Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Compulsive liar....call out or ignore?

59 replies

Redlorryyellowduck · 21/12/2021 10:48

Nc as she knows I'm on here.
A female relative is the most horrific liar I have ever met.
She lies about anything and everything, from small things to big things. Some of these lies are of no consequence (apart from being stupid and weird) but some are more significant.
Luckily I only have to see her a few times a year, but I'm torn between smiling and nodding, and pulling her up on every single lie. Mostly because I'm annoyed that thinks we are all stupid enough to believe her Walter Mitty version of life.
How do those of you unfortunate enough to have a Tom Pepp in your life cope with it?

OP posts:
CounsellorTroi · 21/12/2021 14:02

@Loveisthere

Have a friend like always been to the best restaurants but cannot comment on the menu. Has lots of designer shoes and matching bags but we have never seen them because she doesn't want to show off, there plenty more but I won't bore you. We all play along instead of calling her
Sounds like a girl I used to play with when I was a child. She had all the latest dolls and games, but wasn’t allowed to get them out in front of anyone else. She could do fantastic acrobatic tricks but “wasn’t allowed to”.
Thefantasticfour · 21/12/2021 13:58

My SIL is like this. She lied about so many trivial things, that then moved onto minor health scares, but because it was minor lies no one pulled her up on it. I was really close to her and knew she was lying and so did numerous members of the family but there was no proof and everyone just took what she said with a punch of salt. It all came to a head with me when she came over to my house and told me she'd found out she was pregnant. She said she couldn't tell my BIL because he would make her abort the pregnancy but had me feeling how hard her tummy was and all sorts. She went in depth about the symptoms she was showing and how excited she was. The very same day as this her sister who was on her third round of IVF was in hospital going through the horror of a stillbirth at 27 weeks. I knew she was lying, I knew my BIL would never of even considered an abortion and I just couldn't let it go, she was either going to have to fake a miscarriage to me, or fake a pregnancy and miscarriage to the rest of the family and I just couldn't let her go on with it, especially knowing what her sister was already going through. I told my MIL everything she'd told me and how I was sure she was lying, so she went round to BILs house and sat them both down and confronted her. She had no option to just admit everything, and apparently started counselling etc. I didn't see her or speak to her for a very long time, and then we spoke at a family gathering a couple of years later, where I'm fairly certain she lied about a load of new things about her family and her past. Apparently being called out on lies doesn't stop people like that lying, so now I just keep away from her, and if I do have to see her I just look at her as she speaks and don't really acknowledge what she says if it sounds unlikely.

itsgettingwierd · 21/12/2021 13:58

I know people like this.

I tend to ignore and just allow them more rope.

If you try and hang them they'll twist it as you being unkind and why do you need to challenge etc.

Eventually she'll hang herself because she'd have to,d so many lies she will have forgotten what they are!

user463876887 · 21/12/2021 13:57

Wow I know someone very close to me and who I have to see quite a lot who is exactly like this. Will make up absolutely fictitious stories or heavily embellish or distort others to make them more dramatic and will tell absolute fibs about things that are so irrelevant it makes ME go nuts. I mean why lie for absolutely no reason. Then looked up definition of compulsive liar and yep she fits the bill and they do exactly this. Lie even when there is no need to. She does it so much that we just have to automatically assume she's lying every time she opens her mouth. How do you tell fact from fiction. She's extremely insecure so I wonder if this fantasy world she's built in her head is a way to handle that.

NameChangeCity123 · 21/12/2021 13:52

I would just keep picking holes in what they are saying. They will likely get fed up trying to think of things to make it believable and it lets them know that you're aware they're taking rubbish. Why do people do this? 🙄

Snowmanuel · 21/12/2021 13:49

She doesn’t sound well. At all.

FrippEnos · 21/12/2021 13:45

Redlorryyellowduck

IMO, these people actually believe the lies that they tell.
I think that they have to because if they took a look at the person they actually are they would be disgusted.

Redlorryyellowduck · 21/12/2021 13:29

@NdujaWannaDance I've definitely done that a few times. "Wow, so you had offers from Oxford and Cambridge but turned them down, amazing!" "So you were a fully qualified engineer by the age of 19, I didn't think that was even possible, wow" "So you grew up overseas, despite your parents saying you didn't, crikey, amazing".
She gives zero fucks Hmm

OP posts:
NdujaWannaDance · 21/12/2021 12:58

I'd have to challenge her on the lies, but I think I'd do it in a faux innocent passive aggressive way to avoid a massive fallout, which I assume as she's family would impact negatively on other people.

I'd say 'Really? Gosh, that's odd. Didn't you say last time that blah blah blah? I must have misunderstood because both those thing can't be true. I'm confused!'

That sort of thing. And watch her try to worm her way out of a hole.

the80sweregreat · 21/12/2021 12:29

I think some people embellish a story a lot as time goes on, my late in laws were like this and it always ended up with them being in the right !
( late mil was a textbook narcissist though)
They didn't lie as such , but twisted it to fit their own narrative , even though I knew the story wasn't quite how they portrayed it to others.

trilbydoll · 21/12/2021 12:26

I always assume people like this believe their own lies so calling them out will just melt their brains.

SeparateVaccines21 · 21/12/2021 12:21

My cousin is exactly like this. She’s borderline pathological with her lies to the point we don’t believe anything that comes out her mouth. She’s always been this way as well, it’s so random because the rest of the family are a bit too honest. We don’t know where she gets it from. And there’s no point calling her out on them, she just flat out denies or tells more lies. We had a situation where there were 3 people telling her that her version of events wasn’t true as they were there and she still flat out denied and made up her own scenario. It’s exhausting but she’s never going to change so we just put up with it.

FictionalCharacter · 21/12/2021 12:20

@WorraLiberty

I call them out if I've got the energy and if it's not going to make anyone else uncomfortable.

Otherwise I have a finely practised "Yeah, right" expression on my face.

This is the best strategy. Don’t smile and nod, they’ll think you believe them and it encourages them. Just do that “yeah, right” look. Nothing you can do stops them. If they’re called out they bluster, and everyone feels embarrassed except them. Our own PM does it. Remember when an interviewer asked him what he does in his spare time and he said “I make things. I make….. buses”. Big smirk on his face.
steppemum · 21/12/2021 12:07

worrying that she has a child.

if that child is old enough, I would really want to have a conversation with them to make it clear that you all love their mum, but she does talk fantasy, and it is ok for the child to acknowledge that, and not to believe all the things their mum says.

As a child it must feel like you are being gaslighted all the time

Kbish1 · 21/12/2021 12:03

Depends on how much it impacts you and your loved ones

If its just bollocks that doesn't really mean much, I wouldn't bother. Like just an exaggerated story.

If her lies have real life impacts on people then, then I would have it out with her.

I knew a family member whose lies ended up with people investing financially and losing loads of money. That sort of think I would put a stop to, if I knew before hand.

Redlorryyellowduck · 21/12/2021 12:02

She has been called out before and just told more lies to cover the lies we'd called her on.

Some of the things are beyond possibility due to the timeframes involved, so I wonder if she even cares if we believe her or not if that makes sense, or if she's convinced herself the lies are true.

I'd prefer to call her out each and every time, but she's the mother of a child I care deeply about, she could easily cut me off from the child which would be heartbreaking.

My fear really is that she'll somehow ruin the child's life with her lies and fantasies.

It's just galling to have someone sit at your table, eat your food, and tell you such ridiculous fibs that you feel foolish that she'd even spout them. It's so difficult.

OP posts:
steppemum · 21/12/2021 12:02

I think that the only time I would correct it is if it was about me, or if it was painting someone else in the family in a bad light.
I wouldn't let that go.
But I would probably correct with a gentle - hey aunty Flo, you know cousin Ted would never actually do that to you don't you?

If it is just about herself, let it go.

SheWoreYellow · 21/12/2021 11:59

I have a close relative like this. I try and trip her up, but only so I notice and have ‘proof’. I would never confront her with it. She does it because she wishes the scenarios were true, so I leave her to it.

marykitty · 21/12/2021 11:57

My mother is a compulsive liar. She lies so effortlessly about so many topics, big and small, that I now assume i cannot trust a single word coming out of her mouth.
She does not do it to harm though, she does it to cover her weakness and how her mental issues are impacting her life.

I do not correct her, normally, i just ignore it even though her lies break my heart.
The few times i react it always ends up badly, with tears, so I regret it every single time.

BlackAmericanoNoSugar · 21/12/2021 11:52

I have a, fortunately distant, relative who lives in his own dream world and states possibility or what he would like to be true as fact. If you don't know him all that well it might all seem plausible.

It doesn't impact me all that much because I haven't seen him in person for nearly a decade but he recently told a mutual acquaintance that I had all the historic photos given to me after my grandmother died. The mutual acquaintance was looking for old photos of his house which is a neighbouring house of my grandmother's. Of course that was entirely in my relative's head, I don't have any old photos. I have no qualms about telling people not to believe anything that the relative said as it's more likely to be bullshit than truth.

the80sweregreat · 21/12/2021 11:46

You need a very good memory to be a compulsive liar !!
They will trip themselves up a lot.

Cherrysoup · 21/12/2021 11:41

I'd find it impossible to ignore. So bizarre and she must know that you're aware that she's lying. I'd have to call her out on it.

Crazykatie · 21/12/2021 11:37

There are some people like that, they talk crap most of the time and they don’t even realise they are doing it, l know a few. I just let it go over my head, if they want to make a mess of their lives it’s their choice,

cupofdecaf · 21/12/2021 11:34

One of these in my extended family. I keep quiet usually because it's difficult for her partner that I like. Her own kids though do call her out on it and apparently her partner is always with her when she sees the grandchildren. This makes me think there's something more serious going on than her just lying. I've taken the approach it's probably a mental health issue and try to be kind by just changing the subject. Other people are less kind and quite frank about her.
On the one occasion she really upset me I did struggle though.

Loveisthere · 21/12/2021 11:26

Have a friend like always been to the best restaurants but cannot comment on the menu. Has lots of designer shoes and matching bags but we have never seen them because she doesn't want to show off, there plenty more but I won't bore you. We all play along instead of calling her

Swipe left for the next trending thread