Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Snapped at DH about widowed MIL, feeling guilty

263 replies

pinkchristmastree11 · 22/12/2021 07:59

DH and I are from opposite ends of the country, he is an only child and I have one sibling who is severely disabled.

FIL died suddenly and unexpectedly a few months ago. He was relatively young (only just retired) and still very active. MIL is understandably devastated, they had been together since their teens. They were true soulmates, very dependant on each other and both quite introverted so had very few other friends. MIL has no other living family. She has two close friends, otherwise she doesn't work, doesn't volunteer, isn't part of any local groups, doesn't go to church etc.

She lives 3 hours away from us in a semi rural area with an unreliable bus service and doesn't drive.

DH has suggested she a) learn to drive or b) moves closer to us. Or ideally both. She won't entertain either (I don't really understand her reasons tbh).

Since FIL died DH has been going to visit MIL every third weekend and she's come to stay with us twice for 2-3 weeks at a time. As she doesn't drive, he goes to pick her up which is a six hour round trip.

She's staying with us throughout xmas/new year and last night DH was talking about his next visit in mid-Jan. For the first time, I got a bit annoyed about it. I'm totally exhausted - we have two DC of our own (toddler and primary school), no family support, and life is busy enough at the best of times. Every time he goes to MIL's I have to take a half day annual leave as he usually does pick up in the latter half of the week so I have to cover (and I don't know how much longer my work will tolerate this). Then it's a whole weekend of looking after the DC on my own, DH comes home exhausted and we are all back to work/school/childcare on Monday morning.

I basically said that MIL is a grown adult capable of making her own decisions and I respect that, but she has to accept that if she won't move closer and won't learn to drive, she isn't going to see as much of DH as she would like to and it's time to start cutting down on the frequency of the visits. DH actually agreed with me but I have been feeling so guilty ever since.

Any thoughts on how to handle? Am I a horrible person? Sad What can we do to make the situation easier and help MIL without making our lives even harder?

OP posts:
happychristmasbum · 22/12/2021 12:09

I don't understand why she isn't getting the train? Confused

YANBU

RosesAndHellebores · 22/12/2021 12:09

@Whatwouldscullydo with all due respect no, many older people don't get free bus passes until they are 65 at present. Also, whilst someone under 66/7 may have retired they will be only in receipt of an occupational pension until their state pension becomes payable at 66, 67 or 68. There is no statutory retirement age in the UK and your comment was, imo unnecessarily ageist.

LolaButt · 22/12/2021 12:08

I was widowed in my thirties. Always been really independent, was the higher earner, capable and fairly together.

My husband was killed and I can honestly say it broke me. What a lot of people don’t realise is that in the first year after losing a spouse, the surviving spouse is at a higher risk of dying themselves due to the grief and stress.

It affects you physically and mentally. Sleep is hard to come by and when it does come it’s fairly tortured. Other people are also sad and miss the person who has died but ultimately their day to day lives are still the same. They’re not faced with the suffocation of silence and the empty space in the bed next to them.

Your MIL is now faced with a raft of decisions and responsibilities that she may not have had to shoulder before. Guiding her through these at a gentle but firm pace will be key to her feeling supported.

It’s easy to say move house - her home is where her and FIL had their lives. Moving can feel like a betrayal and an acceptance of the death which she may not be ready for. Forcing it will cause resentment and may complicate the grieving process.

OP, I completely get where you’re coming from. You’re not infallible and also need support to get things done. But I do genuinely implore you to really and truly think about how you would feel if something happened to your husband and those weekends once a month where it is just you and the kids, was your every day life. How would you like others to care for you at your darkest time?

That said, the way things are cannot continue in the long term and compromises need to be made. I know it’s hard to keep supporting people when they’re in the midst of grief, but sometimes you have to make sacrifices for no other reason than it’s a kind thing to do.

Frederica852 · 22/12/2021 12:05

I think you're being a bit of an enabler tbh. Taking annual leave every third Friday in case of evening traffic on the M25 seems silly. Either the kids needs to go to after school club/childminder or DH leaves in the evening.

Also, I don't understand why you all wouldn't go? I know all families are different but if my MIL was suddenly widowed she'd love having the grandchildren staying as often as possible. Then you wouldn't be having to deal with them all weekend on your own and could go out and do things to make some nice memories. Might help take her mind off things.

Lokdok · 22/12/2021 12:04

It was really unkind, but you know that and you're sorry - what more can you do? Definitely understand it impacting on your lives, but your husband and his mum are grieving and they need to take this time to adjust to life without FIL.

Whatwouldscullydo · 22/12/2021 12:01

I wouldn't class getting a bus or train as making a change though.

Even meeting half way would surely be a help.

And don't pensioners get free bus passes?

TinStreet7Qual1ty · 22/12/2021 11:59

It is suggested that people do not make any big life changes in the first year of someone passing away, like moving house

pinkchristmastree11 · 22/12/2021 11:56

It might seem harsh but people really need to think of difficult things as they get older.

Living somewhere with poor public transport when you can't drive is a choice.

I think this sums up my point really. I know it's harsh and I agree with a PP who said my timing was off but she has made those choices and they do have consequences. I'm not saying she needs to make changes immediately but I need to know that this isn't the permanent arrangement because it doesn't feel fair. But maybe I'm expecting too much too soon.

OP posts:
GrannytoaUnicorn · 22/12/2021 11:52

Oh and I'm sure looking after your children on your own is quite possible, given that those of us who are widowed/single parents do it alone day in, day out!

blacksax · 22/12/2021 11:51

@cptartapp

What you say is right. Doesn't sound like MIL has made any plans for what she would do if FIL went first, which was always a 50% chance. No foresight, no preparation for the life she would live and how she would manage. Now she will reap the consequences or have to make different choices. I can't believe she is happy to impose herself and have your busy DH run around after her like this! Indefinitely? It isn't she who should be feeling guilty and sadly the fact it doesn't would taint my opinion of them as a parent. Her wants don't trump yours.
Wow. Total lack of sympathy there towards the newly-bereaved, especially since he was relatively young and had only just retired. You don't make plans for sudden early death.

Of course she's not happy. The love of her life has been taken from her too soon, and she is grieving. You do realise that it usually takes up to two years before you even begin to feel like you can carry on as normal?

BertramLacey · 22/12/2021 11:49

I basically said that MIL is a grown adult capable of making her own decisions and I respect that, but she has to accept that if she won't move closer and won't learn to drive, she isn't going to see as much of DH as she would like to and it's time to start cutting down on the frequency of the visits. DH actually agreed with me but I have been feeling so guilty ever since.

You were right OP and you do need to start thinking about this now, even if you can't make changes right now. I think it's fair enough in the early stages of grieving, but it cannot continue indefinitely. New year, new routine would be my way of dealing with it. Start with gradual changes e.g. she gets the train to you and your DH meets her at the station. And then over time, she needs to realise that her decisions impact her and you are not there to compensate for her poor decision making. I know this sounds harsh, but you do need to protect yourself, not sacrifice yourself to her needs.

I'm going through something not dissimilar with my parents. They're both still alive but they live rurally and rely on my mum as the sole car driver. They're in another country so it can take 24-36 hours to get there. I've offered to support them in moving back to the UK and help them when they're here. They have rejected this. Now that is their decision, but I am not picking up the pieces from that. I have told them that continuing to live where they are means they will see less of me and that they need to make plans according to whoever pre-deceases who.

It is tough and it feels horrible saying these things. But death is awful to deal with anyway so to me it makes sense to get practical things sorted before it happens, then at least you can just deal with the grief, not a load of practical trauma on top of it. Offer your mother-in-law love and support, yes, but do so with a sense of your own needs as well as hers.

GrannytoaUnicorn · 22/12/2021 11:49

Bloody hell @pinkchristmastree11 at least let them have their first Christmas without him before you start stamping your feet and declaring it all unfair on you Hmm It's been just a few months. Surely one single pick up every few weeks could be done by somebody else (or after school care) on a temporary basis? It sounds like you're fine with it as long as their grief doesn't inconvenience you in the slightest Hmm I lost my Dad in 2010 and if mine or my sibling's partner behaved like you I'd be appalled. That first Christmas was excruciating. Have a bloody heart

Clymene · 22/12/2021 11:48

It might seem harsh but people really need to think of difficult things as they get older.

Living somewhere with poor public transport when you can't drive is a choice.

Obviously he is going to have to drive when he goes to stay with her (once every 3 weeks is too frequent) but there is no reason she can't get the train to you instead. Maybe they take turns? So she comes to you for the weekend rather than weeks on end?

RosesAndHellebores · 22/12/2021 11:47

Picking up on the point of travelling and traffic. If DH goes up on a Friday he gets the train and then a cab to MILS. They kept FILS old car for shopping trips etc. He can work on the train. If he drives up, he usually leaves at 6am on a Saturday morning and at that time does Surrey to Yorkshire in 3.5 hours - arrives in time for breakfast and leaves at about 7pm on a Sunday getting home before 11pm.

He manages it OK op and is only a few years younger than your MIL, 64 isn't old.

Whatwouldscullydo · 22/12/2021 11:46

I think you are lacking empathy when you say you don’t understand why she doesn’t learn to drive or move

I think it can be important to distinguish that being a piss taker and being a grieving widow aren't mutually exclusive.

Of course I'm.not saying in this instance that's what's happening. But any other driving thread, well they hate non drivers. Now the consensus is usually it's fine not to drive as long as you don't regularly expect others to pick u up or drop u off.

Expecting people to accommodate the choices you made on precarious foundations was always something people deemed unreasonable.

I didn't drive until I was in my 30s however I was very self sufficient and very adept at getting where I need when I need via public transport. I happen to live somewhere where there a very good bus akd train service. Obviously if I didn't then I'd have had to learn much sooner.

Thing is everything she needs to do is not an instant thing. It took me a yr to learn to drive. It can take years to sell a house, weeks /months to build friendships etc

So how long should op give it bareing in mind this arbitrary length if time after a death its deemed acceptable to broach an issue could well still have 1 yr or 2 yrs ir 3 years added on until the solution is in full set up.

And what is the MILS usual state re time demands on others etc

Sparkletastic · 22/12/2021 11:46

You are perfectly justified in asking DH to scale down the visits. MIL is still relatively young. She's free to make her own decisions but it isn't up to you and DH to shield her from the consequences of those decisions. Your very young DCs are naturally your priority. MIL could see much more of them if in time she chooses to move nearer.

SpiderinaWingMirror · 22/12/2021 11:44

I think a few months ago is 5 mins in the process of grieving.
She should wait a year before making decisions.
Rather than snapping, a conversation with dh about reasonable way forward makes sense.
It's rubbish, been there done it!

comfortablyfrumpy · 22/12/2021 11:44

It's a difficult one. Your MIL has had the rug pulled from underneath her in a big way.

But carrying on with the arrangements you've got now isn't sustainable long term.

I can only suggest sitting down with her in the new year and explaining this to her and seeing how you can work out a plan together to be able to keep in touch and support, but in a way that doesn't cause so much difficulty for your family.

At 64 she can definitely build a new life for herself but it will take time.

Summerfun54321 · 22/12/2021 11:42

I’d keep out of it and let them decide between themselves. They’re both grieving and you making demands at such a sensitive time might permanently damage your relationships with both your DH and your MIL. Plenty of parents manage all sorts of different pick up arrangements while their other half is away, you could hire some temporary nanny help, after school clubs, employ a local student to be an extra pair of hands etc etc… you and your work refusing to be flexible isn’t really your DH’s problem. It’s always a good idea to plan for emergencies like this when one parent has to be absent.

Aprilx · 22/12/2021 11:36

I think you are lacking empathy when you say you don’t understand why she doesn’t learn to drive or move. Do you really not understand that? 😳 Learning to drive would be very daunting as a pensioner, I don’t think I would want to do that (I do drive, I mean if I couldn’t). And uprooting yourself from your home is not as easy as you seem to think either.

But as for the rest, I agree with your generally that the current arrangements are not fair on your family or sustainable. As a start MIL needs to make her own travel arrangements, be that by train, coach or by personal taxi. The length of stays also seem a bit much and need to gradually settle down into something more manageable. You were right to start the dialogue on this.

LittleGwyneth · 22/12/2021 11:31

You're both being reasonable, it's just the kind of horrible shit situation where no-one can get it right all the time. I agree with you though, she either needs to learn to drive (which might be something useful to focus on right now) or move closer to you, or both. Or she needs to find some other ways to feel fulfilled. It's beyond horrible for her and she has my deep sympathy, but him commuting to be with her isn't a long term solution.

NoSquirrels · 22/12/2021 11:31

Why aren’t you all visiting her as a family? Why is your DH going alone?

Please don’t stop him visiting or drastically reduce the frequency. To be perfectly honest, every 3 weeks is not that bad if he’s an only child and all she has going on in her life. He does have a responsibility to her, like it or not, so you need to make a plan that is sustainable. He’s grieving too, remember.

My mum died last year. I feel constantly guilty that I don’t see my dad enough, but I have seen him at least weekly. He has a great support network and is very busy with activities and I am one of 3 siblings. Despite all this he is really lonely. I agree with others that having kids around helps him and us all.

So, I’d suggest -

Keep the 3-weekly visits for now. But try to get into this pattern -

Visit 1: you all go together on a Friday night (despite traffic) for the weekend. Stop for a service station dinner.

Visit 2: your DH goes alone, you don’t take annual leave so he either travels Sat a.m. early or sucks up the traffic Friday night.

Visit 3: she comes to you on the train.

tara66 · 22/12/2021 11:29

This thread made me think of the historical Sati Hindu custom for widows. Some of the reasons were the widow would be reduced to poverty and outcast so she agreed to it and neighbours encouraged it to get the deceased man's land.. There does not seem to have been any thought that her family should care for her.

StickyStickyStickStickSong · 22/12/2021 11:29

@THisbackwithavengeance

Her DH died a few months ago.

Cut her some slack.

Your DH is being a good son. Would you prefer it if he didn't give a fuck?

If you are complaining about having to look after your DCs for a few hours alone without your DH, imagine how she feels now her DH is dead?

Give her time. The situation will have changed in 6 months. At the moment any suggestion of change or effort is too overwhelming for her.

👆🏻 this

Is is being a good son, you DH sounds like a fantastic man and I hope my DS looks out for me like this when I am old. He is setting a good example to your DC and I know it's tough for you at the moment with the kids but like other pp have said it's still raw for her and for your H loosing his dad too they probably want to be in each other's company as much as possible right now. You see things in a different perspective when you lose a parent. I lost my DF when I was 21 and it's brought me and my mom so close I see her every single day (granted she lives in the next street though)
I agree it's tougher on you so there does need to be a compromise somewhere along the line from all parties but try not to snap at him OP he sounds like a good man trying to please everyone

Clymene · 22/12/2021 11:27

Fwiw if your husband leaves 7.30-8, the m25 is usually pretty clear by then.

I think she needs to get the train. And he needs to have some serious conversations with her. She's very young.