Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teachers!

564 replies

MsFannySqueers · 20/12/2021 11:01

So retired/ex teachers are being asked to consider returning to the classroom because of possible staff shortages in the New Year. Is this something you would do?

OP posts:
MrsHamlet · 21/12/2021 16:20

I've terminated teaching placements because the quality of planning and delivery has been so bad yet they've passed observations
Yep. I sacked one trainee after a week and have another needing additional support. Their unis are pressing on as though they're going to be eminently suitable. They're not. But they've paid ...

ParsleySageRosemary · 21/12/2021 16:15

There’s also a lot of questions to be asked about the purpose of education, in a country where it’s main purpose seems to push kids into a life of ever greater debt and lower wages. Teachers are relatively well looked after, but is that all education is good for? TAs have had a shittier time for years.

Workyticket · 21/12/2021 16:14

Some of the people coming through the ECT scheme and others like it will simply never be teachers.

I have people with poor literacy and numeracy skills on our Functional skills maths and English courses who've been promised places on the PGCE course next year

Lots I've met who are already on programmes have chaotic homelives and already poor mental health. No way could they cope in classrooms

I've terminated teaching placements because the quality of planning and delivery has been so bad yet they've passed observations

Some have been brilliant but they are genuinely few and far between. From what I've experienced the teaching crisis is yet to hit its peak sadly.

MrsSantaClausitback · 21/12/2021 16:12

If I wasn’t good enough for 2/3 days and then business reasons weren’t doable after my last maternity leave, then what’s changed? Oh hang on, they’re desperate having pushed out too many experienced teachers…

Not a chance! It’s supply rate so after childcare I’d take home pennies.

Hercisback · 21/12/2021 16:06

Because children desperately need some assistance here before their educational progress is damaged beyond repair.

Such rhetoric.

There's a lot of arguments to be had about what constitutes "progress" in education, and now is not the time or place.

I'm also not sure how a babysitter (because that is what these volunteers will be) can provide much in the way of education. This isn't to deride supply staff. They work incredibly hard in crap circumstances, but because they don't know the students, the lessons aren't great. Often they are given holding work until the class teacher returns.

MrsHamlet · 21/12/2021 16:00

The Early Career Framework is making someone (Teach First amongst others) a lot of money.
It's not making my NQTs anything other than angry and overworked and condescended to though.

ParsleySageRosemary · 21/12/2021 15:57

@MrsHamlet

What’s happened to all the new teachers who graduated this year? Quite a lot who start never complete. Quite a lot who complete don't start teaching. Quite a lot who start teaching go into the private sector.
I’m in one of those groups. Perhaps they should take the time limit off the qualification too, or extend it, or provide routes to look again later. Routes that don’t carry exorbitant fees, or require newbies to jump through hoops and meet standards that older teachers never had to. And put some kind of quality control on placements. They extended the probation period required post-qualification for primary recently, and are showing no sign of removing that extension.
amillionmenonmars · 21/12/2021 15:57

SammyScrounge I spent a career thinking of the children. I lost my health, lost time with my own family and nearly lost my mind because I was thinking of the children, and putting their needs first. I did that for 30 years.

I spent my own money buying resources so that they could have the things they needed. I propped up a broken system because I really cared about giving my students the education they deserved. I loved teaching - I was really good at it. What I didn't like was all of the pointless admin, constant scrutiny and, when I became too expensive the not so subtle managing me out of my job.

Please don't play the 'lets do this for the kids' card. I have been there and done that. And I say no more.

CallmeHendricksGingleBells · 21/12/2021 15:44

And when we try to raise issues, we're dismissed as whinging, leftie Unionists, workshy and goodness knows what else.
And here on MN in particular, we are told that if we don't like it, then we should resign.
But when it then becomes clear, as now, that the wheels are coming off, we are also castigated for not being prepared to come back to help out.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 21/12/2021 15:29

Because children desperately need some assistance here before their educational progress is damaged beyond repair

And teachers have tried. So very hard, but it’s about money. It’s not the teachers it’s the shut government. They should be accountable not passing the ball to the teachers.

FrippEnos · 21/12/2021 15:26

SammyScrounge

Because children desperately need some assistance here before their educational progress is damaged beyond repair.

and the government, ofsted and the dfe should be sorting this out, not rolling it downhill and blaming the teachers.

SammyScrounge · 21/12/2021 15:23

@Tillsforthrills

Why should they expose themselves to help out this inadequate government.
Because children desperately need some assistance here before their educational progress is damaged beyond repair.
MrsHamlet · 21/12/2021 15:12

Do they enjoy their jobs? Are they struggling every day to make themselves go in? Do their colleagues and seniors know the issues? Are they empowered to do anything about it?
I love my job.
But yes... I struggle with the relentlessness that comes from every direction. My colleagues and I have raised issues with the senior team and been dismissed. It won't get easier.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 21/12/2021 15:10

I’m not wondering why teachers are moaning. I’m simply saying that I think the reaction is not reflecting brilliantly on us

Who cares? We are at the bottom of the pile. Get snagged off by the public, shafted by the government.

Maybe people will take notice of how shit the conditions are when there’s no teachers left.

awkwardperson · 21/12/2021 15:10

@amillionmenonmars

If ex teachers and retired teachers trip merrily along to the volunteering table then the shit that teachers have put up with for years, and especially have put up with during covid, will be brushed under the carpet. After all, it can't be all that bad if all of those former teachers are happy to return to the classroom.

It is only by saying a very firm NO and even a FUCK THAT that maybe, just maybe, some people will realise that the way teachers are treated in this country is unacceptable.

As I said before I left early with no job to go on. I have been living off my savings for a year now. Even if you paid me I would not go back into the classroom.

Wow. This and so many other similar extreme reluctance. This is a profession that people go to Uni to qualify for. How awful must being a teacher be to have people leaving all that behind and never ever ever willing to go back.

I feel for the teachers that are still there at the moment. Do they enjoy their jobs? Are they struggling every day to make themselves go in? Do their colleagues and seniors know the issues? Are they empowered to do anything about it?

My mind is blown by this thread.

I will always show compassion and kindness to teachers.

amillionmenonmars · 21/12/2021 14:55

If ex teachers and retired teachers trip merrily along to the volunteering table then the shit that teachers have put up with for years, and especially have put up with during covid, will be brushed under the carpet. After all, it can't be all that bad if all of those former teachers are happy to return to the classroom.

It is only by saying a very firm NO and even a FUCK THAT that maybe, just maybe, some people will realise that the way teachers are treated in this country is unacceptable.

As I said before I left early with no job to go on. I have been living off my savings for a year now. Even if you paid me I would not go back into the classroom.

MrsHamlet · 21/12/2021 14:38

What’s happened to all the new teachers who graduated this year?
Quite a lot who start never complete.
Quite a lot who complete don't start teaching.
Quite a lot who start teaching go into the private sector.

ChloeDecker · 21/12/2021 14:21

@noblegiraffe

What’s happened to all the new teachers who graduated this year?

There weren't enough of them to meet recruitment targets to start with and a significant number never teach in the state sector.

Or even in this country!
noblegiraffe · 21/12/2021 14:12

What’s happened to all the new teachers who graduated this year?

There weren't enough of them to meet recruitment targets to start with and a significant number never teach in the state sector.

Ubiquery · 21/12/2021 14:08

What’s happened to all the new teachers who graduated this year?

Most teacher training is via a post-graduate route. It's a while since sufficient numbers were trained to meet need anyway.

The above are facts. This is just opinion: the move from university-based training to school-based training is a huge error, politically motivated and not in the best interests of children, young people or society.

borntobequiet · 21/12/2021 14:05

I’m retired (Maths) and had long planned to do some supply after retirement, because I love being in the classroom and have a great deal of experience and expertise to offer. However schools are very unsafe places, especially for those of us over 60, so I found something else to do instead.
It’s astonishing that no effort or significant cash was allocated to support education and keep children and staff (and by extension, their families) safe once the virus was better understood. The situation we’re in was totally predictable and was indeed predicted by teachers on MN threads, to be mostly rewarded by derision and contempt.
I’d be very surprised if exams next year go ahead, and if they do, the playing field will be far from level for candidates.

TheHoneyBadger · 21/12/2021 14:02

And! (Sorry mad multiple posting)

Here in England at least we have similar problems to hospitals in that the erosion of other public services impacts massively on us too. Hospitals have bed blocking because of the state of social care, we are massively impacted by the erosion of social services, camhs, ed psych provision, lack of special school places etc.

It's all joined up and the only ones with power to change it are the government and the only thing that motivates them is voters making very clear and loud what they want. That electorate that you think it's a waste of time talking to.

TheHoneyBadger · 21/12/2021 13:58

I also massively agree with those who said they'd want to see slt get their butts in the classroom more (instead of dreaming up more work to pile on us in their lust for outstanding status) before we dragged pensioners in.

Though frankly ime most of them aren't much cop in the classroom.

TheHoneyBadger · 21/12/2021 13:57

@saraclara

I don’t see why anyone would laugh when they asked the same of NHS staff.

@Pumperthepumper my daughter's ward (she's a ward sister) was a Covid ward when that call went out. She laughed hollowly, too. She thought retired doctors and nurses would be mad to come back and risk themselves (it was pre-vaccination, too, so could have been a death sentence, and was for some retired staff who did go back).

I'm glad you said that - I can remember in the first wave the sad reports of retired doctors who'd gone back and ended up dying.

You'd think lessons would be learned.

TheHoneyBadger · 21/12/2021 13:55

I think you'd have liked Thatcher and her whole 'no such thing as society' rhetoric Thumper.

Individual teachers can do nothing much to change their working conditions - it needs to come from way above us and even way above HTs with things as fundamental as funding, inspection frameworks, the removal of a lot of the mandated work that consumes hours of our time in order for, as someone upthread put it, someone somewhere to tick a box.

How do you suggest individual teachers change their working conditions?

At the beginning of this month our school paid an outside agency to come in and do a multi departmental deep dive to see if we were ofsted ready - in the midst of all this madness. I could blame my slt for putting stupid excess pressure on us but they have stupid excess pressure being piled on them from above.

Education, and our working conditions, are a political issue. Speaking out is part of politics. It's not like we work at an accountants and the big boss is in the corner office and we can just tell him no - our big bosses are the government. The government are endlessly manipulating the public's perception of the state of education and what the government is doing for education and writing about what they'll do in their manifestos etc. Should people not criticise the job they're doing? Do parents not need to know what is really going on in schools where they are sending their children? Do you think there's a way to effect our bosses other than informing the electorate?