Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why would you pretend to be poor?

188 replies

Sndhehjzugwvs · 22/12/2021 10:14

Someone recently disclosed to us their annual income. This was done very intentionally to make a point that they were struggling financially... This worried and concerned us.

We have been head scratching as to why they told us this because they absolutely know we do not have spare funds given our income.

Fast forward a couple of months and we find out that they have released very high six figure sum towards a business venture.

Why do some people play the poverty card when they are clearly anything but poor? Sadly, I bet we are not alone in knowing people like this.

We cannot fathom the reason for this disclosure. To be honest, we found it a bit sickening given the concern it caused us when in fact they are clearly more than ok financially. It is true: there is nowt so strange as folk!

We have some family members who are genuinely struggling financially and this false plea of poverty is just horrible when we know the reality of people who ARE struggling.

Why on earth do people not think before causing others unnecessary worry!

Wishing all a peaceful Christmas and a lighter, smile-filled 2022.

OP posts:
Buytoomuchonebay · 22/12/2021 12:35

Growing up my parents claimed we where poor-they’d bought an ex council house but had no money left over

I was shunted off to live with my grandad as they couldn’t pay care fees

(I adored living with him) but we had very little to live on and very little luxuries

We grew up and it turns out my parents had been squirrelling away large chunks of money as they didn’t want to ‘waste it on the kids’ or ‘him’ (meaning my granddad)

We had everything second hand/free food/shoes with holes in them,no proper winter coat/gloves unless she could get one free for us etc

They where comfortable to say the least-looking back my mother always had money for what she wanted

They now use it to lord over my brothers/grandchildrens heads

‘Do/don’t do that or we’ll cut you out of our wills and you won’t see a penny’ (I got cut out years ago)

They’ll proudly tell you how poor they are-even though they have eye watering amounts put away behind the scene’s-it’s like it’s out of sight so out of mind

ScaredOfOverDiagnosis · 22/12/2021 12:22

I know someone that earns £130k, I let her boast, I earn more than her but I let her believe she's this big thing.
It's not worth the hassle, you look like an idoit talking about money and your wealth.
People are jealous. People use you. Modest lives are easier or the perception of modest lives.

user1471554720 · 22/12/2021 12:18

People pretend to be poor as they don't want others judging them or being jealous. I have a very ordinary job and background. I studied by night to get a better quality job. As far as acquaintances/in laws are concerned, I work on an office.

I didn't really spend on drinking and smoking when younger. I still went out and went on hols, albeit cheaply. Now, at 50, I own a second property, have over a 6 figure sum in savings, while still leading an ordinary life. I am not into fashion or nails. If colleagues or friends knew how much savings I had, they would judge me as being mean. However, I find false nails/eyelashes uncomfortable, have no interest in fashion/nights out. I like a dinner out but working, dealing with dcs mean I rarely have energy or get free time to go places I like foreign hols city breaks but dh is not keen. I find sun hols boring.

Contactmap · 22/12/2021 12:14

We have been head scratching as to why they told us this because they absolutely know we do not have spare funds given our income.
So you told them about your low income but can't imagine why they told you about their low income ? I can imagine...

romdowa · 22/12/2021 12:13

I lived with a girl in college like this. When used to beg food , toiletries etc off the whole house because she claimed she had no money and wasn't entitled to a grant because she was repeating a year. At the end of our exams she flew off for a 3 week holiday in Jamaica with her sisters 😡😡 some people just use the pity card to take advantage.

LaBellina · 22/12/2021 12:10

The only time I have ever pretended to be poor was when a pisstaker, now ex friend, tried to borrow money from me. Other then that I see no reason to lie but maybe in your case they had already reserved money for their big investment?

OneRingToRuleThemAll · 22/12/2021 12:09

People treat you differently when they think you have money. In a recent group chat I disclosed that I have no unsecured debt, it made people think I'm loaded. That is far from the case, but people do make assumptions.

mclaw · 22/12/2021 12:09

When she moans I just tell her to downsize or release equity.

mclaw · 22/12/2021 12:07

Obviously income is different to wealth but a low income doesn't mean you are struggling financially. One of my relatives pleads poverty on their income but overlooks their mortgage free 2m house & their 6 months abroad in their holiday home.

fourminutestosavetheworld · 22/12/2021 12:00

Why don't you ask them then?

You have obviously decided that they have lied for nefarious reasons.

Rather than let this fester, why not ask them why they told you they were struggling financially whilst investing significant sums.

I maintain it is possible to be on a modest income as you don't want to dip into investments that are earmarked for pensions or other things.

CharSiu · 22/12/2021 12:00

How did the conversation arrive to become a disclosure made about income?

I never discuss my financial status, it is however bad to lie about it. I would just say I don’t talk about finances if directly asked. The reason I don’t share my status at all is I do not want to be asked for a loan. Plus the fitting in thing is true. There is much chatter about how will the kids be able to afford their own homes amongst my peer group. I just agree that house prices are out of control which is true and say yes I will help DS out somehow which a lot of my friends aIso intend to do. I don’t tell them that I will buy DS a house outright. DH and I are not telling DS yet either.

Icenii · 22/12/2021 11:59

Because people hate well off people.

Youdoyoutoday · 22/12/2021 11:58

@ChiefWiggumsBoy explains it best, the 2 different financial positions are not comparable.

Also there is probably the 'woe is me' aspect of it, folks love being a martyr for some reason!

Sndhehjzugwvs · 22/12/2021 11:56

@fourminutestosavetheworld. Nope. Have other income sources.

OP posts:
Sndhehjzugwvs · 22/12/2021 11:55

@Merryoldgoat

They didn’t tell us about the investment.

OP posts:
Sndhehjzugwvs · 22/12/2021 11:51

@ChiefWiggumsBoy thank you! Could not agree more.

And thanks to all for your insights and observations.

It is stomach churning to have genuine financial concerns. Been there…

It is an insult to those who are struggling to say, pity us when in fact, they are thankfully very much more than ok.

I have a family member in genuine need who I wish I could help in a meaningful way. To compare and contrast their respective situations is a real eye opener. I have never once heard my family member plead poverty.

Anyway, we shall never get to the bottom of this behaviour which is probably for the best!

To all who are struggling with health and/or financial issues, here’s to a healthy and prosperous New Year. Xx

OP posts:
Pigeoninthehouse · 22/12/2021 11:49

I agree with pp it's because they're tight.
Used to work with woman like that, one of the higher earners in business, but would always plead poverty when asked for contributions towards whip rounds, or on work social events. But bought fancy cars outright for cash and other large purchases.
Her choice how she spends her money, but she expected other people to sub her choices.

fourminutestosavetheworld · 22/12/2021 11:46

Are they living off invested income? In which case it is entirely possible to receive a modest income as you need the reserves to last your lifetime, and interest is very low on investments at present too.

That would not prevent them from releasing a lump sum to invest if they thought it would provide a similar return.

Ultimately, you've jumped to conclusions and assumed the worst.

Merryoldgoat · 22/12/2021 11:39

Why wouldn’t you ask them? If someone was close enough to me disclose such personal information I’d be able to say ‘what? You told us you were broke last week - what’s going on?’

But I accept I might be an outlier…

WowIlikereallyhateyou · 22/12/2021 11:30

I prefer people to think i am doing just about ok. I have a thriving business, and we jointly have a very high income,but I certainly wouldnt want my customers knowing that. I wouldn’t want to alienate anyone for sure.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 22/12/2021 11:25

@MrsLarry

Maybe you should read the first line of the OP again. These people are making it OP’s business.

I hate this type of person, and the type of person that justifies it even more.

“Capital is different to income”

Yes I think we all know this. But how dare a person who makes a choice to not liquidate assets compare themselves to a person living in literal poverty? The single mum who struggles to heat the house and feed the kids isn’t the same as the couple who made a choice to invest 80% of their income and now find themselves short of pennies at the end of the month.

It is crass. There was a person on a thread recently insisting that her and her husband who earned the better part of £200k a year were just existing - later posts she admitted she’s putting the max into pensions and other investments. Quite easy to change those things. But poor people can’t cut back anywhere to improve quality of life

Sndhehjzugwvs · 22/12/2021 11:23

It wouldn’t have anything to do with us but for the fact we were specifically told their income.

To the question of why telling us the figure would cause worry and concern: the figure is very low: the mere fact of telling us this is our income got us worried as we had rather assumed their income was more and whilst we expected that they did have an amount of capital, we are flabbergasted at how much capital they were able to release from existing resources. Mentioning the income in the way they did had the implication: help we are struggling. As we have no spare funds, this caused us anxiety. Nobody likes to think of people struggling.

I guess my point is that we were wondering what on earth we could do to help them given the apparently parlous state of their finances when it is obvious that they were anything but parlous. We are so glad they are ok: should have made that clear but we do wonder why they were at pains to tell us their income when it is and never has been any of our business?

It is all a bit strange since they have always been very close mouthed re finances.

OP posts:
MrsLarry · 22/12/2021 11:08

Maybe because none of it has anything to do with you. Lots of people in business seem like they have a lot of money, but in fact they're not actually cash rich.

Canigooutyet · 22/12/2021 10:33

I down play my financial worth. Learned a long time ago that people enjoy spending your money.
If I see people are genuinely struggling, not just saying so, I help out.

Businesses venture money could have come from anywhere in the months since you last spoke. Inheritance, loan, lottery win, gambling, someone else repaying a loan etc.

Orreries · 22/12/2021 10:29

@Aprilx

Their annual income and whether they have any capital are two completely separate things though. Confused

I don’t know why they would tell you their income anyway, but a low annual income does not mean that they don’t have capital.

This.

And also, OP, they presumably didn't realise they were causing you such 'unnecessary worry' and 'concern' -- I can't imagine that most people would think that their income would cause anyone else such a strong reaction.