Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the UK and France should not be sued for manslaughter over migrants drowning?

215 replies

OneRuleForThem · 21/12/2021 17:52

A humanitarian group are suing the two countries saying they left migrants to drown. AIBU to think this isn’t right? I don’t think either “left” anybody to drown and they need to realise that getting on an inflatable boat packed to the rafters and attempting to cross the Channel isn’t a good idea.

OP posts:
rrhuth · 21/12/2021 22:04

@Theythinkitsalloveritisnow

I don't think there is a perfect world, but I think there are ethical rights and wrongs, and there is law, and cases like this can be taken to court to see where the line is at present.

The word 'discouraged' is often used but rarely explained in detail. If any 'discouragement' results in harm, it may not be ethical or legal IMO, and therefore should be challenged.

EmpressCixi · 21/12/2021 22:03

The case is being filed specifically for the one incident on 24th November this year where a boat capsized off Calais, in French waters, drowning 27 migrants.

I agree with suing the French government because it was reported by eyewitnesses that French authorities on the beach did nothing to try and stop them. They just watched them overload that death trap and push off.

I don’t agree with suing the British government though as the agreement with the French is that they should be trying to prevent migrants from attempting to cross. In addition, the tragedy happened in French waters, where British ships do not patrol and so there is no possibility that a British ship or lifeboat would even have been in the area to have then callously leave these people to drown as some have alleged “might have happened”. No evidence it did, and if there was any ship in those waters it would have been a French ship because it’s their waters.

Crazykatie · 21/12/2021 22:02

The French would look after migrants that want to stay in France, those crossing the channel don’t want to stay in France. There is no law to stop them getting into a boat and sailing away “IF” they all agree, if the traffickers are caught they can be prosecuted but not the migrants.

It’s a dangerous crossing I’m surprised more havn’t died but you can’t stop people taking risks, the UK is picking up as many as they can when the enter our waters

Theythinkitsalloveritisnow · 21/12/2021 21:57

@rrhuth

Well it means that the most vulnerable often get left behind confused, it seems fucked up to me. And if you want to minimise deaths then doing nothing to stop people trying to cross the channel also seems fucked up confused. I'm sure you're very well meaning, but has it occurred to you that people like yourself aren't actually doing anything positive?
  • yes it is a fucked up system
  • yes fewer crossings would be better
  • 'people like you' - WTF? I don't know you, you don't know me

My point is that people who are crossing should not be left to drown.

Actually I apologize for that, it was off hand and nasty. But I think there are a lot of people who are themselves lovely, who think the world should be lovely + that the right way to act is to pretend that it's lovely. But it often comes with serious, unintended consequences, in this case people not being discouraged from risking their lives trying to cross the channel, which results in people dying. Confused. It needs realistic approaches, not a "wouldn't everything be fantastic if there were no borders" stuff.
TractorAndHeadphones · 21/12/2021 21:44

@rrhuth

Well it means that the most vulnerable often get left behind confused, it seems fucked up to me. And if you want to minimise deaths then doing nothing to stop people trying to cross the channel also seems fucked up confused. I'm sure you're very well meaning, but has it occurred to you that people like yourself aren't actually doing anything positive?
  • yes it is a fucked up system
  • yes fewer crossings would be better
  • 'people like you' - WTF? I don't know you, you don't know me

My point is that people who are crossing should not be left to drown.

Given that scores of boats made the crossing ; and ONE drowned. Do you really think that they were just told ‘no go back to France’?

Nobody is saying that people should be left to drown. But equally rescue boats shouldn’t be used as accessories to smuggler’s plans.

Fair enough if the enquiry reveals that they did indeed turn them down, they should be punished. However the narrative is that governments are to blame?

They are - in my opinion. But not for failure to recuse people (which is what they have been doing). For failure to stop them making the crossing.

Ironically maybe the case will actually make both countries actually do something to stop people crossing.

EightWheelGirl · 21/12/2021 21:43

Were my family at risk in a war torn country I'd likely do whatever I could to get them to somewhere safer. But what is the long term solution? Surely Europe can't ultimately resettle all the people who would wish to relocate here from the wider world.

rrhuth · 21/12/2021 21:31

Well it means that the most vulnerable often get left behind confused, it seems fucked up to me. And if you want to minimise deaths then doing nothing to stop people trying to cross the channel also seems fucked up confused. I'm sure you're very well meaning, but has it occurred to you that people like yourself aren't actually doing anything positive?

  • yes it is a fucked up system
  • yes fewer crossings would be better
  • 'people like you' - WTF? I don't know you, you don't know me

My point is that people who are crossing should not be left to drown.

EightWheelGirl · 21/12/2021 21:25

The number of people living in slavery today is nearly 4x greater than the entire number of African slaves traded over the trans Atlantic slavery period spanning almost 350 years.

Makes you wonder why people seem keener to moan about what happened hundreds of years ago rather than address what is now an even bigger problem in today's society.

Theythinkitsalloveritisnow · 21/12/2021 21:21

@rrhuth

Ime the people are often lovely, the system however is a total shit show and leaves the most vulnerable in their home countries while the well off and fit fight to the front of the queue to get to the UK. It's not cheap to pay people traffickers!

The fact that others who can not pay also deserve the chance does not mean those who do have the resources to pay are not deserving. The system is undoubtedly a mess, but the fact the system pushes people to illegal routes does not mean those people do not have good claim.

Well it means that the most vulnerable often get left behind Confused, it seems fucked up to me. And if you want to minimise deaths then doing nothing to stop people trying to cross the channel also seems fucked up Confused. I'm sure you're very well meaning, but has it occurred to you that people like yourself aren't actually doing anything positive?
Flaxmeadow · 21/12/2021 21:21

Considering how many people as a country we've raped, enslaved, robbed and murdered over the years, it's good to see all the heartless racists are still alive and well

'We' did not rape, rob, enslave, murder. 'We' come from working class labourers who had no say or vote on any policy on colonialism. Most people never left the tonw or city they were born in

The people enslaving these migrants now are the traffickers, big crime bosses from corrupt and failed states

mclaw · 21/12/2021 21:16

I think they should sue the people trafficking groups (including any NGOs) who organise the journeys. It's a very lucrative (albeit immoral) business for some.

yep

EightWheelGirl · 21/12/2021 21:15

Considering how many people as a country we've raped, enslaved, robbed and murdered over the years, it's good to see all the heartless racists are still alive and well.

Like most European countries have and many non-European countries continue to.

rrhuth · 21/12/2021 21:15

Ime the people are often lovely, the system however is a total shit show and leaves the most vulnerable in their home countries while the well off and fit fight to the front of the queue to get to the UK. It's not cheap to pay people traffickers!

The fact that others who can not pay also deserve the chance does not mean those who do have the resources to pay are not deserving. The system is undoubtedly a mess, but the fact the system pushes people to illegal routes does not mean those people do not have good claim.

Flaxmeadow · 21/12/2021 21:12

...also some of the migrants themselves will be involved or become involved in some of the organised crime

Flaxmeadow · 21/12/2021 21:10

However the bigger problem is the traffickers and we need to get together with other countries and actually do something about them

The problem is those countries, often corrupt, have no will to do anything and just turn a blind eye. The traffickers pay off officials, the police etc. Its big international business. They don't care if the migrants drown, infact they know they will in some instances, as long as they get the money. Then others profit here from forced labour in increasingly corrupted parts of our own towns and cities

The Sky news report on YouTube -Worlds Most Wanted People Smuggler- gives some idea of this horrific slave trade, orchestrated by crime bosses in places like Pakistan & Ethiopia. Like drug smugglers they have connections across Europe. The migrants are like shipping tins of baked beans to them

Onemumtwokids · 21/12/2021 21:07

The legal question is whether the RNLI have a “duty of care” towards these people. I would say no. They are a charity who do their best not a service like the ambulance service. The volunteers put their own lives at risk going out in rough seas and placing a professional duty of care on them is not reasonable and will discourage future volunteers.

I would say the same about Mountain rescue teams. When people choose to do risky activities and get into trouble that requires help from other’s who are volunteering and taking a risk themselves they are very lucky to get that help. It’s not a right.

MatildaIThink · 21/12/2021 21:07

@rrhuth

How many of you have bothered to get to know any refugees and listened to what they have been through and what they want for their lives? Until you have done that, until you have sat in a room with someone who has made that choice and you have listened to them firsthand, I don't think you are qualified to discuss this topic.

I hate these threads. Those who think we shouldn't help are a disgrace and the views expressed sometimes make me wish karma really was a thing.

I work with two people who came to the UK and claimed asylum, one is an Iraqi Kurd, the other is a Bosniak from Kosovo. They do not represent all refugees or asylum seekers, they will in no way represent economic migrants. They suffered war, seeing friends and family killed in front of them, they fled in utter fear for their lives. They both claimed asylum in the first safe country they arrived in, for both that ended up being Greece. They then came to the UK through the EU scheme (of which we are no longer part).

They are both of the view that those crossing the Channel are utterly insane, France is safe and would look after them, probably better than the UK would look after them. I support the UK accepting genuine refugees, I support us joining joint international schemes for managing the distribution of genuine asylum seekers. That does not mean I think it is a good think to allow, or even encourage unofficial immigration, asylum shopping, or undocumented economic migration.

I agree that there needs to be a better way to manage asylum claims and to discourage economic migration, to protect asylum seekers, I don't see that discouraging people from crossing the Channel in inflatable boats is a bad thing, I don't see France as some hellhole that people need to flee.

Theythinkitsalloveritisnow · 21/12/2021 21:06

rruth well I do some work with refugees so am I allowed to comment? Hmm

Ime the people are often lovely, the system however is a total shit show and leaves the most vulnerable in their home countries while the well off and fit fight to the front of the queue to get to the UK. It's not cheap to pay people traffickers!

Wrt to suing the rescue services, sure, go after the people risking their own lives to help those at sea and ignore the people traffickers, the French police not making any effort to stop people, politicians in both countries who won't put in any policies that could actually help the situation....

lovelyupnorth · 21/12/2021 21:04

@Georgeskitchen

The RNLI never ignore distress calls in British waters. In French waters they are the responsibility of the French rescue services. Many are economic migrants who are not fleeing war zones. The UK have given sanctuary to many families fleeing war and for that we should be very proud. Anyone else should apply through legal processes to live here rather than try to enter illegally, at their own risk. So no, we should not be sued if they unfortunately lose their lives trying to enter illegally
Which legal process is that? not sure it exsists currently thats part of the problem.

And whats wrong with economic migrants if they want to come and work bring it on, we are desperately short of workers and that problem is going to get a lot worse over the next few years considering we have an ageing population, low birth rate and have told all the Europeans to fuck off. someones going to need to wipe your arse in the future.

rrhuth · 21/12/2021 21:02

@RufustheFloralmissingreindeer

My point still remains

You are telling everyone whether their comments are positive or negative to ‘shut the fuck up’

And I’m fairly sure that if the thread was just full of detractors you’d complain that no one was sympathetic…because all the sympathetic people are keeping quiet

Quite Obviously I’m going to leave this now because I don’t want to derail

Is there never a topic where you think you should pipe down? There are many where I think I should pipe down (I gave some examples above).
lovelyupnorth · 21/12/2021 21:00

Considering how many people as a country we've raped, enslaved, robbed and murdered over the years, it's good to see all the heartless racists are still alive and well.

Maybe the UK government should set up a safe way they can apply for asylum en-route in say France, if they get rejected they then could apply for other countries.

We take in 1/10th of the asylum seekers of any other EU country, but then we are a heartless bunch on self-seeking racists that voted for brexit and Johnson.

Lets hope they win the cast

SpamIAm · 21/12/2021 20:57

@TractorAndHeadphones it's criminal because it's against the law? International law (SOLAS) places a duty on all ships to attempt to rescue people in danger at sea.

EightWheelGirl · 21/12/2021 20:56

If just a couple of boats are discouraged from crossing by this tragedy, the net saving of life may outnumber the 27 tragic deaths.

TractorAndHeadphones · 21/12/2021 20:55

@RufustheFloralmissingreindeer

My point still remains

You are telling everyone whether their comments are positive or negative to ‘shut the fuck up’

And I’m fairly sure that if the thread was just full of detractors you’d complain that no one was sympathetic…because all the sympathetic people are keeping quiet

Quite Obviously I’m going to leave this now because I don’t want to derail

No, you're perfectly right and again the BBC use this technique of course when they do human interest stories they pick the ones likely to elicit the best reactions

having actually worked with refugees I don't have a blanket 'ye everyone should be let in where they want' policy any more. I used to have a more permissive stance being an immigrant myself so quite strangely it's gone in the opposite direction

RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 21/12/2021 20:47

My point still remains

You are telling everyone whether their comments are positive or negative to ‘shut the fuck up’

And I’m fairly sure that if the thread was just full of detractors you’d complain that no one was sympathetic…because all the sympathetic people are keeping quiet

Quite Obviously I’m going to leave this now because I don’t want to derail