Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

...to have frank talk with a stingy friend?

164 replies

concernedfriend500 · 20/12/2021 19:49

One of the members of our friend group never buys a round. She's happy to accept a drink when someone else is buying, but never reciprocates, apart from one time when her best friend called her out on it. At which point she claimed she wasn't thirsty.
Our friendship group normally meets in pubs for lunch/birthday etc drinks but now it's got to the point where she sits drink-less (she waits to see if someone will buy her a drink) because everyone else has wised up to her . It feels awkward and is in danger of spoiling the vibe when someone gets a round in but misses her out.
So should I have a frank talk with her, and what should I say? This may or may not be relevant but she might be on the spectrum, so not very good at social cues. But she also might just be very stingy (or both). She's not poor btw, quite the opposite.

OP posts:
Shoxfordian · 21/12/2021 06:04

I wouldn’t invite her anymore; she’s taking you all for mugs to keep buying her drinks all night

knittingaddict · 21/12/2021 05:36

@TheFairPrincess

I don't get rounds if you don't want as many drinks as there are people though? How many are there? I couldn't afford to buy 8 drinks and I wouldn't drink 8 drinks myself, for example.
I was going to reply with this. I don't go out social drinking, but if I did this is how I would feel about it. I don't like the concept of rounds and it wouldn't work for me.
UnsuitableHat · 21/12/2021 05:32

She needs to either take part in rounds or sort her own drinks out. If she doesn’t want to go to the bar, she could give someone the money if that’s the issue. I’d see nothing wrong with this being directly confronted, and if I was the friend in question that’s what I’d expect.

Rainbowqueeen · 21/12/2021 05:26

I’d have the discussion. You could say “you don’t seem comfortable participating fully in buying rounds. I’m trying to understand why Could you explain it to me “. Then see what she says. If there is an anxiety issue then you could come up with a solution.

If not you could say “moving forward, to avoid awkwardness and bad feelings, could you either participate fully by taking your turn to buy or just buy your own. “

anon12345678901 · 21/12/2021 05:14

Do rounds without her. I'd explain you're going to though and the reason. Maybe she'll offer to buy. But don't stop the whole group doing rounds simply because of one person.

Marchitectmummy · 21/12/2021 04:44

Do you only meet up in bars / circumstances like this? I would probably just leave out inviting m her to those events in the end not saying that's right!

I think I would be upfront and say something the day before to her like x y z and I are going to buy rounds do you want to join us or prefer to buy your own drinks separately? If she goes with joining you thrn I would Engineer her to be the first or second to buy.

Do that a few outings and she might get it. But you all need to stick to it and if she goes solo leave her with it, you are embarrassed where she isn't.

TreeSmuggler · 21/12/2021 04:32

I think you have to be a bit less attached to the idea of rounds being the thing that makes the night social and fun. OK yes, she hasn't done rounds correctly in the past, but now she gets her own drinks or doesn't have anything and seems totally fine with that. So what's the problem really? Just do rounds without her. It's not fair to say the whole nights "vibe" rests on rounds, ie everyone drinking and doing so at the same rate.

oKoK65 · 21/12/2021 03:53

I'm autistic and I use to have a thing about making sure everyone paid the correct amount so no one lost out financially. One of my friends said to me to look at it as though I'm paying for the company and the event rather than worrying about individual cost. This really helped so now I just split bill and accept sometimes I lose financially and sometimes I gain but I've enjoyed the evening. It's been lovely to read some of the replies that have considered why this might be happening rather than attacking the friend. Also lovely of op to be thinking of how best to manage this without impacting on friendship.

oKoK65 · 21/12/2021 03:44

Not everyone likes to go in rounds as it can end up costly. She may have money problems? What if one of you was to meet her separately or ask during a phone conversation (with no judgment) why she doesn't get a round in. She may have a good reason. If not the person could just explain to her that you guys will let her sort her own drinks out and that fine.

user1471457751 · 21/12/2021 02:50

@Maryann1975 nobody knows if the friend does have a disability. The OP just thinks her friend may be on the spectrum. That's not a diagnosis. The friend could just as easily be tight and rude

Emerald5hamrock · 21/12/2021 01:27

Yes definitely talk to her, if she was is on the spectrum a frank talk is what she needs.
Do it as one on one not as a group.
It is a horrible trait.
I jeered a family member for years he knew the price of everything and the value of nothing, unfortunately his beautiful DC have grown up and have the same attitude.
It makes me cringe they've learned this behaviour.

Somebodylikeyew · 21/12/2021 00:42

Someone posted this earlier, i like this approach:

“The other way is, the next time you're all in the pub and deciding who will buy for whom, to say, "Sarah, would you prefer to buy your own drinks, instead of getting a round?" If she says no, she wants to join in a round, to say in a matter of fact way, "We all need to take it in turns to buy then. Could you buy first?"

RainbowMum11 · 21/12/2021 00:34

We generally do rounds, but if someone is only staying for 1 or 2, or would rather just get their own drinks for whatever reason, Then it's absolutely fair enough.
No pressure either way, but if someone is going to accept drinks brought by otters on multiple occasions but not reciprocate, then it's not on at all.
If you afford a round, don't get into one.

phishy · 21/12/2021 00:24

@sadpapercourtesan

See, that's already making my autistic ass VERY nervous just reading about it Grin

it's informal, it just happens, if there's a large group we split off into smaller groups - can you not see how much of a nightmare that is for an autistic person?

Honestly, if you want this woman to carry on being included and not feel mortified, either leave it alone or stop doing rounds altogether.

What does ‘leave it alone’ mean? That people keep subsidising her?

I think she knows what she’s doing, because when her best friend called her out on it, she didn’t take part in the round and said she wasn’t thirsty.

OP, surely if her best friend has called her out on it in public then she must have spoken to her about it in private as well?

I think she’s hoping to embarrass you all into making an exception for her. Don’t do it!

Restart10 · 21/12/2021 00:20

@blissfulllife

I'd put money on it being a social anxiety thing. I'm on the spectrum and hate going to the bar
So? You just sit there accepting drinks when someone is paying but its social anxiety when it's your turn? You can't possibly use that as an excuse here?
Sorka · 21/12/2021 00:05

Lots of people suggesting she might be struggling with going to the bar. Did she get drinks in when it was table service only, often ordering via an app?

She’s either stingy or obtuse. Either way bluntness is your friend.

Yours,
Someone who is so sometimes too blunt

MyHandbagBetterThanMaryPoppins · 20/12/2021 23:35

Just to reiterate the other posters, the kitty system works around social anxiety/unknowns. Everyone pops in £20 for drinks if you want rounds or, buy your own. Job done.

Fossie · 20/12/2021 23:32

I wasn’t great at this when I was younger. I’m grateful to people who know how to lead a situation. For example, I’m asked by someone who has bought me a drink, if I would like another drink. I say ‘yes’, they then say ‘I think that’s your turn to pay, do you want to give me the cash?’ Simple.

SisterConcepta · 20/12/2021 23:24

Clearly another of life’s takers....everyone knows at least one

ttcpatronisers · 20/12/2021 23:22

@saraclara

I don't get it. Why, in all this time has no one said "it's your round"?

Why not just be straightforward?

Exactly this !!
saraclara · 20/12/2021 23:12

I don't get it. Why, in all this time has no one said "it's your round"?

Why not just be straightforward?

LittleMysSister · 20/12/2021 23:08

@WhoopsWhatsMyNameAgain

I hate rounds. I hate the uncertainty of not knowing what everyone will order and having to pay for it despite it possibly being a lot more expensive than what I'd drink normally. I have money but I don't want to spend it on other people's drinks. Wouldn't mind it as a one off but not every time the group met.

Time to stop rounds and just get your own I think. That way no one is being left out and no one is being taken advantage of.

Is it possible she just doesn't like drinking and pubs anymore? Maybe that's why shes not bothered sitting there empty handed

But everyone else is happy doing rounds?

And this friend is happy to accept the drinks everyone else buys for her, she just never returns the favour. So doesn't sound like it's about her not liking drinking or pubs.

Lilymossflower · 20/12/2021 22:53

She may Well be a CF

Or she may be autistic as you say she may be, and not understand this stuff. In which case a frank talk without anger and not in public would be the best way forward. We autistics don't understand what we did wrong without an explanation

thefourgp · 20/12/2021 22:50

I don’t like buying rounds because I’m not a big drinker and always end up out of pocket but I’d always buy someone a drink if they bought me one. Maybe stop inviting her to group events where everyone else is buying rounds? Or just no-one buy her a drink and let her sit without one. I knew a woman who was briefly part of my social circle and she got left out after a while because she was always sponging off her friends. She even started a go fund me page for a jolly weekend away she pretended was for essential business. She turned up to a hen weekend where she was a bridesmaid without any cash for drinks so the others ended up buying all her drinks. She had no shame. I’ve no sympathy for such people when they’re no longer invited out on social occasions.

WhoopsWhatsMyNameAgain · 20/12/2021 22:49

I hate rounds. I hate the uncertainty of not knowing what everyone will order and having to pay for it despite it possibly being a lot more expensive than what I'd drink normally. I have money but I don't want to spend it on other people's drinks. Wouldn't mind it as a one off but not every time the group met.

Time to stop rounds and just get your own I think. That way no one is being left out and no one is being taken advantage of.

Is it possible she just doesn't like drinking and pubs anymore? Maybe that's why shes not bothered sitting there empty handed