Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teachers!

564 replies

MsFannySqueers · 20/12/2021 11:01

So retired/ex teachers are being asked to consider returning to the classroom because of possible staff shortages in the New Year. Is this something you would do?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SammyScrounge · 10/01/2022 23:50

@MissCruellaDeVil

We can't get supply staff in so doubt retired teachers will want to come in, the standards wouldn't be the same either, teaching moves so fast.
You may find that standards improve! Wink
MsFannySqueers · 23/12/2021 10:35

Please be assured that I have been quietly reading the many and varied replies to my OP. Thank you to all who understood the question I was asking and took the time to reply. So many of your comments resonate deeply with me. To @ChloeDecker who kindly asked my own opinion on retired/ex teachers returning to the classroom in the New Year to cover possible staff shortages. I can only say that @viques explains everything I feel much more eloquently than I ever could. The best post of the thread without a doubt. Wishing all teachers past and present a peaceful and Happy Christmas and a safe New Year.

OP posts:
motherrunner · 23/12/2021 06:00

We’ll just have to see what January brings.

My DD currently have Covid. Yesterday, when I was talking to Test and Trace, I said I have informed their school they were now positive. Call handler responded with ‘We have advised schools to monitor emails over the holiday.’ Then he followed up with ‘Tbh, I can’t see schools going back in January with the amount of calls I’m making to school age kids and school staff’.

borntobequiet · 23/12/2021 05:40

Yes. I think people can judge their own level of risk. I doubt there will be many unvaccinated vulnerable 80 year olds rocking up

That’s irrelevant as risk doubles every six years or so from childhood to old age (according to David Speigelhalter) and the over 50s are at much greater risk of catching Covid than those in their twenties or thirties.
Most actual “retired” teachers will be 55+ (I’m in my late 60s and was, rather unusually, stand-up teaching, albeit in FE, until earlier this year) and therefore at risk. (They are also more likely to have conditions such as hypertension which add to their vulnerability.) Younger ex-teachers who left the profession for other reasons are, as I mentioned upthread, unlikely to want to return to teaching at all.

ILikeBiscuits · 23/12/2021 03:22

BBC article.

echt · 23/12/2021 00:36

Yes. I think people can judge their own level of risk. I doubt there will be many unvaccinated vulnerable 80 year olds rocking up

Being vaccinated doesn't mean you won't catch Covid.

ChloeDecker · 23/12/2021 00:04

[quote Liverbird77]@ChloeDecker I am not currently teaching but I hear you and I understand.

I am sorry you're having to deal with so much.

Anyone who criticises you for listing your horrendous workload isn't worth listening to.
If you need to offload a bit you've got a sympathetic ear here.

I really hope you can have some rest during this holiday.[/quote]
Thank you Smile

Pumperthepumper · 23/12/2021 00:03

@swallowedAfly

Ok well here we don't Pumper. Here, in secondary in England, pensioners are invited to come into crowded classrooms where household contacts don't have to isolate with 30 teens unmasked and mostly unvaccinated. Do you genuinely think that can do no harm? During a crisis period of a pandemic with a new more infectious variant.

I think the Scotland v England thing really makes a difference. We have zero mitigations. You are wearing masks. Of course people here are saying why not start with protecting the staff you have and you're not seeing that with the same poignancy because you do have some protections.

Are children with covid + parents and siblings at home allowed to come to school with no proof of testing there? They are here btw.

Also, what happens if you wear a mask in England? Are you forced to take it off?
Pumperthepumper · 23/12/2021 00:02

@swallowedAfly

Ok well here we don't Pumper. Here, in secondary in England, pensioners are invited to come into crowded classrooms where household contacts don't have to isolate with 30 teens unmasked and mostly unvaccinated. Do you genuinely think that can do no harm? During a crisis period of a pandemic with a new more infectious variant.

I think the Scotland v England thing really makes a difference. We have zero mitigations. You are wearing masks. Of course people here are saying why not start with protecting the staff you have and you're not seeing that with the same poignancy because you do have some protections.

Are children with covid + parents and siblings at home allowed to come to school with no proof of testing there? They are here btw.

Yes, they are. We’re not allowed to ask for proof.

pensioners are invited to come into crowded classrooms where household contacts don't have to isolate with 30 teens unmasked and mostly unvaccinated. Do you genuinely think that can do no harm?

Yes. I think people can judge their own level of risk. I doubt there will be many unvaccinated vulnerable 80 year olds rocking up.

swallowedAfly · 23/12/2021 00:01

Anyway turn into a pumpkin time for me.

swallowedAfly · 23/12/2021 00:00

Ok well here we don't Pumper. Here, in secondary in England, pensioners are invited to come into crowded classrooms where household contacts don't have to isolate with 30 teens unmasked and mostly unvaccinated. Do you genuinely think that can do no harm? During a crisis period of a pandemic with a new more infectious variant.

I think the Scotland v England thing really makes a difference. We have zero mitigations. You are wearing masks. Of course people here are saying why not start with protecting the staff you have and you're not seeing that with the same poignancy because you do have some protections.

Are children with covid + parents and siblings at home allowed to come to school with no proof of testing there? They are here btw.

Pumperthepumper · 22/12/2021 23:37

@Hercisback

Yeah you're a complete goady arse pumper. 👋
I’m copying your sighs.
Hercisback · 22/12/2021 23:37

Yeah you're a complete goady arse pumper. 👋

Pumperthepumper · 22/12/2021 23:37

@swallowedAfly

Oh so we should take what the government offers or shut up and have nothing? Honestly you're being really bizarre. Why wouldn't people say no that's an awful idea let's do this instead?

I assumed you were against masks because you kept saying it's pensioners or nothing and ignoring the lists of suggestions people were putting forward. Glad to hear you're not. Masks in classrooms could make a real difference as they did last time for the brief spell we were allowed them.

We have to wear masks in classrooms in Scotland.
Pumperthepumper · 22/12/2021 23:36

@Hercisback

sigh I'm aware the government are proposing none of those things. They are my ideas to help.

The governments ideas have been mostly shit, as evidenced by the retired teacher policy.

Sigh but none of your ideas are being floated just now. So your ideas mean absolutely nothing. Sigh.
FrippEnos · 22/12/2021 23:35

Pumperthepumper

Well, let’s do nothing then.

Not what I posted.

That’s the only solution being proposed, so let’s just leave it.

Why should I just "leave it"? its an opinions forum

swallowedAfly · 22/12/2021 23:34

Oh so we should take what the government offers or shut up and have nothing? Honestly you're being really bizarre. Why wouldn't people say no that's an awful idea let's do this instead?

I assumed you were against masks because you kept saying it's pensioners or nothing and ignoring the lists of suggestions people were putting forward. Glad to hear you're not. Masks in classrooms could make a real difference as they did last time for the brief spell we were allowed them.

Hercisback · 22/12/2021 23:33

sigh I'm aware the government are proposing none of those things. They are my ideas to help.

The governments ideas have been mostly shit, as evidenced by the retired teacher policy.

Pumperthepumper · 22/12/2021 23:31

@Hercisback

No one has said do nothing.

Priorty vaccines for teachers.
Ventilate classrooms.
Fund schools properly.

Would all actually help.

None of those are being proposed by the government!
Pumperthepumper · 22/12/2021 23:30

@swallowedAfly

I take it you have an issue with masks?
No.
Hercisback · 22/12/2021 23:30

No one has said do nothing.

Priorty vaccines for teachers.
Ventilate classrooms.
Fund schools properly.

Would all actually help.

swallowedAfly · 22/12/2021 23:30

I take it you have an issue with masks?

Pumperthepumper · 22/12/2021 23:27

@FrippEnos

Pumperthepumper

No: the choice is, we continue as we are (not working) or we ask ex-teachers to come in

Or they could put some real mitigations in place.

(can’t hurt).

Unless you are an ex or retired teacher that could get sick and pass it on to family members.

I’m not saying it’s a perfect solution,

Good because its bullshit of the highest order.

I’m saying I can understand why they asked.

Because its cheap and if/when it goes wrong they can continue to blame someone else.

Well, let’s do nothing then. That’s the only solution being proposed, so let’s just leave it.
FrippEnos · 22/12/2021 23:13

Pumperthepumper

No: the choice is, we continue as we are (not working) or we ask ex-teachers to come in

Or they could put some real mitigations in place.

(can’t hurt).

Unless you are an ex or retired teacher that could get sick and pass it on to family members.

I’m not saying it’s a perfect solution,

Good because its bullshit of the highest order.

I’m saying I can understand why they asked.

Because its cheap and if/when it goes wrong they can continue to blame someone else.

borntobequiet · 22/12/2021 21:24

I would imagine that vulnerable ex-teachers wouldn’t apply to go in

Well that’s true in my case, as age is the most significant risk factor for Covid. But ex-teachers who left the profession before retirement age will be those who found teaching unrewarding or difficult. So the choice is between those who love teaching, but are vulnerable because of their age, or those who don’t want to teach anyway.
Impasse.