Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

“Please have lunch ready for 1pm. Thankyou.”

838 replies

diydh · 21/12/2021 16:22

I’m interested to know if anyone else’s husband would say this in the morning before disappearing into his office for several hours. Please be honest.

YABU - yes, fair enough
YANBU - no, he is being quite bossy

OP posts:
JustLyra · 21/12/2021 23:45

[quote WhoopsWhatsMyNameAgain]@JustLyra

"Please have lunch ready for 1pm. Thankyou" is perfectly polite. Says please and thank you.

How would you ask someone? Don't you think it's fair she makes him lunch given she has no work responsibilities or children all day, five days a week?[/quote]
No it’s not polite.

It’s an order dressed up as polite. Asking is polite, that’s not actually asking.

No, there should never be an assumption that your partner will be on hand to make you a specific meal at a time you set. If she’s free at that time it’s perfectly reasonable to ask.

watchingrnfire · 21/12/2021 23:45

I read this out to my dh who said that is extremely rude of the husband to demand lunch and he should make it himself.

WhoopsWhatsMyNameAgain · 21/12/2021 23:42

@JustLyra

"Please have lunch ready for 1pm. Thankyou" is perfectly polite. Says please and thank you.

How would you ask someone? Don't you think it's fair she makes him lunch given she has no work responsibilities or children all day, five days a week?

WhoopsWhatsMyNameAgain · 21/12/2021 23:40

How is working abandoning your children when presumably they're at school all day? They're not there to abandon!

If you want to work, do so.

If you don't, then you need to muck in around the house with grace and not resent making him a lunch.

JustLyra · 21/12/2021 23:40

@WhoopsWhatsMyNameAgain

So you don't work, and you don't care for children during the day. And you find it strange that your husband asks politely for lunch?

I find that quite entitled of you. Are you not willing to help in any capacity?

If I were your husband, unless you had plans otherwise, I would very much expect you to make lunch for us both, and giving you a time thats convenient around work is fair enough!

Politely asks for lunch?

If he politely asked for lunch it wouldn’t be an issue. There’s nothing polite in the way that man told the OP

VestaTilley · 21/12/2021 23:40

Quite bossy? Or just treating you like an unpaid servant?

You’re not a maid. Tell him to make his own lunch.

My husband would never, ever say this to me.

Iamfour · 21/12/2021 23:39

Is he Prince Charles?

WhoopsWhatsMyNameAgain · 21/12/2021 23:38

So you don't work, and you don't care for children during the day. And you find it strange that your husband asks politely for lunch?

I find that quite entitled of you. Are you not willing to help in any capacity?

If I were your husband, unless you had plans otherwise, I would very much expect you to make lunch for us both, and giving you a time thats convenient around work is fair enough!

LizzieSiddal · 21/12/2021 23:34

Some of what you’ve said Op resonated with me. My dh was bright up in a farm, was made to work on it from a young age (despite hating it) and his mum always had a cooked lunch on the table at 1pm.

When we first married, I worked but then had Dc and I kind of fitted into that same role for a short time. Dh didn’t ever demand it though, it just kind of happened. It then became apparent I couldn’t actually go out very much and we realised how stupid it was, so dh just made himself lunch (his mother was horrified). It’s taken years of therapy for him to get to grips with how damaging his childhood was, he is also a workaholic though not as bad as he used to be.

I was wondering if your dh’s childhood has had an effect on how he behaves towards you/expects things to be and if him having therapy could help him.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 21/12/2021 23:32

He would not want me working full time, definitely not. The way he is, he would be insulted. And he would see it as me abandoning my children for nothing

How dare he insinuate that you working is abandoning the children yet he does it so intensively that you have to pick up everything else including pandering to his every whim.

What a fucking turn off.

I'm not saying "you should work" - I'm saying "you should feel free to choose to work if you want"

Have you ever had a weekend away with friends and he stay home with the dc?

ikeepseeingit · 21/12/2021 23:31

Hi OP. I'm concerned that you don't think you can tell your husband you don't want to be beholden to his lunch every day, and that you would appreciate him asking more politely in the future.

Would you be able to sit him down and tell him that you don't mind making his lunch for him when you're already in the house, and you also don't mind him telling you what time his lunch is, but you need to be asked in a less abrupt way. You also don't want to be beholden to his lunchtime every day so won't be making lunch for him if you're going out and busy.

Is it really too much for him to hear that paragraph in your own words? Or do you think he would get sullen and cross/disappointed? If you can't even ask for the basic respect of being talked to nicely then that's not a good relationship to be in.

Friendviv1987 · 21/12/2021 23:27

HNRTWT….tell him to sort his own food out .Am sure he can negotiate a toaster and tin of beans!!

hettie · 21/12/2021 23:20

I don't usually comment on threads like this. But two things strike me. Firstly you might want to find a different therapist, using terms like narcissistic about people you've never assessed is not great. Secondly what does the 'workaholism' do? What purpose does it serve? It can often be about avoiding emotional intimacy, in the same way an affair or an obsessive hobby or alcohol or drugs can be...it absents you from the relationship. What function does the way you've set up your relationship do for both of you and what are the consequences of that and do b you want that?

PickAChew · 21/12/2021 23:14

My domestic set up has similarities in that dh works at home and I'm the "homemaker" but I'm also the carer as both of the boys (mid to older teens) have severe additional needs. Even today, a few days before Christmas, I said goodbye to a CAMHS home visit for one boy and answered the phone to the other boy's social worker.

DH isn't asuch of an arse as yours, OP, but he sometimes gets stuck in work mode and can treat anything I say as an imposition and start to neglect everyone else's needs. Where the similarity ends is that I'm not afraid to lose my shit with him, even if he's so wrapped up in his own self that he doesn't react well. The worst that happens is a bit of shouting and maybe some tears. A decent therapist would get you to the point where you can articulate your needs rather than being meekly grateful for any crumbs thrown un your direction.

nicesausages · 21/12/2021 23:12

I can't imagine living my life like this

Next day you are both free, go out shopping / yoga/ whatever in the morning and ask him to have lunch ready for 1pm for when you are back. That might give him a little insight into his behaviour.

Grotbags2020 · 21/12/2021 23:12

Well we normally have lunch at 12 as we skip breakfast so 1 would be reasonable as I’d be hangry. But regardless of time there is no way my husband would ever demand lunch to be ready at certain time in such a manor (different if we had plans)

I do make my dh lunch everyday which he appreciates and he will tidy the kitchen. But he would never ask for it in such a way it just comes across as rude. More of a demand rather a question

MissCruellaDeVil · 21/12/2021 23:07

No, he can ask his maid to do that! I'm his wife.

Closetbeanmuncher · 21/12/2021 23:07

I agree with your therapist btw.

ArrrMeHearties · 21/12/2021 23:06

Tell him if he wants lunch at 1pm sharp to make it himself

PickAChew · 21/12/2021 23:02

@bofski14

I don't see an issue with it. For all women who don't work and your SO does, at some point you've both sat down and had the conversation where one works to earn the money and one works to keep the house running. Preparing food is a part of that bargain you have struck. If you can't put a bit of food on a plate for your partner who is working all day to make money to support you, then there's something wrong.
If a man who holds down a full time job, like many men, single, partnered or married, can't ask for help with lunch arrangements without sounding rude and entitled, then something is very wrong indeed.
coronafiona · 21/12/2021 22:58

Serve it with a note requesting dinner to be served at a time you would like Grin

PickAChew · 21/12/2021 22:58

@diydh

It’s hard to sum everything up, but I’ll try. I don’t feel hard done by because I feel I have quite a loud if freedom to focus on the children, help them with school and all the other stuff. I have a cleaner and access to money in the same way as he does. None of that is an issue. I have time to keep fit, etc. Yes I have good friends about. Most people would see me as quite confident and together, I think? But with my husband, he’s a workaholic and I think it’s fair to say I have had to fit around that and the kind of temperament that goes with it. I can’t complain as he’s given us a great life, financially. But he is quite rigid about certain things - like his food. If he wants something done, he’s not asking, put it that way. I do find this aspect of him difficult. I can’t kind of ‘joke’ him out if it, or tell him he was being rude, as he wouldn’t see it as a joke.
This is what a gilded cage us all about. There are some good things in your life but they come at the expense of your autonomy. He might not be beating the crap out of you but you're still afraid to put a foot wrong.
Alpacalunchbox · 21/12/2021 22:56

Given that you don’t work, have older kids and have a cleaner….. make your husband a bloody sandwich.

Blacknosugarplease · 21/12/2021 22:53

Me and my husband are sometimes straight to the point like this. I like it. I think it only works if you are or get to be like this with each other and it’s not ‘one sided’ IYSWIM?

PumpkinEye · 21/12/2021 22:51

Seems like you think you have a good ’deal’, and you might have, but it’s sadly a deal and in the end not true love.