Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why would you pretend to be poor?

188 replies

Sndhehjzugwvs · 22/12/2021 10:14

Someone recently disclosed to us their annual income. This was done very intentionally to make a point that they were struggling financially... This worried and concerned us.

We have been head scratching as to why they told us this because they absolutely know we do not have spare funds given our income.

Fast forward a couple of months and we find out that they have released very high six figure sum towards a business venture.

Why do some people play the poverty card when they are clearly anything but poor? Sadly, I bet we are not alone in knowing people like this.

We cannot fathom the reason for this disclosure. To be honest, we found it a bit sickening given the concern it caused us when in fact they are clearly more than ok financially. It is true: there is nowt so strange as folk!

We have some family members who are genuinely struggling financially and this false plea of poverty is just horrible when we know the reality of people who ARE struggling.

Why on earth do people not think before causing others unnecessary worry!

Wishing all a peaceful Christmas and a lighter, smile-filled 2022.

OP posts:
Sndhehjzugwvs · 22/12/2021 17:07

Gosh what a lot of replies. Thank you. Am working my way through catching up. They have released funds from investments apparently. Not investing in a business they run. And to those who have doubted how concerned we were about their financial position, you are just plain wrong.

OP posts:
EyesAsGreenAsAFreshPickledToad · 22/12/2021 17:00

I thought this thread was going to be about that time multi millionaire Xenia got caught larping as a poor person 😂

WowIlikereallyhateyou · 22/12/2021 16:58

DrSbaitso , my business is in healthcare. I wouldn’t want to alienate people and I think there is a difference between looking confidently professional and being seen to show off, for example i visit people in their homes and have a new, quality car,but not showy. I had a loan vehicle once, which was high end, and was immediately asked by some about its cost. Some people see it as doing well, some sadly view it negatively. You can’t win them all, so better to go with the middle ground in my opinion.

OnGoldenPond · 22/12/2021 16:18

Possibly they are funding this business venture with a specific loan which can only be spent on the activity specified in their application? The funds would certainly not be available for day to day spending and they have possibly added every penny of their savings towards getting this venture off the ground.

CouncilHousedAndViolentBaby · 22/12/2021 16:15

@middleager

Jarvis Cocker said it best: "because you think that poor is cool."

Some people with decent incomes - and I see it on here all the time - like to plead poverty when they are comfortably off! Maybe to fit in/pretend they are "one of us."

This
DrSbaitso · 22/12/2021 16:14

@WowIlikereallyhateyou

I prefer people to think i am doing just about ok. I have a thriving business, and we jointly have a very high income,but I certainly wouldnt want my customers knowing that. I wouldn’t want to alienate anyone for sure.
May I ask what the business is? I would have thought customers would feel reassured that they're dealing with a business that's doing well, but I guess there might be some exceptions.
DrSbaitso · 22/12/2021 16:10

Context really matters.

Supersimkin2 · 22/12/2021 16:10

Mean and/or greedy.

Either way, it’s your wallet they’re most interested in.

oftenbaffled · 22/12/2021 16:03

If you didn't doubt them originally when they said their low income

Presumably... they drive an old banger, never holiday, never spend on jewellery and treats etc

So it supports idea they released equity in an attempt to incresase their income

oftenbaffled · 22/12/2021 15:58

What about this scenario
Very common

Property rich i.e substantial equity due to low property prices years ago
low income

So they could have been absolutely correct. The did have a low income. They then released the equity in order to start a business venture, presumably in an attempt to increase their income.

I highly doubt you were very worried about them, given you starting this thread

MintJulia · 22/12/2021 15:37

I was taught not to discuss income with anyone except my boss and the tax man. Bad manners. Certainly not family since it comes across either as boasting or a begging bowl.

I'm as vague as possible with new friends too.

But remember people's perception and reference points are different. I think I am comfortable. My SIL would regard me as poor if she knew. Everyone's idea of wealth is different.

Suzanne999 · 22/12/2021 15:31

@Shiningpath

Income is different from capital.
Exactly. I have a small income & I’m happy with that. Would look paltry to many but my outgoings are low. Capital ( proceeds of business sale, bigger house sale after DH died) is squirrelled away for grandchildren or any emergencies in my life or DDs and families.
Alarmset · 22/12/2021 15:29

No one I know realised how comfortably off I am. They know I have a decent job and can probably guess at the salary, but I bet they don't realised how high it is and they definitely don't know that my mortgage is paid off and I have substantial investments.

It's not that I'm pretending to be poor and incertianly don't want anything from anyone, I keep it to myself because it's none of their business, but also because many of my circle aren't as sorted and I don't want to make anyone feel uncomfortable.

mumda · 22/12/2021 15:08

What do they mean "released"?
If they've borrowed money then that's not the same as being rich.

Borrowing money for a business venture off a residential property is never IMO a good move.

Floogal · 22/12/2021 14:48

Most likely to fit in, especially with students.
Also, was an article about it, many people including actors like to exaggerate or lie about their working class-ness to make it look like they've earned their success on their own.

Personally, from past experience, it's better not to talk about money. 1. If you haven't got much, it's can be embarrassing. 2. If you haven't got much, people may accuse you of trying to milk sympathy. 3. If you have it, you don't want people knowing incase they beg or try to steal from you.

wetpebbles · 22/12/2021 14:27

Most of the wealthier people I know are tight wads

caringcarer · 22/12/2021 14:14

Maybe they were embarrassed they had so.much more than you do. It is weird behaviour though.

Magnited · 22/12/2021 14:04

Fast forward a couple of months and we find out that they have released very high six figure sum towards a business venture.

Perhaps this £750K or so is not personal money? Perhaps it is company money and is there for the proper conduct of the business and not to be drawn out willy nilly. Creditors, suppliers, HMRC and investors have the right to be fully protected and not at the vagaries of a Maxwell-like business owner treating their company like a personal fiefdom.

2bazookas · 22/12/2021 13:36

Con men will stoop to anything. They have no limits. Now you know.

You've learned a valuable lesson about them, at no costs to yourselves.

Hillarious · 22/12/2021 13:22

i get this a lot in the student finance setting I work in where some students on full loans and bursaries are from anything but a poor background. Annual/Household income is a blunt tool for measuring someone's financial need.

equuscaballus · 22/12/2021 13:16

Low income doesn't mean they've never had a high income.

It doesn't mean that they have no savings.

Its possible to have a low earning potential and inherit cash. It doesn't mean they're irresponsible with money.

It sounds to me that these people live within their income and protect their savings from being eaten into.

RoyalFamilyFan · 22/12/2021 13:11

@Aprilx

Their annual income and whether they have any capital are two completely separate things though. Confused

I don’t know why they would tell you their income anyway, but a low annual income does not mean that they don’t have capital.

That is true. But if I had a low annual income, but loads of savings or capital, I wouldn't make out I was poor.
LadyCampanulaTottington · 22/12/2021 12:48

Going by the reactions to high earners and wealthy people on here I can’t blame people for pretending.

We play down our wealth to friends and family because I know we would be treated differently. When anyone asks how my business is going I say fine. It’s easier.

30kperannum · 22/12/2021 12:46

@Icenii

Because people hate well off people.
This, essentially.

In my last job, I was subjected to jibes and sneers from some colleagues, mainly about how I didn't need to work, I could afford to be a SAHM, I didn't need to budget, I was taking up a job someone else could have had etc etc because DH had a high income. Hmm

What about me having worked very hard to get where I was, and wanting to work?

They also had no idea about DH's serious illness and disability, and how many years he earned absolutely nothing as he was so ill, they just saw his job title and made assumptions.

People where I work now have no idea he outearns the CEO - when he can work, but it's not constant or consistent.

TheXmasSkyRemote · 22/12/2021 12:41

Usually where I live, income is undeclared so people can claim more/pay less tax.

I know about three people in my street alone who are making false benefit claims. Mainly relating to partners who don't exist but are staying over every night.