Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the UK and France should not be sued for manslaughter over migrants drowning?

215 replies

OneRuleForThem · 21/12/2021 17:52

A humanitarian group are suing the two countries saying they left migrants to drown. AIBU to think this isn’t right? I don’t think either “left” anybody to drown and they need to realise that getting on an inflatable boat packed to the rafters and attempting to cross the Channel isn’t a good idea.

OP posts:
Mumoblue · 21/12/2021 19:30

They should be sued if they ignored distress calls.

Also the casual way people talk about other humans drowning because they’re “migrants” who “knew what they were doing” is gross.

RuggerHug · 21/12/2021 19:28

You want to add context to that wink littleroundrobin or was it just a twitch?

ChaToilLeam · 21/12/2021 19:26

If distress calls were ignored, yes, they should be sued.

IamnotSethRogan · 21/12/2021 19:25

All these twats who were just lucky enough to be born here think they deserve our safety and comfort more than everyone else

Exhausteddog · 21/12/2021 19:22

Whilst risking your own and/or your children's life in an unsuitable vessel is extremely risky behaviour, we can't just assume they should settle in France/Germany etc because they travelled through there first. As an Island we are probably never going to be the first safe country they arrive in but that doesn't mean we should effectively close borders and say not our problem. Its a global problem and the UK, along with other European countries needs to take in refugees, but hopefully in a more controlled and properly administrated way than people getting onto dangerously unsuitable boats to (attempt to) get here

AyeOop · 21/12/2021 19:20

@TractorAndHeadphones thank you
As far as I know we have coast guards, immigration boats, helicopters and volunteers manning our coast
They would never ignore a distress call, I think it's part of maritime law
To try and sue is quite frankly incredulous IMHO

IamnotSethRogan · 21/12/2021 19:20

MatildaIThink

They decided to risk crossing the worlds busiest shipping lane, in bad weather, in an unfit boat. France is a safe and friendly country, as nice as the UK, not some hell hole. If I was fearing oppression and violence I would be happy to settle in Franch (or Germany, Italy, Spain, Portugal etc. which they will have passed through on the way), I certainly would not risk my children's lives crossing the Channel in a leaky inflatable boat.

Sorry have you see the state of the jungle ? You think that's a nice safe place ?

WhenISnappedAndFarted · 21/12/2021 19:17

If they were in our waters and we left people to die then yes. If they were in French waters and left to die then yes sue France.

However the bigger problem is the traffickers and we need to get together with other countries and actually do something about them.

Tempusfudgeit · 21/12/2021 19:15

Wasn't it in French waters and therefore we're not allowed to enter unless invited?

IamnotSethRogan · 21/12/2021 19:13

If distress calls were ignored and people were left to die, then the absolute dickheads deserve everything they get.

Fomofo · 21/12/2021 19:11

Littleroundrobin, and you think their journey is easy once they get here?

Fomofo · 21/12/2021 19:09

I believe both france and uk ignored distress call, which is reprehensible

RoastedParsnips · 21/12/2021 19:09

traffickers are responsible and France for continuing to allow people to do this, they could stop it but choose not too because of political madness.

RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 21/12/2021 19:06

@IncompleteSenten

It depends. If nobody knew they were there then obviously not. But if they were alerted that there were people in trouble in the ocean and they did nothing then yes they should be held accountable.
This
LittleRoundRobin · 21/12/2021 19:02

@MatildaIThink

They decided to risk crossing the worlds busiest shipping lane, in bad weather, in an unfit boat. France is a safe and friendly country, as nice as the UK, not some hell hole. If I was fearing oppression and violence I would be happy to settle in Franch (or Germany, Italy, Spain, Portugal etc. which they will have passed through on the way), I certainly would not risk my children's lives crossing the Channel in a leaky inflatable boat.
This. ^ They always want to come to the UK though. Often citing the reason that they have 'family' here. Wink
TractorAndHeadphones · 21/12/2021 18:56

@AyeOop

Have you got a link please *@OneRuleForThem*?
metro.co.uk/2021/12/21/channel-tragedy-uk-and-france-sued-for-manslaughter-after-27-migrants-drown-15801971/

Even more disgusting they are watched getting onto these on the beach!
Clearly there are very simple ways, they could be stopped from leaving but France doesn't want them either.

MatildaIThink · 21/12/2021 18:55

They decided to risk crossing the worlds busiest shipping lane, in bad weather, in an unfit boat. France is a safe and friendly country, as nice as the UK, not some hell hole. If I was fearing oppression and violence I would be happy to settle in Franch (or Germany, Italy, Spain, Portugal etc. which they will have passed through on the way), I certainly would not risk my children's lives crossing the Channel in a leaky inflatable boat.

TractorAndHeadphones · 21/12/2021 18:54

@montysma1

You can try to blame the traffickers or the police or themselves. But ultimately if lifeboats opted or were ordered not to save lives at sea then that is criminal and grotesque.
From a legal standpoint how is it criminal? I'm sure someone with more knowledge of maritime law will come along shortly but don't the lifeboats have jurisdiction only in their waters?

Also these people had the money to pay smugglers. They knew which number to call - both numbers in fact. The rescue boats were clearly part of the plan. They knew how dangerous it was.

Suing both countries on the logic that it's their 'right' to be rescued will not only encourage more people to cross but emphasizes that it's somehow the government's responsibility to get people across. Rescue services are for when things don't go to plan. They're not a free taxi service for deliberate use.

AyeOop · 21/12/2021 18:48

Have you got a link please @OneRuleForThem?

Chloemol · 21/12/2021 18:43

Agree

Ilikepalindromes · 21/12/2021 18:43

A bit of personal responsibility has to be taken. They decided to get in the dinghies when they were safe in France.

montysma1 · 21/12/2021 18:43

You can try to blame the traffickers or the police or themselves.
But ultimately if lifeboats opted or were ordered not to save lives at sea then that is criminal and grotesque.

LittleRoundRobin · 21/12/2021 18:39

100% YANBU. It's the risk they take when they get on these inflatable dinghies.

Whilst it's tragic that these people died, I think it's pretty disgusting and shameful that the UK and France are being blamed for them drowning. I mean WTAF? Confused How the hell can anyone even begin to THINK it's our fault? They came of their own accord! No WAY is it the fault of the UK or France, and it's batshit to suggest otherwise!

Aardvarkitsabloodyaardvark · 21/12/2021 18:39

The RNLI will always go to anyone in need.
Their FB page got a lot of abuse not long a go for rescuing migrants and their response was that it makes no difference who is in trouble they will go.
They are alerted by the coastguard.

RowsOfHolly · 21/12/2021 18:32

IF distress calls were ignored, then that is a different matter.

The UK border force have spoken about the difficulties of pulling boats to safety if the occupants do not wish to be helped, as it makes it a very dangerous, possibly catastrophic manoeuvre.

The RNLI have said they will always help.