I am quite good at entertaining the children while she gets on with other stuff!!

Another local DD and children come over for lunch too, so it is a jolly occasion.

My OH died last year so I think that we all like to be there for each other, as my DDs are still very sad about his loss. They are very clear that they do not want me to be on my own over Christmas; although the arrangement we have now existed before OH died.

MinnieMountain · 22/12/2021 13:37

MIL spends Christmas with us every other year. She also lives 10 minutes away. She comes in time for breakfast on Christmas Day, stays the night then goes home.

I’d say a similar idea with you staying at theirs would be perfectly reasonable if they’re concerned about family time.

SallyWD · 22/12/2021 12:39

Of course it's fine, why would you stay over if you live 10 minutes away? Especially if the relationship is toxic!

Hemingwayscatz · 22/12/2021 12:38

Spend Christmas however you want, don’t feel obliged to drag yourself through hell to please others. It should be a happy time, not a miserable one.

Fairyliz · 22/12/2021 12:34

I would find it odd to stay over with people who lived this close unless we all wanted to drink and it was too far to walk home.

toiletbrushlover · 22/12/2021 12:32

@HappyAsASandboy

If they're 10 mins away and you have small children I would set up a new tradition;

Breakfast and presents at home
Over to MIL for lunch
DH and FIL wash up while MIL and you play with the kids (assuming MIL made lunch! Switch MIL and FIL if FIL cooks!)
Home for the late afternoon/evening

That would be my perfect Christmas - loads of time with my kids because no cooking, but get stockings and evening at home!

Hahah great idea.

I'll get away with not helping this year because I'm pregnant, but otherwise I need to chip in Smile

Hopefully we can just alternate things like usual from next year. One year with my family and one year with in laws. That would be the most balanced scenario.

OP posts:
Doggydoodah123 · 22/12/2021 12:31

I think visiting them for just Christmas day is fine. Enjoy making traditions with your own little family and don't feel guilty for it. Since getting married I haven't spent one Christmas with my inlaws and that's just the way I like it. I suffer with anxiety and find visiting my husbands family stressful and uncomfortable and I'd never ever even consider hosting. I actually have a very pleasant relationship with my inlaws despite all this and they trot off to my bil and his wife every year for Christmas which is where they prefer anyway. Win win.

HappyAsASandboy · 22/12/2021 12:20

If they're 10 mins away and you have small children I would set up a new tradition;

Breakfast and presents at home
Over to MIL for lunch
DH and FIL wash up while MIL and you play with the kids (assuming MIL made lunch! Switch MIL and FIL if FIL cooks!)
Home for the late afternoon/evening

That would be my perfect Christmas - loads of time with my kids because no cooking, but get stockings and evening at home!

toiletbrushlover · 22/12/2021 11:52

@GiltEdges

They've expressed they want to see us on both days. When I said, we will just come on Christmas Day for lunch.

In that case, their expectations aren't reasonable. Stick to your guns.

Yeah I think it's OK. They'll just have to get used to it. Hopefully it doesn't cause an argument. It very possibly could. As they expect A LOT of family time. They don't respect that we have our own family. They see us as an extension of theirs, which is a bit of a problem. Anyhow, here's hoping for the best.
OP posts:
GiltEdges · 22/12/2021 11:48

They've expressed they want to see us on both days. When I said, we will just come on Christmas Day for lunch.

In that case, their expectations aren't reasonable. Stick to your guns.

toiletbrushlover · 22/12/2021 11:44

@GiltEdges

They're getting to see us at the last minute. All I've said is, that now we live close by, we don't need to also be with them for three days and I would like to just see them for lunch on Christmas Day.

But have they actually expressed they were expecting you to be there for 3 days? Surely they understand the difference between what you had to do when you lived further away and what's appropriate now you live round the corner?

They've expressed they want to see us on both days. When I said, we will just come on Christmas Day for lunch.
OP posts:
strawberrymilk7 · 22/12/2021 11:43

I think it would be "normal" for you not to stay. I would think staying over would only happened if you lived far away. Growing up we always had Christmas day at home with some evening visitors. My mam would go visiting too as by that point some siblings had moved out/ had their own families

GiltEdges · 22/12/2021 11:41

They're getting to see us at the last minute. All I've said is, that now we live close by, we don't need to also be with them for three days and I would like to just see them for lunch on Christmas Day.

But have they actually expressed they were expecting you to be there for 3 days? Surely they understand the difference between what you had to do when you lived further away and what's appropriate now you live round the corner?

toiletbrushlover · 22/12/2021 11:38

@Kinko

It's entirely reasonable but you've left it a bit late to communicate it. I know my Mum and MIL would both be hacked off if the expectation was that we were staying and we said we weren't today/tomorrow - no matter how close we lived.

Beds would have already been made, towels cleaned and the excitement would have built - so it would feel much more like a crushing disappointment and anger that they went to all that effort. If you'd stated it at the time of the invite it would be fine.

But perhaps your in-laws left inviting you until the last minute?

Not saying you have to stay just consider how to manage the disappointment and brace yourself for it and if it comes understand that it is your fault - so you need to hold your hands up and say, I'm really sorry your disappointed, we left the decision late and should have communicated it sooner, I do apologies for that. Hopefully it amounts to only a grumble but you need to appreciate your lost your right to be indignant about a grumble. If that makes sense?

At the same time though, not the crime of the century! So don't let them string you out for it!

This isn't what happened at all.

We were supposed to be going away - we can't, due to travel restrictions.

In laws weren't expecting to see us this year whatsoever.

Sorry if I didn't express myself clearly.

But yes, if the scenario you explain was actually happening, it would be pretty disappointing for us to just cancel at the last minute.

It's the opposite. They're getting to see us at the last minute. All I've said is, that now we live close by, we don't need to also be with them for three days and I would like to just see them for lunch on Christmas Day.

OP posts:
GrannytoaUnicorn · 22/12/2021 11:34

@HoardingSamphireSaurus

Nope, that seems fine to me.

Stop borrowing trouble and remember you are a grown up now. Enjoy your new traditions ☺️

Borrowing trouble? That's hurting my head slightly. What do you mean?!
Kinko · 22/12/2021 11:31

It's entirely reasonable but you've left it a bit late to communicate it. I know my Mum and MIL would both be hacked off if the expectation was that we were staying and we said we weren't today/tomorrow - no matter how close we lived.

Beds would have already been made, towels cleaned and the excitement would have built - so it would feel much more like a crushing disappointment and anger that they went to all that effort. If you'd stated it at the time of the invite it would be fine.

But perhaps your in-laws left inviting you until the last minute?

Not saying you have to stay just consider how to manage the disappointment and brace yourself for it and if it comes understand that it is your fault - so you need to hold your hands up and say, I'm really sorry your disappointed, we left the decision late and should have communicated it sooner, I do apologies for that. Hopefully it amounts to only a grumble but you need to appreciate your lost your right to be indignant about a grumble. If that makes sense?

At the same time though, not the crime of the century! So don't let them string you out for it!

Alieninmybody · 22/12/2021 11:22

You don't need to show your faces but if you do want to it doesn't need to involve staying for dinner.
You could invite them to yours for a short visit either.

You are an adult, why should their desires trump yours? Why do you care about them kicking off, they don't care about your feelings from the sound of it, so why are you allowing their desire to matter more than yours.

MsJaneAusten · 22/12/2021 11:20

Oh man, in that case, no. Definitely not. Pop round for an hour after lunch. There’s no need to do more than that.

sofakingcool · 22/12/2021 11:15

Based on my own experience, please do what you are planning

We started the tradition of staying at my parents Christmas Eve - Boxing Day when our sons were little. Now the eldest is 18 and I'm sad (and pissed off with myself) that we've not had one Christmas how we would like it.

Don't get me wrong, my parents are nice, but they are very set in their ways - no opening presents unless in day clothes, limited extra treats (biscuits/cakes etc). I would have liked christmases that were relaxed and fun, and now feel I've missed my chance with my own children.

The funny thing is, that we rarely spent Christmas with my grandparents! So it's not even as if we are carrying on that tradition.

I really wish now we'd implemented a alternate Christmas etc, but we didn't and now if we try and change we get guilt tripped Sad

toiletbrushlover · 22/12/2021 11:11

@MsJaneAusten

Totally normal to just go for dinner (or not at all!)

Changing the plans so near to Christmas could be rude though.

We didn't have plans with them. Our plans were to go away. I would be happy not to see them at all. That would be my idea Christmas. But seeing as we are staying, we need to show our faces.
OP posts:
abigailsnan · 22/12/2021 11:10

From a MILs point of view I would welcome my ACs & DGCs for a couple of hours and expect them to return home to carry on their own celebrations & make their own traditions even if they can't make the actual day I would never put up a fuss its their life and I would never interfere demanding they stay over !! thats why I bought a one bed bungalow so no one can stay.

MsJaneAusten · 22/12/2021 11:08

Totally normal to just go for dinner (or not at all!)

Changing the plans so near to Christmas could be rude though.

Glittertwins · 22/12/2021 11:06

Totally normal to do your own thing. We never had extended family over at Christmas growing up so we're quite happy. We're also quite happy having my parents over for a few days as the DCs can still have their new stuff without trekking up and down the motorways too.
The sense of duty is probably the main driver of Christmas arguments - do your own thing. Pop over for a drink / presents for baby and then go home and relax

Dozer · 22/12/2021 11:06

You don’t have a good relationship, so it’s not a given you see them on Xmas day at all! Your plans sound fine.

toiletbrushlover · 22/12/2021 11:05

When I was younger I would always spend the entire period with my parents and brother and then one year when he moved closer to my parents and had a girlfriend, they started spending Christmas Eve alone.

I was left with just my parents, but we all just accepted it as normal that they wanted to cook their own food and create their own traditions.

Now I think we should start doing the same here with our child/ children. Hopefully they'll understand and it won't ruin Christmas.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread