Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

“Please have lunch ready for 1pm. Thankyou.”

838 replies

diydh · 21/12/2021 16:22

I’m interested to know if anyone else’s husband would say this in the morning before disappearing into his office for several hours. Please be honest.

YABU - yes, fair enough
YANBU - no, he is being quite bossy

OP posts:
WhoopsWhatsMyNameAgain · 22/12/2021 09:58

@orreries

If she's not happy then she needs to change that. Lots of people on here aren't particularly happy for one reason or another; half the population are in therapy or on anti depression meds.

Whether or not it's her partner's fault is what this post is about. And from what I can see, him asking for lunch is hardly an issue. And I don't find the way he asks rude.

She has acknowledged she made the decision not to work, so she needs to change that if she thinks that will make her happier. That's not just on him (unless he blocks that of course).

30mph · 22/12/2021 09:55

Your level of ignorance about family investments and financial planning is concerning and comes across as symptomatic of your status in the marriage. You are legally married, yes? Not just a religious ceremony?

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 22/12/2021 09:54

My own background is also like that to a less rigid extent.

Yes, so it's not far from your own "normal"?

Also, he has a lot of trauma due to his father’s behaviour who used to always set him in competition against his brother and also used physical punishment.

So your DH is a pretty damaged person? What is your DH doing to repair his own damage and make sure he doesn't spread it to others?

the therapist says everyone is a narcissist

Everyone? Does she say you are a narcissist? Or is she saying that you you been raised by narcisstic people who made this your "normal" growing up so you fell for someone else with similar tendencies?

Orreries · 22/12/2021 09:53

[quote WhoopsWhatsMyNameAgain]@Orreries

Domestic drone?!

Their kids are in school full time. They have a cleaner. So hardly domestic drone. She has full access to their finances. And she says not working was a joint decision. Not even sahm given the kids aren't at home during working hours. She's unemployed.

It feels like I'm reading something different as I just can't see the hardship.[/quote]
Does the OP sound like a happy, fulfilled person to you?

Whether or not the kids are at school, or there is a cleaner doesn't alter the fact that the OP appears to have no meaningful existence outside the home. She says that her DH 'never discussed' whether she would work or not after they had children, and he seems to have been the instigator, though she went along with it, and she sounds passive and over-conscious of his moods and feelings, and his capacity for making her life difficult if she crosses.

Yes, she's unemployed, evidently low-level unhappy, and apparently without agency in her own life.

I'm puzzled at what looks enviable in the OP's life. I'm not seeing it.

WhoopsWhatsMyNameAgain · 22/12/2021 09:53

@thepeopleversuswork

I genuinely don't see what's wrong with Please can I have lunch at 1, thank you. Or the like.

Hes letting her know when it suits around work. Unless she has other plans, she needs to be helping and one way of doing that is making lunch.

thepeopleversuswork · 22/12/2021 09:51

[quote WhoopsWhatsMyNameAgain]@Orreries

Domestic drone?!

Their kids are in school full time. They have a cleaner. So hardly domestic drone. She has full access to their finances. And she says not working was a joint decision. Not even sahm given the kids aren't at home during working hours. She's unemployed.

It feels like I'm reading something different as I just can't see the hardship.[/quote]
Gordon Bennett.... it's not about the "hardship". It's about the way he speaks to her! Why is this so difficult to understand?

MajorNeville · 22/12/2021 09:49

No. It's nothing to do with him not daring, he simply wouldn't consider anything other than getting his own lunch.

123becauseicouldntthinkofone · 22/12/2021 09:48

Said the lord of the manor to the maid!!!!! i would make sure i am on a call at 1pm and see if he makes you something.

WhoopsWhatsMyNameAgain · 22/12/2021 09:46

@Orreries

Domestic drone?!

Their kids are in school full time. They have a cleaner. So hardly domestic drone. She has full access to their finances. And she says not working was a joint decision. Not even sahm given the kids aren't at home during working hours. She's unemployed.

It feels like I'm reading something different as I just can't see the hardship.

WhoopsWhatsMyNameAgain · 22/12/2021 09:41

@C8H10N4O2

So you don't work, and you don't care for children during the day. And you find it strange that your husband asks politely for lunch?

Why do you and others keep saying that the OP doesn't work? Her DH doesn't want her to work and has effectively blocked her from working because he wants a "corporate wife" both for his easy life and status.

Who do you think runs his house, manages all the family activities, all the kids stuff and family stuff whilst Mr Big is swanning around all over the place on his business travels and being Disney dad at weekends and far too important to deal with trivia like feeding himself.

Its bloody rude to order your partner around like a Victorian servant girl.

How you can possibly interpret that order as "polite" is bemusing.

Where does op say he wants a corporate wife? She said before she didn't want to work either, it was a mutual choice
thepeopleversuswork · 22/12/2021 09:38

@diydh

I wouldn’t get overly hung up on what the therapist says and would try to decouple this from how you are feeling. I don’t think calling everyone in sight a narcissist is constructive.

As you say the picture is very nuanced and your husband is clearly not a monster and there seem to be some positive things about your marriage.

I do think developing some independence, whether through work, volunteering or education, is a good idea. You really need to develop a sense of your own perspective on this situation.

We may not be in LTB territory but you clearly are sensing that something in the way you relate to each other is not working for you and your husband seems incapable of allowing you to have much autonomy of thought.

I do think having something else outside of him and the children to focus on will give you that perspective and allow you to sift through what is reasonable and what is just entrenched behaviour which you may need to push back on.

He probably won’t like it initially but that’s tough. You are not abandoning him or your children, you are making an entirety reasonable stand to get some space in your own life. His reaction to your wanting to do this will tell you a great deal about what your next move should be and whether you can accommodate each other’s needs over the long haul.

Orreries · 22/12/2021 09:35

@Bollindger

I'm going to get blasted for this, but hear me out. He is busy, you always cook for him. So in his mind he has a short window to eat lunch with you. So he said can you do lunch for 1. You say he does dates, is willing to let you hire help, and wants you to have freedom from working. I think your complicit in the life style you have, and to be honest most people would love your life. You could sort out a self employed side hussel if you want to, your children are now old enough to not need watching 100% of the time.
What exactly do you think most people would envy about the OP's life? She is a SAHM to three children and financially reliant on a man who can't make himself a sandwich who never discussed the issue of her working with her when they started to have children, who casually tells her to make his meals as if she's the hired help, she's afraid of his moods, she's in therapy because she's unhappy -- and she's so confused and unsure of herself that she had to post on the internet to know whether she was unreasonable to resent his casually issuing orders?

There's absolutely nothing to envy in this. And yes, the OP is 'complicit' in her own sidelining into a domestic drone -- but surely that only adds to her woes?

Broads93 · 22/12/2021 09:32

Tell him women have rights now, equality is hard for males to accept.

Bollindger · 22/12/2021 09:28

I'm going to get blasted for this, but hear me out.
He is busy, you always cook for him. So in his mind he has a short window to eat lunch with you. So he said can you do lunch for 1.
You say he does dates, is willing to let you hire help, and wants you to have freedom from working.
I think your complicit in the life style you have, and to be honest most people would love your life.
You could sort out a self employed side hussel if you want to, your children are now old enough to not need watching 100% of the time.

thepeopleversuswork · 22/12/2021 09:17

[quote Porcupineintherough]@Pallisers I doubt your grandfathers ever had to say anything. Having food ready for the man of the house when he came in from work was pretty standard practice back in the day, as were making hi pack up if he took one. Do you really think providing food was something housewives only did when they fancied it?[/quote]
Good grief 24 pages in and people are just not grasping this are they?

No one is saying its unreasonable of the husband to politely ask the OP to make lunch (particularly as she's not working). No one is saying making lunch for your husband makes you a Stepford Wife.

It's the way he speaks to her. He talks to her like an employee, not a partner.

SleepOhHowIMissYou · 22/12/2021 09:15

I would ask if his arms were broken?

Amberfromcamber · 22/12/2021 08:52

He is happy for you to do what you want as long as there is no impact to him.

For what it's worth the roles are reversed in my house, DH is a sahd to 3 young teens and I am the breadwinner and working mainly at home due to the pandemic.

I have never asked him to make my lunch but if I am busy and haven't been down for lunch he does send me a text asking if he can get me anything.

If you are ever going to want anything different in your life other than facilitating the lives of your DH and DCs especially with your children growing up I would start making some changes.

diydh · 22/12/2021 08:50

I didn’t expect so many posts and have woken up to quite a lot. I can’t reply to everything, but just wanted to say a few things so I’m not misunderstood.

To the posters saying, “Ffs making his food is the least you can do as you’re not working,” well, yes, I know this which is exactly why I don’t tell him to “get your own” etc as most people clearly would on this thread. Patterns in a relationship don’t just happen overnight, it’s more subtle.

Also there is the context of his family and his upbringing in which some cultural differences exist, eg. family gatherings, it’s women who deal with the food and men have nothing to do with that kind of thing. I’m not saying it’s an excuse and he’s not religious, but this is where he’s coming from and we all internalise things from our childhood and past. My own background is also like that to a less rigid extent. Also, he has a lot of trauma due to his father’s behaviour who used to always set him in competition against his brother and also used physical punishment. I think he is a workaholic because it’s become a defence and if he’s busy he doesn’t have to think too much. He is also very competitive in sports and surrounds himself with others like him. I don’t think it’s healthy and they take it too far, but you can’t deconstruct all that. So I have tried to balance things out, especially since we had children, but it’s been going on since I met him, in retrospect. It’s not all bad by any means. But he’s not the easiest to live with all the time and I posted because I have a therapist who says he is a narcissist and the manner he spoke to me yesterday struck me as this. But then the therapist says everyone is a narcissist and I’m not sure about her so may leave and find a different one.

OP posts:
Littlehouseinthebigcity · 22/12/2021 08:45

I would actually appreciate this! My DH works from home. I am very part time so essentially a Sahm 3-4 days a week and the amount of times I've got lunch ready for all of us only to find he's on a call and it's just me and the kids! Communication isn't a bad thing, it depends on the circumstances. If you're both working it's a bit different obviously!

C8H10N4O2 · 22/12/2021 08:38

So you don't work, and you don't care for children during the day. And you find it strange that your husband asks politely for lunch?

Why do you and others keep saying that the OP doesn't work? Her DH doesn't want her to work and has effectively blocked her from working because he wants a "corporate wife" both for his easy life and status.

Who do you think runs his house, manages all the family activities, all the kids stuff and family stuff whilst Mr Big is swanning around all over the place on his business travels and being Disney dad at weekends and far too important to deal with trivia like feeding himself.

Its bloody rude to order your partner around like a Victorian servant girl.

How you can possibly interpret that order as "polite" is bemusing.

crazyjinglist · 22/12/2021 08:31

I could cry for the many, many women who willingly give up their independence, and a potentially fulfilling future, for a selfish narcissistic wanker.

Well yes... but there are also plenty of women who don't work for a while when their children are little, but aren't married to narcissistic wankers. I don't think men become narcissistic wankers purely because of their wife's current employment status. If you've married a narcissistic wanker, then he's going to behave like one regardless. But yes, it's easier to extricate yourself from him if you're financially independent.

supergloo · 22/12/2021 08:08

Mine would say it but it's not acceptable

Porcupineintherough · 22/12/2021 08:07

@Pallisers I doubt your grandfathers ever had to say anything. Having food ready for the man of the house when he came in from work was pretty standard practice back in the day, as were making hi pack up if he took one. Do you really think providing food was something housewives only did when they fancied it?

girlmom21 · 22/12/2021 07:58

I don't know if you have boys or girls but would you be happy if your daughter ended up in a relationship like yours?

If not, why? Why do you live in a way you wouldn't want her to?

georgarina · 22/12/2021 07:50

Wouldn't even phrase it that way to a housekeeper tbh