Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teachers!

564 replies

MsFannySqueers · 20/12/2021 11:01

So retired/ex teachers are being asked to consider returning to the classroom because of possible staff shortages in the New Year. Is this something you would do?

OP posts:
BarkminsterBlue · 21/12/2021 10:19

@ArseInTheCoOpWindow

I was teaching 25 years. There is no significant change between 2016 and when l left in 2020.

It’s the rise of academies and their non recognition of unions that have caused teaching to become so shit.

And academies were Gove? In 2011?

Academies were New Labour, 2003. You’re thinking of free schools.

With respect I think if you had returned to the classroom in September 2020 and then again in March 2021 you would have noticed a significant change in the students’ needs post school closures.

BarkminsterBlue · 21/12/2021 10:17

@manysummersago

You see I don’t agree with that at all. I haven’t noticed any vast difference between now and 2016. What happened in 2016 that changed behaviour and everything else for the worse so dramatically?
An arbitrary date because it was five years ago, which some might feel isn’t very long and would make a return easier.

You must teach in a very different context to me if you see no difference between the skills, knowledge, and emotional maturity of a typical year 9 child in 2016 and a year 9 in 2021.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 21/12/2021 10:16

I was teaching 25 years. There is no significant change between 2016 and when l left in 2020.

It’s the rise of academies and their non recognition of unions that have caused teaching to become so shit.

And academies were Gove? In 2011?

Appuskidu · 21/12/2021 10:16

@manysummersago

No, I can’t see that, tbh. I’m not trying to be obtuse but if I was in my sixties and had gone back to my former school to help, I can honestly say OFSTED would not even feature in my list of things to worry about!
I actually don’t know a single older teacher who didn’t leave significantly affected by the system of inspection/observation/scrutinies in school. Several were threatened with capability before leaving. They were outstanding teachers, but expensive and had their own ideas, and the heads wanted cheap and malleable.

Going back into a school where pressures like Ofsted are a risk, I know exactly why they would refuse. Some still talk about how being observed gave them stress, sleepless nights etc-they would never put themselves back in that situation.

For you to say that if wouldn’t bother you is great, but it doesn’t mean it wouldn’t bother them.

If they had called for ex teachers to come back and said they’d pay them £200 take home a day and Ofsted was paused (because all the inspectors would be ‘stepping up’ to volunteer in classrooms as well) then it might have been a slightly different story. Who knows.

ChloeDecker · 21/12/2021 10:15

For the record, in my forties, teaching for nineteen years.

But you haven’t fully been teaching this entire pandemic since it started. That makes a difference .

BurningTheClocks · 21/12/2021 10:13

@manysummersago

at being young.

Supply teachers have been treated like shit on a shoe for two decades and more. I don’t blame them for moving on.

Sorry, I thought you’d just had a baby. 🙂 As a supply teacher in her 60s, OFSTED doesn’t affect me, but the impact in schools already struggling through the second year of a pandemic is huge. Staff are frantic, snappy and tearful, or dictatorial and unrealistic, which makes supply harder.
FrippEnos · 21/12/2021 10:13

@manysummersago

I don’t really care if anyone volunteers or not. I’m just pointing out that when cries of teacher bashing go on, this is why.

People are free to say loudly they won’t volunteer but it doesn’t look good. That’s all.

Whatever we do as teachers "won't look good".

This isn't why teacher bashing goes on. Its because its led by the government, the media, social media and fuck wits such as us4them as something to do when they have nothing else to do or report on.

And I do actually believe that this might just have had a modicum of a possibility if the government el al hadn't spent the last 2 years going on about how safe schools were and not putting any mitigations in place then crying foul when teachers and unions said that this wasn't good enough.

Bellafrenum · 21/12/2021 10:13

@BarkminsterBlue

No doubt this will get me labelled holier-than-thou again Hmm but the great unspoken truth here is that it is largely irrelevant whether former teachers wish to return to the classroom right now. Someone who left the classroom in 2016, say, whether because they could not cope, or were ready to retire, or wanted to try something else, simply will not cope in a 2022 classroom. Too much has changed. The behaviour has never been more challenging, the gaps in student knowledge have never been bigger, and the gulf between the students with most and least privilege has never been wider.

Amanda Spielman needs to announce the suspension of all Ofsted inspections until at least Easter, if not to the end of the academic year, and immediately redeploy all inspectors and HMIs into classroom teaching roles. They have QTS, current DBS, and (we are told) up-to-date knowledge of the curriculum. Ofsted’s website states that it has over 1800 staff and contracts over 2300 inspectors. Those Ofsted staff who are not qualified teachers can bring urgent capacity to support those school staff in admin and learning support roles whose numbers are also decimated.

I’m sure it would be very popular with the serving teacher workforce.

This is a brilliant idea. I know a couple of Ofsted Inspectors who are ex SLT.
ChloeDecker · 21/12/2021 10:12

I can honestly say OFSTED would not even feature in my list of things to worry about!

But it would feature on the list of the teachers and Headteachers of the schools that they would be going in to, considering the pasting Ofsted has already given schools this term, a situation that the NHS or vaccination programme has not had to consider.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 21/12/2021 10:12

Obviously fick and fuck are the same thing.
Not sure where the random B came from

manysummersago · 21/12/2021 10:12

You see I don’t agree with that at all. I haven’t noticed any vast difference between now and 2016. What happened in 2016 that changed behaviour and everything else for the worse so dramatically?

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 21/12/2021 10:12

Why on Earth would anyone want to go back?

Micromanaging
Toxic culture
Bullying of older staff
Destroying self esteem
No money
No time.
Destroying mental health
Crap money

Yep, there’s the kids. I miss that bit. But would l go back?

FUCK NO.

And this should become our sawnsong. Teachers have been treated like utter shit for so long by managers,parents on here, this government.

And now they are stuffed and the horse has bolted.

FICK NO

B

Bellafrenum · 21/12/2021 10:11

I am a teacher and love my job, despite how difficult the government often make it. I honestly can't think of a single reason why a retired teacher would go back.

BarkminsterBlue · 21/12/2021 10:10

No doubt this will get me labelled holier-than-thou again Hmm but the great unspoken truth here is that it is largely irrelevant whether former teachers wish to return to the classroom right now. Someone who left the classroom in 2016, say, whether because they could not cope, or were ready to retire, or wanted to try something else, simply will not cope in a 2022 classroom. Too much has changed. The behaviour has never been more challenging, the gaps in student knowledge have never been bigger, and the gulf between the students with most and least privilege has never been wider.

Amanda Spielman needs to announce the suspension of all Ofsted inspections until at least Easter, if not to the end of the academic year, and immediately redeploy all inspectors and HMIs into classroom teaching roles. They have QTS, current DBS, and (we are told) up-to-date knowledge of the curriculum. Ofsted’s website states that it has over 1800 staff and contracts over 2300 inspectors. Those Ofsted staff who are not qualified teachers can bring urgent capacity to support those school staff in admin and learning support roles whose numbers are also decimated.

I’m sure it would be very popular with the serving teacher workforce.

Teachers!
manysummersago · 21/12/2021 10:10

I’m not saying people can’t get out, or want to get out of teaching Confused and I’m certainly not saying anyone should have to volunteer.

What I am saying is that this ‘how dare they even fucking ASK’ doesn’t really reflect very well on us as a profession. Sorry, but it doesn’t.

Can’t argue about it all day, I know I’ll be flamed, but there it is.

As for whether schools are safe for people of retirement age, only they can answer that. I wouldn’t expect or want someone to do something they aren’t comfortable with, but I do notice a massive difference here between ‘If you don’t want to get vaccinated, leave your job’ (NHS and care) and ‘if you don’t want to catch covid, leave your job’ (appalling to say, apparently.)

That’s a bit of a badly written post but adults have choices that children don’t. And they might not always be palatable choices but they are choices.

I know I haven’t had covid yet and seriously even I don’t know how as I’ve had children who tested positive breathe ON and but there we are. It seems almost random.

For the record, in my forties, teaching for nineteen years. I’m not some fresh faced just out of college graduate eager to make a mark Grin

ChloeDecker · 21/12/2021 10:09

I have been finding that those responding to people quite rightly questioning the DforE on this, on here and other places like Twitter, by saying that teachers are not covering themselves in glory, are either not volunteering themselves or who have not fully worked in their school this entire time and therefore, haven’t really a clue as to where people who have worked tirelessly in unsafe conditions all this time and know how awful this has been for children’s education and why this is not the solution DforE should have plumped for are coming from.

amillionmenonmars · 21/12/2021 10:06

Do you think schools are safe for people of retirement age to be working in manysummersago?

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 21/12/2021 10:03

manysummersago
*The vaccination centres are stuffed with volunteers, doctors and nurses went to the hospitals …

we aren’t making ourselves look good with the ‘fuck no’ responses.

There’s a group on fb called ‘aGet out of teaching’ it’s got 42k people who think like the ex teachers on this thread.

42k desperate to get out. Not an inconsiderable amount.

So me and 42k teachers are saying ‘Fuck no’

If parents don’t like it, I’m sure Boris will help them🤷🏼‍♀️😂

manysummersago · 21/12/2021 10:02

No, I can’t see that, tbh. I’m not trying to be obtuse but if I was in my sixties and had gone back to my former school to help, I can honestly say OFSTED would not even feature in my list of things to worry about!

Appuskidu · 21/12/2021 10:00

Except those who are volunteering with the booster programme are going to have some safety mitigations to protect them in the nhs. They also won’t be awaiting ofsted to come in and scrutinise them. And they also won’t have been likely managed out of their job for a multitude of reasons previously.

This. The two are worlds apart and if you can’t see that, it is quite worrying.

manysummersago · 21/12/2021 09:56

at being young.

Supply teachers have been treated like shit on a shoe for two decades and more. I don’t blame them for moving on.

Noodledoodledoo · 21/12/2021 09:55

I am a teacher - I have volunteered to help at my childrens school on my day off - so I am kind of doing my bit. I could probably do similar at my own school but my day off is something I have in place to manage my life. Sounds selfish but I am a better parent/teacher because of it!

maddy68 · 21/12/2021 09:51

Supply teachers weren't given furlough last year so they went into other jobs.

It's a definite no from me ;)

amillionmenonmars · 21/12/2021 09:50

manysummersago - I am wondering - what is the situation like in your school? Hand on heart - do you think it is a safe place for someone in their 60s, or even older, to be working?

Perhaps you are lucky and work in a school where the children follow instructions to wear their masks, perhaps you can open your windows, perhaps you don't have 35 people in a room designed to hold a max of 25 (and if social distancing were in place no more than 14 people). Perhaps your HT isn't allowing parents into school for parents evening.

If this is the case then I can understand why you think that former teachers should be volunteering.

My reality is that I have former colleagues who have none of those things in place. I am really scared for them. I would not want to see any older colleagues working under those conditions. reputation of th profession be damned. It is time teachers stood up and said enough is enough.

Icenii · 21/12/2021 09:45

Education, care work, NHS. How on earth are we going to make these work? Its depressing reading on MN about these industries and I have no idea who can change it.

DDad at 75 was called out of retirement in a completely unrelated industry to any of the above. He was happy to do it but is now tired and I hope he doesn't carry on for too much longer. Its been 6 months so far.

Swipe left for the next trending thread