Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

kids know what their bodies need to eat, better than their parents do- hmm

106 replies

me4real · 20/12/2021 00:57

Someone said this on a binge eating forum I'm on.

'You knew how to eat intuitively when you were little. Binge eating has taken over intuitive eating. So you just need to remember what you already knew.'

I don't have kids but AIBU to think this unlikely? She said that kids will eat what their body needs of something, then stop. I think parents have to tell kids what to have or they'd eat just treats or something and not stop till they're obese.

She says her daughter will eat some ice cream (on holiday- which implies she's not allowed it the rest of the time maybe?) but never finish it. She pushed it away and said 'I had enough.' I wonder if her kid has picked up some anxieties about food or weight from her mum. (Unless she'd eaten loads beforehand maybe.)

I know every kid is different though, I suppose.

YABU- kids intuitively know what their body needs to eat and will eat only those things and stop when they should stop. We need to recapture that as adults.

YANBU- she's wrong, kids eat what they want to eat, unless they have food issues or something.

I'm not saying an intuitive eating style isn't potentially helpful for some people.

I'm just questioning the claim that kids eat intuitively and are the experts in how much of something they need, and we should be like them.

OP posts:
MrsColon · 20/12/2021 15:34

It depends on the kid. Some will self-regulate, others will gorge until they're stuffed. I think most kids self-regulate, but the ones that don't can be a nightmare to parent.

LittleGwyneth · 20/12/2021 14:51

I would suggest that not calling certain types of food 'treats' would be a good start to trying to have a healthy attitude towards food.

Some people are better at self regulating, and I think some of that is genetic. But the people with the best attitudes towards food are generally the ones whose parents were the least obsessive about it.

You are more likely to stuff the whole ice cream down after you've finished if you see it as a rare 'treat' which won't come again. Whereas if you can put it back in the freezer and have it tomorrow, no big deal.

Bushkin · 20/12/2021 14:20

I think some do and some don’t. As kids I definitely over ate and all the wrong things, my sister didn’t. If my 2 my son will eat well when hungry, string preferences for fruit & veg, will stop half way through pudding and say he’s full can’t he save it for later- his sister would force herself to finish it

liveforsummer · 20/12/2021 14:17

My dc don't have any restrictions around food and will frequently leave desert too. There's definitely no anxieties there but I guess I have inadvertently influenced a more savoury than sweet tooth because thats what I have so that's what I fed them when little. Never made cakes and puddings etc. Im sure they wouldn't eat exactly what they need if left to their own devices, I don't think that's a thing but they don't over eat. I've never forced them to finish a plate or say they can't have a treat until food is eaten so I let them self regulate in that way which seems to have paid off.

HaaaaaveyoumetTed · 20/12/2021 13:56

I didn't think they could regulate the amount, especially of a 'treat' food. Choosing the right foods is obviously even less likely.

But they can if given unlimited access to foods and brought up with no hierachy of good or bad food. DD is 3 for example. We've never given value to any food over and above another. At a buffet I can let her go wild because she will eat what her body needs and won't eat the "treat" stuff to excess, even when there is an unlimited amount. Yesterday we had a roast dinner with cherry pie and custard for dessert. DD ate loads of broccoli, carrots and potatoes and some custard. She could have had more of any of it, and chose more carrots. DS is 6 and society is already influencing his idea of "treat" foods. School insist on a certain amount of main meal eaten before they can leave the dining hall and I've noticed a big difference in how he views food because of it.

CharlotteMaytimes · 20/12/2021 13:45

Really depends on the child, OP. One DS has no sweet tooth at all, eats very healthily naturally, just has a palate that prefers veg, fruit, blah blah, more in winter, less in summer, likes water as a drink etc. Another DS would eat ice cream topped with sugar all day every day, and has been known twice to eat until literally sick. No difference in emphasising/shaming 'treat' foods or healthy foods, just a genetic thing from me and their dad.

Most of the kids I know eat only until they are satiated, and if we weren't in an obesogenic environment, it would mean most children were pretty healthy.

3WildOnes · 20/12/2021 13:03

I can’t relate to my friends who eat so much that they feel sick, I will always stop eating when I am just the right amount of full. I’m not sure if it is nurture or nature though.

3WildOnes · 20/12/2021 13:00

I eat ‘intuitively’ as do my children. We all stop eating when we are full and never eat to excess. We are all slim. I try not to have too much processed food in the house and once it is gone it is gone. They are welcome to help themselves to food as they wish throughout the day except maybe an hour before mealtimes. They can eat as much or as little as they like at each meal. There is always the option to have pudding but they don’t always choose to eat it. Pudding can be anything from ice cream, to home made brownies, to yogurt and fruit.

honeylulu · 20/12/2021 12:48

Children will usually stop eating when they feel full. I will carry on stuffing myself until I'm really uncomfortable sometimes because I'm greedy or I "don't want to waste it". Childlike self regulation would be better for me and my digestion! So I agree in that sense.

However one of my children is fussy and a snackaholic. She will eat tiny meals and claim to be "so full" but can put away seemingly unlimited biscuits and crisps if she gets her hands on them, long after any actual hunger must have dissipated. People who've seen her doing it have said "she must be hungry" (as she is slim but not underweight). No, she just likes unhealthy snacks! I've no objection to biscuits and crisps per se but eating them as the bulk of daily intake us not good self regulation.

Cyw2018 · 20/12/2021 12:22

My DD is nearly 4.

We did (mostly) baby led weaning but even when she was spoon fed she was allowed to push the spoon away without a fuss.

We do a grazing plate when she gets in from preschool. She eats, more or less, what she wants when she wants at home, we just restrict junk food coming into the house.

We have NEVER associated food with emotions, reward or punishment, this is an absolute rule, I had this done to me as a child to a massively damaging level and have always battled with emotionally eating, body image and weight issues. If I say she can have an ice-cream on a day out then I always follow through.

My DD is a healthy weight and much slimmer than several of her peers, she will push away the remains of a dessert if she is full (for me to Hoover up as my self regulation is well and truly f**ked).

So YABU OP it does work.

me4real · 20/12/2021 12:09

Lots of people in recovery from BED talk on and on about intuitive eating and how it's what our bodies are 'used to' but I don't think that's true and I think actual intuitive eating is really difficult unless you have always had a healthy relationship with food (I also have BED, and intuitive eating just does not work!).

@HippyMoon I pretty much agree with you on that, I just didn't want people to come on and defend IE and the thread become solely about that, when I mostly was wanting people's views on the 'kids as examples of how to eat' bit. One thing that maybe helps is amplifying that fullness cue/not getting as hungry, by drinking a lot of water, eating a lot of fibre etc.

@Bunnycat101 Going by the rest of the posts, I think it's down to luck what the child's natural tendency is maybe.

It doesn’t sound like the person was suggesting kids should have unlimited access to junk food, more that they should just be supported to eat as much as they like and not pressured to eat more.

@Kanaloa It's a group for adults who binge and how to stop themselves from bingeing now. She wasn't talking about how to help child development, but how adults can help themselves now/in the future. But I just thought it was an amusing point as experts in intuitive weight management is not what I think children are like (not that I'm an expert at all.)

Sorry - meant to also say - it seems you’re conflating that with an argument that children will specifically intuitively pick what they are supposed to eat.

@DropYourSword I wasn't necessarily doing that- I didn't think they could regulate the amount, especially of a 'treat' food. Choosing the right foods is obviously even less likely.

But from the thread it sounds like some can, some can't.

I thought that given access to the cupboard with the kitkats or other treats in for instance, those would vanish fairly quickly. But I suppose people with kids do tend to keep a few things in the house, and they don't need to lock it up. Smile

@rainbowmash I don't particularly agree with the idea of 'intuitive eating.' The only reason I wrote a caveat about it in my OP is I was more about discussing her claim that kids are good at knowing when to stop eating high cal foods. So I didn't just want fans of IE coming on saying 'you're wrong, intuitive eating's great' as that's not what I was posting about with my OP.

One of my DC is not that keen on puddings. However he's quite capable of filling up on other junk.

@MargaretThursday Yes, junk is junk, what I thought would apply equally to savoury junk.

I didn't used to like the idea of calling some foods junk BTW, but recently I've been doing MyFitnessPal, and have realized there are a lot of processed foods with hardly any nutritional merit- they give us a lot of calories but it's not like it's hard to get calories in our world. For instance a jam doughnut has pretty much nothing but calories, compared to several pieces of fibre-high fruit or something.

I know food isn't just about nutrition though, it's also a social thing and /or for pleasure.

I can't choose between your choices as I don't agree with either. I think we do need to encourage kids ot listen to their bodies.

@steppemum My question wasn't about children and what parents should do with them. It was about whether it's true that kids naturally know when to stop with food.

and wrt to the ice cream. I have a sweet tooth, love cakes and chocolate, but I have never liked ice cream much, and would have been the one pushing my bowl away even as a small child.

Yes, that was just an example, obviously some people like some treats more than others.

Nope, definitely would not work in our house. When my DS was four we had a really good conversation around why people choose to be vegetarian. DS thought this was a very good idea as 1) he loves animals (good start), and 2) He could live on a diet of only chocolate (not quite so good).

@Brainwave89 I was a vegan for 6 months when I was 19. I mostly lived on chip shop chips. Grin

OP posts:
Thesearmsofmine · 20/12/2021 10:02

I don’t know the science behind it but my own dc are very good at self regulating.
We’ve never done the finish what’s on your plate thing or made a big fuss around food, they will all stop when they’ve had enough, some days they eat more than others. All are healthy weights.

BogRollBOGOF · 20/12/2021 09:54

My two are good on self regulating. They generally have good appetites that facilitate healthy growth patterns, but they do ebb and flow. Their desire for food fluctuates as their growth concertinas, they'll have a hungry phase then as their face shape softens, the appetite tails off then next week they're leggier than ever and their face is leaner again.

I've never made them clear their plates (indeed people comment that I will leave a bite or two on my plate when I've reached my limit and maintain a healthy weight) and if they are less hungry than usual my question is "Is your tummy happy?" and they don't tend to force food in because it's there.

At a buffet, they will put a modest amount on their plate then go up and down umpteen times. Better than piling a plate up from the start even if it doesn't change the quantity of food consumed in the end, plus those little bursts of movement are healthy and pace the appetite.
Admittedly DS (8) did unusually eat to queasy point at a Christmas party last week, but it was the first buffet he'd been to in 2 years since he was 6. There wasn't much savory on offer either.

Brainwave89 · 20/12/2021 09:35

Nope, definitely would not work in our house. When my DS was four we had a really good conversation around why people choose to be vegetarian. DS thought this was a very good idea as 1) he loves animals (good start), and 2) He could live on a diet of only chocolate (not quite so good).

BiBabbles · 20/12/2021 09:22

I don't think there is a universal rule on this that can be applied to all children. I wouldn't assume a child who pushes away ice cream must have automatically ate loads earlier or has picked up on food anxiety when there is a wide range of other options and natural differences.

Feeling hungry or full is interoception, so like the sensory information of knowing when one needs sleep, so I'd guess most kids have some sense of it even if they don't always follow or understand it. Some kids will naturally follow internal cues better than others, everyone has their off days on this, and some will need more support & struggle with it more whether it's struggling by overeating when the option is available or not understanding that they're hungry. Some kids are more sensitive to certain flavours or get more pleasure or discomfort from certain foods.

I've had kids go through times on both sides of that, the not eating is one we've had advice from HCPs on - no anxiety, just would get distracted or want to do something else and didn't seem to get hunger cues so we had to ensure she was frequently cued to eat and had easy to eat options. I had one where we were still working on understanding hunger cues until, I want to say 7 or so though it was worst when she was 3-4 when yes, she was the kid who would push away treats because running around was much more fun.

Aozora13 · 20/12/2021 09:16

I think it depends a lot on the kids - mine would 100% get scurvy if left to choose what to eat, but will stop eating even “treat” food like ice cream when full. I like to think this is because of all the breastfeeding and baby-led weaning plus not being restrictive about treats but really I think it’s just them.

At my DDs last birthday party I noticed that the kids ranged from the ones who ate a couple of bites of party food then wanted to get back to playing straight away, to one in particular who packed away a phenomenal amount. But from that sample of 15, most of them chose more snacks than they could eat and were happy to leave what they didn’t want.

Mermaidsh1t · 20/12/2021 09:15

Sugar and refined carbs are horribly moreish. If we can eliminate or restrict these from the diet then eating intuitively is far easier.

steppemum · 20/12/2021 09:05

So actually, infant and young child obesity is down to parenting, not the children themselves. Parents can, and should, say no to unhealthy food/portions.

yes I agree with this.
The whole concept of self regualting does assume that they have access to a wide variety of foods.
SEN aside, pretty much all kids will eat a good balanced diet if presented with it from day 1.
The non veg eaters are usually ones who have not been offered veg from babyhood

IgneousRock · 20/12/2021 09:05

My DC (age 12 to 16) have always had free access to the fridge and the cupboards and I only stop them having a snack if it's nearly time for a meal.

I cook healthy meals, but they're never made to finish their plate (or even "have one more bite" etc).

They are all very slim and very good at regulating their food intake.

I don't think all kids are like this, but some are.

DisappointingAvocado · 20/12/2021 09:03

My 2 and 4yo are both very good at self-regulating amounts of food. If I let them have free reign on what food they chose, I would not expect it to end well, but certainly quantities, yes YABU. Sometimes my son will ask for a second helping of pasta, then eat every bit of the second bowl except a single pasta shape. I find it quite remarkable because I don't know any adults who wouldn't just force in the last piece to clear their plate. And yes both of them have left some ice cream or cake because they're full.

I see it as my job to choose the what and their job to choose the how much. We've never encouraged either of them to finish their plate and hopefully they will retain some of the ability to self-regulate into adulthood.

NeedAHoliday2021 · 20/12/2021 09:01

Dd1 is very controlled re eating - will open a packet of biscuits, have 2 then walk away. Dd2&3 rarely finish a slice of cake but dd2 is constantly wanting food and would binge if I let her. All dc are different but Dd1 would slot into the listening to her body. She doesn’t love food so she’s not ruled by it… I go through life meal to meal!

FlamesEmbersAshes · 20/12/2021 08:57

While I don’t think either of my DCs would choose the healthiest food - they’d both probably go for creamy pasta over something more balanced - they are both very good at knowing when they’re full. Both have been know to leave a single forkful or pasta of half a cupcake because they’ve had enough food.

I don’t think that’s so unusual? And I think that’s probably what the person on the forum was trying to say.

Whereas I would always eat the pasta or cupcake - full or not! I don’t listen to my body’s cues in the same way.

SpidersAreShitheads · 20/12/2021 08:56

I have 12 yr old twins and they have free rein to eat sweets/chocolate/biscuits etc if they want. I don’t put restrictions on what they have.

At meal times I have never enforced a clean plate policy nor have I withheld pudding if they didn’t eat every scrap of dinner. At times I’ve asked them if maybe they could manage three more mouthfuls, for example. Sometimes they’ll say yes, and other times they’ll say no. Either is fine.

Their attitude to food is incredibly balanced. They’ll indulge in sweet stuff or crisps if the mood takes them but not every day. They eat healthy home-cooked dinners well. If they’re halfway through dinner, a pudding or a chocolate bar, if they’re full they will stop eating. They’re both a healthy weight.

I should also add they’re both autistic so sensory difficulties etc. food touching etc, we’ve had to work very hard over the years to cultivate a relaxed attitude to eating. But it’s worked and I think a large part of it has been allowing my DC to be guided by how they feel.

I actually wish I had the self control they had over food!!

Our approach to food might not work for other kids, but it’s turned out really well for us. I don’t often get to celebrate a parenting win 😂😂😂

RedToothBrush · 20/12/2021 08:56

The thread is about ability to self regulate.

So how does your point work if kids can self regulate?

You are merely supporting my point.

MyComputerGetsSadWithoutMe · 20/12/2021 08:55

My kids can push sweet things away and say they've had enough and they LOVE sweet stuff, they know that it makes them feel sick if they carry on after the 'enough' feeling happens.

Swipe left for the next trending thread