Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Snapped at DH about widowed MIL, feeling guilty

263 replies

pinkchristmastree11 · 22/12/2021 07:59

DH and I are from opposite ends of the country, he is an only child and I have one sibling who is severely disabled.

FIL died suddenly and unexpectedly a few months ago. He was relatively young (only just retired) and still very active. MIL is understandably devastated, they had been together since their teens. They were true soulmates, very dependant on each other and both quite introverted so had very few other friends. MIL has no other living family. She has two close friends, otherwise she doesn't work, doesn't volunteer, isn't part of any local groups, doesn't go to church etc.

She lives 3 hours away from us in a semi rural area with an unreliable bus service and doesn't drive.

DH has suggested she a) learn to drive or b) moves closer to us. Or ideally both. She won't entertain either (I don't really understand her reasons tbh).

Since FIL died DH has been going to visit MIL every third weekend and she's come to stay with us twice for 2-3 weeks at a time. As she doesn't drive, he goes to pick her up which is a six hour round trip.

She's staying with us throughout xmas/new year and last night DH was talking about his next visit in mid-Jan. For the first time, I got a bit annoyed about it. I'm totally exhausted - we have two DC of our own (toddler and primary school), no family support, and life is busy enough at the best of times. Every time he goes to MIL's I have to take a half day annual leave as he usually does pick up in the latter half of the week so I have to cover (and I don't know how much longer my work will tolerate this). Then it's a whole weekend of looking after the DC on my own, DH comes home exhausted and we are all back to work/school/childcare on Monday morning.

I basically said that MIL is a grown adult capable of making her own decisions and I respect that, but she has to accept that if she won't move closer and won't learn to drive, she isn't going to see as much of DH as she would like to and it's time to start cutting down on the frequency of the visits. DH actually agreed with me but I have been feeling so guilty ever since.

Any thoughts on how to handle? Am I a horrible person? Sad What can we do to make the situation easier and help MIL without making our lives even harder?

OP posts:
Clymene · 22/12/2021 12:48

@frogswimming

I would suggest she moves in with you. You'd have an extra pair of hands to take the pressure off even if it's just making sure the kids don't destroy the house while you're in the shower, your kids would have their grandma near them, she doesn't have much to leave behind by the sound of it. Win win.
That's possibly the most terrible idea I've seen on here for a long time
canary1 · 22/12/2021 12:48

LolaButt

But I do think it is selfish. And many people here have not dissimilar views.

What on earth do you think this says ‘ about me as a person’ ? That I think asking all this time of your son who has a young family is unreasonable? That I believe not learning to drive or do things for yourself has consequences and asking others to make up for these is selfish?

What nonsense you talk. I am perfectly happy that I am just stating objective facts!

Squeezita · 22/12/2021 12:47

@TinStreet7Qual1ty

Different people react differently to grief

Some people take a short time, some a long time, some forever

But it's not others people jobs to drive you around forever.
RosesAndHellebores · 22/12/2021 12:44

I agree with inawe over the driving. MIL has a little bit of an excuse as she's 85 and lives in a City. But a woman of 64 not driving seems unusual. She's only a couple of years younger than me.

Cheeeesecake · 22/12/2021 12:43

YANBU. Tricky situation for all of you. I think you have to make clear is that what you’re doing now is short-term, and you need to soon make a plan for long-term.

Are there any of those retirement villages near you? The ones where houses are cheaper for over 55s. That way she could make friends and also be closer to you.

RosesAndHellebores · 22/12/2021 12:42

Like BertramLacey we have always had plans too. Many years ago DH made sure I knew where all the essential docs were, set up wills, etc.

inawe · 22/12/2021 12:42

It's very early days yet, but it isn't sustainable. It's good your DH is on the same page, but he needs to make it clear to her that it's breaking you.

How old is she? Has she ever worked or is she retired too? If she's in good health she needs to be using trains to get to yours.

I understand how difficult it can be - my FIL died when MIL was in her 60s and she had never worked, never driven. She also had a problem with using trains and taxis, but no problem at all with my DH doing a 4 hour round trip to ferry her around. I reached my breaking point after a 4 week stay at ours one Christmas a couple of years after he died, when my own widowed dad took me to one side and said something needed to change (after he'd watched me run round after her, while she criticised the food I cooked, criticised my parenting and much more) - he said this will destroy your marriage.

I know this won't change your situation now, but I actually take a very dim view of people (and it is usually women) who never learn to drive, especially if they live rurally, if there is no practical or financial reason not to. I have seen at least 5 widowed women in this situation over the past twenty or so years, all left with a car that they can't drive. All of whom have expressed regret that they never learned.

BertramLacey · 22/12/2021 12:38

You don't make plans for sudden early death.

My partner has a will that includes provision for his still-dependent DC. My will included provisions for my horse, when I had one, in case I died early and suddenly. It's not unusual to make plans for a sudden, early death. It's grim, but it is practical. And whilst it might seem very harsh, ultimately it does mean that if the worst happens, you can deal with the grief without also having to sort out all the practical shit.

The last thing I wanted was for me to be hit by a bus and for my family to be thinking 'wtf do we do with the horse?' If you've got dependants or a spouse/ partner, it's a good idea to do these things. I recognise that not everybody does but it's not an outlandish thing to prepare for.

TinStreet7Qual1ty · 22/12/2021 12:32

Different people react differently to grief

Some people take a short time, some a long time, some forever

TinStreet7Qual1ty · 22/12/2021 12:30

In UK the average ife span is into a person 80s

Although the stats may adjust down due to covid

So yes, could be another 20+ years

I would suggest encouraging independence over time

LolaButt · 22/12/2021 12:29

@canary1

Gosh she is very selfish wanting to take her sons time from his family life
That says a lot about who you are as a person.
Wexone · 22/12/2021 12:29

I do get you OP and you have my sympathies. We are in similar situation except my FIL died 4 years ago. We live alot nearer like only down the road but nearly every eve my partner has to go visit her. We have to consider her in everything we do now . Were lucky that she does drive and before Covid she had a good social life. There are others in the family but as we have no children it seems to be left to us to visit her. It annoys me as our evening is interrupted most days. If we are on the way home from somewhere and we are passing we always have to call in , which means we are delayed getting home. I more than likely then will get some job to do like order something on line or fix something. I do love her and she is a very nice women however it can be exhausting. Himself is like its only down the road , its only half an hour but doesn't get it by the time that we finish work do dinner and go to her house its like 8pm before were home so wind down time is reduced before we go to bed around 10 or if i need to do anything to get ready the next morning am rushing. One thing i would suggest though is don't mention moving house etc yet - we were advised not to suggest any big changes for the 1st year. I would do as people say reduce the visit time, you go sometimes, then try going by train etc and showing her how to use it. Or suggest driving lessons but i would wait a bit before doing this, she is only in the early stages of grief

frogswimming · 22/12/2021 12:28

I would suggest she moves in with you. You'd have an extra pair of hands to take the pressure off even if it's just making sure the kids don't destroy the house while you're in the shower, your kids would have their grandma near them, she doesn't have much to leave behind by the sound of it. Win win.

canary1 · 22/12/2021 12:26

Gosh she is very selfish wanting to take her sons time from his family life

1967buglet · 22/12/2021 12:26

When my MIL lost her husband, she was 70. DH, her only child, went once a week to see her (about a hour drive each way) for two months. I also told him he should go on a holiday with her she had had planned before her husband’s decease, so he did that for 10 days whilst I stayed at home (we were engaged, not married at that point).

After that, we got married, moved across the country due to DH’s new job, and then we saw MIL once a month for years. We’d call her and check on her in the interim, but she said, well, I need to get on with it, don’t it? And she did. She’s been active and busy…she doesn’t drive, but is in a small market town and has been involved in social groups, volunteer work, civic society, and took bus and rail trip with other retired people all over the world. I’m v. proud of her…she’s done retirement right and is a joy to be around.

She’s in her late 80s now. I took a job to be closer to her….we are 20 minutes away. We go over about 2-3x a month for a visit/to fix things/help her out, and I talk to her on the phone every few days.. DH and I don’t have kids, so we weren’t juggling like the OP.

The point for OP is that visits will increase as she gets older. She’ll need more…we just were over there to help sort through some paperwork and fix some lights in her cellar, and to drop off some Christmas presents. If you get in a pattern now of being over there a lot, your MIL will get more dependent, and she is only 64. My MIL was still doing pharmacy locums at that age, in fact till she was 75. It is OK to tail things off after 5 months a little…get her to take the train to see you, go over once a month or every six weeks for a while, rather than every three weeks. You can call or face time in between to see how she is doing. Yes, she is still grieving, and that’s very, very hard. But you’ll only get resentful if you are running yourself ragged. YANBU to take this gradual approach or broach it with your DH.

TinStreet7Qual1ty · 22/12/2021 12:22

The person I have been supporting is older, but some of the same things apply.

Things learnt

nokidshere · 22/12/2021 12:21

When my mil was bereaved after 50yrs of marriage we also had a baby and a toddler. We went to visit her monthly for the weekend, one month we would go as a family and the next month DH went with the children and I stayed home. Not only did I get a break but the children took MIL mind of things for a couple of days.

Then the house next door to us came up for sale and she moved there. Perfect solution.

You are being harsh on the timings though. It's only 3 months. In terms of grieving that's a very short period of time.

Youdoyoutoday · 22/12/2021 12:18

Honestly, from your title and first half of your post, I was kinda thinking you were the arsehole here but actually reading on, I whole heartedly agree with you.

Your DH is thankfully on the same page as you so you both need to talk to MIL and explain to her that this can't carry on, you can't be expected to use all your holidays just so DH can drive up and he can't be leaving you on your own with 2 small kids, it's not fair.

Also, I know its only been 5 months and it's still a tough time but at 64 years old, she could well have another 20-25 years left, this arrangement can't go on forever and she will need to learn to be independent.

Good luck OP, I know this is difficult, my dad was left on his own after mum passed away but he only lives a mile away and trying to get him out and about has been difficult especially with all the lockdowns etc. Luckily he does spend time with us and has a little cleaning job but he can be quite reluctant to help himself sometimes and it does grate when he is a grown man and I have 2 kids to look after.

NorthSouthcatlady · 22/12/2021 12:17

@Whatwouldscullydo the elephant in the room is she isn’t a pensioner, even though people seem to think she is. So she wouldn’t qualify.

TinStreet7Qual1ty · 22/12/2021 12:15

The state retirement age if MIL in UK is 66

You can check her state pension forecast on www.gov.uk

Roussette · 22/12/2021 12:13

Flippin' heck @pinkchristmastree11

I am older than your MIL. I just cannot imagine being like this when my DH dies, I would just feel so so guilty expecting my adult DC to spend all that time supporting me. I know without doubt they will be wonderfully supportive but I would not let them spend every third weekend with me with a huge journey to do so. They have their own lives to lead. Does your MIL think it's going to be like this forever? With your DH doing this? Or does she think he's just supporting her through this difficult grieving time? I wonder...

I think you may have to cope with this - like this - for a year or so, and then, slowly pull back a bit whilst supporting her by telephone etc. and making small changes as a PP said, like the train. Is she computer savvy? Can you do facetime or zoom calls?

Whatwouldscullydo · 22/12/2021 12:12

Ageist to ask if she has a bus pass. Really?

Berthatydfil · 22/12/2021 12:10

Half a days leave every 3 weeks

TheHoptimist · 22/12/2021 12:10

Asking her to move is unreasonable and I know so many people for whom this has been a disaster. left home and community to live near children- some of which have then moved.

For less than the cost of moving she could have an account with a local taxi firm. Call them when needed and they invoice monthly- taken straight from bank

Set up online food deliveries. Think local as well-the farm shop and local store deliver here as well as various national stores (and we are very remote!)

This is what my DM and most of her friends do- works really well.

Berthatydfil · 22/12/2021 12:09

Could he take the kids every other time or something if looking after them is the main issue.

This is a good idea and I'll suggest it but honestly I think he'll be really unhappy at this suggestion. The toddler is at a tricky age and I think he'll find it tough to manage on top of supporting his mum. She's not very proactive about helping.

Ok so the toddler is tricky - he’s the dad ? Why should YOU be left to manage said tricky toddler on your own PLUS another child when there are 2 adults (him and his dm) who could ? The only way for him to get better at parenting this tricky toddler is to actually do it.

Your MIL is an adult and can therefore manage her life needs etc your dc cannot and harsh as it sounds he cannot prioritise her needs over his children indefinitely. If FIL managed transport and other household matters and was her source of socialisation she will need support to get some independence whether that’s learning to drive, using public transport, expanding her social circle , starting hobbies or interests. If your DH steps into his fathers role this won’t happen and if she’s relatively young you could have 20 years of it.

Half a days leave every weeks works out at nearly 9 days in a whole year - that could be almost half your allowance for the entire year - it’s just not sustainable if you want to have a family holiday, need the odd day/ half day for personal reasons etc.

I think you need a plan to reduce the visits, include the dc, stop the use of your annual leave and encourage her independence.