Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the UK and France should not be sued for manslaughter over migrants drowning?

215 replies

OneRuleForThem · 21/12/2021 17:52

A humanitarian group are suing the two countries saying they left migrants to drown. AIBU to think this isn’t right? I don’t think either “left” anybody to drown and they need to realise that getting on an inflatable boat packed to the rafters and attempting to cross the Channel isn’t a good idea.

OP posts:
MintJulia · 21/12/2021 20:47

Both the French & the British are jumping up and down saying it's dangerous, don't try to cross.

The immigrants ignore the pleas and the warnings, sneak past the French police and launch in the dark. They are often too small to be seen on radar, most are grossly overladen, they have no comma, no lights and the channel is a big busy place.

Any lawsuits should be against the people traffickers.

saoirse31 · 21/12/2021 20:45

If distress calls were made and ignored and if there was avoidance due to claimed Ng boat nor in their territory when they were, I don't know if this was the case, but if it was, then yes, one r both were responsible

TractorAndHeadphones · 21/12/2021 20:44

@rrhuth

On the question posed by the OP - whether the governments should be sued - IMO it is reasonable to try to challenge this legally. The law is there to be used, the courts can decide if it is a) a reasonable case and b) whether there was wrongdoing. People who do not want to use the law to challenge a government can get to fuck too!

My views are that sometimes “A person may cause evil to others not only by his actions but by his inaction, and in either case he is justly accountable to them for the injury.” - and so this seems a good case to pursue legally to see what the verdict is.

Yes - it will be interesting to see how far it goes.

Mill's Harm principle is interesting. 100% accountability but 0% responsibility.

This is a story about four people named Everybody, Somebody, Anybody and Nobody. There was an important job to be done and Everybody was sure that Somebody would do it. Anybody could have done it, but Nobody did it. Somebody got angry about that, because it was Everybody’s job. Everybody thought Anybody could do it, but Nobody realized that Everybody wouldn’t do it. It ended up that Everybody blamed Somebody when Nobody did what Anybody could have.

rrhuth · 21/12/2021 20:40

On the question posed by the OP - whether the governments should be sued - IMO it is reasonable to try to challenge this legally. The law is there to be used, the courts can decide if it is a) a reasonable case and b) whether there was wrongdoing. People who do not want to use the law to challenge a government can get to fuck too!

My views are that sometimes “A person may cause evil to others not only by his actions but by his inaction, and in either case he is justly accountable to them for the injury.” - and so this seems a good case to pursue legally to see what the verdict is.

rrhuth · 21/12/2021 20:34

@RufustheFloralmissingreindeer

rrhuth

Don’t disagree with any of your post

It just irritates me when people say you shouldn’t comment on something you haven’t experienced

Means even positive comments shouldnt be made

On some topics people should just shut the fuck up.

I don't profess to know much about women who are in refuges for example - I defer to those who do know. I don't know much about victims of CSA - I defer to those who do know.

Sometimes the appropriate comment if you don't know about things is 'I don't understand why they come' and then listen.

NotSoLittle · 21/12/2021 20:34

" A spokesperson for the French Maritime Prefecture said its rescuers investigate every call that they receive and that an inquiry was underway into the calls received that night.

"Sometimes we receive hundreds of calls in a night, each call is dealt with, and we have to work out which boat they are referring to," said Veronique Magnin.

Callers sometimes express a preference to be rescued by the British, she said. However, this would not change the legal obligation for France to act.

The British coastguard declined to comment on Utopia 56's legal complaint. It said that on November 24, it had received more than 90 alerts from the Channel area including 999 emergency calls.

"Every call was answered, assessed and acted upon, including the deployment of search and rescue resources where appropriate," it said. "

Not unreasonable to think that, although calls were made, without an accurate position it's not easy to deploy rescue services. And if they're getting such high numbers of calls (and especially without a position fix) immediate rescue mightn't be possible. Although tragic I don't know what help suing is going to do?

TractorAndHeadphones · 21/12/2021 20:34

[quote rrhuth]@TractorAndHeadphones I never said refugees were a homogenous mass - that is exactly why people should meet a few before spouting shit.[/quote]
Ah, but they could meet the 'sensible' refugees who agree that Channel crossing ones are risking lives unnecessarily (yes, I have met quite a few who think this), or the ones who aren't very pleasant/grateful to have been saved.

Not necessarily going to change people's opinions are they, probably solidify them in fact.

RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 21/12/2021 20:29

Plus mumsnet would have to shut 🤔

RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 21/12/2021 20:28

rrhuth

Don’t disagree with any of your post

It just irritates me when people say you shouldn’t comment on something you haven’t experienced

Means even positive comments shouldnt be made

rrhuth · 21/12/2021 20:27

@TractorAndHeadphones I never said refugees were a homogenous mass - that is exactly why people should meet a few before spouting shit.

rrhuth · 21/12/2021 20:25

@RufustheFloralmissingreindeer

How many of you have bothered to get to know any refugees and listened to what they have been through and what they want for their lives? Until you have done that, until you have sat in a room with someone who has made that choice and you have listened to them firsthand, I don't think you are qualified to discuss this topic

You realise that anyone like myself who absolutely thinks that people should be safe and rescued and helped should also not comment due to your ‘rule’

Always a topic that makes me very angry.

Absolutely sick of the ignorant shits who have never once spoken to anyone in this situation talking absolute crap.

There are some moral absolutes. Knowingly leaving people to drown is wrong.

Georgeskitchen · 21/12/2021 20:22

The RNLI never ignore distress calls in British waters. In French waters they are the responsibility of the French rescue services. Many are economic migrants who are not fleeing war zones. The UK have given sanctuary to many families fleeing war and for that we should be very proud. Anyone else should apply through legal processes to live here rather than try to enter illegally, at their own risk. So no, we should not be sued if they unfortunately lose their lives trying to enter illegally

TractorAndHeadphones · 21/12/2021 20:21

@rrhuth

How many of you have bothered to get to know any refugees and listened to what they have been through and what they want for their lives? Until you have done that, until you have sat in a room with someone who has made that choice and you have listened to them firsthand, I don't think you are qualified to discuss this topic.

I hate these threads. Those who think we shouldn't help are a disgrace and the views expressed sometimes make me wish karma really was a thing.

It is unfortunately a function of democracy that the general public has to have an opinion on topics that they're not qualified to comment on. Most of us would love to not comment, and just enjoy drinking our tea, but we can't do that.

'Refugees' themselves are not a homogenous mass. I have worked with them across several countries and in different contexts. The majority of refugees are resettled in neighbouring countries anyway, and certainly not in Europe. What's similar is that people have a glorified image of certain countries - are willing to risk everything to go there, aren't disabused of that notion and then when they get there realise it's not what they were told. Britain has a reputation for being more welcoming/diverse, better benefits, but also easier to stay even if your claim is denied, to go underground (as there's no national ID here). Many come and find that it's not so great after all. Of course something are true like language being easier (also translators etc being easier to find) but life here isn't easy.

This isn't limited to refugees. A lot of people from my home country come to the U.K for university, planning never to return. Thinking that it's easy to get a job in the UK, there's lots of opportunity here, schools hospitals and the social structure is great. Our country doesn't have things like benefits.
Many end up returning eventually after realising that they'd need to save umpteen years to buy a house, it takes ages to get an NHS specialist appointment and many state schools are crap.

And these are people who have full access to the internet obviously but you don't really get it until you've gone there yourself.

People shouldn't be left to drown, of course. But they shouldn't be encouraged to make the journey. Blaming governments for letting people drown is a sticking plaster. It's not addressing the true issue.

GucciBear · 21/12/2021 20:04

Headoverhead. Thank you - some sensible comments at last.

RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 21/12/2021 20:03

How many of you have bothered to get to know any refugees and listened to what they have been through and what they want for their lives? Until you have done that, until you have sat in a room with someone who has made that choice and you have listened to them firsthand, I don't think you are qualified to discuss this topic

You realise that anyone like myself who absolutely thinks that people should be safe and rescued and helped should also not comment due to your ‘rule’

rrhuth · 21/12/2021 19:48

How many of you have bothered to get to know any refugees and listened to what they have been through and what they want for their lives? Until you have done that, until you have sat in a room with someone who has made that choice and you have listened to them firsthand, I don't think you are qualified to discuss this topic.

I hate these threads. Those who think we shouldn't help are a disgrace and the views expressed sometimes make me wish karma really was a thing.

Justkeeppedaling · 21/12/2021 19:47

Surely the traffickers should be sued for manslaughter. It was they who caused the deaths of these, and many other people

lifeturnsonadime · 21/12/2021 19:44

come here

lifeturnsonadime · 21/12/2021 19:43

This thread is really shocking.

It is completely and utterly reprehensible to let people drown if you know they are drowning because you don't like their politics and don't want them to come her.

Yes the traffickers are ultimately responsible BUT any government which wilfully allows people to die should be held accountable.

Teaandcakeordeath83 · 21/12/2021 19:43

The easiest way to shut down the traffickers is to have centres set up in France/ the countries of origin or through the diplomatic embassies where these poor people can apply for asylum safely and without having to resort to risking their lives. By having absolutely no strategy to deal with these people anywhere other than UK soil we are inviting these disasters to carry on unfolding and empowering the traffickers. Remember how many of these cases actually get refugee status when they are processed here, these aren't fraudulent applications- we aren't giving them safe options to take.

Politicians have no appetite for actually doing anything remotely sensible though and would much rather vilify these people. Too bloody consumed with their precious tough on immigration narrative and demonising everyone else as "other".

If our emergency services deliberately ignored the distress call when/if it was in our waters or France did the same then they are just as accountable as the traffickers. It is reprehensible.

RuggerHug · 21/12/2021 19:36

Well Bagamoyo1 it seems like utter cuntery but I thought I'd give them a chance to explain themselves just in case I misinterpreted it.

Woeismethischristmas · 21/12/2021 19:36

If I decided to take a dinghy to France and drowned en route. It’d be my fault. I think those who got on the boat were responsible for their own safety. Obviously the smugglers supplying the boats were also responsible for encouraging people to get on a non- seaworthy craft.

Fanmango · 21/12/2021 19:35

Surely they should be putting pressure on finding the people that are making huge profits off of trafficking people. No, I don't think they should sue.

Bagamoyo1 · 21/12/2021 19:34

@RuggerHug

You want to add context to that wink littleroundrobin or was it just a twitch?
Do you genuinely not understand? Because I can probably explain if you like.
MatildaIThink · 21/12/2021 19:30

@IamnotSethRogan
Sorry have you see the state of the jungle ? You think that's a nice safe place ?
They are in "The Jungle", because they refuse to register in France, if they registered in France and claimed asylum they would be housed, fed, kept safe, their children educated etc.

They are making a choice to live illegally in France, to refuse the help and protection of the French state. France homes and feeds tens of thousands of asylum seekers every year, the ones trying to cross the Channel refuse to engage with that system.