Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the UK and France should not be sued for manslaughter over migrants drowning?

215 replies

OneRuleForThem · 21/12/2021 17:52

A humanitarian group are suing the two countries saying they left migrants to drown. AIBU to think this isn’t right? I don’t think either “left” anybody to drown and they need to realise that getting on an inflatable boat packed to the rafters and attempting to cross the Channel isn’t a good idea.

OP posts:
Paquerette · 22/12/2021 14:36

@vivainsomnia

We know the traffickers are scumbags. No need to distract the issue here which is whether the French and British authorities acted as they should.

What I read is that the seas were calm that day, there wasn't unexpected huge activities and rescues. They were in the water fir 11 hours. They claim they called both authorities and each pass the buck saying they were in the other side of waters and so not their responsibility.

If this is all untrue, then fair enough. If it true then, absolutely that some should be held responsible.

That's why it is fair enough there should be a court case to get it all out in the open.

This was on BBC news last night. The coastguards had 90 calls that day, the boat left France at 10 pm, and sank a couple of hours later.

The traffickers MO is to put an overloaded unseaworthy boat out to sea, and the passengers are given the phone number of the UK coastguards to call and ask for help. In that situation, with pretty much every boat calling for help, in the dark, it must be difficult to figure out which boats need immediate assistance, and where they are.

DeepaBeesKit · 22/12/2021 13:28

No matter what anyone says, france, or the numerous other countries surrounding it through which migrants pass, is not a war zone. It is a safe developed country. Only a minority of migrants are determined to settle in the UK, far more happily opt for Germany or France because these are fundamentally safe places to rebuild your life. Migrants who drown in the channel have made a choice to go on those boats & to take their children with them. Its terribly sad, I suspect many are very misinformed when making those choices but it does not make it the fault of the UK or France that people put their lives at risk in this way.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 22/12/2021 13:21

[quote Lockheart]@daimbarsatemydogsbone when the choice is "get in the boat or we'll shoot you / your child" I would think that's very simple, don't you?

www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2021/11/25/bit-like-drowning-scene-film-titanic/

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10244087/The-migrants-told-cross-shot-SUE-REID-exposes-trade.html[/quote]
At that point I agree it's a simple choice - but there's always a lot in the run up to that point.

For the avoidance of doubt - I am not unsympathetic to the plight of these people at all - I am sure there's every likelihood I'd do the same if I was them.

That's a different issue from the wider ones at play.

I do think the UK should establish better legal routes to facilitate refugees resettlement in the UK.

vivainsomnia · 22/12/2021 13:16

We know the traffickers are scumbags. No need to distract the issue here which is whether the French and British authorities acted as they should.

What I read is that the seas were calm that day, there wasn't unexpected huge activities and rescues. They were in the water fir 11 hours. They claim they called both authorities and each pass the buck saying they were in the other side of waters and so not their responsibility.

If this is all untrue, then fair enough. If it true then, absolutely that some should be held responsible.

That's why it is fair enough there should be a court case to get it all out in the open.

TractorAndHeadphones · 22/12/2021 12:18

@Theunamedcat

We cannot solve the worlds problems Afghanistan is a good example of this 10 years of occupation reverts in 7 days

Seriously what was the point? politics? Did we actually help ANYONE by going in?

We could however not interfere at all. War needs resources and prolonging what should just have been a civil war in the name of ‘democracy’ doesn’t do any good. Even countries that ostensibly have ‘dictators’ while not the best place for human rights can remain relatively stable. Only the people of a country can fight for change, nobody else and it’s a gradual cycle.
Theunamedcat · 22/12/2021 12:11

We cannot solve the worlds problems Afghanistan is a good example of this 10 years of occupation reverts in 7 days

Seriously what was the point? politics? Did we actually help ANYONE by going in?

rrhuth · 22/12/2021 11:17

@Tiny2018

As per usual, this is a poor attempt to paper over the cracks of the issue rather than get to the route of the problem.

Put the money towards dismantling and imprisoning the trafficking rings who shamelessly profit from people desperately in search of a better life for themselves and their families.

But the trafficking is not the root of the problem.

The root of the problem is in war zones, in Afghanistan, Syria, Libya and in oppression/turture in so many other countries, and the fact there is no safe way out.

Some see a perilous journey as less scary than staying put or years stagnating in refugee camps. I understand why some choose the option.

My mind is constantly blown by the fact I got born here, and they got born there. The randomness of life still makes me feel weird.

AuntyBumBum · 22/12/2021 11:09

@thedefinitionofmadness

Threads like this make me want to leave mumsnet forever (again) But I suppose it is good to understand how little understanding or compassion there is in the world. No-one puts their child in a boat unless the water is safer than the land.

Our immigration policy (and France's) is what causes people to have to try to enter the country in perilous ways. And those policies are based on racism and economic policy founded on the model that we don't have enough to go round.

Well said, I'm hoping that the thread title is attracting a certain type of person, and is not representative, but it's pretty depressing.
thereisonlyoneofme · 22/12/2021 11:05

Sorry havent read all the posts but if they did make a call and no response perhaps it was because the lifeboats etc were already overwhelmed rescuing other migrants ?

RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 22/12/2021 11:01

An acquaintance of mine worked in the navy and patrolled foreign waters

They said that the traffickers would overload boats and not worry about the seaworthiness of the vessel, they would also force people into the boats

Didnt matter to them whether those people finished the journey alive

Tragic

Lockheart · 22/12/2021 10:38

@daimbarsatemydogsbone when the choice is "get in the boat or we'll shoot you / your child" I would think that's very simple, don't you?

www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2021/11/25/bit-like-drowning-scene-film-titanic/

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10244087/The-migrants-told-cross-shot-SUE-REID-exposes-trade.html

vivainsomnia · 22/12/2021 10:33

Utopia 56 said it “intends that investigations be carried out to determine the responsibilities of the French and British rescue services in this tragedy,” adding that the people were abandoned “despite calls to the English and French rescue services
Yet 70% of Mumsnet think that it's their own fault and they have no right to seek to know the truth as to what happened or didn't happen.

Threads like this make me want to leave mumsnet forever (again)
I agree. I've read quite a few shocking threads but this one leaves me completely deflated about humanity especially when lost in between all the threads moaning about Xmas Sad

thedefinitionofmadness · 22/12/2021 10:26

Threads like this make me want to leave mumsnet forever (again)
But I suppose it is good to understand how little understanding or compassion there is in the world. No-one puts their child in a boat unless the water is safer than the land.

Our immigration policy (and France's) is what causes people to have to try to enter the country in perilous ways. And those policies are based on racism and economic policy founded on the model that we don't have enough to go round.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 22/12/2021 10:22

@Chasingaftermidnight

I certainly would not risk my children's lives crossing the Channel in a leaky inflatable boat

No. No one would do that for fun. So… what does that tell you about the position these people are in?

It's not quite that simple is it?
daimbarsatemydogsbone · 22/12/2021 10:14

www.france24.com/en/europe/20211220-france-uk-authorities-face-manslaughter-lawsuit-over-deaths-of-27-migrants-in-channel-capsizing

The Paris prosecutor’s office said it has received a manslaughter lawsuit for failure to help in the tragic capsizing last month of a boat in the English Channel that cost the lives of at least 27 people trying to reach Britain.

The manslaughter lawsuit, filed Friday by the French humanitarian organization Utopia 56, accuses the maritime prefect of the Channel and North Sea, the Regional Operational Centre for Surveillance and Rescue of Gris-Nez in the Pas-de-Calais and the British Coast Guard of not doing enough to prevent the deaths.

Utopia 56 said it “intends that investigations be carried out to determine the responsibilities of the French and British rescue services in this tragedy,” adding that the people were abandoned “despite calls to the English and French rescue services.”

Chasingaftermidnight · 22/12/2021 10:14

I certainly would not risk my children's lives crossing the Channel in a leaky inflatable boat

No. No one would do that for fun. So… what does that tell you about the position these people are in?

Tiny2018 · 22/12/2021 10:11

As per usual, this is a poor attempt to paper over the cracks of the issue rather than get to the route of the problem.

Put the money towards dismantling and imprisoning the trafficking rings who shamelessly profit from people desperately in search of a better life for themselves and their families.

Chasingaftermidnight · 22/12/2021 10:10

Is France ‘safe and friendly’, if you’re living in one of the Calais camps?

Sure, France isn’t war torn. But I wouldn’t exactly describe the conditions in the migrant camps as humane.

anotherbrewplease · 22/12/2021 10:07

I certainly would not risk my children's lives crossing the Channel in a leaky inflatable boat

How very fortunate for you that you will never be put in a position to have to make such a choice. Because you're living in the 'right' part of the world - and because you are so obviously superior to some poor desperate sod.

Lockheart · 22/12/2021 10:07

Everyone's talking about them merrily getting into the boats as if it was a choice made entirely from free will.

How much free will do you think you have when a gun is being pointed at your or your child's head?

"They chose to get in" Hmm

anotherbrewplease · 22/12/2021 10:04

Utterly depressing how selfish, self righteous and completely deprived of any human kindness people have become

Completely agree with this.

Be prepared for a heck of a lot more refugees with Syria and Afghanistan continuing in crisis as well as mass migrations due to global warming.

Dragongirl10 · 22/12/2021 10:03

They decided to risk crossing the worlds busiest shipping lane, in bad weather, in an unfit boat. France is a safe and friendly country, as nice as the UK, not some hell hole. If I was fearing oppression and violence I would be happy to settle in Franch (or Germany, Italy, Spain, Portugal etc. which they will have passed through on the way), I certainly would not risk my children's lives crossing the Channel in a leaky inflatable boat.

This ^^

TractorAndHeadphones · 22/12/2021 09:58

@Puzzledandpissedoff

They were all already dead when they were discovered

I thought there were two survivors (?), but if they did all lose their lives, who told Utopia 56 about the calls/refusal to come and rescue them?

There were two survivors
Puzzledandpissedoff · 22/12/2021 09:52

They were all already dead when they were discovered

I thought there were two survivors (?), but if they did all lose their lives, who told Utopia 56 about the calls/refusal to come and rescue them?

Oneborneverydecade · 22/12/2021 09:12

@lifeturnsonadime

I think it is absolutely right that action be taken. If it is correct that distress calls were made and ignored then regardless the reasons they were in the waters if they could have been saved they should have been.

As a nation we shouldn't leave people to die. That's absolutely horrific.

This