Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

“Please have lunch ready for 1pm. Thankyou.”

838 replies

diydh · 21/12/2021 16:22

I’m interested to know if anyone else’s husband would say this in the morning before disappearing into his office for several hours. Please be honest.

YABU - yes, fair enough
YANBU - no, he is being quite bossy

OP posts:
Rp735 · 22/12/2021 17:40

Mine would and so would I. Who ever doesn't have meetings through lunch time does lunch. We discuss our schedule in the morning. It really depends on the context.

Janemain · 22/12/2021 17:39

My ex husband would never have dared. He would have been:

a) told to get fucked
b) been served something disgusting or laced with laxatives
c) came home to his bags packed

Bertiebiscuit · 22/12/2021 17:38

Are you wife - or servant???? The note I would leave in reply to anyone who spoke to me this way is unprintable - divorce him, he's an a*se

FM2013 · 22/12/2021 17:35

.My DH tried it once when he started working from home. At 12pm I marched our 4 lovely children into his office and told him he was looking after them for 30 mins so I could get his lunch ready on time. He never asked again. I'm not against making him lunch but he can feck off if I'm having it ready for a certain time every day.

Redshell · 22/12/2021 17:33

A swift F* off often offends but can be quite effective 😂

SharonEllis · 22/12/2021 17:32

No, unless we had agreed that I would do lunch that day for some reason. Then it would be 'thanks would 1pm be OK?' Otherwise I can't imagine that conversation ever happening.

Mumof3girlygirls · 22/12/2021 17:30

My husband wouldn't even dare to dream to say that to me without it being a joke.... he knows full well he would be wearing his lunch at 1pm if he ever did!!

Oscarsdaddy · 22/12/2021 17:27

Hope you took him coffee & biscuits in at 10.30

Orreries · 22/12/2021 17:01

@diydh

On the cultural differences part, his family are quite liberal overall and it’s not been an issue really. But I will never forget, just after we got married, his elderly grandmother who was quite a character made us sit down as a couple in front of her and she looked me in the eye and told me straight off the bat that if I was to die suddenly while my husband was displeased with me, then I would not be able to enter Paradise! Just like that, she said it. And then she told me I must take good care of my husband and be obedient and then he would be sure to shower me in endless gold (or something along those lines). All sorts of ‘advice’ was given. Not least from his mother.

California - I agree, the. ‘If you were a man you would be a ‘cocklodger’ thing doesn’t really apply, so it’s hard to know how to respond to that.

My DH's (white, Western) grandmother used to try to pull that kind of stunt as well, about marital duties and rights -- this woman had had thirteen children who survived to adulthood, and used to kneel down to take off her philandering old soak of a husband's shoes when he came in, and scurry around feeding and cleaning up after 'her boys' even when they were adults defaulting 'home' between marriages, before ending her days in hospital after she had a bad fall in her 80s over one of her lazy sons' sportsbags, which he left lying on the hall floor for her to wash its contents.

I used to laugh and say that fortunately the world had moved on and there was contraception, education and professional careers for women, and that DH was a far better cook than I was.

diydh · 22/12/2021 16:53

Classicblunder - I have got into the habit if not asking him to do things like that in the house because of the ‘I’m too busy and can’t be out upon’ vibe he gives off. It’s easier to do it myself. But if I needed anything for myself or the children and asked him, he would never say no. And he will always offer to pick them up and take them places if he can.

OP posts:
diydh · 22/12/2021 16:48

On the cultural differences part, his family are quite liberal overall and it’s not been an issue really. But I will never forget, just after we got married, his elderly grandmother who was quite a character made us sit down as a couple in front of her and she looked me in the eye and told me straight off the bat that if I was to die suddenly while my husband was displeased with me, then I would not be able to enter Paradise! Just like that, she said it. And then she told me I must take good care of my husband and be obedient and then he would be sure to shower me in endless gold (or something along those lines). All sorts of ‘advice’ was given. Not least from his mother.

California - I agree, the. ‘If you were a man you would be a ‘cocklodger’ thing doesn’t really apply, so it’s hard to know how to respond to that.

OP posts:
Classicblunder · 22/12/2021 16:16

How would he react if you asked him to do something (domestic) for you? E.g "could you please make me a coffee?" Or *I have an appointment, could you please make the kids some lunch?"

thatsallineed · 22/12/2021 16:15

OP chooses not to work Well, I'm sorry @MollysDolly but that's not the case. Her DH has told her that she has no need to work, he'd feel insulted if she did, and that she would be abandoning the children. He can't even understand why she would want to. So basically he's vetoed it, and the OP doesn't really have that choice.

CariadWelshcake · 22/12/2021 16:05

Op, re your husband being a narcissist. I think it’s something I’d ignore given that in my experience over many decades in a culture where men are treated very differently it can often come across that they’re narcissist to when they’re in fact only a product of their upbringing.

crazyjinglist · 22/12/2021 15:48

Some poor woman followed the advice given on here, left her husband and very much regretted it.

One woman? Wow. Wonder how many have either left their husband and been thankful for MNers' advice, and how many ignored MNers' advice, stayed with their abusive husbands and lived to regret it...

CaliforniaDrumming · 22/12/2021 15:36

Ah, I get the cultural thing now. A lot of Asian men, my own husband included, are very driven workaholics because they come from cultures where there is no social security or safety net if they fail. And they have the responsibility of parents.

I am not asking you to leave your DH but I am glad you are considering volunteering and getting some space for yourself. You are not a cocklodger. That concept does not exist in our cultures. But you should claw back some independence. Everything can't be about him.

I think you need an Asian therapist who understands these things but that can wait.

Edue · 22/12/2021 15:34

Quite bossy, needs this Christmas song to cheer up fumacrom.com/3GUGM

Clymene · 22/12/2021 15:32

@Bollindger

Please be aware some of the posts vilifying your DH are from man haters. Some poor woman followed the advice given on here, left her husband and very much regretted it.
GrinGrinGrin

I think that sounds like a good idea @diydh

You are a person who is worthy of respect, with opinions and priorities.

Orreries · 22/12/2021 15:31

@Bollindger

Please be aware some of the posts vilifying your DH are from man haters. Some poor woman followed the advice given on here, left her husband and very much regretted it.
Only a total lunatic would end her marriage because a bunch of strangers on the internet told her to.
Bollindger · 22/12/2021 15:16

Please be aware some of the posts vilifying your DH are from man haters.
Some poor woman followed the advice given on here, left her husband and very much regretted it.

diydh · 22/12/2021 15:09

thepeopleversuswork and Orreries others - Thankyou. What I am taking away from all this is that I’m going to do some volunteering in some capacity. I realise I need some headspace that’s not just about him and my kids. To be honest, I was in that frame of mind before lockdown, but then lost track with all the home school and everything else, not to mention having him WFH. I’m feeling the need to get galvanised. Thankyou for all the comments.

CaliforniaDrumming - yes he is Asian and from an Islamic culture.

Bluntness - there are different types of disrespect and different family structures. I’m focusing on what I perceive to be the negative aspect of my dynamic with DH, but that’s not all there is that the kids see.

OP posts:
Bluntness100 · 22/12/2021 14:27

Also what do your kids think? Do they hear him behave like this? What sort of role models do you feel you’re giving them in terms of equality and mutual respect?

Bluntness100 · 22/12/2021 14:26

This is very sad, he treats you like a housekeeper or domestic employee. Sure he might be nice at other times, but that’s what he’s doing, he’s treating you like domestic help.

This must have eroded your self confidence, self esteem and dignity.

I guess you’re suited though he wanted soneone who would behave like this and you agreed to do it. Many of us, myself included would have told him to go fuck himself if he expected us to stay home. Never mind ordering food from us like we were a servant.

Orreries · 22/12/2021 14:23

@thepeopleversuswork

OP I think you need to forget about the cocklodger stuff: this is a complete red herring. There’s clearly no resentment at all from him that you don’t work so put that to one side.

It sounds as if - within the parameters of his worldview - he is considerate and courteous. He clearly is not trying to wind you up or be unkind. This is, in his mind, an entirely appropriate way for a man to talk to his wife. I don’t know if he’s a narcissist or not and it doesn’t really matter: he clearly thinks this is the right way for a man to interact with wife.

The fact that you have not worked for years and have facilitated his lifestyle has contributed to this because it has increased his power and you have given the impression that you are fine with this so there’s never been any pushback. This can’t be helped now but the fact is that if you want to change the dynamic here you will have to take the lead. His default now is that he is active and autonomous and you are passive and basically an adjunct to his life.

That apparently suited you for a while and now doesn’t. And that’s OK; you are allowed to change your perspective.

I don’t know your husband so I have no way of knowing whether this is something he can come to terms with over time or if it is a complete dealbreaker for him.

But the fact is you clearly want to reframe your relationship in a way which gives you more autonomy.

The reasons why work or some other outside focus will help are myriad. But the most important one is that it will help you stop automatically seeing everything through the lens of his needs. You need to do this if you want to have a chance of getting your life back. Ultimately whether or not your marriage is going to survive you will be in a better position if you have something else in your life.

OP, this is a good post with some sensible advice. I agree, ignore the 'cocklodger' stuff that is coming from other people with their own issues, and is fundamentally nothing to do with your situation and focus on how you would like to change things to suit the way you feel now, and the wishes you have now. It is, absolutely, allowed to change your mind about how you live. It is allowed and should in fact be encouraged for you to put yourself first, and stop seeing yourself primarily as a facilitator of the activities of others.

Best wishes.

thepeopleversuswork · 22/12/2021 14:20

OP I think you need to forget about the cocklodger stuff: this is a complete red herring. There’s clearly no resentment at all from him that you don’t work so put that to one side.

It sounds as if - within the parameters of his worldview - he is considerate and courteous. He clearly is not trying to wind you up or be unkind. This is, in his mind, an entirely appropriate way for a man to talk to his wife. I don’t know if he’s a narcissist or not and it doesn’t really matter: he clearly thinks this is the right way for a man to interact with wife.

The fact that you have not worked for years and have facilitated his lifestyle has contributed to this because it has increased his power and you have given the impression that you are fine with this so there’s never been any pushback. This can’t be helped now but the fact is that if you want to change the dynamic here you will have to take the lead. His default now is that he is active and autonomous and you are passive and basically an adjunct to his life.

That apparently suited you for a while and now doesn’t. And that’s OK; you are allowed to change your perspective.

I don’t know your husband so I have no way of knowing whether this is something he can come to terms with over time or if it is a complete dealbreaker for him.

But the fact is you clearly want to reframe your relationship in a way which gives you more autonomy.

The reasons why work or some other outside focus will help are myriad. But the most important one is that it will help you stop automatically seeing everything through the lens of his needs. You need to do this if you want to have a chance of getting your life back. Ultimately whether or not your marriage is going to survive you will be in a better position if you have something else in your life.