Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teachers!

564 replies

MsFannySqueers · 20/12/2021 11:01

So retired/ex teachers are being asked to consider returning to the classroom because of possible staff shortages in the New Year. Is this something you would do?

OP posts:
hungrypanda2008 · 22/12/2021 09:32

I completely understand why people would not return. I’ve taught for almost 3 decades in what are deemed good schools and challenging ones. The job can be thankless. Many parents and carers do not understand the personal sacrifices made and unappreciative. Pupils can be the same. From many there is a sense of entitlement. From some, simple hostility. Many are ill equipped to deal with life and lack resilience. It is sad to see. More times though I feel sorry for the pupils that could really do with my time and energy instead of me dealing with behaviour. And this is even in the good schools. I’ve been sworn at (was called a c* at least once a week in one school) more times than I could ever estimate. The problem with many jobs like teaching (social services the same) is people have this idea that we are public servants so that allows them to abuse, blame and ridicule as they see fit. Coupled with the micro management, many tasks that are about someone somewhere justifying their job, poorly qualified SLT and long unpaid hours (many people are shocked when I say I’m only paid until 3.20 and not for ‘holidays’ - this should be known a lot more than it is but it wouldn’t suit) teaching conditions are poor. So no, I’m not offended when people who have left complain how bad it was because they are more than likely telling the truth. I’m sure there will be lots of people who disagree with my comments but I speak from experience - I’ve taught for almost 3 decades and I’m still going strong with a good reputation. I know I’m fortunate - there’s not many people that are in my position. It also means I’ve seen what the profession can do to people particularly the younger ones, many of whom decide life must have more to offer & leave after a few years

BustopherPonsonbyJones · 22/12/2021 09:16

@noblegiraffe

Asking retired teachers to come back and work as supply isn't about catching kids up, it's about keeping schools open. They are needed as a warm body in front of the class because absence of that is causing year groups to be sent home and schools to close, and it will be worse with omicron.

This period of time is something the children will need catching up from.

What is needed is massive investment in education. An extra teaching assistant with every class in primary. More permanent teachers in secondary.

Any ideas such as longer school day, rearranging holidays etc are attempts to use current teachers for free. As the call to retired/ex teachers has shown, there is zero goodwill in the system. And that is the fault of the government. They need to work massively to fix the broken relationship.

I completely agree. I would add that wages for all those working in schools (and particularly support jobs, like TAs) need to be considerably better paid to draw people in, particularly at the moment when there are safer career options to choose. The government should also expect to pay for any overtime they want teachers to provide.
FrippEnos · 22/12/2021 09:06

Pumperthepumper

What do you think should be done?

sashh · 22/12/2021 08:53

@2toastornot2toast

Hmm hilarious as if!!! Cant even get supply staff this term and we were throwing money at them. Ex and retired teachers also would struggle to be up to date on the constantly moving nature of teaching.
In case anyone thinks this isn't true, I was offered £1000 a week to do supply at one college.

But I'd have had to stay in a hotel.

I've done supply where I have to stay in a hotel but at the time I could claim that as expenses, but the government decided it 'wasn't fair'.

So for me to do supply, that isn't near home, I need to cover my travelling expenses.

Hercisback · 22/12/2021 08:43

Not many students missed an entire two years! The majority have had most of last year and some of the year before. Even then, some sort of education was provided to do at home.

That's what I mean by the rhetoric. Instead of a sensible conversation about education, we are telling kids they'll fail forever because they have missed two years. That's not true.

noblegiraffe · 22/12/2021 08:43

Asking retired teachers to come back and work as supply isn't about catching kids up, it's about keeping schools open. They are needed as a warm body in front of the class because absence of that is causing year groups to be sent home and schools to close, and it will be worse with omicron.

This period of time is something the children will need catching up from.

What is needed is massive investment in education. An extra teaching assistant with every class in primary. More permanent teachers in secondary.

Any ideas such as longer school day, rearranging holidays etc are attempts to use current teachers for free. As the call to retired/ex teachers has shown, there is zero goodwill in the system. And that is the fault of the government. They need to work massively to fix the broken relationship.

Pumperthepumper · 22/12/2021 08:31

Ok, but to the immediate problem? Do we just write off two years of education?

Hercisback · 22/12/2021 08:21

The solution is wholesale society overhaul, which won't happen. Extra hours tuition don't (and won't) really help. Extra tuition only works with good communication and alignment with the class teacher.

Pumperthepumper · 22/12/2021 08:14

@CallmeHendricksGingleBells

Also, "getting in first" is not really a solution to the wider problem, is it? Not everyone can do that, clearly, and as Herc says, what if there isn't anyone suitable in the first place?
What is the solution, do you think? To catching the children up, I mean.
CallmeHendricksGingleBells · 22/12/2021 07:52

Also, "getting in first" is not really a solution to the wider problem, is it?
Not everyone can do that, clearly, and as Herc says, what if there isn't anyone suitable in the first place?

itrytomakemyway · 22/12/2021 07:52

HOD here. No disrespect to supply teachers - what many have to put up with in schools is terrible - large double classes crammed in together, covering any and all subjects outside their specialism, kids who play up because it's 'just a supply', lack of support from SLT for behaviour issues. Don't even get me started on pay and conditions......

However, I do laugh at the idea of keeping a list of names of good supply in my little black book. I have not had a decent supply teacher in my subject for years. Even specialists applying for permanent posts are thin on the ground, and supply teachers in my subject area are as rare as hen's teeth. We have had long term supply in to cover several maternity leaves and long term sickness in my dept over the last decade. Not one of them was any good. Following the most recent changes to the GCSE and A Level spec the supply teachers really struggled with the content. I had no choice but to timetable them onto GCSE classes, but they just did not have the up to date subject knowledge to do it properly.

I have spent hours and hours trying to support long term supply cover. I provide everything - lesson plans, lesson materials, assessment materials. I support with marking, assessment and moderation - all of this and trying not to let my own classes suffer. I am exhausted.

The point I am trying to make SammyScrouge is that much as I would love to be able to get together a list of good supply to choose from there is no one to put on the list. In the last year having ANY supply in has been nothing short of a miracle. I have had to resign myself to hope for people to cover lessons who can at least manage behaviour.

It IS a babysitting service. My exam results do suffer as a result. I wish I lived in a part of the country where good, reliable subject specialist supply teachers were in such abundance that I could keep a list of them to chose from.

Hercisback · 22/12/2021 06:48

As to the value of supply teachers, heads of department keep a little black notebook with the names of good people and hopes that he gets in first and bags them because a babysitter is no use to us.

My whole point is that a babysitter is no use.

Lucky for your HOD. I can't think of a good maths supply teacher we've had in the past 8 years.

I'm a teacher in case you hadn't noticed Hmm. More than aware of exams coming up with 3 exam classes. I still think this DfE idea is shit.

SammyScrounge · 21/12/2021 22:56

@Hercisback

Because children desperately need some assistance here before their educational progress is damaged beyond repair.

Such rhetoric.

There's a lot of arguments to be had about what constitutes "progress" in education, and now is not the time or place.

I'm also not sure how a babysitter (because that is what these volunteers will be) can provide much in the way of education. This isn't to deride supply staff. They work incredibly hard in crap circumstances, but because they don't know the students, the lessons aren't great. Often they are given holding work until the class teacher returns.

The national exams are in May. That's why teachers are looking at progress. As to the value of supply teachers, heads of department keep a little black notebook with the names of good people and hopes that he gets in first and bags them because a babysitter is no use to us.We have no time for looking at our navels contemplating the nature of progress and heaving great sighs over its incomprehensibility. There are exams to be sat.
TheHoneyBadger · 21/12/2021 19:38

I dunno. I'd pay good money to watch them try and manage for a day. Would make great reality tv.

noblegiraffe · 21/12/2021 19:01

I wouldn’t want those toxic anti-science vile idiots round my kids.

CatJumperTwat · 21/12/2021 18:54

Instead of paying ex teachers, let's get Twats4Them fans in. I'm sure they'll have no issues with the risks and would gladly do it free, as they care soooo much about the children.

icelolly12 · 21/12/2021 17:19

Hell no

KTheGrey · 21/12/2021 17:17

Open secret that the cost of supply runs about £200 a day, of which the teacher gets about half. The schools could keep their own registers and offer a better rate, but such is the baffling indifference to taking control of the situation among school management that this almost never happens. And the government would like supply teachers to rally round and help agencies stay in business by catching Covid and not getting paid for their sick leave, while still being treated with little respect or gratitude ... No, you'd have to be hard up to take that, can't see the incentive.

MrsHamlet · 21/12/2021 16:47

It's never one teacher who decides whether a trainee is making expected progress in my school. The subject mentor and the professional mentor observe together - and then we invite the university to triangulate the judgement.

Workyticket · 21/12/2021 16:42

@ParsleySageRosemary

The question of placements probably needs its own thread somewhere where it could be discussed properly, but it’s odd how many are called crap by one teacher who’s in a bad mood or doesn’t like them - because x? - and then go on to perform fine in another environment. Placements are weird things that do not work out for a variety of reasons, not least one-off events in the school. A lot depends on how the teacher gets on and works with the student socially - it shouldn’t be like that, but it is.
The ones I'm talking about would absolutely not do any better in another classroom. Poor numeracy and literacy and home lives which are already unstable aren't conducive to working in education regardless of the mentor.

One of mine had never worked - her mental health probably won't allow her to work consistently for quite some time yet she was still accepted because she could get the loan?

MrsHamlet · 21/12/2021 16:32

We've had 5 this term.
One left.
One was terminated.
One will struggle to meet the standards.
One is struggling with workload already.
One will be okay.

starrynight19 · 21/12/2021 16:31

In the last two weeks before my school closed for Xmas we had children coming into school with symptoms. Children returning from isolating earlier than they should have done. Children getting positive results whilst they were in school and waiting for parents to come and collect them.
Abuse to staff for sending symptomatic children home , asking them to complete the full isolation period , keeping them apart from their friends when positive etc
Staff testing positive , then when we could get supply for their classes they were testing positive.
When we couldn’t get supply because they simply didn’t turn up TA’s we’re left to run the classes. So the only mitigations we had left of class bubbles became useless.
I caught covid from my class.
Who in their right mind would go back to that scenario on supply rates with no sick pay who are potentially vulnerable as well. It’s nonsense. But a good way to deflect from the governments responsibility towards safety in schools again.

ParsleySageRosemary · 21/12/2021 16:31

The question of placements probably needs its own thread somewhere where it could be discussed properly, but it’s odd how many are called crap by one teacher who’s in a bad mood or doesn’t like them - because x? - and then go on to perform fine in another environment. Placements are weird things that do not work out for a variety of reasons, not least one-off events in the school. A lot depends on how the teacher gets on and works with the student socially - it shouldn’t be like that, but it is.

Workyticket · 21/12/2021 16:26

@MrsHamlet

I've terminated teaching placements because the quality of planning and delivery has been so bad yet they've passed observations Yep. I sacked one trainee after a week and have another needing additional support. Their unis are pressing on as though they're going to be eminently suitable. They're not. But they've paid ...
I've not taken 1 for a couple of years because it's painful. The last one was on a £26k bursary and did fuck all. No prep, turned up late... I already had him on a written warning. His uni tutor turned up to see him. She watched, apologised to me and then passed his observation

No way was I putting my GCSE year classes through that so I got rid. He's not the first by a long shot.

user290814356289 · 21/12/2021 16:25

A family member has just left teaching. She qualified and has been teaching for the last 5 years. She would never go back.