Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think schools should send reading books home over the holidays?

166 replies

DeepaBeesKit · 20/12/2021 11:49

My kids school hasnt sent any reading book or library book home at all for the holidays. AIBU to think this is daft because
a) it sends the message that reading is hard/not enjoyable and one needs a "break" from it
b) its likely to widen the gaps between children with engaged parents who'll ensure their kids keep reading/enjoying books any way, and the kids for whom the reading book from school was the only book in the house.
c) it's a shame for a keen reader who'd happily get stuck into a book over the winter holidays when the weather is crap outside.

OP posts:
PlanktonsComputerWife · 20/12/2021 16:59

Bully for you. It's been very different for the children at my child's school. When the lockdown began they will still in Year4, and got no maths instruction.

timanddaisy · 20/12/2021 16:56

@PlanktonsComputerWife

tbh OP given how behind the y6s are, and the test looming in spring, I'm a bit surprised there were no reading comprehension or maths worksheets sent home. I don't think a bit of proper homework would have hurt.
Oh give over.

My Y6s are exactly where they should be. We provided excellent online learning and they are actually the best cohort we've had for years.

So I made the decision as their teacher to give them a break. They've worked damned hard and were just as exhausted as the staff. Two weeks of downtime with their families is exactly what they need. Not more bloody worksheets!!

WorraLiberty · 20/12/2021 16:50

@DeepaBeesKit

The main (pre-covid) reason at our school seems to be this idea that reading is a chore from which you deserve a break. I think that's the part I disagree with most.

I don't think this qualified as a teacher bashing thread, given that many schools do send home books it's clearly something that divides opinion.

The main (pre-covid) reason at our school seems to be this idea that reading is a chore from which you deserve a break. I think that's the part I disagree with most.

Reading is a chore for some kids and adults who don't enjoy it, or find it very difficult.

Those who don't, will normally have other books to read anyway.

LittleBabyCheeses · 20/12/2021 16:47

Every child in our school got a book as their Christmas present.

LethargicActress · 20/12/2021 16:40

We sent home books for our ks1 class, some parents asked for extra and we happily obliged. But I can guarantee that more than half of the children won’t have even looked at their books over the holidays. Some parents will write in the diary to say that they’ve read their school books and about all the other books their children have been enjoying, which is fabulous. Some parents will send their children back in January with all the work and Christmas stuff still in the book back from last term having not even opened it, and nor will their children have seen a book from home either.

Schools sending home books over Christmas is not the problem for the children you’re talking about.

AskItaliano · 20/12/2021 16:39

I think it's pretty awful if they're lumping books in with homework, making a big deal about how lovely it is to 'have a break' over the holidays from it. Doesn't really go hand in hand with encouraging reading for pleasure's sake!

If they're worried about not getting books back then it'd be nice if they'd set a piece of homework over the holidays to read a book and write a little review of it, any book. Can be a newspaper article, whatever. Just to encourage continuing to read.

But I'm biased, I don't see reading as some onerous things that's a relief to be freed from.

Sadly there will be kids who don't have access to a book at home.

dotsandco · 20/12/2021 16:32

Well I sent my class home with their usual two reading books, plus an extra one because it was the holidays, AND a library book for 'pleasure reading' 🤷‍♀️

Please don't tar us all with your own experience OP! If you have an issue with your child's school, speak to them directly!

sleighbelleuk · 20/12/2021 16:32

I bought all the children in my class a book for their Christmas present. I tend to do it every year. For some of them, it's one of the few books they're ever given.

LethargicActress · 20/12/2021 16:31

@CallmeHendricksGingleBells

You think that primary schools should have sent homework home over Christmas? Just what proportion of kids do you think would have complied with that?
Reading isn’t homework. The whole point is that it is supposed to become a built in part of life, for both pleasure and necessity.

If you see it as homework you’re doing it wrong.

southlondoner02 · 20/12/2021 16:31

@PlanktonsComputerWife

tbh OP given how behind the y6s are, and the test looming in spring, I'm a bit surprised there were no reading comprehension or maths worksheets sent home. I don't think a bit of proper homework would have hurt.
About 15 pages of english and maths here (year6). No reading books though. Not sure whether all the kids do it all. We have quite a few train journeys so it usually gets done then.

I'm also seeing threads on here about how children don't do anything in the last couple of weeks before Christmas. Definitely not the case here - classes as usual until the last day when they played games/ watched a film

viques · 20/12/2021 16:27

@KTheGrey

Depends on whether the school's can afford to lose the books. It may surprise you to hear that some maybe can't. I am constantly irritated by the necessity of buying glue sticks for kids out of my own pocket, I try to draw the line at books.
I once had to speak to a parent about replacing a reading book he had used to write messages and phone numbers on. He was really cross with me and didn’t see the issue, because as he pointed out, the phone numbers were on the inside cover so the actual text was still readable , it wasn’t as though he had lost the book!
KTheGrey · 20/12/2021 16:12

Depends on whether the school's can afford to lose the books. It may surprise you to hear that some maybe can't. I am constantly irritated by the necessity of buying glue sticks for kids out of my own pocket, I try to draw the line at books.

melj1213 · 20/12/2021 15:37

The main (pre-covid) reason at our school seems to be this idea that reading is a chore from which you deserve a break. I think that's the part I disagree with most.

It's not just reading though and for some children reading is a chore. Sending books home is not going to make it any more appealing, if anything it will put pressure on some children to spend their holiday reading even if it is something they struggle with ... just like if you sent a child who struggles with numbers home for the holidays with a maths workbook.

As a child I was never more than an arms length from a book, and devoured every book in the children's library week in, week out ... I still hated being sent home for the holidays with a book I was expected to read, whether I liked it or not.

Pascha · 20/12/2021 15:28

Mine did bring books home. They did last year too when the school knew it was closing.

DeepaBeesKit · 20/12/2021 15:26

The main (pre-covid) reason at our school seems to be this idea that reading is a chore from which you deserve a break. I think that's the part I disagree with most.

I don't think this qualified as a teacher bashing thread, given that many schools do send home books it's clearly something that divides opinion.

OP posts:
Blossom64265 · 20/12/2021 15:11

At our school, parents could come into the library with their kids during drop off or pickup and check out books. I’m guessing that will have stopped with Covid though, dd moved up right when it hit so now accessed the library solo at her school anyway. They also have free access before and after school, during lunch, and can ask for a pass if they have finished their work in a class.

I do agree that there should never be a break from reading. It’s something to be done daily for pleasure.

Moonlaserbearwolf · 20/12/2021 15:07

@MyCatEatsPrawnCrackers

We didn't allow reading books to go home during the Christmas and Easter holidays as only half of them would be brought back and it was costing the school a fortune to replace them.
That's such a sad reason. Our school charges parents for lost books, but appreciate this might not work in a deprived area.

OP, I agree with you. We always make sure our children have school reading books for the holidays - and children chose their own books (within reading bands), plus a non fiction of their choice which could be beyond their reading level, but can be read with a parent. So important for children to be able to chose their own books.

Ewock · 20/12/2021 15:02

Should have added out sucks to be anyone right now as cases are out of control

CheeseCrackersAndChutney · 20/12/2021 15:02

We don’t have enough books to send more than one home at a time

MyCatEatsPrawnCrackers · 20/12/2021 14:58

We didn't allow reading books to go home during the Christmas and Easter holidays as only half of them would be brought back and it was costing the school a fortune to replace them.

morechocolateneededtoday · 20/12/2021 14:54

I was surprised for all the same reasons as you OP. DC1 has just started reception so I don't know what would have happened in normal times but we were very fortunate for covid not to have impacted last few weeks of term much so I want to say that the norm is not sending them home.

We go library regularly so just picked up a few extra for holidays to make up for it. Definitely reading at much slower pace over the break but did not want to stop completely as we were in a good rhythm and progressing really well.

LlamaParma · 20/12/2021 14:54

If your kid is a keen reader read a book that’s not from school. It’s not like they’re not readily available Hmm

Sirzy · 20/12/2021 14:53

On the whole school reading books aren’t going to encourage a love of reading. They are great for helping develop the reading skills but the love of reading comes from elsewhere.

Perhaps you could talk to the school about creating some sort of book exchange system to help those with no access to books?

teaandtoastwithmarmite · 20/12/2021 14:50

My DD hasn't had any reading books for years. They're all online now and she doesn't like it that way. She does bring home library books though but she picks them.

EmpressCixi · 20/12/2021 14:49

I think YABU. We had books assigned to read over term breaks and holidays complete with having to write a book report to hand in on first day back at school. I absolutely hated this as the books were always some stupid boring “classic” children’s book. I do love to read and hated having to force myself through books about Dick Whittington and his stupid cat, or the prince and the pauper fuckery. I’d have to force myself to do the school book and write an arse licking report before I could dive back into reading about dragons or spaceships.

Swipe left for the next trending thread