Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think schools should send reading books home over the holidays?

166 replies

DeepaBeesKit · 20/12/2021 11:49

My kids school hasnt sent any reading book or library book home at all for the holidays. AIBU to think this is daft because
a) it sends the message that reading is hard/not enjoyable and one needs a "break" from it
b) its likely to widen the gaps between children with engaged parents who'll ensure their kids keep reading/enjoying books any way, and the kids for whom the reading book from school was the only book in the house.
c) it's a shame for a keen reader who'd happily get stuck into a book over the winter holidays when the weather is crap outside.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TheWayTheLightFalls · 22/12/2021 06:44

I don't agree OP. There are a couple of things being conflated here imo -

Reading as "homework" v reading as pleasure and how to encourage it. I think this is a combined task for schools and parents to model and develop, and just sending books home (during the holidays or otherwise) won't do it.

The family/home environment and widening attainment gaps - it's what we all saw during lockdown, surely? Some kids raced ahead with the benefit of parental attention and/or resources, others lagged badly behind. Again, sending books home won't do much, imo, unless the issue you're trying to address is "families who'd like to encourage reading but have neither the time nor money to encourage reading themselves".

General availability of books for children that want them - libraries, innit. Though the ones near me haven't reopened post-covid, if we can even say that we are post-covid. I expect however that if a child asked their teacher to borrow books during the holiday they'd be allowed to do so.

twocatsandtwokids · 22/12/2021 06:31

Surprised by the votes on here, as a teacher and a parent! Yes I’d have been really annoyed if my 5 year old hadn’t brought home a reading book for the almost 3 week break, as the momentum we’ve built up since September would have been lost. We’ve got loads of books at home but she’s on a certain scheme so is working through that. They bring home 2 scheme books each time.
My 8 year old would have been fine without one as he mainly reads his own books anyway, but he has one so we’ll have a look at some point!

FancySomeChips · 22/12/2021 06:19

Solidarity with @Randallthecat though.
It’s been horrendous!

VashtaNerada · 22/12/2021 06:18

I’m a teacher and I managed to sort out books for everyone on the last day but only by whacking a film on while I managed sorting out letters / cards / presents / schoolwork for everyone while my TA facilitated book swapping. It was a bit of a nightmare and they were swapping books right up to hometime. I can totally understand why other classes (esp if they don’t have a TA) didn’t manage to get round to it.

FancySomeChips · 22/12/2021 06:17

My class went home with 2 reading scheme books and a library book.

Don’t generalise with your negative judgements please!

PlanktonsComputerWife · 22/12/2021 05:44

Despite technological advances I think so many children are disadvantaged by a lack of reading.

This.

And how lovely, when you're stuck at home over Christmas with brothers fighting, dad drunk, and mother having a meltdown over the Christmas meal in the kitchen, to have a book to escape into.

Many of the avid readers I know became so over the course of a particular childhood holiday trapped with family, or a particular convalescence, bored out of their skull. The point is that there were books available at the right time when they were more needed.

Frazzled50yrold · 22/12/2021 00:17

It's a wasted opportunity in terms of developing a love of reading or even to use as a point of discussion after the holidays.
Despite technological advances I think so many children are disadvantaged by a lack of reading.

gingerbiscuits · 21/12/2021 23:47

Thank you! 💗 Understanding, appreciative parents make up for the utter cockwomblery of the Dept for Education & the Government who have thrown us under the bus for the past 2yrs!!

SleepingStandingUp · 21/12/2021 22:40

Most of up appreciate what you're doing @gingerbiscuits

gingerbiscuits · 21/12/2021 22:21

@SleepingStandingUp

It's been a hell of a term in education - the worst so far - & that's saying something, considering the past 2yrs!! 💗 Hope you feel less awful very soon! why has this one been harder than the previous last two years *@gingerbiscuits*? Genuine qn from a parent
Horrific levels of Covid within the school - staff & kids - we've been on our knees for weeks, just trying to get by. Stress & sickness levels are through the roof. All the usual responsibilities plus desperately trying to do what we can to catch the kids up. Nowhere near enough measures in place to keep us safe. Pressure upon pressure. Plus we all have our OWN children to worry about. It's been the hardest term I've taught in 8yrs!!
CeibaTree · 21/12/2021 22:20

@DeepaBeesKit

It's a school policy. No books/homework over the holiday. They make a bit of a thing of what a lovely break it is.
Sounds a great policy, holidays are holidays and should be a lovely break.
SleepingStandingUp · 21/12/2021 22:04

[quote Hercisback]@SleepingStandingUp
No measures to stop covid spread in schools so much higher staff absence. DfE online learning rules for isolating students are much stricter. Behaviour is appalling.[/quote]
Most of us appreciate what you're doing x

Hercisback · 21/12/2021 22:00

@SleepingStandingUp
No measures to stop covid spread in schools so much higher staff absence. DfE online learning rules for isolating students are much stricter. Behaviour is appalling.

SleepingStandingUp · 21/12/2021 21:43

It's been a hell of a term in education - the worst so far - & that's saying something, considering the past 2yrs!! 💗 Hope you feel less awful very soon! why has this one been harder than the previous last two years @gingerbiscuits? Genuine qn from a parent

Mojoj · 21/12/2021 18:53

That's what libraries are for.

TheKeatingFive · 21/12/2021 13:03

They should definitely send them home with school library books, yes.

KaycePollard · 21/12/2021 13:01

@Randallthecat

The reason our children haven’t got reading books is that half our staff went off with covid. Brought in by children whose entire families had covid, except the child who hadn’t had a positive lateral flow. Surprise surprise these children DID have covid, passed it on to staff. So on half the staff we have supervised children, done calendars, Christmas cards, Christmas parties, Christmas decorations, Christmas dinner, zoom assemblies, Christmas jumper day, handing out Christmas cards and all the other tat that primary age children love to do at Christmas, and that lots of parents would complain if they didn’t receive - ON TOP of assessments, English, maths and topic, as well as safeguarding, being social workers, doctors, parents, hairdressers, cleaners and the myriad of other jobs being a teacher entails. So apologies our reading books didn’t get sent out, perhaps Santa might bring your child a book. And I now have covid for Christmas, so that’s an extra bonus.
@Randallthecat Thanks for all you do - and I'm sorry that so many parents have so little respect for your health & safety, and that the government has pushed teachers under the bus over these last 2 years.
Plumbear2 · 21/12/2021 10:40

It's Christmas, let them have a break. If you child wants to read then provide the books for them. My son's in high school and tjank fully has no homework. Is been a tough term and he needs a break to just relax, play and enjoy himself as do primary kids. It's not school time, it's up to you to provide the books.

gingerbiscuits · 21/12/2021 10:28

@Randallthecat

The reason our children haven’t got reading books is that half our staff went off with covid. Brought in by children whose entire families had covid, except the child who hadn’t had a positive lateral flow. Surprise surprise these children DID have covid, passed it on to staff. So on half the staff we have supervised children, done calendars, Christmas cards, Christmas parties, Christmas decorations, Christmas dinner, zoom assemblies, Christmas jumper day, handing out Christmas cards and all the other tat that primary age children love to do at Christmas, and that lots of parents would complain if they didn’t receive - ON TOP of assessments, English, maths and topic, as well as safeguarding, being social workers, doctors, parents, hairdressers, cleaners and the myriad of other jobs being a teacher entails. So apologies our reading books didn’t get sent out, perhaps Santa might bring your child a book. And I now have covid for Christmas, so that’s an extra bonus.
100% feel your pain & completely understand. It's been a hell of a term in education - the worst so far - & that's saying something, considering the past 2yrs!! 💗 Hope you feel less awful very soon!
Rainartist · 21/12/2021 09:40

@DeepaBeesKit

library

I'm mindful of the kids in homes where no one will take them.

Unfortunately if the childs parents are not engaged with their learning they probably wouldn't encourage the child to read anyway if they didn't want to. A child who wants to read will find a way to do so and even if a book was sent home will probably have finished it quickly anyway.
DappyApple · 21/12/2021 09:28

I wish my dcs school would have given them a break over the holidays when they were in primary. Books got sent home relentlessly throughout the week, weekends, and holidays with exception of the summer break.
But because they put so much pressure on reading (yet spellings weren’t important) my dd who did struggle at school absolutely hated reading aloud. She lost the joy of reading altogether. I would have to fill in her diary without knowing whether she’d read the book or not!

She was so much better reading her own books at her own pace with no added pressure.

Ive had to replace/pay for a few lost school books over the years, and spent many a Monday morning searching for a misplaced book.
I would have much rather used dds own books to do home reading.

elliejjtiny · 21/12/2021 00:33

My year 6 dc is a free reader so he reads a book from home anyway. My year 3 and year 4 dc are on the school reading scheme and they didn't bring home a school reading book. Tbh I was relieved. My dc will happily read their own books to themselves or to their teddies etc at a time that suits them. Getting them to read the school reading book to me is a nightly battle though and it's nice to have a break.

SleepingStandingUp · 21/12/2021 00:18

[quote babachic]@SleepingStandingUp it is awful. But it's just a reflection of the poor funding and resources given to schools these days Sad[/quote]
I meant the parents BTW. How do you destroy books routinely or lose them that often?? I've sent the odd one back with extra cellotape and I've lost one over first lock down but I paid for it but it's a rarity in 4 years!

babachic · 21/12/2021 00:17

@SleepingStandingUp it is awful. But it's just a reflection of the poor funding and resources given to schools these days Sad

SleepingStandingUp · 21/12/2021 00:14

@babachic that's ridiculous