Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

SIL expectations - boarding school and covid risk

85 replies

Catkitkat · 19/12/2021 19:07

We are guardians to my SIL’s (who lives in Italy) son who is at boarding school in England since September.

My nephew stays with us for a night or so each time he flies in and out of the country. He is 17 so doesn’t need much from us otherwise.

He is returning in January and will stay with us while he waits for his day 2 test - massively inconvenient as our DD is sitting the 11+ just days later. She will be trying to study that weekend and needs peace and quiet. I’m also paranoid that he might test positive. If rules tighten they may require close contacts to isolate and my daughter would miss her exam.

I would like to ask him to postpone his arrival until the day of/after my daughters exam. He would miss three or four days of the term. Am I being unreasonable?

Sister in law also fully expects us to deal with the fallout - driving three hours one way to collect him and house him here while he isolates - should he test positive for covid during the term but that’s another story… wouldn’t exactly jump for joy if it happens but could handle it, unless we would all be required to isolate along with him under new/tightened rules.

OP posts:
Catkitkat · 20/12/2021 02:13

[quote BasiliskStare]@Catkitkat at 17 does he not have a close enough friend he could go to this time? ( i.e. one with not a person doing an exam ) I think if agreed with the school he could do this.[/quote]
I just wonder if anyone would be happy to have him stay with them under the circumstances, everyone is probably going to be worried about covid… and it’s a very international school, it doesn’t sound like he has made any close English friends Smile most of them seem to be also international students

OP posts:
Catkitkat · 20/12/2021 02:11

Thank you @bumbleymummy so much goes into preparing for these exams, it’s obviously difficult to comprehend for SIL what is at stake here. She thinks we are being slightly ridiculous, to her it’s just some random test and she can’t appreciate our concern at all

OP posts:
bumbleymummy · 20/12/2021 02:07

@SeaToSki

All the boarding schools round here have set aside rooms for international boarders to come back and isolate in while waiting for test clearance. SIL should ask the school what provisions are possible
I was going to say the same. It seems unreasonable for your SIL to expect your DN to isolate at yours with your DD doing her exam if this is an option.

Best of luck to your DD btw. It’s been a stressful 18+ months for them all. I hope it goes well.

BasiliskStare · 20/12/2021 02:05

@Catkitkat at 17 does he not have a close enough friend he could go to this time? ( i.e. one with not a person doing an exam ) I think if agreed with the school he could do this.

Catkitkat · 20/12/2021 02:00

@BungleandGeorge

Have you checked with the school that he can’t go back before the PCR? That’s unusual unless things have changed very recently
Good point, SIL told us this, definitely worth double checking. Although I suppose if he tests positive they’d send him straight back to us
OP posts:
Catkitkat · 20/12/2021 01:58

@CakesOfVersailles I think some people are planning on keeping their children home I until the exams, just to minimise risk… everything is up in the air at the moment, I for one did not anticipate things to escalate to the point of another lockdown this quickly. Perhaps the exams are all going to be cancelled, and perhaps put nephew’s school won’t even reopen on January, who knows. Nightmare!

OP posts:
BungleandGeorge · 20/12/2021 01:54

Cross posted, I would definitely ask the school for their policies! They may even be on the website

BungleandGeorge · 20/12/2021 01:53

Have you checked with the school that he can’t go back before the PCR? That’s unusual unless things have changed very recently

Catkitkat · 20/12/2021 01:53

@BungleandGeorge

Boarding schools have been opening early for international students to return. Are they trying to avoid the extra cost? I think it’s reasonable to say no this time as you don’t want your daughter to miss her exam
Interesting, I will look into this
OP posts:
Catkitkat · 20/12/2021 01:52

@SeaToSki

All the boarding schools round here have set aside rooms for international boarders to come back and isolate in while waiting for test clearance. SIL should ask the school what provisions are possible
Thank you, I will have her check with the school, but it sounded like the have told her they need a negative pcr before they return
OP posts:
CakesOfVersailles · 20/12/2021 01:51

I am presuming this is your husband's sister.

Send your DH to get him and take him to a hotel until he gets his results? Get your DH to tell his sister she will have to pay for a hotel?

Do you have a bedroom far away from the others? Like a sleep-out or a granny flat?

Is the nephew himself polite and well behaved? If you explained the situation would he co-operate with you and properly isolate? I wouldn't think a 17 year old would be disruptive to studying, it would be more the covid risk that would concern me.

Does he have any other relatives who could help as a one-off (e.g. another aunt/uncle/grandparent?).

Alternatively, do you have any relatives you could take DD to for a few days?

It's tricky because as his UK guardians, you do need to step up (or end the arrangement). I don't think convenience really comes into it when you are a guardian. That's why it's usually either very close family or a paid arrangement - no one else is willing to put up with it!

However to be honest if your DD is in school her cousin is unlikely to be an especially great risk to her.

BungleandGeorge · 20/12/2021 01:51

Also can’t international students isolate at school if they get covid? I don’t think guardians are expected to go and get a child with covid? Isn’t that increasing spread?

Catkitkat · 20/12/2021 01:50

@PAFMO

Given the number of Covid cases in the UK compared to Italy, he's far more likely to pick it up from you than the other way round tbh. I'd certainly be wary of sending my daughter to a British family at the moment if I was in that situation.

If you don't want him to stay with you, then arrange for him to go back to the school instead. He'd have more fun with his friends, and your daughter can study in peace.

He can’t return to school before he has had the day 2 PCR
OP posts:
Catkitkat · 20/12/2021 01:49

@NotAnotherPushyMum

You shouldn’t have agreed to be his guardian if you didn’t want the responsibility. My ds has overseas students in his class and the last two years has been a complete nightmare for them. Thankfully their guardians understand their responsibilities.

Surely at 17 he’s not going to be causing so much fuss that he’s going to disrupt your 11yr old.

We don’t mind the responsibility. I’m not massively concerned about covid either, it’s just on this one occasion that I am worried as my daughter’s 11+ could be jeopardised, however unlikely it may be

You are correct in pointing out that he is unlikely to disturb dd much, he might do a little bit as that’s just his personality, so its not ideal timing

OP posts:
BungleandGeorge · 20/12/2021 01:46

Boarding schools have been opening early for international students to return. Are they trying to avoid the extra cost? I think it’s reasonable to say no this time as you don’t want your daughter to miss her exam

Catkitkat · 20/12/2021 01:46

@Bubblty

Why are you expected to look after him in this country? Is there more to this or is she just being cheeky and assuming you'll do it each time.
No, nothing more to it at all, I think international students always need a U.K. based guardian in order to be able to attend boarding school here. My husband was happy to offer, we did the same for her other child a few years ago in non covid times and it was entirely undramatic. Very different situation these days though, covid has raised the stakes condsiderably
OP posts:
Catkitkat · 20/12/2021 01:42

@ChateauMargaux

Who's relative is this? Is it your husband's sister? What kind of relationship do you have with the family in general? Have they offered hospitality to you or your family in the past? Would you ever expect that they would offer something in return?

Families who have children in boarding school have had a tough ride these last two years... this is not how they imagined sending their children to boarding school would be. ..

Is there anywhere he could self isolate without putting your daughter at risk of missing her exam?

Oh gosh. Where do I begin. She is a hugely self centred person. SIL has never thanked us for offering to be guardians or for housing/feeding/driving her son when he comes to stay. We are told of his arrivals and departures once flights have been booked, she would never consider asking if it’s convenient for us to have him here. She is truly one of a kind.

She couldn’t care less about DDs 11+, and I’m. It just saying that… husband is a bit of a doormat in all of this and while I try to initiate a conversation with her about the practicalities, she speaks with him 90% of the time

OP posts:
Catkitkat · 20/12/2021 01:35

@DizzyCow63

What do students from abroad do if they don't have family in the country? I would expect the school would have some facility in place for students to isolate while waiting on their day 2 test and would be asking SIL to use that on this occasion, it's unfair to expect you to risk him testing positive and your DD missing her exam.
I think international students always have to have a guardian in the country. I think you can use a professional service if you don’t have friends or family who can help
OP posts:
NeverEndingFireworks · 19/12/2021 20:12

@DizzyCow63

What do students from abroad do if they don't have family in the country? I would expect the school would have some facility in place for students to isolate while waiting on their day 2 test and would be asking SIL to use that on this occasion, it's unfair to expect you to risk him testing positive and your DD missing her exam.
They have named Guardians. Some are paid, most UK based kids would be extended family. I was a named guardian for my cousin's DS, similar age, boarding for 6th form - just because his single parent mother sometimes had to travel outside the country for work and she was NC with her parents. The wealthy kids from overseas, with no family in the UK, had a professional guardian, arranged and paid for by parents.
Bubblty · 19/12/2021 20:10

@toomuchlaundry

Most international boarder families appoint a guardian in the country that their child goes to school. Guardians don't have to be family members but I assume are treated as in loco parentis in situations like this. So if a boarder needs to quarantine/isolate before going back to school then that is what the guardian is for.
I seeee thanks for explaining
SeaToSki · 19/12/2021 20:10

All the boarding schools round here have set aside rooms for international boarders to come back and isolate in while waiting for test clearance. SIL should ask the school what provisions are possible

tara66 · 19/12/2021 20:05

Let your SIL know asap so she can ask school to make other arrangements with some one else to have DN or find out if he can go directly to the school itself. They must have an isolation area for borders from abroad..
Except by now they are probably not contactable because of holidays.

Madcats · 19/12/2021 19:57

Check with the school.

I am pretty certain that most set up one or more of the houses for incoming overseas students in one of the previously quite strict lockdowns.

Good luck with 11+

Totalwasteofpaper · 19/12/2021 19:56

There is no way I would jeporadise my child's 11+ for this

The options would be:

  • He can come after and be 3-4 days late
  • He can stay in a hotel
  • His mother and father make other arrangements
PAFMO · 19/12/2021 19:51

Given the number of Covid cases in the UK compared to Italy, he's far more likely to pick it up from you than the other way round tbh. I'd certainly be wary of sending my daughter to a British family at the moment if I was in that situation.

If you don't want him to stay with you, then arrange for him to go back to the school instead. He'd have more fun with his friends, and your daughter can study in peace.

Swipe left for the next trending thread