Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU - Training as a nurse - to work in Aesthetics only!

158 replies

Wishingitwassummer · 21/12/2021 18:56

I’ve came across this a fair few times now. Student nurses completing their nursing degrees as they want to work in aesthetics (and aesthetics only).
This is just such a waste of government funding. I’m in Scotland - so we don’t pay tuition fees and the bursary is still available.
Now I know this will only be a very small minority of people who are doing this but it just doesn’t sit right with me at all.
AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
morechocolateneededtoday · 22/12/2021 10:26

@Wishingitwassummer

It is a shame that the NHS is losing so many good nurses. I’ve seen a fair few go down the ANP route. But even they are underpaid for the work they put in and the extra responsibility. It really does sadden me, the state of our healthcare system.
So here is the real problem. The underfunded state of our healthcare system. Instead of discussing this, you are patronising and judging nurses which is a predominantly female career.

Health professionals that do placements without pay all provide some level of labour during their placement which in turn they benefit from by learning essential skills for their future career. The NHS gets the labour without paying a wage, the individual gains skills usually partly funded by a bursary which does not come close to minimum wage but allows them to continue studying. It should not leave them obligated to be employed by the NHS as it is an essential part of funding. Once they go on to work for NHS (which the majority of them do), any further education and training (such as the independent prescribing course you speak of) usually means they are tied to their organisation for a fixed period which is appropriate

Hiddenmnetter · 22/12/2021 10:25

I find this attitude is the basic way in which our society gets by not paying nurses decently. My wife is a nurse, and her pay hasn't gone up except for promotions ever since she started. So this last "pay rise" still means nurses are earning less in real terms than they were when she started 8 years ago.

The term "vocation" has a specific meaning- it is a calling by which you come closer to God. It is a specifically Christian term that is leftover in the nursing world because many, many hospitals used to be staffed by nurses who were also nuns.

This is unobjectionable to me, because when someone becomes a nun or a priest or a monk etc, they have done this specifically with the intention of not having a career- their stated intention is to give their life to this work as a way of serving God.

If you aren't a dedicated or ordained religious though, it is frankly taking the piss. Most women (and it is mostly women) are grossly underpaid and overworked in this profession because they ought to "care". Yes, great that they care, but at the end of the day, if you don't pay them enough they won't stick around to keep caring because they have to earn enough to provide for their families. It's total bs.

If you want there to be some guarantee of return for the bursary, then sure put in one year after qualifying or whatever. But total bs to say "call me old fashioned but I thought nurses were supposed to care". You can't care if you can't afford to care, and it's outrageous that our society insists on it.

Wishingitwassummer · 22/12/2021 10:20

@ichifanny Possibly, but that’s not what my thread was about.
As someone said previously, taking government funding to go private asap is a bit shit.

OP posts:
morechocolateneededtoday · 22/12/2021 10:18

They aren’t free labour, or shouldn’t be.

Absolutely they shouldn't be but have you worked on a hospital ward yourself? The only way I can accurately describe it is free labour. Hospitals are so short staffed and screaming for nurses, students fill the gaps because there is no-one else to do so

FWIW I am not a nurse myself but have spent most of my career on hospital wards in a number of specialties so have met and worked with many student nurses

ichifanny · 22/12/2021 10:05

I know someone who has been working on the side the whole pandemic in their self employed trade and claiming all the grants and loans possible while earning over and beyond their usual wages , they built an extension on their house with one of the 20k ones , maybe people should concern themselves with people like that and what they owe the public purse rather than nurses already working on too low pay doing the job of 3-4 people in their training alone .

CounsellorTroi · 22/12/2021 10:05

@Wishingitwassummer

I believe many moons ago, before Nursing was degree only, student nurses were paid when on placement.
I was a student nurse for a while before it was degree only. We were paid, full stop. Not just for working on the wards. Went out on the wards after eight weeks of initial training.
RandomLondoner · 22/12/2021 09:52

We aren’t public property because of our training .

Yes, given that slavery has been abolished, intellectual capital always belongs to individuals.

If the public wants to ensure a return on any education funding, they need to get it via interest on a loan. (Though in the case of people doing on-the-job training, the option of working for low pay is also valid.)

Nomoreusernames1244 · 22/12/2021 08:49

You may not think you are judging women, those who you think are supposed to be caring and make a difference in peoples lives, but you certainly arent answering whether you have an issue with doctors or other more traditionally male professions doing the same, your iritation seems to be reserved for 'girls’

Imo it’s anyone who recieves funding or bursary for their degree.

You want to go into private practice, whether that’s nursing, medicine, law, airline pilot, take student loans like everyone else.

If you receive governmental funding so you significantly reduce that debt, knowing the intention is to support you into state school teaching, nhs nursing/medicine, whatever, then yes there should be an expectation that you work in that field.

Dr’s I think have to work in the nhs post graduation as they have one or two pg years before they’re fully qualified.

As for “thousands of hours working for free” if they haven’t graduated they can’t practice. Those hours are part of their course and necessary training. They need supervision and assessment, which costs money. They aren’t free labour, or shouldn’t be.

Toomanyradishes · 22/12/2021 08:41

You may not think you are judging women, those who you think are supposed to be caring and make a difference in peoples lives, but you certainly arent answering whether you have an issue with doctors or other more traditionally male professions doing the same, your iritation seems to be reserved for 'girls'

Maybe the care and the making a difference in peoples lives is reserved for people you arent seeing, maybe they are choosing an option with regular hours because they have children, or care for relatives. Maybe they are choosng abetter paid profession to support their family, or because they want a family.

Maybe after working thousands of hours for free for the nhs during placement they dont owe you or anyone else anything.

AgathaMystery · 21/12/2021 23:57

OP YANBU & I agree with you but for a different reason. I do not think nurses or midwives should be doing aesthetics. I don’t care how many courses they have been on etc etc. I will only go to an experienced medical doctor for my treatments. I’ve seen WAY too many nurses on social media with hair down, fake eyelashes on, gel nails etc doing fillers/Botox. All these things are big infection control no-nos. I have visited a few clinics and the only one I am happy to be treated at it owned by a medical doctor. I know if I have an adverse reaction she will treat men and probably keep me alive until I get to hospital. Doubtful a newly qualified nurse would.

Atla · 21/12/2021 23:56

When I started my training in 2009 the bursary in NI was £504 per month. When on placement we worked full time, all shifts - nights, weekends, long days - with no enhancement for unsocial hours etc.

Nursing isn't badly paid, per se, but it IS in relation to the level of clinical skill, responsibility and professional accountability placed on you. I have always worked in the NHS but I don't begrudge anyone taking a different path.

FeelingSoGrinchy · 21/12/2021 23:53

Well that wouldn't work would it, lots of people complete training in nursing, physiotherapy, occupational therapy etc, and go straight to working for a private company, charity, set their own business up, or work abroad.

Nurses here in England pay 9k a year in fees. They don't owe the NHS anything when they graduate.

Wishingitwassummer · 21/12/2021 23:47

For a couple of years, yes.

OP posts:
Friendviv1987 · 21/12/2021 23:46

So what are your thoughts about Drs,Physios,OT ,Radiologist,…should they all stick with the NHS when they qualify?🤔

youvegottenminuteslynn · 21/12/2021 23:41

@anxiouswaiting

I don't understand the issue.

I have over 30k debt for my nursing training, I worked 2300 hours clinical placements which included nights, weekends, public holidays etc for free. At £9 an hour (which is what I got and a carer working to support my family while I trained) that's £20,700 of free care work I have given before you consider all the breaks I missed and the times I stayed late to help where I was needed.

How does that leave me owing anyone anything? I trained in a job just like other people train for their jobs, why would I then owe the NHS a year or more of work?

I do work in the NHS, but I am not sure why people would think I should be obligated to?

I'm not saying I agree with the rules around who can do aesthetics etc, but the arguement that nurses owe for their training doesnt sit well with me. There are many types of nursing both NHS and private. We dont get to choose to train for private practice, it's one training for all regardless of where you go on to work. I'm not sure why it is a problem that some nurses choose to go in different career directions and that these are seen as not worthy, or not caring enough.

As I said I do work in the NHS and I love the area I work in but I dont judge other nurses for the path they have chosen outside of the NHS.

I know a few nurses and midwives who do aesthetics, all of them also do some sort of work either as bank or in a part time position in another nursing area. I doubt many purely do aesthetics.

Interested to see if OP comes back to this properly.
Wishingitwassummer · 21/12/2021 23:38

Yes, and hopefully do something that makes a difference in peoples lives.

OP posts:
youvegottenminuteslynn · 21/12/2021 23:35

@Wishingitwassummer

Other health professionals do placements without pay…
And are equally, and quite rightly, able to change jobs after training, surely?
Wishingitwassummer · 21/12/2021 23:33

Other health professionals do placements without pay…

OP posts:
CliveThighs · 21/12/2021 23:33

I think you should be looking at why these young women are more tempted by a career in aesthetics than nursing - could it be nursing pay & conditions, working hours not being family friendly, staff shortages, work pressures, etc are all far worse in typical NHS nursing work as opposed to aesthetics? They'll have spent time on the wards during their training, they'll know what life on the front line is like. If things were amazing they could be swayed to specialise in any number of NHS nursing jobs.

If you had to choose between a working life filled with stressful 12 hour A&E shifts for not much pay, or a working life with more flexible hours, less aggressive patients, better pay, etc in aesthetics then guess which one is the more attractive option.

anxiouswaiting · 21/12/2021 23:33

I don't understand the issue.

I have over 30k debt for my nursing training, I worked 2300 hours clinical placements which included nights, weekends, public holidays etc for free. At £9 an hour (which is what I got and a carer working to support my family while I trained) that's £20,700 of free care work I have given before you consider all the breaks I missed and the times I stayed late to help where I was needed.

How does that leave me owing anyone anything? I trained in a job just like other people train for their jobs, why would I then owe the NHS a year or more of work?

I do work in the NHS, but I am not sure why people would think I should be obligated to?

I'm not saying I agree with the rules around who can do aesthetics etc, but the arguement that nurses owe for their training doesnt sit well with me. There are many types of nursing both NHS and private. We dont get to choose to train for private practice, it's one training for all regardless of where you go on to work. I'm not sure why it is a problem that some nurses choose to go in different career directions and that these are seen as not worthy, or not caring enough.

As I said I do work in the NHS and I love the area I work in but I dont judge other nurses for the path they have chosen outside of the NHS.

I know a few nurses and midwives who do aesthetics, all of them also do some sort of work either as bank or in a part time position in another nursing area. I doubt many purely do aesthetics.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 21/12/2021 23:33

And I didn’t just set out to ‘judge’ women. Jeez.

You're doing a bloody good job of it!

youvegottenminuteslynn · 21/12/2021 23:32

@Wishingitwassummer

I wouldn’t say nurses have ‘very low’ pay. They are paid less than others who have a degree, agreed. And I didn’t just set out to ‘judge’ women. Jeez.
I said they are on very low pay for a couple of years ie during their degree. In fact, I was wrong to say that. They're on zero pay, living off their bursary for the equivalent of well below minimum wage. Your attitude towards this is baffling.
Wishingitwassummer · 21/12/2021 23:30

I wouldn’t say nurses have ‘very low’ pay.
They are paid less than others who have a degree, agreed.
And I didn’t just set out to ‘judge’ women. Jeez.

OP posts:
youvegottenminuteslynn · 21/12/2021 23:26

@Wishingitwassummer

It is a shame that the NHS is losing so many good nurses. I’ve seen a fair few go down the ANP route. But even they are underpaid for the work they put in and the extra responsibility. It really does sadden me, the state of our healthcare system.
You can think something is sad without having such a judgemental attitude to the individuals involved.

These girls are only doing it because they HAVE to do the degree.

Setting aside your patronising 'girls' wording, someone gets through a nursing degree has worked bloody hard and their work has included gruelling hours as well as often traumatic and unpleasant tasks, especially over the last couple of years. As someone in healthcare you surely know that more than most.

Also you say about the shortage in nurses. Without nursing students, even including those who leave to do something non NHS based, there would be an even larger gap in nursing roles being filled.

Your posts are dripping in judgment of people, predominantly women, who work hard for very low pay for a few years not earning even minimum wage for a job that's arguably harder than many many others physically and emotionally.

Maybe reflect on whether you're arguing the right side of things here...

anniz91 · 21/12/2021 23:25

@Wishingitwassummer

Sorry if it sounds judgemental. Yes I do currently work in the NHS. Yes, it is shit.
So you can't really blame them.

Anyone working in the NHS currently is battling burnout and student nurses can see that. So I don't blame them. I switched to bank shifts because I couldn't take it anymore. I don't blame anyone who wants to get out!

Swipe left for the next trending thread