Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why would you pretend to be poor?

188 replies

Sndhehjzugwvs · 22/12/2021 10:14

Someone recently disclosed to us their annual income. This was done very intentionally to make a point that they were struggling financially... This worried and concerned us.

We have been head scratching as to why they told us this because they absolutely know we do not have spare funds given our income.

Fast forward a couple of months and we find out that they have released very high six figure sum towards a business venture.

Why do some people play the poverty card when they are clearly anything but poor? Sadly, I bet we are not alone in knowing people like this.

We cannot fathom the reason for this disclosure. To be honest, we found it a bit sickening given the concern it caused us when in fact they are clearly more than ok financially. It is true: there is nowt so strange as folk!

We have some family members who are genuinely struggling financially and this false plea of poverty is just horrible when we know the reality of people who ARE struggling.

Why on earth do people not think before causing others unnecessary worry!

Wishing all a peaceful Christmas and a lighter, smile-filled 2022.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
annatwink · 31/12/2021 04:35

@Shiningpath

Income is different from capital.
😂😂Only someone comfortably off could say that. Even a home gives you access to money if you're desperate. And you can get desperate, even in this country. For example, cash to pay for cancer treatment not available here.
Sndhehjzugwvs · 24/12/2021 16:31

Hi all,

Did a reply earlier and lost it when internet dipped briefly.

The funds in question have come from investments. Not a loan. Not a re-mortgage.

Anyway, I’m going to focus on the people I love. Real people. Not actors playing the pity me card!!!🤣🤣

Ho, ho, ho and Merry Xmas to you all! 🎄🎄🍷🍷🍷🎄🎄

OP posts:
gunnersgold · 24/12/2021 16:07

I work in retail and my dh is a very high earner , I do it to keep busy and pretend to be the same as everyone else because I don't want them to hate me ! 🤷‍♀️.. I mean I don't lie but for example I would never disclose our lifestyle is different to theirs .

BigBamBoom · 24/12/2021 15:59

May I take a guess, as the OP isn't providing details?

These must be family or pretty close friends for the OP to be so concerned at them struggling. OP is not well off. Friends/whoever are planning a large business investment and realise this will look bad to OP, maybe hurt their feelings at being out of the loop, so they drop into conversation the fact that they're not swimming in money at the moment. Both things are actually quite likely to be true - if they're about to take on a big loan they may be being careful with their outgoings.

M1526 · 24/12/2021 15:37

It is very odd
I've had similar, not the same - in laws pleading poverty in retirement.

We helped out with some discretionary stuff.

A couple of years later DH was helpful enough to move furniture when they bought a new set. It had pay stubbs and retirement papers on the desk - turned out FIL final salary was a good 20k a year more than DH earned, and in retirement due to the excellent pension at his employer, FIL had more net income than my DH was earning gross at that point. I bitterly regret "helping' (subsidising!) From our income for those 2 years of pleading pension poverty. Especially when I'll never have the luxury of SAH like mil did after being in the workforce for about 5 year'ls then giving up working entirely to focus on kids. We're the idiots.

oftenbaffled · 24/12/2021 15:30

@Crunchymum

Haven't RTFT but surely you'd have a "ball-park" of there earnings based on profession? For example I know my BIL and SIL (banker and very senior NHS role) earn more than my BIL and SIL who are postal worker and part time admin in school.

I've used very polarised examples but it would be very unusual for an investment banker to be on £20k or a postal worker to be on £100k a year.

And also their lifestyle Of which the Op makes no reference to at all and has not answered So presuming it fit in with the “low income”
Crunchymum · 24/12/2021 14:46
  • their
Crunchymum · 24/12/2021 14:46

Haven't RTFT but surely you'd have a "ball-park" of there earnings based on profession? For example I know my BIL and SIL (banker and very senior NHS role) earn more than my BIL and SIL who are postal worker and part time admin in school.

I've used very polarised examples but it would be very unusual for an investment banker to be on £20k or a postal worker to be on £100k a year.

oftenbaffled · 24/12/2021 14:37

@Snog

Only rich people draw a distinction between income and capital, because poor people only have income. Many people never own capital in their entire lives.
This is a really insightful post I agree
Snog · 24/12/2021 13:31

Only rich people draw a distinction between income and capital, because poor people only have income. Many people never own capital in their entire lives.

JellyOnAPlatewithicecream · 24/12/2021 12:56

But did they actually say they were under financial strain, or was that just assumed?

RoyalFamilyFan · 24/12/2021 09:41

Of course, it is lying.
X we have a really low income. We are only earning £ a month so are under financial strain.
But fails to mention the savings etc they do have - it is a lie.
Wealth is about income, savings, investments and assets.
This thread has surprised me how many people are willing to lie about not having much financially when they do. I only have 1 friend that occasionally slips into the - oh I cant afford it, when she can. I just say of course you can afford it, you might not want to spend that much money, but you can afford it.
But the outright lying the OP describes and many on here think is okay would make me avoid that person. I wonder if some on here who think having money makes people treat you differently is because they were lying to friends, and when the friends find out they treat the differently? Because this would be me. I don't care of you are very wealthy, but if I found out you had lied I would be unhappy and that would be obvious.

JellyOnAPlatewithicecream · 24/12/2021 03:05

Also telling someone you have a low income isn't pretending to be poor as such, it's just saying you have a low income. Unless they also stated that they also have no savings / investments / assets to fall back on.

JellyOnAPlatewithicecream · 24/12/2021 03:03

I'm not sure if them telling you their low income was to make you worry about them, unless they were actually saying things like we can't afford to eat / pay the rent?

Ericaequites · 24/12/2021 02:20

@ttcpatronisers I’m in a similar situation. It was better when no one nice talked about money.

RoyalFamilyFan · 24/12/2021 00:15

I think differences in money can cause issues as not everyone can afford to do the same things. But as long as you are all sensitive and willing to be flexible it is fine. The issues arise if those with money absolutely refuse for example to go anywhere except expensive restaurants.

TizerorFizz · 24/12/2021 00:12

I think you simply know who is genuine in the end. Friendship isn’t about money.,

RoyalFamilyFan · 24/12/2021 00:06

@TizerorFizz that is how it is in my friendship group.
TBH there are users of people however much money you have. I have seen those people and people on MN talk about it all the time. It is a life skill to identify and stay away from those people.

TizerorFizz · 23/12/2021 23:59

@MatildaIThink
My DH has earned serious money over the years and we decided to enjoy it. I simply don’t care if anyone thinks we are flash! We have substantial savings, several properties and very nice cars and used to have wonderful holidays, pre covid. I like my clothes and my jewellery. We have extensive savings portfolios. But…….

The key isn’t what you have. It’s what sort of person you are. We have had the same friends for 40 plus years. They clearly know we have more assets than them but that doesn’t make us awful people or not worthy of friendship! It’s all about valuing people as people, not what they have or indeed choose to hide. Who cares if you have diamond earrings or overpay the mortgage. We don’t have one! Personally I preferred the earrings but no one ever thought that was an issue regarding friendships.

RoyalFamilyFan · 23/12/2021 23:57

But why present themselves as struggling? Most people do not present themselves as struggling. It is not the norm to do that. Most people don't talk about what they earn.

Mamanyt · 23/12/2021 23:53

For me, it would entirely depend on the context. I've known some very wealthy people who presented themselves as somewhat struggling because they had been taken advantage of so often that they preferred not to have it happen again. Others who did not want to be befriended simply for status. Some had plenty of assets, but were cash poor. And a few who were just plain mean-spirited.

RoyalFamilyFan · 23/12/2021 23:52

@MatildaIThink I have zero issue with people not discussing income or wealth. It is when people lie I think there is an issue.
I think a lot of people don't really pay attention to other people anyway, they are too focused on themselves. I do pay attention. So while I don't know peoples levels of income unless they volunteer it, and I don't need to know, I can see when people are fine financially, when they are not, and when they are struggling but pretending not to. And plenty of people with money dont do conspicuous consumption. But they also rarely cut their own hair or go to the absolute cheapest hairdresser or buy ASDA clothes. And if they have money and do these things, then they are always very obviously mean.

ttcpatronisers · 23/12/2021 23:50

. Though I know that neither, my husband, my brother nor I would claim poverty, but neither would we make proclamations of our income.

Exactly this

RoyalFamilyFan · 23/12/2021 23:47

@Faretheewellmyfairyfay of course we understand this, we are not stupid. People borrow against their house and/or take on debts to secure a better future. Whether it is to start or invest in a business. or study, or move across the world. It really isn't rocket science.
But it is still a choice being able to do that.

MatildaIThink · 23/12/2021 23:42

I don't know about pretending to be poor, but most people don't know and would not be able to tell my husband and I both have six figure incomes, we both pay quite a bit into pensions and overpay our mortgage, but we are not flash, we do not engage in conspicuous consumption etc. Someone might guess we earn £100k between us but the figure is three times that. My brother earns £400-500k a year, only a few people (me, my husband, our mum and two of his friends) have any idea what he earns. Again outwardly you might think he earned good money, but he pays into pension and investments, he overpays his mortgage, but he drives a ten year old car, wears normal clothes, doesn't go on expensive holidays, or go out and be flash etc. I am sure when he moves in a year his wealth will be a bit more obvious, but he will still go down the pub with friends, wearing Levis jeans and a no brand T-shirt and no-one would have a clue.

Now the why is because being a high earner makes some other people act oddly, it encourages hangers on, some people get jealous or entitled, they treat you differently because you have a comfortable income. There is also very little need to discuss money most of the time, it would seem crass to go around telling people one was a high earner when there is no need. Though I know that neither, my husband, my brother nor I would claim poverty, but neither would we make proclamations of our income.