Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the UK and France should not be sued for manslaughter over migrants drowning?

215 replies

OneRuleForThem · 21/12/2021 17:52

A humanitarian group are suing the two countries saying they left migrants to drown. AIBU to think this isn’t right? I don’t think either “left” anybody to drown and they need to realise that getting on an inflatable boat packed to the rafters and attempting to cross the Channel isn’t a good idea.

OP posts:
vivainsomnia · 22/12/2021 09:11

nobody is saying that anybody should be left to drown. If evidence really comes out saying they were told to piss off and drown then yes, completely fair. And the legal challenge is certainly allowed
That's exactly what some posters have implied. Their choice, their risk.

So ultimately, you agree that it is fair to raise a legal battle in case indeed, they raised the alarm and were told as claimed that both countries put the onus on the other and ignore their plea.... for 11 hours.

If it comes out in court that they never called, or they did, but there were genuine reasons why they couldn't get to them in time, that's fair enough. That's why we have a court system.

To say that they shouldn't even be allowed to plead their case because it's their fault they died for wanting a better life is inhuman.

AuntyBumBum · 22/12/2021 09:09

You are being thoroughly unreasonable, and prejudiced in the true meaning of the word. If there's no case then the claimants will lose.

PoloMintHum · 22/12/2021 09:07

Yanbu. If all illegal entries to the UK were returned then there wouldn't be this issue. There needs to be a process whereby migrants can apply from other countries before they get here and be accepted or rejected.

TractorAndHeadphones · 22/12/2021 09:05

If it’s not clear this was bound to happen sooner or later!

My replies aren’t clear perhaps as I don’t disagree with the legal challenge. In fact it might force governments to actually do something to stop people from crossing. Like fence the beach or send them back to France.

But in terms of ‘legal challenge because these people are owed rescue’ - this was an accident waiting to happen. I’m inclined to believe that based on the costs guards’ previous records they were not roundly told to piss off. If they were I will gladly change my opinion. But the mindset that’s it’s something shocking is like holding a bowl of honey at an odd angle and being shocked that some of it fell down.

HotPenguin · 22/12/2021 09:05

There's a story about this case on the BBC news website. One young woman who died was coming here because she wanted to be a doctor. It's terrible but I don't think offering a taxi service across the channel is the solution. I also feel the charities in the UK who provide food, shelter, clothes etc to people in the jungle need to take a hard look at themselves - they're basically providing a service to people smugglers by providing them with a steady stream of victims, some of whom wouldn't come if charities weren't facilitating it.

TractorAndHeadphones · 22/12/2021 09:01

@vivainsomnia

OMG, 75% agreeing. This the most harrowing thread I've read especially so close to Xmas.

I'm so glad to hear both countries are being sued. These people called the authorities. First the French who said they were in British waters. By the time they called the British, they had drifted back to French waters. It is utterly utterly utterly disgraceful.

Agree, it was a choice they made or their parents and caregivers made for them. It is a choice to come to the UK
So next time you go on holiday abroad, your kids struggle in the sea, is it ok for the locals to watch and let them die because it was your choice to go in holiday to their country.

Utterly depressing how selfish, self righteous and completely deprived of any human kindness people have become.

Strange how all the people who have ACTUALLY worked with refugees have given more balanced views - including refugees themselves Hmm

nobody is saying that anybody should be left to drown. If evidence really comes out saying they were told to piss off and drown then yes, completely fair. And the legal challenge is certainly allowed.

What people are talking about is the expectation that a rescue team much like an ambulance service would be sent out immediately. From what I have read they don’t have an army of boats standing by, they received several calls and rescue sometimes cannot be attempted because of weather, because they’re too far etc etc. If they’re closer to the French channel for example it’s common sense to get French boats which are nearer to rescue them rather than faffing about to get a British boat which might be too late. They can’t teleport.

Since several thousands of crossings have been made without failing the evidence is that the rescuers are actually very good at their job. This is not the latest in the series of tragedies. This is one boat capsizing which given what they’re trying to do is not an unpredictable consequence!

However the language used in the media demonises the rescues services and completely portrays the refugees as innocent people who are owed a service. That this something shocking, that should never have happened.

Once again I repeat they should not be left to drown but they do bear some responsibility for making the journey. It’s unexpected and shocking for something with all safety features to sink. It’s NOT shocking for an overloaded rubber dinghy to sink. The fact that so many so far have been rescued is the miracle rather than the other way around.

vivainsomnia · 22/12/2021 08:46

I would say the same about Mountain rescue teams. When people choose to do risky activities and get into trouble that requires help from other’s who are volunteering and taking a risk themselves they are very lucky to get that help. It’s not a right
So easy to say when it's you being affected isn't it? Easy to focus on activities that you yourself most likely to engage in.

How about sati go that we should have lifeguards in pools because if you chose to go swimming in the local pool and your kid struggles, it was your choice to take your kid swimming.

If you have a car accident because for a second, you lost your concentration, you shouldn't get help because it was your choice to take your kids to a Xmas show?

Or maybe, if your house goes in flame because you forgot to turn all the Xmas tree lights off at night, that too would be your choice so why should firefighters risk their life for you.

Such a self centred view of the world when those concerned are so remove from anything you are incredibly lucky to never have to experience in your life.

EwwSprouts · 22/12/2021 08:44

Sorry that was a PP post that I meant to bold.

I agree with it.

EwwSprouts · 22/12/2021 08:43

It depends.
If nobody knew they were there then obviously not.
But if they were alerted that there were people in trouble in the ocean and they did nothing then yes they should be held accountable.

vivainsomnia · 22/12/2021 08:41

OMG, 75% agreeing. This the most harrowing thread I've read especially so close to Xmas.

I'm so glad to hear both countries are being sued. These people called the authorities. First the French who said they were in British waters. By the time they called the British, they had drifted back to French waters. It is utterly utterly utterly disgraceful.

Agree, it was a choice they made or their parents and caregivers made for them. It is a choice to come to the UK
So next time you go on holiday abroad, your kids struggle in the sea, is it ok for the locals to watch and let them die because it was your choice to go in holiday to their country.

Utterly depressing how selfish, self righteous and completely deprived of any human kindness people have become.

Campervan69 · 22/12/2021 08:40

@Onemumtwokids

The legal question is whether the RNLI have a “duty of care” towards these people. I would say no. They are a charity who do their best not a service like the ambulance service. The volunteers put their own lives at risk going out in rough seas and placing a professional duty of care on them is not reasonable and will discourage future volunteers.

I would say the same about Mountain rescue teams. When people choose to do risky activities and get into trouble that requires help from other’s who are volunteering and taking a risk themselves they are very lucky to get that help. It’s not a right.

This
IncompleteSenten · 22/12/2021 08:03

@EightWheelGirl

If somebody got in their car drunk and later tried to sue me for not stopping them I'd be a bit Confused.
Would you have been a police officer on duty when you watched them and did nothing? Because only that would be comparable to emergency services not attending an emergency situation.

Nobody would sue an individual who happened to notice a boat now would they?

Offmyfence · 22/12/2021 07:41

@Crazykatie

“They are in France, a safe country. They do not need to get to the UK. Just why are they all so keen to get here?.”

Many have friends and family in the UK, English is their second language, often quite good, we treat migrants better that other countries. Once they arrive here they all claim Political Assylum proving that false is very difficult in the majority of cases.

The personal stories of individual migrants is heartbreaking but how many should the UK allow, because half of Africa and much of the Third World travel here .

So we let them drown? Because we've "got enough"

I think some people forget these are also sons, brothers, mothers, fathers and real people!

MatildaIThink · 22/12/2021 06:51

@TooBigForMyBoots
You are not a state force.fbiscuit If someone gets in their car drunk and the cops stand back and watch, that's different.
The best comparison in this case would be that the person got in their car drunk, went and crashed their car, then after a phone call asking for help saying that they had crashed "Somewhere in Kent", could not be found before they died. It is one thing to watch and refuse to help, it is entirely different to be asked for help, but not be able to help because you do not know where that person is, whilst also dealing with 50+ other simultaneous car crashes.

Crazykatie · 22/12/2021 06:05

“They are in France, a safe country. They do not need to get to the UK. Just why are they all so keen to get here?.”

Many have friends and family in the UK, English is their second language, often quite good, we treat migrants better that other countries. Once they arrive here they all claim Political Assylum proving that false is very difficult in the majority of cases.

The personal stories of individual migrants is heartbreaking but how many should the UK allow, because half of Africa and much of the Third World travel here .

Offmyfence · 22/12/2021 03:52

@FruitFeatures

All of the responses saying basically that it’s ok that they were left to freeze to death in terror are absolutely sickening. You are sociopaths. You do realise you’re talking about human beings, right?
This 💯
TooBigForMyBoots · 22/12/2021 01:04

@EightWheelGirl

If somebody got in their car drunk and later tried to sue me for not stopping them I'd be a bit Confused.
You are not a state force.Xmas Biscuit If someone gets in their car drunk and the cops stand back and watch, that's different.
mydogisthebest · 21/12/2021 23:39

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

FruitFeatures · 21/12/2021 23:18

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

EmpressCixi · 21/12/2021 23:11

Don’t forget that on the 24th, this wasn’t the only boat attempting the crossing. Every day there were dozens of boats. On November 11th a new record was set with 1,185 migrants making the crossing that day. Hundreds are being rescued every day, so it’s not realistic to expect that everyone can be saved. Similar to how many patients have died waiting in ambulance queues to get to A&E because of the NHS being overwhelmed.

From what I know, there was no distress call. No flares. Nothing. A French fisherman discovered the bodies and capsized boat and then called the French coast guard straight away. They were all already dead when they were discovered.
www.france24.com/en/live-news/20211126-so-many-dead-next-to-us-fisherman-recounts-channel-migrant-drama

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 21/12/2021 22:54

I dont know the ins and outs of it.

But I do think the fact that the migrants might have made 'stupid decisions' should be irrelevant. Medics save people who have chosen not to be vaccinated even though they are vulnerable. Mountain rescue save people who have chosen to climb mountains in bad weather with no experience or equipment or provisions. Paramedics save people who have drank far too much or done some idiotic activities like tombstoming or some weird tiktok trend involving drinking household cleaning products. If we start deciding who to save based on moral judgements about their own contribution to their situation then it's a slippery slope to removing treatment for obese people etc by the nhs, its not for us to make those judgements.

So they should sue if there is a case to answer in my opinion

EightWheelGirl · 21/12/2021 22:38

If somebody got in their car drunk and later tried to sue me for not stopping them I'd be a bit Confused.

Brainwave89 · 21/12/2021 22:33

Let’s wait and see what the evidence says. I personally doubt distress calls were actively ignored. If this were the case there would be many more instances of deaths in the channel. Due to the excellent work of the coastguards and RNLI fortunately there have not been large numbers of deaths. Fundamentally I believe that we should strongly discourage anyone from getting into an unsafe boat to cross the channel. Whilst the UK should take some refugees this should be capped and the Dover route should be closed down by agreeing automatic repatriation back to France, which is a safe country.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 21/12/2021 22:28

How many of you have bothered to get to know any refugees and listened to what they have been through and what they want for their lives?

I haven't known any refugees who've used people smugglers, but have interviewed a UK organisation who profess to act on their behalf and what struck me was their willingness to accept whatever they were told without question - indeed the very idea that things might not be exactly as presented was incomprehensible to them, maybe at least partly becase they themselves were lying to secure their funding

I don't imagine that anyone wants refugees to die, whether in the channel or elsewhere, but before getting too excited about this it might be worth waiting to find out what actually happened - which may or may not tally with the tale Utopia 56 have to tell

TooBigForMyBoots · 21/12/2021 22:07

If they ignored intelligence, distress signasl or their own rules, then they should be sued.