Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my cleaner should stay for two hours?

231 replies

Holeandthentwo · 20/12/2021 15:27

I pay for a cleaner to clean my house every other week. The minimum you can pay for is two hours, which is fine.

However, I’ve noticed over the months that she leaves early. At first it was only ten minutes or so and I didn’t care, but it’s built up and built up so that today she arrived at 2pm and left at 3pm. I always make myself scarce when she’s there so I’m not getting in her way, but I know the times because my Ring doorbell sends an alert as she arrives and leaves.

I’m torn about whether to say anything, because it’s now half the time I pay for, but she is a good cleaner, provides all the equipment, and is happy to let herself in with the key, and I feel trusting of her having a key.

Should I say anything? Or just accept that she can clean the house in half the time I pay for?

YABU - say nothing because the clean is still being done

YANBU - say something because it’s not what I’m paying for

OP posts:
Allthesefolks · 20/12/2021 19:49

YANBU, My best cleaner would ask for extra jobs and said she’d do them if she finished the general clean earlier, god I miss her!

Dimondsareforever · 20/12/2021 19:43

Just remind them that if they finish all the jobs before the 2 hours they are to do x y and z to make up the 2 hours. (So give a long list of extras).

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 20/12/2021 19:42

£14 per hour is rubbish for a business. However that's a different conversation.
Anyhow she should stay the full 2 hrs unless agreed before hand.

dustofneptune · 20/12/2021 19:31

Have you booked her through a company that sends her, or is she independent? If she's sent via a company, the company will usually give her a list of tasks expected in a standard 2-hour clean. Even if she's independent, she might be working to a task list based on what you've asked her to do?

I had a cleaning job once, in my 20s.

The company would book me in for X amount of time, and there would be a list of tasks I'd need to complete within that time.

The company would actively encourage me to get it done fast, especially if the client was home (so that I could out of their way).

The company also didn't factor in breaks or a lunch hour, nor sufficient time to travel between bookings. Which also forced me to work faster... so that I could actually eat... or get to the next booking.

I also just found that as I got to know the clients' homes, I got into a flow and could get everything done in significantly less time than when I started.

So could it be that she is working to tasks, rather than time booked?

Or that she's under time pressure from her company, if she works for a company?

Ultimately it's a communication thing. I'd talk to her and ask first. People don't always leave early because they're lazy. Sometimes they're just efficient, pressured, or there is a communication breakdown.

tttigress · 20/12/2021 19:29

Why not stay in the house when she is cleaning? You might at least get 1 hour 30 or 1 hour 40.

I understand it is a tricky situation, it hard to find someone you trust, to let in you house, but on the other hand you could say she is nicking £15-£20 of you per visit, by not doing the full 2 hours.

BertramLacey · 20/12/2021 19:22

Well, if a dental nurse gets a tenner an hour, then 14 for a cleaner is a bit steep.

That's an argument to pay dental nurses more, not to pay cleaners less. And besides, as PPs have pointed out you cannot compare a rate for direct employment with those for self employment. I always build other factors into my hourly rate. I don't get holiday pay or sick pay. I have to pay towards a pension and my NI. I have to pay for my own insurance.

Also, some people seem to be assuming that the OP is paying £14 per hour. She hasn't said what she pays, someone else mentioned that rate. And she is paying for two hours because that is the minimum timeframe her cleaner will allow for, not because she has two hours of work to do necessarily. As a self-employed person I charge more for shorter jobs than for longer-term jobs because I have to allow for travel time in between lots of short jobs otherwise.

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 20/12/2021 17:52

Also whether I would immediately get rid or not would depend on her response when I explain she’s left an hour early.

LethargicActress · 20/12/2021 17:44

@Luredbyapomegranate

You need to give her more work!

Can’t blame her for leaving if she’s finished

There is no way any house is ever so clean that it’s ‘finished’ in an hour. There is always something else that can be cleaned.

For £14 an hour, a professional cleaner should be able to show a bit of initiative, instead of trying to rip off their clients.

speakout · 20/12/2021 17:39

Or you could just have an open conversation with her to re-affirm the arrangements you have.
Perhaps she is under the assumption that you are paying her to do a set number of tasks, so once they are finished she can leave. Some cleaners are very quick and efficient, others take more time.
If you are paying her for a set amount of time then that needs to be clarified- and if she completes the basic stuff in less time -then as other posters have said then you need to have a discussion about jobs that can be done less frequently- hoovering behind sofas, sorting out cupboards, emptying and cleaning the cutlery drawer. You could give her a list of the stuff that is less of a priority if she completes the basics with time left over.
In any case I see no need for conflict or bad feeling- just an honest open discussion about expectations.

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 20/12/2021 17:38

Can’t blame her for leaving if she’s finished

It’s cheeky fuckery because she has a minimum requirement of 2 hours. I am sure there are plenty of things she can do if she actually wanted to. Our cleaner cleans silverware if she has run out of things to do. Or sorts out cupboards etc. Doesn’t really matter / if she has genuinely run out of things to do (which I doubt as one hour is not a long time to clean a house!!!) then she needs to explain that to the person paying her snd find more tasks. You don’t simply leave an hour early - halfway through your shift!

Ninananna · 20/12/2021 17:37

My cleaner did this and used to have her husband in for coffee at 11 am. I knew nothing about this as at work. My neighbour told me. I gave her more jobs to do and told her a coffee break was fine but my house was not a cafeteria. I also used to pay her when she was ill until she seemed to be ill every other week. I like to be fair with people but not taken for a mug.

Concestor · 20/12/2021 17:37

@Luredbyapomegranate

You need to give her more work!

Can’t blame her for leaving if she’s finished

She should either use her initiative and do extra cleaning, or if she really can't think of anything else that might need doing (which I find very hard to believe) she should ask. Or she could say she's only done X time so to only pay her for that.

What she should not do is piss off early and still charge for the full time.

MGMidget · 20/12/2021 17:31

She should tell you she has finished everything and is there something extra you'd like her to do? Surely there are areas she could deep clean on a rotation each week to make up the time or perhaps she could do some ironing for you? I would say that you have noticed she is finishing early and could she therefore add x,y, z to her list of jobs to do in the two hours you are paying her for. Also, say that if she finishes before the two hours are up can she ask you what else you'd like her to do if she's unable to take the initiative and identify areas that need more attention? Does she actually do everything in just an hour? I mean if you run your finger over the higher shelves and under the sofa do you pick up dust? Is a tide line starting to form on the bath? We had a tide line start forming on our bath when a cleaner was supposedly cleaning it every week. Needless to say I don't think she'd touched it for months!

ChampagneLassie · 20/12/2021 17:31

I'd say I noticed you were only here an hour last week - if you've done most of the normal clean, if you're not sure how to fill the time - either give me a shout or have a look at this list of other jobs etc

Curiousmouse · 20/12/2021 17:30

I have got rid in this situation. Most people do.. It doesn't usually improve.

Pigeoninthehouse · 20/12/2021 17:29

I think it depends if you are paying her to do a job, i.e. clean your home, or you are paying her to stay in your house for 2 hours.
Providing you home is clean when she leaves, I see no point in someone sitting in your property to make up time.
If you want her to stay longer, giver her more jobs to do to make up her time.

Luredbyapomegranate · 20/12/2021 17:29

You need to give her more work!

Can’t blame her for leaving if she’s finished

woodhill · 20/12/2021 17:25

@PrimalIceScreamer

Please say something. My cleaner used to do this. At first, I didn't mind because she did clean the house but like you eventually she was constantly leaving an hour earlier. When I mentioned it, she claimed she was doing extra at other times (she wasn't). We still kept her on but I found that her cleaning standards dropped and she was cutting corners elsewhere in order to leave early.

Eventually DH asked me would I leave my work 1 hour early all the time? What would my manager think? What would that say about my standard and professionalism?

I gave her a chance to rectify it - she didn't so I got rid of her.

Yes that's it

Also the cleaners should not act if they are doing you a favour.

peboh · 20/12/2021 17:18

Is all the work being done in an hour? If so, I'd be looking at finding a cleaner who charges by the hour rather than two hourly.
Are you leaving her a list of what you expect doing?

TrufflesAndToast · 20/12/2021 17:18

It’s mind boggling to me that someone who is of an age (adult) and a life position to have a weekly cleaner is tying themselves in knots over what to do when their employee walks off the job after half their paid shift. Honestly, baffling. How is this a topic of discussion?!

Blondeshavemorefun · 20/12/2021 17:16

A few mins fine. Not an hour

Tho is the house spotless

PrimalIceScreamer · 20/12/2021 17:14

Please say something. My cleaner used to do this. At first, I didn't mind because she did clean the house but like you eventually she was constantly leaving an hour earlier. When I mentioned it, she claimed she was doing extra at other times (she wasn't). We still kept her on but I found that her cleaning standards dropped and she was cutting corners elsewhere in order to leave early.

Eventually DH asked me would I leave my work 1 hour early all the time? What would my manager think? What would that say about my standard and professionalism?

I gave her a chance to rectify it - she didn't so I got rid of her.

Wheresthebeach · 20/12/2021 17:12

She can't be doing a very thorough job to clean a house in 1 hour IMO. Dusting, vacuuming, cleaning bathrooms and kitchen all in 1 hour?

This is why I got rid of our cleaner - I don't want to be chasing people to do their job properly. If you are paying for 2 hours, then she should be cleaning for 2 hours. It won't be beyond her ability to find cleaning to do without you spelling it out. By all means raise it but I'm not convinced there will be a long term improvement.

2bazookas · 20/12/2021 17:09

@DismantledKing

If I was paying for 2 hours I’d expect them to be there for 2 hours.
I would be there when she arrives, to GET YOUR KEY Back.

It doesn't matter how good she is at cleaning. What matters is that she's a dishonest conniving cheat who has already stolen from you.

MrsMurdstone · 20/12/2021 17:03

I would assign her a special job each week (clean oven, clean windows, do ironing etc).