Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the UK and France should not be sued for manslaughter over migrants drowning?

215 replies

OneRuleForThem · 21/12/2021 17:52

A humanitarian group are suing the two countries saying they left migrants to drown. AIBU to think this isn’t right? I don’t think either “left” anybody to drown and they need to realise that getting on an inflatable boat packed to the rafters and attempting to cross the Channel isn’t a good idea.

OP posts:
CorrBlimeyGG · 21/12/2021 18:30

They called both the English and French lifeguard for help. Those calls were ignored. That is gross negligence.

Campervan69 · 21/12/2021 18:28

The people who drowned made the decision to risk their children's lives. They were safe in France.

RowsOfHolly · 21/12/2021 18:28

The traffickers should be relentlessly pursued and caught. They are responsible.

I do think that given that an overwhelming % of migrants who arrive in this way have their case approved, for asylum, family reunification etc , that there should be a sensible agreement between the UK and France (and Belgium, with coast just up the road from Calais) about assessing and processing people, relieving their desperation.

But in the end the criminal activity is those who take money for such dangerous attempts, and responsibility rests with those who choose to take what is now known to be incredibly dangerous. Given that they are in France, a safe country.

I do think in the past migrants may not have been fully aware of the danger. They may never have Serb the sea. No idea of the cold, the height of swell in the middle of the channel, the implications of a boat which does not have a rigid bottom, which does not have separate inflatable chambers.

But by now, the dangers are known.

Horst · 21/12/2021 18:26

Honestly I think it’s bonkers. There’s clearly dispute over who’s waters they where in.

Frankly they decided to get into dangerous freezing waters paying smugglers most of them planning on calling for rescue as part of the plan. If anyone’s to blame it’s the smugglers go after them. Next is the french police who often watch the boats being launched and just do nothing. They know they are not going for a family beach dingy ride but knowingly let them attempt the dangerous trip.

Suzanne999 · 21/12/2021 18:24

No.
Efforts should go into finding the scum who traffic these people and make money out of their misery.

Tealightsandd · 21/12/2021 18:22

I agree with you - I find it hard to believe the RNLI would ignore a distress call.

RuggerHug · 21/12/2021 18:20

Unfortunately money makes people pay attention, not lives lost.

Theunamedcat · 21/12/2021 18:19

But DID we ignore a distress call? The lifeboat people are committed to responding despite everyone saying they shouldn't they have been doing it regardless

anon12345678901 · 21/12/2021 18:11

@Heartoverheadheadoverheart

Agree, it was a choice they made or their parents and caregivers made for them. It is a choice to come to the UK. I understand some very valid reasons why some refugees may prefer to settle here than else where. I really don't blame them for seeing here as somewhere which will give them hope for a good future. I really do empathise with them. But, no one forced them to come here via the channel rather than settle else where or try other means. They assessed the situation and thought the rewards were worth the risk.
I agree with this. If anyone should be sued, it should be the traffickers. Not either country.
Tealightsandd · 21/12/2021 18:11

As a nation we shouldn't leave people to die. That's absolutely horrific.

Agreed. But very sadly we do. On a regular basis. Perhaps a humanitarian group should sue the UK government over the 100s of homeless left to die on our streets every year (both migrant and British born).

www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/homeless-man-found-dead-near-25750376

Probably more helpful (than sueing) whether over the trafficked migrant crossings or the homeless left to die on the street, would be constructive practical action.

Heartoverheadheadoverheart · 21/12/2021 18:09

I haven't read the story myself. I do agree that if we know they are in distress we should do all we can to help and action should be taken if we have deliberately sat back whilst people died. I do believe though like the other poster that the responsibility lies with the people traffickers and the lack of a proper plan by the whole world on how to deal with all of this.

IncompleteSenten · 21/12/2021 18:08

It depends.
If nobody knew they were there then obviously not.
But if they were alerted that there were people in trouble in the ocean and they did nothing then yes they should be held accountable.

Tealightsandd · 21/12/2021 18:05

I think they should sue the people trafficking groups (including any NGOs) who organise the journeys. It's a very lucrative (albeit immoral) business for some.

lifeturnsonadime · 21/12/2021 18:01

I think it is absolutely right that action be taken. If it is correct that distress calls were made and ignored then regardless the reasons they were in the waters if they could have been saved they should have been.

As a nation we shouldn't leave people to die. That's absolutely horrific.

Heartoverheadheadoverheart · 21/12/2021 17:57

Agree, it was a choice they made or their parents and caregivers made for them. It is a choice to come to the UK. I understand some very valid reasons why some refugees may prefer to settle here than else where. I really don't blame them for seeing here as somewhere which will give them hope for a good future. I really do empathise with them. But, no one forced them to come here via the channel rather than settle else where or try other means. They assessed the situation and thought the rewards were worth the risk.