Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Told I need to have a more dominant personality

28 replies

Maddymorphosis · 19/12/2021 13:48

Work in community care, and sometimes I feel like people's element of choice is taken away.
I completely understand the statement in my question, but I also dislike insisting (forcing) people to do things and wonder if I am cut out for this job.

For instance we have a lady with dementia who I went to visit yesterday morning. In her care plan it is stated that we are to support her to get washed and dressed. Yesterday she said she just wanted to stay in bed and asked me to bring her breakfast in bed. I asked once more to check if she was sure, said ok and then noted on the report that she hadn't been ready to get up yet.

When I arrived for the lunchtime visit her granddaughter was there. She asked me for 'a word' , told me that she was not happy at all that her grandmother was still in pyjamas and that I hadn't done my job correctly.

I explained she had not felt like getting up and that I had logged it, she then seemed to empathize and say her Grandma was sometimes stubborn and that it was hard but that I needed to 'have a more dominant personality'. She then compared me with another carer called Hannah who is 'much more dominant'.

I do understand the issue but also think the lady should be entitled to remain in bed if she wishes.

I've had it with another family where their elderly father doesn't always want to eat. We still make his meals and leave them out for him, but he won't always eat even if we prompt. The family complained we 'need to make sure he eats them'.

Outside of force feeding, there isn't much we can do.

Another lady who needed to be prompted to use the toilet. Sometimes she'd refuse, we'd try and prompt again but she'd still refuse, again we couldn't force her.
My agency sent out an email saying that "Walking to the toilet is not an option for her, we are to insist that she goes on every single visit."
My colleague also told me I needed to be 'firm' with her.

Maybe I am the problem, but I don't agree with trying to force the clients, they are grown adults but sometimes treated like babies. I'm not going to shout at them or get angry just to coerce them into things.

What would you do in these situations? Does it seem like I need to be stricter?

OP posts:
Maddymorphosis · 19/12/2021 13:55

Yes I understand they are worried completely, they do seem to expect magic sometimes and take it out on us.

On the occasional day I don't really feel like getting up and dressed so I don't, she could have had her personal care at lunchtime, she shouldn't have that choice removed because she's elderly.

OP posts:
pinkypier · 19/12/2021 13:54

Fwiw OP I think you are absolutely in the right. I completely agree that you can't remove all personal liberty and choices from people, as long as they are able to communicate what they want that should be respected as far as possible.

The problem will be that you are dealing with very emotional and anxious family members who will take out their worries on you.

Rise above it - I would want someone like you taking care of my elderly relatives rather than a dominant bossy person.

Maddymorphosis · 19/12/2021 13:50

I did not agree with the way the granddaughter took me into a room to 'tell me off' and essentially tell me to change my personality.

OP posts: