Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teachers!

564 replies

MsFannySqueers · 20/12/2021 11:01

So retired/ex teachers are being asked to consider returning to the classroom because of possible staff shortages in the New Year. Is this something you would do?

OP posts:
BurningTheClocks · 21/12/2021 09:42

Maybe manysummers is still one of the young, enthusiastic teachers with some experience, rather than elderly and excessively experienced like many of us responding. 🤣

starrynight19 · 21/12/2021 09:32

@manysummersago

I don’t really care if anyone volunteers or not. I’m just pointing out that when cries of teacher bashing go on, this is why.

People are free to say loudly they won’t volunteer but it doesn’t look good. That’s all.

Teacher bashing goes on regardless so it makes little difference.
amillionmenonmars · 21/12/2021 09:31

Teacher bashing is a public sport in the UK. I don't want any retired teachers to put their health at risk just too make the profession look 'better'.

A million former teachers could sign up and many on MN would still be on here complaining that Johnny had a 3 minute detention he didn't deserve and that all teachers are workshy bullies with too many holidays.

starrynight19 · 21/12/2021 09:31

@manysummersago

The vaccination centres are stuffed with volunteers, doctors and nurses went to the hospitals …

we aren’t making ourselves look good with the ‘fuck no’ responses.

Except those who are volunteering with the booster programme are going to have some safety mitigations to protect them in the nhs. They also won’t be awaiting ofsted to come in and scrutinise them. And they also won’t have been likely managed out of their job for a multitude of reasons previously.
BurningTheClocks · 21/12/2021 09:29

Sweetie, people have been bashing teachers for decades, for countless different things. So the idea that not volunteering will result in more abuse fills most of us with indifference. Many will not even notice.

manysummersago · 21/12/2021 09:26

I don’t really care if anyone volunteers or not. I’m just pointing out that when cries of teacher bashing go on, this is why.

People are free to say loudly they won’t volunteer but it doesn’t look good. That’s all.

amillionmenonmars · 21/12/2021 09:26

I believe that so many are saying 'no' for very good reasons. You cannot treat a profession with such disdain and expect anything else. Schools have been propped up with the good will of teachers for years.

IF anyone had thought this at the start of the pandemic, perhaps we would not have been in this mess. How many teachers were at the very back of the queue when it came to vaccinations? How many HTs refused to allow mask wearing in schools? How many schools have windows painted shut so that even basic ventilation can not happen?

Why should retired and former teachers be expected to put themselves at risk now when the health of school staff has been ignored?

I do volunteer. In a vaccination centre. I feel perfectly safe there, and I am happy to play my part. I don't give a damn if I am judged for 'letting the side down'. I was let down too. So were my colleagues in schools across the UK.

BurningTheClocks · 21/12/2021 09:23

@manysummersago

I understand that and it’s up to you *@amillionmenonmars*

But we aren’t the only ones who’ve been asked to volunteer. We are the only ones being so vocal in saying no, though.

Is anyone else being asked to volunteer in similar circumstances though? Do you understand the differences that amilliinmenonmars is trying to point out to you? I had a brief Meldrew moment when I heard OFSTED we’re back to inspecting, but after over three decades in the classroom, it was only a moment.
manysummersago · 21/12/2021 09:17

I understand that and it’s up to you @amillionmenonmars

But we aren’t the only ones who’ve been asked to volunteer. We are the only ones being so vocal in saying no, though.

amillionmenonmars · 21/12/2021 09:15

I don't care about 'looking good'. The system didn't care about me when it was breaking me.

I am putting my health and the health of my family first - after 30 years of putting work first I think they owe me that much.

amillionmenonmars · 21/12/2021 09:13

The vaccination centres are staffed with volunteers in PPE who ask every person who passes through the door about their health. They refuse entry to anyone who is maskless. They have contact with each person for a matter of minutes.

Teachers are in poorly ventilated rooms with sometimes 30 plus other people, many of who are unvaccinated. Some of whom have covid symptoms but have been sent in anyway.

You simply cannot compare the two.

Italiandreams · 21/12/2021 09:12

There are reasons this isn't ideal and none of them are because the retired teacher can't do the job as has been suggested.

First of all the reasons we need more teachers is because so many have Covid so putting vulnerable people into that situation where there are pretty much no mitigations against covid is ridiculous begin with.

In primary at least , it's really difficult to teach children you don't know properly as so much of it is based on what you know about children, so while supply may keep things open , it certainly isn't a solution to helping children catch up up - depends what we are trying to achieve. While I can see the argument for helping to with childcare etc, currently we are expecting schools not only to maintain standards but also accelerate it and OFSTED are expecting this too and not making any allowances. Who would want to volunteer for that amount of scutiny, it would be an impossible ask for anyone. Unless we get more realistic about things like that people would be mad to put themselves in the situation.

I think clear leadership from the government is needed , with what they want to achieve and a realistic plan of how this can be done, at the moment it's all an impossible task. Schools are trying their best but they are too often being asked to achieve the impossible with the resources they have.

manysummersago · 21/12/2021 08:59

The vaccination centres are stuffed with volunteers, doctors and nurses went to the hospitals …

we aren’t making ourselves look good with the ‘fuck no’ responses.

onedayoranother · 21/12/2021 08:51

I know a couple teachers who have done this. They loved teaching and were great teachers so they have been happy to step in, but to their old school only. I don't think money was a factor, though I'm sure it helps.

DelphiniumBlue · 21/12/2021 08:39

@BurningTheClocks

They’re also trying to lure back all the Teach First members who were not only trained for free, but paid whilst they did the training. Hyped and praised, the way forwards and all that jazz. 60% left teaching within 5 years.

And yes, supply rates are low, haven’t changed in years and you get no support if you are ill or isolating.

Wasn't that the. intention with Teach First? That it was a temporary thing before going on to some swanky job in management consultancy? The teach First teachers that I met did 6 weeks training ( over the summer hols) before taking on their own class, and they would go back to be doing management consulting training in the holidays between terms. It was a finite thing for 2 years as far as I can can recall. Maybe they hoped some would stay in teaching but it was never intended to be permanent. The idea was to attract people with good degrees to give the benefit of their education to children in the short term. They will be earning 6 figure salaries now and really unlikely to want to give that up.
CoffeeWithCheese · 21/12/2021 08:26

Actually I clicked through the Gov link the other day out of interest - wouldn't mind going back into the classroom short term in the local area if the need arose (and I'll happily chip in and cover my own kids' school unpaid if it kept it open)... it's just a list of supply agencies and 'sign on with one of these please'

I got OUT of supply because I was sick of the crap pulled by these agencies - they're not getting me back on their books cos then they don't leave you alone - so this "drive" is just a "please sign on for supply".

starrynight19 · 21/12/2021 08:20

@Inertia

Redeploy all the OFSTED inspectors. No inspection under current circumstances can possibly be meaningful, so use their skills in short-staffed schools.

Would surely have the added bonus of bringing standards up, since the rest of us could learn at the feet of these gurus of enlightenment.

Absolutely couldn’t have put it better myself
amillionmenonmars · 21/12/2021 08:14

Sorry - so many typos in there!!

amillionmenonmars · 21/12/2021 08:12

In response to a PP who said this thread is kicking current teachers in the teeth - it really isn't.

God knows I have every sympathy for every teacher in the UK. Wat they have gone through over the past two years has been hellish. Left on the front line as cannon fodder by a gov who has made no effort to provide them with safer working conitions. And derided by many parents who see them as little more than glorified childcare.

The parets on MN who have complained about online learning - too much, too little, to hard, too easy. They have no idea, none, how bloody hard it is to try and produce and deliver lessons online and offline . Often being asked to do so at a moments notice.

I was teaching at the start of covid. I was given zero tech support. I had to go out and buy a laptop just before the first lockdown because my own laptop did not have the capacity I needed to produce and upload learning materials. It cost me several hundreds of £ because at that time everyone was rushing to buy new tech. My school did not provide me with this, nor was I refunded the money. My SLT, by the way, have their phones and laptops provided through school. I know I will not be the only teacher who had to do this. I also know many teachers sourced tech for their own students - some hunted down old laptops to be refurbished, others paid for things themselves.

I am in no way having a go at teachers or the profession. I loved my job and I think the rewards of teaching are incredible.

But I will never go back into the classroom. Teachers in the UK have been treated so badly - not just in this pandemic, but for many years. Bullying managers, inspection teams who have no clue, the press, many of the general public - the constant level of scrutiny, the desire to cut costs and the lack of understanding and respect for good teachers - it just wore me down.

So, again, no. I will not go back in to prop up a system that took so much from me.

brassmonkeybrassband · 21/12/2021 08:10

How realistic is the Ofsted redeployment idea? We need to lobby the government

Gooseysgirl · 21/12/2021 07:48

And I totally agree about redeploying ofsted inspectors... I would pay good money to see an inspector Hirt I know manage a class of four year olds

Gooseysgirl · 21/12/2021 07:45

Absolutely no fucking way

natrew · 21/12/2021 06:39

Pre-Covid we always used some of our retired teachers for supply. However covid changed that, they stopped coming in. We also had 2 teachers retire earlier than they had planned.
I noticed Nadhim Zahawi pleading for these teachers to sign up even if it was just for a day a week. That is literally a body in front of the class babysitting, we need supplies to commit for a week.

loopylindi · 21/12/2021 06:22

hell would freeze over first

echt · 21/12/2021 05:12

Jesus: a lesson plan, one lesson observed. Blush