Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

...to have frank talk with a stingy friend?

164 replies

concernedfriend500 · 20/12/2021 19:49

One of the members of our friend group never buys a round. She's happy to accept a drink when someone else is buying, but never reciprocates, apart from one time when her best friend called her out on it. At which point she claimed she wasn't thirsty.
Our friendship group normally meets in pubs for lunch/birthday etc drinks but now it's got to the point where she sits drink-less (she waits to see if someone will buy her a drink) because everyone else has wised up to her . It feels awkward and is in danger of spoiling the vibe when someone gets a round in but misses her out.
So should I have a frank talk with her, and what should I say? This may or may not be relevant but she might be on the spectrum, so not very good at social cues. But she also might just be very stingy (or both). She's not poor btw, quite the opposite.

OP posts:
Helpstopthepain · 20/12/2021 22:48

what should I say?

Just ask if she’s okay

LittleMysSister · 20/12/2021 22:44

@Jennifer2r

I do understand people saying they hate rounds, but the crucial part of sitting out of rounds is saying 'no, thank you, I'll buy my own' when someone offers you a drink! Not accepting one then never making a move to buy one back!
Agreed!
LittleMysSister · 20/12/2021 22:43

I wouldn't bother actually sitting down and talking to her about this - it sounds like it's already been broached by your best friend and she has made excuses and brushed it off.

I'd do as someone else said above and just casually ask "you sorting your own drinks today Emma or are you coming in on the rounds with us?" when the first drinks are being ordered. She will likely say she'll stay alone.

RosesAndHellebores · 20/12/2021 22:24

@Maryann1975, I recall DH getting DS to help him get in a round in his younger years at the rugby club, etc. Certainly dd used to be given a fiver to get a round for her friends like the mummies at the Tennis club.

Why would you hope a kindly friend would take one of your ds's aside and explain. Isn't it a basic life skull that parents help with? Rather like buying a train ticket, asking a question in a shop, going to the Dr's, tipping the hairdresser, etc?

Jennifer2r · 20/12/2021 22:05

I do understand people saying they hate rounds, but the crucial part of sitting out of rounds is saying 'no, thank you, I'll buy my own' when someone offers you a drink! Not accepting one then never making a move to buy one back!

user33323 · 20/12/2021 22:02

The reasons rounds happen is to avoid en masse queuing. It is polite to offer friends if they'd like a drink when you get up to go, but yes, then there are obvious downsides when it is your turn but you aren't ready, or maybe if you are autistic and find ordering en masse difficult. What about only choosing places with app based table service?

Needawayout · 20/12/2021 21:44

We have unfortunately drifted apart from a friend like this who causes so much difficulty when out for drinks and meals that it just wasn't worth it, despite offers of advice and help. They were ADHD which made them highly disorganized but also v anxious about spending money. They insisted on only paying their share of the bill even when it worked out more expensive for them, and often tried to pay less than their share ! They never bought rounds but happily accepted drinks from everyone else. But then weirdly at the end of the night or weekend when they realised they had loads of money left they would then suddenly be v generous and buy gifts or pay for taxis etc.. I think they just had no ability to cost out the night and plan their spending. But at the end of the day it just annoyed everybody and spoiled nights out so they just stopped being invited - hope you have more success !!

Silvershroud · 20/12/2021 21:40

It's a bit condescending to suggest they are on the spectrum. The few people I know like this are quite upfront- if someone wants to treat them to drinks or cigarettes that's fine, but they don't want to waste their own money. They don't feel uncomfortable, it is the people who don't treat them that feel uncomfortable when we are out.

ttcpatronisers · 20/12/2021 21:30

Just say let's all buy our own drinks, or when it's her turn say so and so, your turn to buy - she can't refuse?!

Lollipop999 · 20/12/2021 21:29

On a slightly different note, one of my friends and I would arrange to meet for a coffee and when we sat down in the cafe she would bring out one she’d brought from home in a flask.

It happened a couple of times and was so embarrassing. I never did work out why, if it was stinginess or another reason but I haven’t arranged to meet up since!!

Lollipop999 · 20/12/2021 21:25

#some glug down their drinks

Lollipop999 · 20/12/2021 21:24

I’m not keen on rounds to be honest as generally I drink a lot less than the others I’m out with.

If I do buy one, I like to buy the first as it’s less awkward and embarrassing. I never understand when to buy a round as people drink at different rates. Some glue down their drink, whereas I take my time with mine. I may have a g&t then just a tonic after as
I can’t hold my drink at all.

A kitty is only really fair if you’re all drinking the same and at the same rate.

If anyone is driving I would always buy their drinks for the evening but otherwise I am much more comfortable just buying my own although I do agree that it ruins the vibe definitely .

Wellington17 · 20/12/2021 21:20

Have you spoken with your other friends about it? If you want to get out of the awkwardness you COULD make up an excuse as to why you or one of the others doesn’t want to be included in rounds that night (might have to leave early etc) then another member of the group says “ok so who’s wants to be included tonight?” and ask everyone one by one. Her response should tell you whether she wants to be included or not. One of you already saying you don’t want to be included will make it easier for her to say no if she feels awkward about not wanting to be part of it. If she says yes, then make sure she gets one of the earlier rounds.

But contrived but saves embarrassment/awkwardness

woodlandarchitect · 20/12/2021 21:18

@Maryann1975 if they explain that they have autism then their friends will help. I’ve never had a friend not help me in social situations like this because they know I’m autistic. Have faith! Teach them to speak up Flowers

Newcomer68 · 20/12/2021 21:16

I'm just over five foot. In the days before covid19 (and before I got old enough to admit I hated crowded pubs/wine bars etc) I used to absolutely dread having to go up to the bar.

It's not that I mind paying for a round, quite the opposite; I just used to hate being deliberately ignored by the pretty young female barmaids (which happened frequently) or having to wait until I could catch the eye of one of the kinder young men (evidently reminded of their mums or aunties!)

We usually did do kitties though. I now much prefer having to order via an app. Long live kitties and long live the app!!!!

And then I also used to dread having to run the gauntlet with the drinks when my nose was roughly at the same level as the armpits in the crowds. I don't mind a nice quiet country or suburban pub but I still don't understand the appeal of urban sardine watering holes!!!

If she isn't contributing though that's a different thing entirely, definitely try the kitty. Or just get her tap water!!

mam0918 · 20/12/2021 21:15

Just don't do rounds.

I never understand rounds, just buy your own drinks as you want/need them with your own money and then this issue couldn't exist - I have yet to come across one single good reason for rounds.

Also, my thought would be if someone never buys their own drink and doesn't repay drinks maybe they simply can't afford it.

I know I have some friends that INSISTS on buying everyone a drink even though most of us don't want to buy rounds (I can buy my own 2/3 vodkas and cokes but not a round of mixed drinks for 12 people and I wouldn't need that many drinks in turn either) because we cant afford it, they always say 'dont worry about it' but are very heavy handed and its bloody awkward.

CeibaTree · 20/12/2021 21:13

What happens when she isn't included in your informal rounds? If she is happy just to buy her own drinks, then just leave her to it and carry on as you are splitting off into rounds with people who are happy to do so.

Maryann1975 · 20/12/2021 21:12

As the parent of two autistic dc, I hope that If one of them was in this situation, a kind friend would Take them to one side and explain how the round system works and check if they needed support with it. One dc in particular has high anxiety andwould hate to have to go to the bar and order anything, but would also hate to have to ask a friend to come to the bar to help, so if a friend could offer with that, it would make a massive difference.

@colourfulpuddles Do you mean it is the friends fault she has a disability? Would you say that to someone in a wheelchair?

Loveisthere · 20/12/2021 21:07

We had a friend like this and when one of the group said its your round she grudgingly paid but stayed at the bar did not come back and join us. Next day complained on group txt that £12.10 had been taken out of her bank account then dissed us all in the same txt. It is very unfair to put the group on edge by being stingy

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 20/12/2021 21:06

She’s just tight. You should all agree to get her to buy the first round next time. Will she say she doesn’t want one then?

I’d just say to her, Look, you’re coming across as tight, and it’s not pretty.

Yogaandcocoa · 20/12/2021 21:04

Or if you all just want to exclude her from rounds and see if she asks then do that.

3luckystars · 20/12/2021 21:03

I wouldn’t open my mouth. If she says anything to you or asks your advice, I’d explain that people take turns buying rounds, and it’s probably her turn but I would not buy her another drink or say anything.

Yogaandcocoa · 20/12/2021 21:03

I think I'd just want to buy my own drinks but otherwise talk to her about it alone

Arren12 · 20/12/2021 21:03

I'm autistic and the complete opposite in that if someone buys me a drink I am anxious for them to accept one back. Il sit with my drink anxious that I must buy them one as soon as they finish so I don't look mean. I hate when people don't accept drinks (or anything for that matter) when they have bought me one. I try offer the first round always. A lovely generous friend of mine buys me lots of coffees and treats and will never accept one back when I offer and it makes me so anxious as I always feel awkward or in debt in some way. Example she bought me two coffees this week and i have thought about it for days since and I'm thinking about texting her to say i owe her drinks or something like that. Its because I have learnt its the right thing to do to buy someone a drink back but its hard for autistic people to know when the right time is or when is polite or if I'm saying the right thing in the right way. Urrrggghh
I don't mind going to the bar. But a night out to the pub is fun at the time but utterly exhausting for me and takes me time to recover after (not from alcohol but masking)
We are all different and some of my autistic friends sound similar to yours. Its really hard actually.

I'm constantly sat in groups second guessing if I'm missing social qs or saying the right thing etc sigh its a tough thing to have.

colourfulpuddles · 20/12/2021 21:03

Leave her out. It’s her own fault.

Rounds are ridiculous anyway.