Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the UK and France should not be sued for manslaughter over migrants drowning?

215 replies

OneRuleForThem · 21/12/2021 17:52

A humanitarian group are suing the two countries saying they left migrants to drown. AIBU to think this isn’t right? I don’t think either “left” anybody to drown and they need to realise that getting on an inflatable boat packed to the rafters and attempting to cross the Channel isn’t a good idea.

OP posts:
Puzzledandpissedoff · 22/12/2021 17:42

the Telegraph and other news outlets reported in August that all Afghan refugees can fly/ferry/train to U.K. with no passport or documents to claim asylum

Obvious question I know, but if this was allowed, how would anyone know whether they'd really originated in Afghanistan rather than somewhere else?

EmpressCixi · 22/12/2021 17:19

@tinierclanger
Some refugees do get places on the Eurostar, ferry or plane. I watched a BBC documentary that followed a refugee, Hassan, who paid for a fake Czech passport and then flew into Heathrow undetected. At which point he turned himself in to the border force as an asylum seeker.
m.youtube.com/watch?v=QeLSbI2oi7o

Liverpool bomber Emad Al Swealmeen reportedly entered the UK with a forged passport from Jordan.

Also, the Telegraph and other news outlets reported in August that all Afghan refugees can fly/ferry/train to U.K. with no passport or documents to claim asylum.

newname12345 · 22/12/2021 17:16

@tinierclanger The problem is that not everyone is coming here for the reasons you say.

Take Mohammed Shekha who one of the few survivors. There is a report of an interview with him on Kurdish TV where he said the only reason he was coming to the UK was to earn enough money (£45,000) to pay for medical treatment in India for his sister. He was then intending to return home to his family. I might be misunderstanding but he doesn't sound like a refugee who was fearing for his life.

tinierclanger · 22/12/2021 16:56

@user1471447863

Overloading a boat is stupid and asking for trouble

Using a small inflatable boat to cross the channel is asking for trouble when there are safer means, like buying a ferry, eurostar or plane ticket. Don't come out with any crap like they cannot afford a ticket - they pay these people smugglers thousands.

I know some bits of Calais are a shithole but its not exactly Kabul. Nobody is crossing the channel to escape war-torn France and while France may not be the wokest country its not like the gays/trans/nonbinary etc are sneaking themselves across the border to escape persecution.
They are safe in France, they can follow the correct procedure and apply for asylum there & come here in safety and comfort on the Eurostar once they are regularised

Those do-gooders time would be better spent helping these people use the correct legal channels in france.

Assuming you’re posting this in good faith, here is a link to an explanation of why asylum seekers don’t just get on a plane or ferry.

TL/DR because they can’t
www.liberties.eu/en/stories/why-refugees-do-not-take-the-plane/16316

Nayday · 22/12/2021 16:42

YABU and disrespectful to the circumstances of people getting on that boat to have written the words "they should have known...".

Yeah they probably did know - they were desperate and the fact you can't imagine being desperate and acting out of desperation is indicative of your privilege.

They weren't "safe" in jolly Calais as some have written. Their shelters destroyed before they travelled, no safe home to return to - some with relatives in the UK.

It's a fucking tragedy, can't you see that?

TractorAndHeadphones · 22/12/2021 16:32

@user1471447863

Overloading a boat is stupid and asking for trouble

Using a small inflatable boat to cross the channel is asking for trouble when there are safer means, like buying a ferry, eurostar or plane ticket. Don't come out with any crap like they cannot afford a ticket - they pay these people smugglers thousands.

I know some bits of Calais are a shithole but its not exactly Kabul. Nobody is crossing the channel to escape war-torn France and while France may not be the wokest country its not like the gays/trans/nonbinary etc are sneaking themselves across the border to escape persecution.
They are safe in France, they can follow the correct procedure and apply for asylum there & come here in safety and comfort on the Eurostar once they are regularised

Those do-gooders time would be better spent helping these people use the correct legal channels in france.

A lot of them don't have any passport or documentation, how do you expect them to buy a plane ticket? The smugglers are likely paid directly by whoever is gathering the money for them.

Don't spout such nonsense ...

TractorAndHeadphones · 22/12/2021 16:28

@Mamamia7962

But where are the migrants getting their money from? If the traffickers are charging between £3,000 - £6,000 per head, why are they not using that money to provide food for their families, no way would I let my children starve in a camp and rely on the French Govt for hand outs as and when if I had that amount of money.

They can only be forced on to a boat if they have the money to pay surely. A lot of this doesn't make sense.

Well a lot of the refugees are the privileged of their own country. That's how they managed to get this far. They have family, contacts etc who can put up the money. The refugees I know (i think a PP mentioned similar as well) have claimed asylum successfully in a 'safe' country and then just moved to the UK as an EU citizen. It's now more difficult. And the UK has very strict policies to prevent chain migration. You cannot bring your family over unless they are your spouse or children under 18. In very very rare circumstances you can bring your ageing parents over but only after proving there's no way they can stay in your home country. If they can just get to the UK however they can try to claim asylum and even if said claim is rejected they're unlikely to be deported.

This isn't limited to refugees btw a lot of people from my country of origin have a reputation for overstaying and I know a few myself. It's why we have more stringent visa checks than people of neighbouring countries. It's a lot harder to stay illegally in the rest of Europe.

EmpressCixi · 22/12/2021 16:20

He also said many were not even wearing life jackets. I do blame the traffickers for that.

EmpressCixi · 22/12/2021 16:18

The only source of information they have are the call logs and interviews with those on duty.

I did post the France24 article where they interviewed the first rescuer to arrive there. It was a French fisherman and he then called in the French Coast guard said they “arrived right away” so perhaps as fast as could be expected? He said he’s haunted by the dead bodies he saw, one floating right by the capsized boat. He said he wished he’d got there five minutes earlier so he might have saved them.

user1471447863 · 22/12/2021 16:17

Overloading a boat is stupid and asking for trouble

Using a small inflatable boat to cross the channel is asking for trouble when there are safer means, like buying a ferry, eurostar or plane ticket. Don't come out with any crap like they cannot afford a ticket - they pay these people smugglers thousands.

I know some bits of Calais are a shithole but its not exactly Kabul. Nobody is crossing the channel to escape war-torn France and while France may not be the wokest country its not like the gays/trans/nonbinary etc are sneaking themselves across the border to escape persecution.
They are safe in France, they can follow the correct procedure and apply for asylum there & come here in safety and comfort on the Eurostar once they are regularised

Those do-gooders time would be better spent helping these people use the correct legal channels in france.

tinierclanger · 22/12/2021 16:16

@LittleRoundRobin

100% YANBU. It's the risk they take when they get on these inflatable dinghies.

Whilst it's tragic that these people died, I think it's pretty disgusting and shameful that the UK and France are being blamed for them drowning. I mean WTAF? Confused How the hell can anyone even begin to THINK it's our fault? They came of their own accord! No WAY is it the fault of the UK or France, and it's batshit to suggest otherwise!

I couldn’t disagree more. This happens because safe routes of passage have been closed. Our government policy is culpable; we can’t deny responsibility.

To those harping on once again about how people “always” come to the UK, the vast majority of them don’t. People who do are coming here because

  • they have friends or family here, who can help them to settle and rebuild a life
  • they speak English as a second language

I am really sickened that some people take such a casual attitude towards these utterly tragic deaths.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 22/12/2021 16:11

A lot of this doesn't make sense

It rarely does, and as if things aren't already bad enough, some of the "agencies" involved have a tendency to cloud things

Since they appear to be French I have very little knowledge of Utopia 56, but as said upthread I was briefly involved with a local one and it wasn't pleasant

TractorAndHeadphones · 22/12/2021 16:08

Also r.e conflicting reports
The guardian link I posted above said that at around 3 a.m 2 hours after the initial trouble a rescuer responded and told them to hold up a torch. They tried using their phones but the phones quickly fell into the water

Most other sources only state the ‘several calls’ and some say people were in contact with their families very very hard to find the truth

TractorAndHeadphones · 22/12/2021 16:03

@Puzzledandpissedoff

Utopia 56 said it “intends that investigations be carried out to determine the responsibilities of the French and British rescue services in this tragedy,” adding that the people were abandoned “despite calls to the English and French rescue services.”

I'm aware of what they've claimed, but am interested in how they're supposed to know what happened. It seems someone else has heard there were two survivors, but on a crowded boat in crisis, doubtless with others screaming and shouting, is it realistic that these two were aware of who was calling who and exactly what was said?

Same with refugees being "forced into boats at gunpoint" ... again, is there any verifiable evidence of this, or is it hearsay?

It could also be several people on the same boat calling at the same time, confusing the rescue services!

How hard can this investigation be though? The only source of information they have are the call logs and interviews with those on duty.

No eyewitnesses, CCTV/dash cams etc to check. Unless I’m being thick it should be clear cut

Mamamia7962 · 22/12/2021 16:02

But where are the migrants getting their money from? If the traffickers are charging between £3,000 - £6,000 per head, why are they not using that money to provide food for their families, no way would I let my children starve in a camp and rely on the French Govt for hand outs as and when if I had that amount of money.

They can only be forced on to a boat if they have the money to pay surely. A lot of this doesn't make sense.

EmpressCixi · 22/12/2021 15:50

Yes I agree @NeverDropYourMoonCup on maritime law and answering distress calls if you are able. But even that is no guarantee of successful rescue with zero lives lost. It’s not unheard of for boats/ships to get into trouble, get a distress call through with exact location, send up flares and the nearest ships just don’t get there in time for all or most passengers/crew on the boat/ship.

So the fact that 27 drowned isn’t proof they were deliberately left to die.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 22/12/2021 15:47

Utopia 56 said it “intends that investigations be carried out to determine the responsibilities of the French and British rescue services in this tragedy,” adding that the people were abandoned “despite calls to the English and French rescue services.”

I'm aware of what they've claimed, but am interested in how they're supposed to know what happened. It seems someone else has heard there were two survivors, but on a crowded boat in crisis, doubtless with others screaming and shouting, is it realistic that these two were aware of who was calling who and exactly what was said?

Same with refugees being "forced into boats at gunpoint" ... again, is there any verifiable evidence of this, or is it hearsay?

NeverDropYourMoonCup · 22/12/2021 15:40

Maritime Law is Maritime Law. You answer distress calls. Whoever is making them.

EmpressCixi · 22/12/2021 15:32

I agree with the court case to establish the facts as to whether any attempted distress calls did actually go through. And if so, what the French and/or British rescue response was after receipt. So much is unknown right now, I am seeing conflicting statements in the press so don’t know what is fact and what is alleged. Which is why Utopia56 is calling for a full investigation. If they were callously ignored and left to die, then I think whoever is responsible should be held accountable.

Rinoachicken · 22/12/2021 15:29

I would imagine the call went something like:

We need help we’re sinking
What’s your location?
English Channel
Can you be more precise?
We’re in the open ocean in the the channel
Do you have a flare or light or any way you might get the attention of a passing vessel?
No

I mean, what on earth can they do with that information? And the 90 others just like it all in the same night? Just set off, risking the rescuers lives also and just hope you find someone? And then if you do you still wouldn’t know of the people you found were the ones who called or some other group

Wynturphelle · 22/12/2021 15:27

www.bbc.co.uk/news/resources/idt-b7bd2274-88b1-4ef9-a459-be22e180b52c

This article reports that, 'All of them were economic migrants and nearly all of them had previously tried - and failed - to get to Britain via legal routes multiple times. They had all also attempted to cross the Channel at least three, and in some cases six, times before in small boats.'

That level of desperation is shocking. Even more so, the fact that one family of four paid £32,000 for the journey.

Three other rescues occurred that night too.

Georgy12 · 22/12/2021 15:27

@lifeturnsonadime

I think it is absolutely right that action be taken. If it is correct that distress calls were made and ignored then regardless the reasons they were in the waters if they could have been saved they should have been.

As a nation we shouldn't leave people to die. That's absolutely horrific.

This with bells on.
EmpressCixi · 22/12/2021 15:25

Our immigration policy (and France's) is what causes people to have to try to enter the country in perilous ways. And those policies are based on racism and economic policy founded on the model that we don't have enough to go round.

I think you have it backwards, the UK immigration policy is one of the most liberal and anti-racist in the world. That is why they want to come here. Not only is it one of the cheapest visas going to come and work here, you can acquire citizenship after only 5yrs residency. U.K. also allows dual citizenship, so does not force migrants to renounce their home country unlike many other countries do.

I’m not saying we should make immigration stricter than it is to solve this problem. But your post is backwards. They would not risk their lives if we were a country that refuses vast majority of asylum applicants and immediately deports them back to their home country. Or a country that might let them stay, but never let them acquire citizenship.

Rinoachicken · 22/12/2021 15:24

Do we know they were ignored? Or was it just next to impossible to locate them in miles and miles of open sea, in a tiny boat that doesn’t show up on radar when they have no flares or navigation equipment to give any would be rescuers even a rough approximation of their location. Pair that with this I’m being one of 90 odd calls all the same and honestly it’s a miracle ANY rescues are successful.

TractorAndHeadphones · 22/12/2021 14:52

@vivainsomnia

We know the traffickers are scumbags. No need to distract the issue here which is whether the French and British authorities acted as they should.

What I read is that the seas were calm that day, there wasn't unexpected huge activities and rescues. They were in the water fir 11 hours. They claim they called both authorities and each pass the buck saying they were in the other side of waters and so not their responsibility.

If this is all untrue, then fair enough. If it true then, absolutely that some should be held responsible.

That's why it is fair enough there should be a court case to get it all out in the open.

Where did you read this? Also where 11 hours? www.google.co.uk/amp/s/amp.theguardian.com/uk-news/2021/dec/21/asylum-seekers-drowned-in-dinghy-shipwreck-named-by-bbc

Boat sank a couple of hours after getting into trouble, a couple of hours after that survivors attempted another call