Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

kids know what their bodies need to eat, better than their parents do- hmm

106 replies

me4real · 20/12/2021 00:57

Someone said this on a binge eating forum I'm on.

'You knew how to eat intuitively when you were little. Binge eating has taken over intuitive eating. So you just need to remember what you already knew.'

I don't have kids but AIBU to think this unlikely? She said that kids will eat what their body needs of something, then stop. I think parents have to tell kids what to have or they'd eat just treats or something and not stop till they're obese.

She says her daughter will eat some ice cream (on holiday- which implies she's not allowed it the rest of the time maybe?) but never finish it. She pushed it away and said 'I had enough.' I wonder if her kid has picked up some anxieties about food or weight from her mum. (Unless she'd eaten loads beforehand maybe.)

I know every kid is different though, I suppose.

YABU- kids intuitively know what their body needs to eat and will eat only those things and stop when they should stop. We need to recapture that as adults.

YANBU- she's wrong, kids eat what they want to eat, unless they have food issues or something.

I'm not saying an intuitive eating style isn't potentially helpful for some people.

I'm just questioning the claim that kids eat intuitively and are the experts in how much of something they need, and we should be like them.

OP posts:
Starcaller · 20/12/2021 01:07

Ellyn Satter division of responsibility is basically this. You decide what and when, they decide how much/if they want to eat it.

me4real · 20/12/2021 01:06

But they do know when they've had enough, just like the little girl who pushed her ice cream away.

@WorraLiberty IDK. I think a lot of them would get fat given the opportunity to just eat what they wanted.

OP posts:
Foldinthecheese · 20/12/2021 01:06

I think if you don’t make certain foods into a big deal, then kids will sort of see all foods as equal. So, if you don’t always make pudding then reward or make certain food into ‘treats’, they have less value and can be taken or left more easily. My 2yo DD has certainly pushed away cake or similar when she’s had enough. Unfortunately, we live in a culture that presents certain foods as special, so I think it’s difficult to sustain that kind of attitude. I do try to encourage my children to take a moment to check in with their bodies before they have second helpings.

BeyondOurReef · 20/12/2021 01:05

My toddler wanders around eating random stuff he finds on the ground. Or would if I let him.

He’s completely unprincipled and almost random in what he chooses to eat at any one time. He’d live entirely off bananas and blueberries if he could. He often throws food on the ground. And then tries to eat it when he’s down there (before I can clean it up).

He thinks the exact same food on my plate is much more delicious than the food on his plate.

I’m not sure we should be trying to emulate toddlers in our eating habits.

WorraLiberty · 20/12/2021 01:04

I can't pick either of those because it has nothing to do with a kid pushing away ice cream Confused

She says her daughter will eat some ice cream (on holiday- which implies she's not allowed it the rest of the time maybe?) but never finish it. She pushed it away and said 'I had enough.' I wonder if her kid has picked up some anxieties about food or weight from her mum. (Unless she'd eaten loads beforehand maybe.)

No it doesn't necessarily imply she's not allowed it the rest of the time and no, having enough ice cream and deciding she doesn't want any more, has nothing to do with her mum's anxieties about food or weight. She just didn't want any more ice cream Confused

Kids obviously don't know what their bodies need to eat because they're too young to lean science.

But they do know when they've had enough, just like the little girl who pushed her ice cream away.

GrandmasCat · 20/12/2021 01:00

Not sure really, my son was allergic to dairy and he used to stuff himself full with milk.

My nephew is intolerant to gluten but he would live of wheat bread and pasta alone if you left him to decide what to eat.

Swipe left for the next trending thread