Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Christmas morning Covid test being demanded

859 replies

Quarks69 · 22/12/2021 08:27

Is everyone else having these? My sister in law has demanded this from my side of the family as her elderly parents are going to be at the dinner. With a family of five and three are my busy teens I am worried that we could end up with no xmas day if one of us is asymptomatic (for the second year running obvs).

I do get that we are in bonkers times, but Was so looking Forward to seeing everyone, including my parents, that this is making me cross...isn’t this the point of the jabs!?

OP posts:
TheHoptimist · 22/12/2021 09:31

@wateraddict

We are testing before we go shopping or see anyone, every time.
Before you go shopping is probably the reason there are no tests for those who actually need them. Including face to face workers
notacooldad · 22/12/2021 09:31

Seems pretty sensible to me.
Well done to SIL for having the balls to do this.

Toplowlight · 22/12/2021 09:30

If you’re happy to take LFTs twice a week anyway why on earth are you suddenly making a fuss about it now?!

Like your whole thread has been about how it’s wrong that this is being demanded, it might ruin your plans, people have too much faith in these tests… and now you want us to believe you’re testing twice weekly?!

MousesBack · 22/12/2021 09:29

You sound pretty selfish if you'd rather give Covid to an elderly person than risk your Christmas Day!
Yes, responsible people ARE testing before they meet anyone, and yes, it pays to make a back up plan and have a second Christmas meal in the freezer in case plans are disrupted, which let's face it, is not unlikely.
I am hoping to go to my parents' house, but with family members working in public facing roles right through to Christmas Eve, all bets are off as to whether it will actually happen. I've not got a turkey (don't eat meat anyway) but have enough food in the house that I could put together a nice Xmas-ish dinner for my own family, if it came to us having to stay at home at short notice - a realistic prospect.

Staryflight445 · 22/12/2021 09:29

‘ My in-laws actually are vulnerable and although we won't be seeing them on Christmas Day, I have seen them 4-5 days a week, every week since this whole thing started and none of us have ever taken a test before doing so ’

You wouldn’t have the same arrogance about this if you’d spread covid to one of them and they died.
Survivor bias does not make this ok.

SoupDragon · 22/12/2021 09:29

I am fully jabbed, wear a mask and take lfts bi-weekly.

So why on Earth are you complaining about taking a bloody test??

Lovemusic33 · 22/12/2021 09:29

We are testing before visiting anyone.

I was due to have a friend over today, he messaged to say he had a cold, he’s anti vax so obviously not vaccinated, I asked him to take a test if he wanted to come over and he refused (which is fine) so he’s no not coming.

I think it’s a fair request to make, if you don’t want to test then don’t go.

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 22/12/2021 09:29

I wouldn’t go if I had it, but am curious if everyone out there is testing.

At the moment if I am meeting anyone outside my own household indoors then yes I am testing. Doubly so if they are elderly. LFTs don't always pick up the fact that you have Covid but they do pick up when you are most likely to infect other people, with or without symptoms.

Of course I don’t want to endanger lives. I guess my issue is that we have all been jabbed. If we get it, it’s not going to endanger lives. Both sets of parents are old not vulnerable.

Old means vulnerable to Covid.

Is everyone really testing all the time?

I don't test all the time. It hasn't been necessary until very recently and I don't meet people much (sad life me!) and pre-Christmas events have been cancelled. But I have been testing regularly and since the last couple of weeks, when I'm going to meet people outside my household indoors, I test. Omicron is not funny.

Do you have any faith in the jabs?

Triple jagged is a big improvement on double (or nothing at all!) but it isn't a total guarantee. Omicron spreads very easily so the more safety measure we take the safer everyone is.

We need to do all these things to meet up reasonably safely this Christmas. Not just say "We're testing so we don't need to vaccinate" or "we're vaccinated so we don't need to test".

No, I wouldn't ask my guests to test. Vulnerable people should assess their own risk and don't join any gatherings if they are worried.

Most people wouldn't want to have to tell their own parents "sorry but if you want to come to my house for Christmas you'll have to take the risk because Bro and his family wont do tests". They would rather say "Enjoy yourselves, we've all made it as safe for you as we possibly can".

TheUndoingProject · 22/12/2021 09:28

I’m genuinely shocked a teacher is planning on deliberately not testing to avoid having to isolate. Especially when the health of elderly extended family members is at risk. How on earth would you feel if they were hospitalised because of your selfishness? Clearly you and your kids wouldn’t actually be alone if tested positive because you could celebrate Christmas as a nuclear family.

Bagamoyo1 · 22/12/2021 09:28

I don’t think it’s a big deal doing LFTs in this situation. I think lots are doing it. At least that’s all you have to do. My parents have refused to come for the planned Christmas dinner even if we have negative LFTs, as they feel the children are too high risk 🙁

EdenFlower · 22/12/2021 09:27

OP, you are very disillusioned about the effectiveness of the vaccines. Yes, they seem to prevent serious disease for most, but serious disease is classed as needing hospitalisation. People are still catching Covid, it doesn't prevent the spread, and people are still being very unwell with covid. It's not just like a common cold.

How is it such a hassle to just get the whole family to do a lateral flow? It's a 2 minute job. And as for 'busy teens' On Christmas day? Pah!

Elfonaledge · 22/12/2021 09:27

I think the jabs being like a seatbelt analogy is a good one.

I trust that I'm better protected if I crash with a seat belt than without, and that a seat belt will mean that most crashes are fairly mild health wise. However I also accept that some crashes result in death or serious ill health even if I'm wearing one.

Wearing a seat belt doesn't mean I suddenly take more risks, don't bother breaking, or deliberately crash because I know the seat belt will look after me. I'd also drive more carefully with a baby in the car or with vulnerable people!

I have the jab because I feel it offers some protection, not 100% but a good amount. However I also aknowledge that I still have to do other things to keep safe, and that it doesn't make me immune

neverbeenskiing · 22/12/2021 09:27

She can ask, not demand.

Are you joking? It's her house! She's perfectly entitled to set the rules about what happens in her home and if OP doesn't like it she's free to decline the invitation and cook her own Christmas dinner.

Those saying just lie and say you've tested negative should be ashamed of themselves. Yes, OP by all means lie to your family safe in the knowledge that if one of your "busy teens" passes covid onto an elderly relative and they end up on a ventilator or worse it was worth it so you didn't have to endure the hardship of cooking your own turkey and roast potatoes Hmm

Staryflight445 · 22/12/2021 09:27

It’s an absolute joke isn’t it @CrapDrawer
We’re down with it over Xmas thanks to parents relying on LFTs for actual symptoms (and admitting this, sending their kid into school with a headache and sore throat just because their lft was negative and they didn’t want to be inconvenienced by doing a PCR because you know, that last week at school is really exciting).

If people just stop leaving the house when unwell with symptoms/ taking LFTs and relying on the results when they have symptoms and people start to utilise the accessibility of getting a PCR done, we’d be much better off.
Don’t go to someone’s house at Xmas without doing an LFT first. Especially not if anyone has symptoms that could be COVID.
Ignorance is not bliss.
LFTS are to catch symptomless covid, they’re not 100% but don’t be a twat. It takes 15 minutes out of your day to ensure you’re protecting vulnerable people.

NovemberNovemberDarkNights · 22/12/2021 09:27

@icedcoffees

I wouldn't test nor would I ask anyone else to take one.

I've been flamed for that on here before but I don't mix with anyone vulnerable and I think we're all adults and capable of deciding whether to socialise or not. If someone had symptoms I would expect them to isolate but I wouldn't ask someone who was asymptomatic and healthy to take a test. The plastic waste is insane for one thing, and they're always accurate either.

How do you know who is vulnerable? I don't 'look' vulnerable, and IRL I don't go on about my underlying conditions which make me very vulnerable. Other peoples vulnerability isn't for you to assess.

There's a FUCKTON more plastic waste when people get very I'll with covid, so stop your daft virtual signalling.

People testing positive, even without obvious symptoms have enough viral load to pass it on to others.

Stop digging your heals in & being so selfish & careless with other peoples health.

Abraxan · 22/12/2021 09:26

People like me have been putting themselves at risk daily, to teach your children. I am fully jabbed, wear a mask and take lfts bi-weekly.

But this doesn't make sense though.

You are happy to take bi weekly LFTs to reduce risk at school, to your colleagues and pupils.

But you are aghast at the idea of taking a LFT to reduce the risk to your own family.

Why are your colleagues and pupils a higher priority to you than your family at Christmas?

wincarwoo · 22/12/2021 09:26

[quote icedcoffees]@SilverRingahBells my apologies, I didn't realise you were the thread police Wink

Vulnerable elderly relatives are also perfectly capable of deciding whether they want people to test or not before visiting, so I don't see that my comment is irrelevant.

My in-laws actually are vulnerable and although we won't be seeing them on Christmas Day, I have seen them 4-5 days a week, every week since this whole thing started and none of us have ever taken a test before doing so 🤷🏻‍♀️[/quote]
That's pretty reckless considering the virulence of omicron.

ratussbaguss · 22/12/2021 09:26

@Newjobnewstart

Just say you tested and it's negative. I'm not testing unless I have symptoms. Lfts are the most reliable anyway so u could still be positive even with a lat flow.
This is exactly the attitude that I fear some of my family members have taken. Ignorant, dangerous, selfish, the list goes on. OP, YABU
TangfasticsAreFantastic · 22/12/2021 09:25

I'm doing an LFT every day this week. I don't want to ruin Christmas if I have caught it, but I would feel even worse if I had it and transmitted it to the 10 people coming over on Xmas Day. Three are in their 70s and one is severely immunocompromised so even with three full jabs (not even a booster) catching Covid could still kill her.

What is the harm in doing a test?! Should my relative stay at home, wrapped in cotton wool permanently because she's got a compromised immune system, or should we, as her family, do what we can to make her feel comfortable enough to be involved with Christmas? She's had a shit 2 years as it is, with practically becoming a hermit because of Covid. The least we can all do is stick a swab up our nose.

Iwonder08 · 22/12/2021 09:25

No, I actually don't think elderly should stay at home. I think they should assess their own risks and make their own decisions. The risks of people around them not being vaccinated, refusing to do tests, doing the tests wrong, lying about the tests etc. If they are vulnerable to the extend that they are avoiding public places altogether, including transport, supermarkets, restaurants then absolutely, nobody who is not jabbed and tested should be near them. In all the other cases I would accept the fact they will eventually encounter someone covid positive.

Kitkat151 · 22/12/2021 09:25

You sound selfish

Abraxan · 22/12/2021 09:25

@Iwonder08

No, I wouldn't ask my guests to test. Vulnerable people should assess their own risk and don't join any gatherings if they are worried.
One of the ways a vulnerable person (which also includes all elderly people) can reduce their risk is if everyone around them, including themselves, take a LFT before they meet up in close contact.

At Christmas most people spend time with loved ones. Who wouldn't want to do anything they can to reduce the risk to one of their loved ones 🤷‍♀️

Quarks69 · 22/12/2021 09:24

@Staryflight445

I was looking forward to Xmas too but can’t enjoy now thanks to people like you.
People like me have been putting themselves at risk daily, to teach your children. I am fully jabbed, wear a mask and take lfts bi-weekly.

But feel free to get on your high horse.

OP posts:
IamtheDevilsAvocado · 22/12/2021 09:24

@egglette

You say she's "demanded" it from your side of the family but I doubt she's doing/has singled you out to spite you. Yes it would be crap to miss out on Christmas again this year but if your plan involves seeing elderly/vulnerable people I think you just have to take the hit and be prepared to do something separate if you test positive.
Yup...

We're all testing on the morning... No wish to infect/be infected...

We have standby yummy frozen stuff and will make our chirstmas dinner on boxing day.

Ivalueloyaltyaboveallelse · 22/12/2021 09:23

Wow how selfish, I can’t believe that you’re happy to possibly spread covid to vulnerable elderly so as long as you get your Christmas. Have you done any tests OP? Or are you just happy ignoring all so you don’t ever have to isolate as it’s a massive inconvenience to you and your families life, unbelievable!!

Swipe left for the next trending thread