Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

“Please have lunch ready for 1pm. Thankyou.”

838 replies

diydh · 21/12/2021 16:22

I’m interested to know if anyone else’s husband would say this in the morning before disappearing into his office for several hours. Please be honest.

YABU - yes, fair enough
YANBU - no, he is being quite bossy

OP posts:
diydh · 22/12/2021 22:43

Most things in life I can ask him, but there are some things I feel I can’t. The way he would react is a certain look on his face which is hard to explain if you don’t know him. So I avoid it and just do stuff myself because it’s easier.

OP posts:
PoloMintHum · 22/12/2021 22:40

I think your life sounds idyllic! You get everything paid for, no stress of working, paying bills etc. He has politely asked for lunch at 1pm.

I'm sure you have your own stresses, but seriously, you are very lucky not to have to work and he doesnt sound like a bad man.

If you don't want to do the home/kids stuff then you could work instead.

Mollymoostoo · 22/12/2021 22:34

Mine would as a joke, knowing I would tell him to do one.

CharlotteMaytimes · 22/12/2021 22:31

This is how women almost always feel at first on threads like this: “He takes me out”, “he buys me gifts”, “there’s nothing else I could ask for”. But if that’s all you wanted in life, really and truly, you wouldn’t be posting here.

Most people at most points in their adult lives want kindness, respect, mutual support and companionship. Being treated like a well-paid PA doesn’t offer any of those things.

Good luck, OP. You deserve a good life Flowers

retirementrocks · 22/12/2021 22:24

How very dare he!

Twillow · 22/12/2021 22:16

In this particular situation, from what I've read of your posts here, I actually do think it's reasonable.

  • you don't have an employment, so your work (by agreement) is taking care of the home/kids/family
  • you would presumably be making lunch for yourself anyway
  • he has a busy schedule while wfh
  • he said it politely and informatively

I don't think you should wait on him hand and foot, and should be careful to maintain as much downtime as he has, but making lunch at a convenient time doesn't sound like the request of a narcissist on face value.

diydh · 22/12/2021 22:08

I respect that - not redirect that!

OP posts:
diydh · 22/12/2021 22:07

He does do a lot for me. I mean, he carries all the financial responsibility and that’s not easy and U redirect that. He makes an effort in terms of us having time as a couple and that does help me to not feel taken for granted. He has always been like that. He is affectionate and complimentary. If I asked him to go out at 3am and get me something he would go. He would never say no to something like that. He is very generous with my family as well. Those are some positives, for balance. He makes a big effort on birthdays and other occasions as well. That’s a few things.

OP posts:
hopingforabrighterfuture2021 · 22/12/2021 21:52

@diydh you’ve had so, so much advice and so many comments, it’s probably massively overwhelming! There are obviously some great things about your marriage, but also some troubling things. I think the absolute crunch point will come if/when you decide to talk to him. If you are able to have a calm and rational conversation with him and he is open to discussion/validates how you’re feeling then that tells you you have a marriage worth saving. If he gets angry/refuses to engage/is dismissive etc that’s a different situation. I wish you the best of luck, please let us know how you get on.

Classicblunder · 22/12/2021 21:48

Has he ever done anything for you that seriously inconvenienced him? Not throwing money around. Something like looking after the kids so you could go out or away with friends or to pursue your interests or cancelling his extreme sports commitments sometimes because you needed support?

girlmom21 · 22/12/2021 21:46

@diydh how does he prioritise and support you?

NoNotMeNoSiree · 22/12/2021 21:44

@diydh

Yes this is as I thought. And yes, his words were - “darling, please have lunch ready for one o’clock, Thankyou.’ Then he just sort of walks off.

He will think this is totally normal and he’s just trying to be helpful in communicating his schedule. That’s what he would say.

I had to check to see if there was any more to this before commenting, and yeah there is - eh no, I'd be telling mine to go bollocks Grin Nothing wrong with doing lunch for him, but he doesn't get to dictate when/what etc it should be on the table!
mediciempire · 22/12/2021 21:44

@diydh

hopingforabrighterfuture2021 - This is the thing. When he was working and out hopingforabrighterfuture2021 in the day, I only had to organise dinner for him, if he was coming home. Now he’s here most days, I feel like I have to factor in what he’s having for lunch and if I was going to be out, I’d have to leave him something in the fridge or factor this in.
Would he be angry if you didn't?

My dad is an immigrant from the same background as your husband and I often made him lunch and factored in whether there would be something for him to eat in the house because he doesn't cook meals, he just cooks bits of things. He would never ask me to cook for him, I would offer. If he was hungry and wanted food and I hadn't done anything he would eat toast or make himself egg and toast or eat lots of fruit or snack on bits and he wouldn't complain about it because he didn't expect it as a given.

If your husband would get angry about you not having made him food, I think that is pretty awful and not really a cultural thing at all especially if he grew up in the UK so you shouldn't take it as it being the norm. What would he do if you hadn't made him food and had gone out?

diydh · 22/12/2021 21:40

On reflection, the reason I posted yesterday (I did not expect this level of response)! is because I had a session where the therapist was referring to him as a narcissist. When someone puts a word like that in your head, it makes you doubt what you’re doing in general and if you are being manipulated or something like that. It is true that he expects me to make and serve him his food and this is nothing new. But when he was blunt with telling me his timings yesterday, I was asking myself if this was ‘the narcissist’ speaking, if you see what I mean? And I started to over-analyse the whole dynamic and then I posted on here to see if I was BU.

There is obviously a wider context as well and I’ve tried to explain that. When the pp asked what my children must think, I am obviously going to feel a bit defensive in answering that. But if I try and give context, it will sound like excuses probably. So all I can say is yes, they do live in a home where they see me serving him lunch and dinner. But I do that for the whole family, to be honest. But also they will see other examples of the way we work well together. They would never hear either of us tell each other to f off, for instance. We don’t bicker and they would see him prioritising and supporting me in many ways. Just not food-related!

Having said all this, I see clearly where the problem is and I 100% see that other women would not accept the way he spoke to me and that’s it’s far from ideal. I am grateful to all the people who bothered to post.

OP posts:
Fluffmum · 22/12/2021 21:40

Er no?!?

DDMAC · 22/12/2021 21:26

I can’t see it in your replies sorry if I’ve missed it but do you feel any resentment towards him.

takethegirloutofwales · 22/12/2021 21:25

Mine tried it once when I was on maternity leave with a 22 month old and a newborn. “Please make it a priority to find my keys today”. Ummm. I think my priority is keeping your children alive…he’s not tried it since and my eldest is now nearly 14.

Classicblunder · 22/12/2021 21:23

@Hexagon

So, those of you who think it's impolite - how would you word a request for lunch at a certain time? I wouldn't be even slightly offended by a request similar to the one the OP quotes (neither would my husband).
I wouldn't - I think lunches during the working day are for each person to sort out their own.

But we do eat dinner together and what I would say there is "hey, I have a few things to finish up so would you mind if we eat at 8?" And my DH would feel able to say "I'm really hungry, can we do 7", I might say "sure, I will finish up after dinner"

That's a normal interaction to me - key is that there's questions, not polite commands and the ability of both parties to compromise

WhoopsWhatsMyNameAgain · 22/12/2021 21:08

@hexagon

Same. I've been with my partner over 10 years and as I know him well, and he's a kind, generous person, it would take quite a lot for me to question his kindness.

I'm often at home, not working, when he's WFH. He'll often call down from his office "can I have a coffee please?". Shock horror, I make one because I have the time and inclination. If he said "make me a coffee now", I'd tell him where to go, but I honestly can't see anything wrong with what OPs husband asked. I'd probably ask the same if my partner didn't work or have childcare responsibilities.

OP - ultimately this is your relationship and only you and he know how things go down. Tone is everything and none of us heard the tone he used or how this is different to his usual tone. As others have said, some people communicate like that with no ill intention. Others find it rude. You know your husband.

But be careful to jump to conclusions based on an internet forum. You sound very influenced by your therapist and by posters here. Your comments on this thread are inconsistent with how you portray your partner. At times you refer to him as kind, generous. Other times you infer he has narcissistic qualities and wants you to be stuck at home.

You need to take responsibility for your own actions. It seems you are where you are due to joint decision making. It worked for you. If it no longer works for you, go out and find your place in the world. It's not your partner's fault your set up doesn't work for you anymore. And you need to speak up if something doesn't work, he won't know unless you tell him.

JustLikeaJingleBell · 22/12/2021 21:02

[quote phishy]@JustLikeaJingleBell would he do it to men as well? And at work?[/quote]

What a weird thing to say

Yes he'd be like that to anyone because he's on the spectrum

He would think that because he hasn't been pulled up on it thus far that's it ok to behave like that.

But also it takes a long time for him to understand that certain actions and behaviours of his are socially unacceptable.

He just doesn't get it but he slowly learns how to behave and put on the Aspergers / autism mask.

Notmrsfitz · 22/12/2021 20:59

Mine might say - I’ll be back about 5 so can we eat at half past.

But to be honest, I don’t mind- if it fits into his plans then I will go along with it

Kite22 · 22/12/2021 20:59

Completely agree @JustLyra

Even if, they were replying in the first 3 or 4 posts, but, the fact the OP has talked since then about how she creeps around on eggshells not daring to do something that might upset him, and some posters are still defending the situation is staggering

JustLikeaJingleBell · 22/12/2021 20:56

You need to sit down and talk all this through with him

You've reached a point where all your DC are independent and you have more head space to think about yourself.

You know things aren't quite right but they're not awful and you do have a nice enough life

You really absolutely must talk to your DH to process your relationship.

You also need to work out what you now want from life.

cinderhella · 22/12/2021 20:56

@JustLyra

I can't believe how many people on this thread think that the mere use of please and thank you makes his order polite.

It's baffling.

Same, it’s a directive not a request and therefore utterly rude
CaliforniaDrumming · 22/12/2021 20:53

@Hexagon

So, those of you who think it's impolite - how would you word a request for lunch at a certain time? I wouldn't be even slightly offended by a request similar to the one the OP quotes (neither would my husband).
I wouldn't confine my wife to the house every day at lunch time, for one, so she can make my Very Important Lunch. Or stop her from ever travelling anywhere on her own.