Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teachers!

564 replies

MsFannySqueers · 20/12/2021 11:01

So retired/ex teachers are being asked to consider returning to the classroom because of possible staff shortages in the New Year. Is this something you would do?

OP posts:
motherrunner · 22/12/2021 11:01

@noblegiraffe

Are you primary, pumper? Because your idea of supply teachers doing group work helping kids to catch up might make sense in primary when they are with the kids all day everyday for an extended period but really wouldn’t work with the ‘doss lesson’ model of cover at secondary.
Secondary kids love supply teachers - means they don’t have to work!
noblegiraffe · 22/12/2021 10:35

Are you primary, pumper? Because your idea of supply teachers doing group work helping kids to catch up might make sense in primary when they are with the kids all day everyday for an extended period but really wouldn’t work with the ‘doss lesson’ model of cover at secondary.

Pumperthepumper · 22/12/2021 10:32

@ChloeDecker

But I can’t see how it would hurt in relation to catching up on missed education.

And if the retired or ex teacher wasn’t very good or is now not very good? The elephant in the room really.

Besides, if the DforE hadn’t tendered to the lowest monetary offer of catch up tutoring to a Dutch firm that has not delivered, we may well have not been as quite in the mess we are in, in the first place.

What do you suggest instead?
ChloeDecker · 22/12/2021 10:32

But I can’t see how it would hurt in relation to catching up on missed education.

And if the retired or ex teacher wasn’t very good or is now not very good? The elephant in the room really.

Besides, if the DforE hadn’t tendered to the lowest monetary offer of catch up tutoring to a Dutch firm that has not delivered, we may well have not been as quite in the mess we are in, in the first place.

Pumperthepumper · 22/12/2021 10:30

@FrippEnos

Pumperthepumper

I agree that it stops them falling further behind, but it won't allow them to catch up.

That will always require extra time, teaching and effort from all involved.

I don’t think anyone would deny that.
FrippEnos · 22/12/2021 10:28

Pumperthepumper

I agree that it stops them falling further behind, but it won't allow them to catch up.

That will always require extra time, teaching and effort from all involved.

ChloeDecker · 22/12/2021 10:28

Just because you’re in charge of a whole class doesn’t mean you can’t do group work though? I don’t know much about the English system but working in groups isn’t unusual in Scotland.

Working in groups in my subject doesn’t work if I want any of them to be where I want academically but if you are Primary (I assuming that you are, apologies if not) then I can’t comment on the pedagogy of that.

noblegiraffe · 22/12/2021 10:26

Are you primary, pumper?

Pumperthepumper · 22/12/2021 10:25

@FrippEnos

Pumperthepumper

So would your pupils doing the catch up work also be expected to do the current work as well?

Even in this scenario the pupils that are behind are still behind.

But they’re not as far behind as they would be. There will always be an attainment gap, this is a bridging measure.
FrippEnos · 22/12/2021 10:24

Pumperthepumper

So would your pupils doing the catch up work also be expected to do the current work as well?

Even in this scenario the pupils that are behind are still behind.

Pumperthepumper · 22/12/2021 10:21

@FrippEnos

Pumperthepumper

The previous poster wrote a possible (workable) solution that isn't the governments plan.
The plan (in case you missed it) is to put ex and retired teachers in front of entire classes, not to have them in front of small classes so that the pupils can catch up.

Just because you’re in charge of a whole class doesn’t mean you can’t do group work though? I don’t know much about the English system but working in groups isn’t unusual in Scotland.
FrippEnos · 22/12/2021 10:20

Pumperthepumper

The previous poster wrote a possible (workable) solution that isn't the governments plan.
The plan (in case you missed it) is to put ex and retired teachers in front of entire classes, not to have them in front of small classes so that the pupils can catch up.

MrsHamlet · 22/12/2021 10:12

I'd be happier with my retired colleague catching up my students than the person they've employed to do it. It's going to create me loads of extra work

Pumperthepumper · 22/12/2021 10:11

@FrippEnos

Pumperthepumper

How would bringing in retired teachers help with catching up on missed education?

It may stabilise the amount that the pupils are missing or have missed but in order to catch up the retired teachers would have to put in extra time.

The previous poster just wrote out a comprehensive argument for it. Why would they have to put in extra work?
FrippEnos · 22/12/2021 10:10

Pumperthepumper

How would bringing in retired teachers help with catching up on missed education?

It may stabilise the amount that the pupils are missing or have missed but in order to catch up the retired teachers would have to put in extra time.

natrew · 22/12/2021 10:03

I think retired teachers would be great for the catch up program, especially if schools could hire them directly. We have some excellent teachers who have retired in the last few years who would be fantastic, and the fact they already know the school would be such a bonus. They don't particularly want to return to whole class teaching, but would for smaller group work. I can imagine this would be far more effective that the random tutors we had for the previous catch-up (who were of varying quality). It should also be more cost effective as it cuts out the middle man (someone made a fortune from the previous tutoring program and it wasn't the tutors!).

Pumperthepumper · 22/12/2021 09:57

@MrsHamlet for the UK. We have notoriously poor attendance rates for a developed country.

Pumperthepumper · 22/12/2021 09:56

@FrippEnos

Pumperthepumper

IMO any short term solutions will become a long term sticking plaster and nothing will get resolved.

Bringing retired teachers back won’t solve every problem in education, no.

But I can’t see how it would hurt in relation to catching up on missed education.

MrsHamlet · 22/12/2021 09:48

on top of a system with notoriously terrible attendance rate
For whom?

My year 13 missed the end of year 11 and didn't sit GCSEs. They had one period of lockdown teaching in y12 (attendance in one class was excellent; in the other two, the students who did not very much do not very much face to face either). During any periods of self isolating, I was teaching them online. They're not "behind" except in experience of exams.
My year 11 have had a similar experience. They missed the end of year 9 but we don't start GCSE until year 10 so they've missed no content. They will sit reduced exams anyway.
Year 7 and 8 are our biggest problem years - but it's skills they're lacking.

FrippEnos · 22/12/2021 09:47

Pumperthepumper

IMO any short term solutions will become a long term sticking plaster and nothing will get resolved.

ChloeDecker · 22/12/2021 09:46

What is the solution, do you think? To catching the children up, I mean.

In my opinion, the government doing more or at least doing something to keep the existing teachers actually in their classrooms. Both from dealing with health and safety properly, vaccinating us sooner and finally supporting teachers who stay in teaching, rather than keep throwing good money after bad on the ITT front.

I can only speak as a Secondary teacher in England, in a subject with very few specialists because we have the potential to earn way more with better working conditions outside of teaching and never having seen the same supply teacher twice (who can rarely teach the subject anyway) the DforE’s current focus is the wrong one for giving children what they need, in my subject.

HesterShaw1 · 22/12/2021 09:45

I think so many teachers leave the profession completely broken and disillusioned with it, that they'll have a hard time enticing them back.

Teaching needs to be a nicer, more rewarding job basically. And that needs enormous investment.

FrippEnos · 22/12/2021 09:44

Pumperthepumper

(* I can see where this conversation will go)

If the SoW are in place this shouldn't be an issue. As long as you get the right teacher in the right department. More often its an issue for the more practical subjects where machines or tools are used.

Tracking, Marking and setting work have been extras for supply teachers which they get paid extra for, this could be an issue.

HesterShaw1 · 22/12/2021 09:42

They want then to register with supply agencies? And therefore relinquish a large part of their pay packet?

Or are they asking them to volunteer?

Pumperthepumper · 22/12/2021 09:35

@Hercisback

Not many students missed an entire two years! The majority have had most of last year and some of the year before. Even then, some sort of education was provided to do at home.

That's what I mean by the rhetoric. Instead of a sensible conversation about education, we are telling kids they'll fail forever because they have missed two years. That's not true.

I should have said ‘disrupted education for two years, on top of a system with notoriously terrible attendance rate’ then. And actually, we are seeing a huge amount of children becoming deskilled - pen control, for example. Dexterity, being unable to use scissors, difficulties in peer attachment, language issues, not to mention the mental toll of two years of covid.

But you must agree that children have missed a substantial amount of education surely? Or no, they’ll all be fine?

@FrippEnos I think if I was in charge and not just an anonymous voice on the internet, I would be encouraging trained staff back too. And when they get there, they have a plan of work to follow, set by the kids’ existing teachers (* I can see where this conversation will go) to try and bridge the gap. It’s only babysitting if you think that’s all we’re good for, and we’re not - how many people on this thread have said they’d return to the classroom if it meant no extra garbage?