Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

SIL expectations - boarding school and covid risk

85 replies

Catkitkat · 19/12/2021 19:07

We are guardians to my SIL’s (who lives in Italy) son who is at boarding school in England since September.

My nephew stays with us for a night or so each time he flies in and out of the country. He is 17 so doesn’t need much from us otherwise.

He is returning in January and will stay with us while he waits for his day 2 test - massively inconvenient as our DD is sitting the 11+ just days later. She will be trying to study that weekend and needs peace and quiet. I’m also paranoid that he might test positive. If rules tighten they may require close contacts to isolate and my daughter would miss her exam.

I would like to ask him to postpone his arrival until the day of/after my daughters exam. He would miss three or four days of the term. Am I being unreasonable?

Sister in law also fully expects us to deal with the fallout - driving three hours one way to collect him and house him here while he isolates - should he test positive for covid during the term but that’s another story… wouldn’t exactly jump for joy if it happens but could handle it, unless we would all be required to isolate along with him under new/tightened rules.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
PAFMO · 22/12/2021 13:30

@Ginger1982

I've never understood folk who send their kids to boarding school in a different country, but I guess that's a whole other issue.
An excellent education, good job prospects. An advanced level of a second language that you'd never get by sitting in a French GCSE class, broadening your cultural horizons, learning about how others live. That sort of thing.
Ginger1982 · 22/12/2021 13:02

I've never understood folk who send their kids to boarding school in a different country, but I guess that's a whole other issue.

RandomMess · 22/12/2021 12:47

And that's how she sees her family - minions to make her life easier.

Catkitkat · 22/12/2021 11:01

SIL is extremely tricky to deal with, but she is also extremely successful in her career - c suite position in a major company… this kind of personality and/or behaviour seems to serve her very well in professional settings (or perhaps she is more diplomatic when it comes to work, who knows).

OP posts:
JacquelineCarlyle · 21/12/2021 21:26

Goodness - she sounds awful! Good luck Op.

RandomMess · 21/12/2021 19:53

Geez she really is ungrateful and entitled isn't she?

Catkitkat · 21/12/2021 19:26

@TractorAndHeadphones couldn’t agree more. Their family dynamic is not great in my opinion, my SIL pretty much gets away with murder for some reason. I’m not too keen to play along with it, and fortunately don’t have to get too involved very often as we live in different countries.

‘Spineless’ DH has actually stood up to his sister in the past but last time he did, she didn’t speak to him for about 18 months, and things have only just normalised somewhat. Their parents are not getting any younger, FIL is 87 and not in great shape, so I think everyone should try their best to spare them any further upset if at all possible.

Anyways DH told his sister that on this occasion, we can’t accommodate her son before he gets a negative day 2 pcr, and things really blew up. She got shouty and said some pretty horrid things. She thinks we are being ridiculous, but ultimately agreed to book him a 4 hour test.

So that’s where we are now. Fingers crossed he actually tests negative, and that this won’t cause any lasting family drama…

Thank you so much to everyone who took the time to write. I really appreciated an outside perspective.

OP posts:
TractorAndHeadphones · 21/12/2021 16:22

OP people behave the way they’re enabled. I know it’s not as simple at that but your H should grow a spine. If not you will grow one for him.

Rich enough to send son to boarding school but not a penny coming your way. What’s the point of keeping in touch with family if it benefits you neither emotionally nor financially?

BasiliskStare · 21/12/2021 16:12

Also once he turns 18 no longer needs a guardian ( I presume ) so maybe a different conversation depending on what he intends to do after finished last exams at school as to how SIL BIL & Nephew sort things out.

BasiliskStare · 21/12/2021 16:09

DBIL Flew in from abroad to stay with his DS ( university not boarding school ) took a few days off and WFH - it is possible - isolated took all the tests but they did have in country they live in some hotel isolating thing. It is her DS - I think she should be the one sorting out with the school what the rules are then asking you what you are prepared to accommodate - I get that you have offered to be a guardian- but just at the moment things are stranger. Trouble is if she refuses to you are left in a very awkward position. All best to you & very best wishes for DD's exams

OutOfBounds · 20/12/2021 20:50

Can't SIL not fly over with him and they both stay in a hotel?

If she kicks off then remove yourselves from guardianship all together?

Catkitkat · 20/12/2021 20:38

@toomuchlaundry

Did you not discuss this with the SIL before? Surely with travel plans/tests being tricky for the last 18 months you must have thought it might not be as simple as pre COVID times. You took on the guardian role, unfortunately this sort of comes with the role
Of course it’s part of being a guardian, I completely agree. I just think things have escalated very quickly these past weeks with omicron so we are trying to navigate these new challenges as they come up
OP posts:
Catkitkat · 20/12/2021 20:36

@billy1966

OP,

I mean this kindly, but have a hard look at that waster husband and at yourself.

Protecting a relationship where no one gives a damn about your daughter?

Utterly shameful.

Your poor child.

This sort of bull only happens on MN.
IRL I simply cannot imagine this being entertained for a minute.

I see your point, but I think I can find a way to protect my daughters interests in January, and in general, without my husbands relationship to his family being impacted. But if I can’t, of course my daughter and other children will always come first.

Putting things in writing particularly on a public forum really highlights the absurdity, maybe that’s why it’s so helpful to do so sometimes

OP posts:
londonmummy1966 · 20/12/2021 16:59

I'd just go back to her now and say that it won't be possible for her sn to come to you in January and it is for her to make alternative arrangements either with the school or with a professional guardian company, SHe then has time to find and implement a plan B. If she doesn't like it just mirror back her behaviour and make it clear you aren't bothered how it inconveniences her. At the end of the day if she can't come up with a better plan she'll have to come with her son and book into a hotel with him until they've had their day 2 tests.

Don't offer to try and help her find a solution its her problem to sort out not yours.

toomuchlaundry · 20/12/2021 16:44

Did you not discuss this with the SIL before? Surely with travel plans/tests being tricky for the last 18 months you must have thought it might not be as simple as pre COVID times. You took on the guardian role, unfortunately this sort of comes with the role

billy1966 · 20/12/2021 16:19

OP,

I mean this kindly, but have a hard look at that waster husband and at yourself.

Protecting a relationship where no one gives a damn about your daughter?

Utterly shameful.

Your poor child.

This sort of bull only happens on MN.
IRL I simply cannot imagine this being entertained for a minute.

Catkitkat · 20/12/2021 16:10

We spoke to the school who have confirmed that he needs his negative pcr before he can enter the school. They also confirmed that they are unable to take him in one day early, so SIL has given us correct info.

DH now understands my arguments better and is going to speak with his sister to explain what we are, and are not prepared to do for our nephew on this occasion. Negative pcr is non negotiable. To be continued I am sure

OP posts:
GrumpyLivesInMyHouseNow · 20/12/2021 15:26

Just say no, he's old enough to take himself off to a hotel

SallyWD · 20/12/2021 15:00

To be honest I'd do it. It's family. You can ask him to be quiet when your daughter's studying.

RandomMess · 20/12/2021 14:42

It's one thing being a guardian it's another when the parents don't communicate with you and discuss options for flight times etc and just do what the hell they like without seeing if compromise is required!

jeaux90 · 20/12/2021 14:33

My daughter goes to school with international boarders and part time boards herself.

The girls usually go straight to the house and do their test there, isolate if they have to until term starts.

Maybe it's one of those times your SIL needs to fly with him, hotel for a couple of nights unless the school can take him.

toomuchlaundry · 20/12/2021 14:26

What year is the nephew in, does he have mocks when he starts back?

ittakes2 · 20/12/2021 14:25

He's 17 - book him an airbnb near you and offer to collect him (masked up) and leave meals for him.
There is no way I would put extra stress on my child before the 11 plus.

user313213521 · 20/12/2021 14:18

@NotAnotherPushyMum

You shouldn’t have agreed to be his guardian if you didn’t want the responsibility. My ds has overseas students in his class and the last two years has been a complete nightmare for them. Thankfully their guardians understand their responsibilities.

Surely at 17 he’s not going to be causing so much fuss that he’s going to disrupt your 11yr old.

The OP probably signed up for this 3-5 years ago and didn't see a global pandemic in her crystal ball.

OP - don't jeopardise your child's 11+. They'll have to make other arrangements - at 17 he can cope in a hotel or Airbnb by himself for a couple of days.

RandomMess · 20/12/2021 14:15

I wouldn't be beyond having Covid and be in isolation that ends the evening before her test!!

He's 17 she could book a hotel room for him at the airport for several nights.