Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Snapped at DH about widowed MIL, feeling guilty

263 replies

pinkchristmastree11 · 22/12/2021 07:59

DH and I are from opposite ends of the country, he is an only child and I have one sibling who is severely disabled.

FIL died suddenly and unexpectedly a few months ago. He was relatively young (only just retired) and still very active. MIL is understandably devastated, they had been together since their teens. They were true soulmates, very dependant on each other and both quite introverted so had very few other friends. MIL has no other living family. She has two close friends, otherwise she doesn't work, doesn't volunteer, isn't part of any local groups, doesn't go to church etc.

She lives 3 hours away from us in a semi rural area with an unreliable bus service and doesn't drive.

DH has suggested she a) learn to drive or b) moves closer to us. Or ideally both. She won't entertain either (I don't really understand her reasons tbh).

Since FIL died DH has been going to visit MIL every third weekend and she's come to stay with us twice for 2-3 weeks at a time. As she doesn't drive, he goes to pick her up which is a six hour round trip.

She's staying with us throughout xmas/new year and last night DH was talking about his next visit in mid-Jan. For the first time, I got a bit annoyed about it. I'm totally exhausted - we have two DC of our own (toddler and primary school), no family support, and life is busy enough at the best of times. Every time he goes to MIL's I have to take a half day annual leave as he usually does pick up in the latter half of the week so I have to cover (and I don't know how much longer my work will tolerate this). Then it's a whole weekend of looking after the DC on my own, DH comes home exhausted and we are all back to work/school/childcare on Monday morning.

I basically said that MIL is a grown adult capable of making her own decisions and I respect that, but she has to accept that if she won't move closer and won't learn to drive, she isn't going to see as much of DH as she would like to and it's time to start cutting down on the frequency of the visits. DH actually agreed with me but I have been feeling so guilty ever since.

Any thoughts on how to handle? Am I a horrible person? Sad What can we do to make the situation easier and help MIL without making our lives even harder?

OP posts:
DaphneduM · 22/12/2021 09:26

It's still very early days - your mother-in-law and husband are still grieving and for now I would suggest just supporting them both as you have been doing so far.

When mil is thinking more clearly I'm sure she will recognise that this situation cannot continue as it is too much for your dh and your family. Cut her some slack, imagine yourself in her position. Of course you'd want to see your child frequently for support while your loss is still so raw. She couldn't have foreseen that father-in-law would die so young. Given time, maybe she will come round to moving to be nearer to you - but it's not for the faint hearted at the best of times. If she does decide, she will need a massive amount of support to deal with the move. Also hard to move areas and leave her friends. Sorry OP, I think actually you are being a bit selfish and insensitive here - you are young and capable surely of looking after your children unaided for the weekend every three weeks? Certainly your husband can do the drive in the evening to save you having to take annual leave to pick up your child. I'm sure this situation will be time-limited anyway - all concerned in their heart of hearts know this is not sustainable - but now is not the time for you to force the issue and add to everyone's distress.

GatoradeMeBitch · 22/12/2021 09:26

Might be cheaper and more convenient to pay for her to get a taxi to the nearest train station.

Animood · 22/12/2021 09:26

@THisbackwithavengeance

Her DH died a few months ago.

Cut her some slack.

Your DH is being a good son. Would you prefer it if he didn't give a fuck?

If you are complaining about having to look after your DCs for a few hours alone without your DH, imagine how she feels now her DH is dead?

Give her time. The situation will have changed in 6 months. At the moment any suggestion of change or effort is too overwhelming for her.

People aren't split into "good sons" on the one hand and people who "don't give a fuck" on the other! There is a balance to be struck!!

Realistically OPs DH needs to balance the needs of his mother, his wife and his children.

Additionally, poor DH! He is grieving and sounds like he is running himself ragged trying to do the right thing!

In my view His current levels of visiting swing too much in favour of his mother, to the detriment of his wife and children.

I think cutting down gradually is reasonable. His mum is an adult. Driving herself and / or getting public transport is a reasonable adjustment for her to make. As are visits every 6 weeks or so as opposed to every 3 weeks.

arootintootingoodtime · 22/12/2021 09:25

Well, you and your DH agree that it's time to space these visits out. So time for a discussion about possible options going forward. Lots of good ideas here.

What does your DH do when he's there? Is he doing the shopping, taking her to friends, out for lunch? Is it company? If he is doing lots of jobs and errands, make a list of what he does and tackle each one by one and find a new solution, that's more sustainable. I.e., if he's doing the shopping look at delivery services, or getting a big freezer for the garage etc. But definitely do all this when the three of you are together. Your MIL will probably need help to look at the options, but she can make some decisions, if you take it all out of her hands it's continuing the problem really.

Then if your DH is going to provide some company and moral support, rather than rushing around getting things done, hopefully he'll be less tired when he gets back.

Obviously, you feel bad for snapping - but none of us are perfect! If it's out of character and you've apologized, cut yourself some slack. It's stressful for you to, in different ways.

Foolsrule · 22/12/2021 09:24

@Dozer - that’s out of order. I agree with @mollypuss1. It isn’t a big deal!

mollypuss1 · 22/12/2021 09:23

@Dozer

You win today’s martyr medal, mollypuss
Cheers!

Although I don’t think pointing out that driving three hours each way, once a month, is really not that long a long drive that warrants time off work makes me deserving of such high honour.

Hankunamatata · 22/12/2021 09:22

The relative would book taxi to ger Nan to bus or train station

Hankunamatata · 22/12/2021 09:21

If you dont mind her staying then she could get the train or bus. My nan regularly travelled from up north to for reaches of south to stay with relatives on bus or train.

Other thought would be - would she considered a holiday home near yourselves if that's doable money wise?

CharityDingle · 22/12/2021 09:21

Any thoughts on how to handle? Am I a horrible person? sad What can we do to make the situation easier and help MIL without making our lives even harder?

No, you're not a horrible person. It's better that it got said, now, rather than festering. I wouldn't expect mil to move, no. Apart from anything else, it's a very recent bereavement so not a time to be making big decisions like that.
Both she and your husband are grieving so the visits are as much for his benefit as hers, I guess. I agree with suggestions that he start to bring one or both children with him, to give you a break. I don't think a three hour drive on two separate days at a weekend, is huge, tbh. And as has been said, presumably he isn't doing very much in between the journeys.
The half day thing needs to stop by the sound of it, so both of you need to discuss how that can happen. The visits need to be gradually reduced too. If MIL is staying over Christmas and into January, the next visit should be pushed out to a month from then, imo.
As I said, better it's out in the open, and discussed calmly before it became a routine, with you having to do all the work.

Diana8 · 22/12/2021 09:18

@Keepitonthedownlow

I think you are being impatient, insensitive and selfish
Agree. So little empathy is being shown.
lanthanum · 22/12/2021 09:18

Alongside gradually reducing the visits, another thing to try would be next time she visits you, encourage her along to some social activities in your area with people her own age - send her along, or see if you have a neighbour who would take her with them. It might take a bit of research to find what's on, but if she begins to see that she could make new friends in your area, the idea of moving may become easier to contemplate.

SchadenfreudePersonified · 22/12/2021 09:18

As long as the present situation continues your MIL has no incentive to change anything about her life - she will need to go out, make new friends, expand her life etc - she is a comparatively young woman and could potentially have another 20-30 years ahead of her.

I think that you and your DH have done the right thing by supporting her they way you both have (he by visiting, you by enabling - in the good sense of the term - him, and by making her welcome when she visits you for prolonged visits), but this obviously can't go on indefinitely.

You are right that you need to start cutting these visits (both ways) down. Try to do it gradually, and use the very real reason that your work won't allow it - you can't risk losing your job over this.

Cut back the frequency of his visits to her, and the duration of hers to you. It is of ultimate benefit to all of you to do this.

Blinkingbatshit · 22/12/2021 09:17

You’re entirely right to have opened the discussion with your dh - you’ve also done the right thing so far in supporting this but it does now need to scale back considering he agrees with you it’s too much. Whilst mil is with you over the Christmas break it is probably time to start gently steering the conversation this way ‘hey mil, we’ve been sorting the new year diary and dh needs to be here with the children / he’s becoming very exhausted and we need to reduce his time on the road’ etc. She needs to understand the children are the priority and she’s welcome to fit it but needs to take more responsibility. Cheekily - How about some L Plates for Christmas?!😆

EssexLioness · 22/12/2021 09:17

@janbaby22

I also think that suggesting she move or learn to drive, and then not understanding her reasons why, only a few months after her husband has died is insensitive.
I agree with this. There are a range of reasons. She may be too nervous/ just not want to drive. She has years of memories in that area and the home she shared with DH, friends, familiarity. Expecting her to uproot in this way is thoughtless as that would be a huge upheaval and stress on top of grieving the loss of her husband and best friend.

Having said that, I can understand you snapping. The situation sounds tough but I think that is largely your husband’s fault. A 3 hour drive isn’t so bad that he should expect you to take half day off work each time! I travel longer to see family and yes it’s draining but he can do it all in between work. Pack his bags the night before then drive up there straight after work, come back Sunday evening. If he is finding it hard going then gradually cut down the visite

TimTeleporter · 22/12/2021 09:16

I can't see that he needs to change anything apart from take the toddler with him. He could take the school age one with him if he left after school on a Friday too. He sounds like a supportive son who cares about his family. That's a good thing right. I wouldnt expect her to make life changing decisions months after her loss. Moving house is massive.

Dozer · 22/12/2021 09:12

You win today’s martyr medal, mollypuss

HalfWomanHalfMincePie · 22/12/2021 09:11

I also think her husband has just died so her making decisions about moving and/or learning to drive is just too soon right now.

It's also ok to not be able to sustain this level of visits. Can you and your husband talk (and maybe apologise for being short) and start to plan how this might be slowly reduced back down.

This could start with him not setting off until you're home from work on a Friday. Or even early Saturday morning if it's a traffic thing. 3 hours is really not a HUGE journey - and perfectly doable on Sat morning then back Sun pm (in normal times I 'commute' 3 hours and back in the same day, one day a wekk).

This would also be for her benefit - otherwise the risk is that she goes through one massive change (bereavement), gets used to this new life of constant visits and then it all has to change again. It gives her
afalse impression of whar her life where she is might be, iyswim. Better to ease everyone slowly into something more sustainable long term.

mollypuss1 · 22/12/2021 09:08

Im always baffled by people who make a big deal out of a relatively short journey. A 6 hour round trip really isn’t that long. You leave after breakfast and you’re there before lunch! I do that at least twice a month, there and back in a day with a 5 year old in tow to visit my mother and because my DH has a season ticket for his home football team. Why doesn’t he leave Sat morning and come back Sun evening once a month and take the kids with him?

bigbluebus · 22/12/2021 09:07

He needs to sit down with his mother and have a frank discussion about the future. She needs to start talking about how she's going to build a life for herself - I'm assuming she's in her 60's so she could have many years ahead of her. The current set up is not sustainable for you as a family - nor is it right that she relies on you so much. Time to wean her off this very high level of in person support.

Notonthestairs · 22/12/2021 09:07

Any house move has to come from her.

What are the most stressful events in anyone's lives? - divorce, bereavements and house moves. Wrapping 2 of the 3 in to less than a few months would only lead to greater dependency not less.

You might assume geographical proximity might make life easier - but there will be a knock on impact (visits at weekends and evenings?).

Don't rush in to solving it - she should be encouraged to come up with a plan.

Besides DH sounds like he's looking to wind things down a bit anyway.

But absolutely the Op shouldn't be losing annual leave - childminders or husband leaves later.

Natty13 · 22/12/2021 09:06

When you got married did he say "forsaking all others" or "forsaking all others apart from my mum"

He's a husband and father first and son second. Its a shit situation and its gut wrenching feeling torn between the 2 as anyone who has been in similar situations knows but this can't continue and the blessing here is that he agrees with you. Do you want your marriage and home life to fester if nothing is done? Of course not so sit down after Christmas and work out what you prefer - cutting down or stopping right away. She is a grown adult who has choices, choices have consequences. Why would she learn to drive when she clearly doesn't have to? If she knows your DH will stop neglecting his family in favour of her she might make different choices.

Gottasinggottadance · 22/12/2021 09:03

@janbaby22

I also think that suggesting she move or learn to drive, and then not understanding her reasons why, only a few months after her husband has died is insensitive.
This. Whilst the current situation sounds unsustainable and it's not unreasonable to consider ways to make it easier for you all, it's completely unreasonable of you to expect her to make major life decisions within 3 months of a bereavement. It's advisable not to decide anything such as moving house within a year of being bereaved. Give her some time.
Cocomarine · 22/12/2021 09:02

@Lalliella

Can he not drive up there on a Friday evening after work to at least save you having to take the half day off? YANBU
I was going to post this. At the very least I don’t understand why you’re regularly taking annual leave when you think your employer might not like that, instead of him going up later on Friday night. And you say he’s exhausted - why? 3 hours is less than the weekly commute that many people do. It’s not that long, and he’s just relaxing with him mum in between. I think it needs to change because he’s not with you and that may be tiring for you. Not because it’s “exhausting” for him!
billy1966 · 22/12/2021 08:57

OP, you were absolutely right to say this.

Taking precious annual leave?

Ridiculous.

Two small children and you work full-time?

Your MIL sounds very selfish that she thinks every third weekend is reasonable.

Even more selfish that she thinks a 6 hour round trip is reasonable.

She needs to think about other people.

Her son has a young family.

She is not infirm.

There is no reason why she can't get public transport/taxi to visit you.

Of course she is shocked, so is your husband.

However, when people have young children a little bit of consideration is not too much to ask.

Perhaps your husband needs to take the children with him.

It might focus his mind more.

Her insisting she lives rurally and not drive has consequences.

For HER.
Not you.

Keepitonthedownlow · 22/12/2021 08:56

I think you are being impatient, insensitive and selfish

Swipe left for the next trending thread