Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teachers!

564 replies

MsFannySqueers · 20/12/2021 11:01

So retired/ex teachers are being asked to consider returning to the classroom because of possible staff shortages in the New Year. Is this something you would do?

OP posts:
MrsHamlet · 22/12/2021 13:39

@phlebasconsidered

No you're not mrs h. I am a year 6 teacher and my reading interventions are outside of lessons, in the afternoons. The child requiring intervention still stays in my English and maths lessons with appropriately modified work. The intervention teacher is a teacher employed for just that. The whole prevailing ethos now is that to remove the child from class teaching for core subjects just leads to them being further behind. Intervention is on top of, not in place of.
Thank God... I thought I was going mad there for a minute. Our EAL students do the same.
ChloeDecker · 22/12/2021 13:39

@viques

They should have been more honest in their adverts.

Hello retired ,burnt out, incompetent, managed out, disillusioned - delete as appropriate - former teachers. As you know for the past thirty or so years successive governments have vilified and denigrated the teaching profession, blaming teachers for all life’s ills from teen anxiety , eating disorders and failure to speak a language other than English to county lines, at the same time we have turned your working lives upside down many times, introduced new policies at four o clock on a Friday afternoon to be implemented on Monday morning, we have tweaked your working conditions and allowed Academies to undermine your professionalism , your minimal qualifications and salaries. During the recent unpleasantness we lied about providing equipment for home learning, expected schools to provide PPE equipment from already depleted funds and refused vulnerable children access to meals. Since schools returned last September we have denied that schools are vectors for infection and have insisted that to maintain standards Ofsted inspectors will expect all children to have been learning and progressing at pre Covid closure levels.

But that is water under the bridge, we are all on a learning journey, and can move forward together.

For example , even we at the Department have recently learned that unaccountably, considering the care we have taken over recruitment and retention within the profession, that there is a shortage of teachers and even poorly paid supply teachers willing to stand in freezing cold classrooms and expose themselves to Covid from unvaccinated and untested children. It now appears likely that even factoring in putting all TAs, midday assistants and lollipop people in front of classes we will have a shortage of warm bodies come January. So, how about it? Why not come back into the profession you love, teach a curriculum you are unfamiliar with, learn how to do marking with green and purple pens, risk being vilified by an Ofsted inspection to breathe in the viral exhalations of anxious children . We will pay you a teeny tiny amount of money, completely unrelated to your experience and qualifications, and who knows, you might even be featured on national news as a Teacher Hero, wouldn’t that be something to mention to your grandchildren when they ask what you did in the Great Pandemic.

Formal applications not necessary, just turn up, please bring your own pritt sticks and pens.

Thank you for writing this!
phlebasconsidered · 22/12/2021 13:37

No you're not mrs h.
I am a year 6 teacher and my reading interventions are outside of lessons, in the afternoons. The child requiring intervention still stays in my English and maths lessons with appropriately modified work. The intervention teacher is a teacher employed for just that. The whole prevailing ethos now is that to remove the child from class teaching for core subjects just leads to them being further behind. Intervention is on top of, not in place of.

ChloeDecker · 22/12/2021 13:37

Teachers who are already complaining of being overworked? Those teachers are going to do the lunchtime and after school boosters if they are there?

We already are. Aren’t you? You think about the children, right?!

TheHoneyBadger · 22/12/2021 13:34

Formal applications not necessary, just turn up, please bring your own pritt sticks and pens

God yes - don't be expecting any glues that haven't dried up and died by the end of the first half term.

What they should be doing is what has been needed for years - having trained specialist literacy intevention going on in a meaningful way outside the classroom, addressing the lack of basic skills that the children with attainment gaps have and that can't be closed by just shoving them onwards with a full timetable and telling the classroom teachers who have 5 classes to teach that day to 'differentiate' for them. I've not yet worked out how to meaningfully differentiate GCSE History for a child with KS1 literacy skills - I can make them learn stuff and be interested but with 29 other students many of whom will have their own needs I can't teach him to read or write.

We need enough actual permanent staff in school for people to have more space on their timetables to do interventions - for people with the skill sets to actually do that to be allowed out of their specialist subject for a period or two a week to give to that kind of intervention.

We need social workers and counsellors IN SCHOOLs where they're actually needed and specialist workers who understand processing disorders or sensory issues.

We need meaningful behavioural issues intervention to target that child and improve their outcomes whilst simultaneously allowing teachers to make sure the other 20 kids aren't losing ground because of the time it takes away from teaching a lesson.

And these things need to be permanent not a 6 week fix because the problems in schools have briefly become visible to the public in a way that they can't 100% wilfully ignore.

But all of this requires money and paying people who are actually trained and qualified to do the jobs needed which means proper salaries. It means retaining quality teachers and listening to them about what resources they need. Successive governments pretend to care about education but no one actually seems to 'care' enough to properly invest in it and listen to the experts.

MrsHamlet · 22/12/2021 13:33

Students who need reading intervention in my school have that outside of English lessons. Not instead of; as well as.
Not by teachers but by learning support staff trained in reading intervention.
Perhaps we're unusual in that.

Pumperthepumper · 22/12/2021 13:31

@MrsHamlet

Your Bob might not be. Mine is. But not by teachers. By trained learning support staff.
That’s a bold statement! No teacher ever given your bob a wee hand in his education?
manysummersago · 22/12/2021 13:29

Outside of your lessons, or instead of your lessons?

And tbf MrsH it is a bit of an odd attitude.

CaptainMyCaptain · 22/12/2021 13:22

I doubt if they'll persuade retired teachers in their 60s and over to go into an environment so riddled with covid all the younger teachers have gone off sick with it. Those who have left teaching for another career ... have other careers.

Besides which I was treated so badly at the end of my 30 year teaching career they would have to drag me kicking and screaming to get me into a classroom.

MrsHamlet · 22/12/2021 13:21

Your Bob might not be. Mine is. But not by teachers. By trained learning support staff.

Pumperthepumper · 22/12/2021 13:19

@MrsHamlet

So tough luck for those kids then? That's not what I said and you know it. If Bob missed Holes because he was off, that's not the end of anyone's world. If Bob has a low reading age, then he's getting appropriate interventions from trained adults outside of my lessons.
He isn’t though. That’s why they need more teachers.
MrsHamlet · 22/12/2021 13:14

So tough luck for those kids then?
That's not what I said and you know it.
If Bob missed Holes because he was off, that's not the end of anyone's world.
If Bob has a low reading age, then he's getting appropriate interventions from trained adults outside of my lessons.

viques · 22/12/2021 13:12

They should have been more honest in their adverts.

Hello retired ,burnt out, incompetent, managed out, disillusioned - delete as appropriate - former teachers. As you know for the past thirty or so years successive governments have vilified and denigrated the teaching profession, blaming teachers for all life’s ills from teen anxiety , eating disorders and failure to speak a language other than English to county lines, at the same time we have turned your working lives upside down many times, introduced new policies at four o clock on a Friday afternoon to be implemented on Monday morning, we have tweaked your working conditions and allowed Academies to undermine your professionalism , your minimal qualifications and salaries. During the recent unpleasantness we lied about providing equipment for home learning, expected schools to provide PPE equipment from already depleted funds and refused vulnerable children access to meals. Since schools returned last September we have denied that schools are vectors for infection and have insisted that to maintain standards Ofsted inspectors will expect all children to have been learning and progressing at pre Covid closure levels.

But that is water under the bridge, we are all on a learning journey, and can move forward together.

For example , even we at the Department have recently learned that unaccountably, considering the care we have taken over recruitment and retention within the profession, that there is a shortage of teachers and even poorly paid supply teachers willing to stand in freezing cold classrooms and expose themselves to Covid from unvaccinated and untested children. It now appears likely that even factoring in putting all TAs, midday assistants and lollipop people in front of classes we will have a shortage of warm bodies come January. So, how about it? Why not come back into the profession you love, teach a curriculum you are unfamiliar with, learn how to do marking with green and purple pens, risk being vilified by an Ofsted inspection to breathe in the viral exhalations of anxious children . We will pay you a teeny tiny amount of money, completely unrelated to your experience and qualifications, and who knows, you might even be featured on national news as a Teacher Hero, wouldn’t that be something to mention to your grandchildren when they ask what you did in the Great Pandemic.

Formal applications not necessary, just turn up, please bring your own pritt sticks and pens.

Pumperthepumper · 22/12/2021 13:08

@MrsHamlet

And if he was already sitting at early level for reading? So is now a further year behind? Teaching reading as a skill is not something secondary teachers are trained for. We use learning support who are trained to do that.
So tough luck for those kids then?
MrsHamlet · 22/12/2021 13:06

And if he was already sitting at early level for reading? So is now a further year behind?
Teaching reading as a skill is not something secondary teachers are trained for. We use learning support who are trained to do that.

Pumperthepumper · 22/12/2021 13:03

@ChloeDecker

these are all things that need to happen anyway though. We’re talking about this immediate problem of filling in some missing education. How do we do it? Without asking some ex-teachers to come in?

Again, make sure their existing teachers are actually teaching in front of them.

How is this hard to follow, I don’t get it?

Teachers in Secondary have the knowledge of their pupils, the knowledge of what they have done/haven’t done, can do the lunchtime and after school boosters if they are there (supply/ex/retired teachers wouldn’t be doing this for example.)

Is it that you think? That these ex teachers will be additional members of staff in a classroom that can do interventions, like in Primary? Is that why you are saying what you are saying?

Because in Secondary, they would be the only person in the room, covering staff absence as we don’t tend to also have permanent TAs in Secondary (in fact, I have not had a TA in my classroom for many years) so there wouldn’t be an adult who knows the children/curriculum/syllabus etc. or possibilities for break away group work/interventions.

The DforE now need to do what they can to keep Secondary staff physically in the classroom. I cannot possibly comment on Primary (which again, although you haven’t said, your posts do seem to indicate you are Primary in Scotland)

Teachers who are already complaining of being overworked? Those teachers are going to do the lunchtime and after school boosters if they are there?
ChloeDecker · 22/12/2021 13:00

these are all things that need to happen anyway though. We’re talking about this immediate problem of filling in some missing education. How do we do it? Without asking some ex-teachers to come in?

Again, make sure their existing teachers are actually teaching in front of them.

How is this hard to follow, I don’t get it?

Teachers in Secondary have the knowledge of their pupils, the knowledge of what they have done/haven’t done, can do the lunchtime and after school boosters if they are there (supply/ex/retired teachers wouldn’t be doing this for example.)

Is it that you think? That these ex teachers will be additional members of staff in a classroom that can do interventions, like in Primary? Is that why you are saying what you are saying?

Because in Secondary, they would be the only person in the room, covering staff absence as we don’t tend to also have permanent TAs in Secondary (in fact, I have not had a TA in my classroom for many years) so there wouldn’t be an adult who knows the children/curriculum/syllabus etc. or possibilities for break away group work/interventions.

The DforE now need to do what they can to keep Secondary staff physically in the classroom. I cannot possibly comment on Primary (which again, although you haven’t said, your posts do seem to indicate you are Primary in Scotland)

Pumperthepumper · 22/12/2021 12:46

@MrsHamlet

Do we just accept that those children will have huge gaps in their education and leave it there? What gaps? Who decides that something is important? Because if my year 10 didn't read Holes in year 8, that actually doesn't matter one iota.
And if he was already sitting at early level for reading? So is now a further year behind?
Pumperthepumper · 22/12/2021 12:44

@ChloeDecker these are all things that need to happen anyway though. We’re talking about this immediate problem of filling in some missing education. How do we do it? Without asking some ex-teachers to come in?

quietinhere · 22/12/2021 12:44

@MsFannySqueers

So retired/ex teachers are being asked to consider returning to the classroom because of possible staff shortages in the New Year. Is this something you would do?
Never in a month of Sundays. Not because I fear Covid though!
ChloeDecker · 22/12/2021 12:42

How is doing more to reduce teacher absence going to be worse academically for the pupils? This is where you have lost me actually. Especially as getting ex teachers back in schools is also teacher focused. Hmm
In England, the govt has just reduced the 10 day isolation period to 7, precisely for the reason to reduce absent NHS staff. Now, I am not suggesting this is the best decision but does show the govt can put in measures when they want to.

If the govt had/will put in:

  1. A properly funded ‘catch up’ programme that actually got to the children who need it
  2. Vaccinated staff earlier to reduce the situations where school staff suffered badly with Covid and were off long term or where not at their best when they returned
  3. Invested in proper ventilation systems to reduce the risk of the virus spreading (and not waited until delivering just 8 CO2 monitors in the last week of term, in my school of 1800+ pupils and in my classroom of 33 computers, regularly goes up to 2000ppm with the windows open)
  4. If they did not put in a pay freeze on existing teachers and properly funded teachers to stay and not quit
  5. If they had rolled out the vaccination programme to 12-15 year olds earlier, rather than at the end of November (in my school)
  6. If the govt actually paid what was needed to ensure all pupils and staff had the tech and Internet access that they need right from the word go
  7. If the govt funded the additional services properly, such as CAMHS, Social Care and the police, then they could also have reduced the issue of pupils who haven’t returned to school yet and supported all mental health with measures such as paying for a full time, permanent professional counsellor in every school.

Then there would be less disruption in the first place, young people would be getting the education they deserve and ex/retired teachers could stay safely away from school buildings, hopefully putting less pressure on the NHS, should they get Covid badly.

How anyone could not think these are better measures is beyond me and shouldn’t be making excuses for the government or criticising teachers who are speaking out (and in my case, that has been emailing my MP consistently)

MrsHamlet · 22/12/2021 12:31

Do we just accept that those children will have huge gaps in their education and leave it there?
What gaps? Who decides that something is important? Because if my year 10 didn't read Holes in year 8, that actually doesn't matter one iota.

Pumperthepumper · 22/12/2021 12:21

@ChloeDecker

What is the solution, do you think? To catching the children up, I mean.

In my opinion, the government doing more or at least doing something to keep the existing teachers actually in their classrooms. Both from dealing with health and safety properly, vaccinating us sooner and finally supporting teachers who stay in teaching, rather than keep throwing good money after bad on the ITT front.

I can only speak as a Secondary teacher in England, in a subject with very few specialists because we have the potential to earn way more with better working conditions outside of teaching and never having seen the same supply teacher twice (who can rarely teach the subject anyway) the DforE’s current focus is the wrong one for giving children what they need, in my subject.

This one? I thought this was more teacher-focused than child-focused. Do we just accept that those children will have huge gaps in their education and leave it there?
ChloeDecker · 22/12/2021 12:17

What do you suggest instead?

I already suggested some things, based on my opinion and experience in Secondary, a few posts ago. Sorry if you missed it.

motherrunner · 22/12/2021 11:02

(And that’s not a criticism of supply, just how they’re viewed by the pupils and to SLT they are just a body to stop kids killing each other).