Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To make covid fudge

234 replies

Decorbreadthegingerate · 19/12/2021 12:21

DD, 6, halfway through covid isolation and climbing the walls with boredom. We thought about making fudge today to gift to family members when isolation ends on Xmas eve. Would you eat the covid fudge?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
St0rmTr00per · 22/12/2021 15:49

@CrumpledCrumpet the idea of little snotty hands mixing the fudge just makes me heave. I dont care what is in the snot, its the fact there is spit and snot flying round. In my experience little ones arent 100% on hygiene so if I knew one had a bit of extra mucus flying round i wouldnt be eating things they made. I rarely eat things kids (or some adults) have made anyway.

Sparklepants53 · 19/12/2021 20:33

One thing I think worth mentioning is home-made baked goods at home is a totally different kettle of fish to something like peppermint creams made at school.

At home it’s 1:1 supervision and the cakes/biscuits/fudge have been cooked and not excessively handled.

In school, with a ratio of 15 children to an adult and often uncooked and high nibble-risk items such as peppermints, fruit salad or rocky roads, I could understand the squeamishness. But I don’ think anyone gifts the stuff their kids make in school!!

cinci · 19/12/2021 19:35

[quote icedcoffees]@Pigeoninthehouse - yes, I'm aware of that, but I suppose I just think people should be allowed to decide what they do and don't want to eat without being labelled weird, rude or selfish for doing so. Everyone has reasons for eating the way they do and most of those reasons won't be rational, but that doesn't mean people should be labelled rude or selfish as a result.

I do eat out in restaurants but as I said, I don't have a personal relationship with the staff, so if there's an issue, I can speak up and complain, not eat the meal/just pick at the chips or whatever - it's not as easy to do that when the food is made and prepared by someone whose feelings you care about, so it's easier to avoid the situation by not eating that homemade food in the first place.

My personal issue is more with textures than germs anyway - I'm autistic and have serious problems with some textures and I would hate to try something a friend baked me and have to rush off to spit it out or be sick. So I just don't try it in the first place as I find it a lot easier that way.[/quote]

You're right and it makes me squeamish when people talk over my food, or I have to watch someone prepare it. But you just can't think about these things because it's one of those things you can't fully control

Pigeoninthehouse · 19/12/2021 19:27

@icedcoffees

Unless you have evidence to the contrary, then thinking all home cooked food is unhygienic compared to outside sources is odd, which you have pretty much validated, by explaining you have issues with food.

I've never said I think all home-cooked food is unhygienic.

What you eat is your own business, but if you are talking about insults and being rude. I think its quite rude to put perfectly good food in the bin, implying or stating that home cooked food is dirty, disgusting and germ ridden.

Of course the obvious thing is to not accept it in the first place, but what are the other options once you've already been gifted the food, though? For example, if someone has given you some homemade fudge but it was wrapped up and you didn't open it for a few weeks as you were waiting for Christmas. Nobody has actually given me an answer as what the alternatives are if you're not going to eat it yourself.

You can't return it, you can't really re-gift it to someone else, you can't donate it to a food bank or charity as they won't accept it, so if you won't eat it, what else is there to do with it?

I don't bake, but would imagine a few home bakers might be quite offended by that, what about their feelings?

Well, if I was a home baker, I wouldn't bake for people who hadn't already asked me to do so, so no feelings would be hurt if they said no.

I've never said I think all home-cooked food is unhygienic

You have stated, or implied all the way through this thread that home baked food is unhygienic, you are also defending people with a similar view point.

Of course the obvious thing is to not accept it in the first place, but what are the other options once you've already been gifted the food, though? For example, if someone has given you some homemade fudge but it was wrapped up and you didn't open it for a few weeks as you were waiting for Christmas. Nobody has actually given me an answer as what the alternatives are if you're not going to eat it yourself
I have never been gifted food by a stranger, let your family, friends, work colleagues know about your issues and intolerances, that would presumably go someway to reducing what would appear to be the avalanche of unsolicited home baked good you receive ?
Any stubborn gift givers that are undetered by this information, can have their gifts taken into work, hobbie group etc and distributed there.

Well, if I was a home baker, I wouldn't bake for people who hadn't already asked me to do so, so no feelings would be hurt if they said no.

Well that's just you and you've explained countless times on this thread you have issues with food, plenty of people don't and they like to share what they make. Providing that they are not physically forcing you to eat the food, then why should other people miss out.

clary · 19/12/2021 19:18

Yh good point, hopefully my friend actually wants to eat the cake. I am staggered at the position of some on here tho, that many many people feel like this about home made food.

I have worked in the food industry and if you are squeamish about your friend the amateur baker, then you had better not eat anything processed. I could tell you some tales. It's not really practical tho to only eat what you grow and prep yourself. Or is it? Not for me anyhow

icedcoffees · 19/12/2021 18:35

Unless you have evidence to the contrary, then thinking all home cooked food is unhygienic compared to outside sources is odd, which you have pretty much validated, by explaining you have issues with food.

I've never said I think all home-cooked food is unhygienic.

What you eat is your own business, but if you are talking about insults and being rude. I think its quite rude to put perfectly good food in the bin, implying or stating that home cooked food is dirty, disgusting and germ ridden.

Of course the obvious thing is to not accept it in the first place, but what are the other options once you've already been gifted the food, though? For example, if someone has given you some homemade fudge but it was wrapped up and you didn't open it for a few weeks as you were waiting for Christmas. Nobody has actually given me an answer as what the alternatives are if you're not going to eat it yourself.

You can't return it, you can't really re-gift it to someone else, you can't donate it to a food bank or charity as they won't accept it, so if you won't eat it, what else is there to do with it?

I don't bake, but would imagine a few home bakers might be quite offended by that, what about their feelings?

Well, if I was a home baker, I wouldn't bake for people who hadn't already asked me to do so, so no feelings would be hurt if they said no.

butterupbuttercup · 19/12/2021 18:23

If you make proper fudge, the heat alone (115c) will kill anything off!

Twopenny · 19/12/2021 18:22

@CrumpledCrumpet But why would you be concerned about someone coughing or sneezing on it if you didn’t think that transferred live virus?

I know this wasn't addressed to me, and the person it was addressed to has already answered...but I can't believe you've had to ask why someone wouldn't eat food that's been sneezed on Shock

Pigeoninthehouse · 19/12/2021 18:21

*Why is my way of eating automatically irrational, but yours is totally rational, though?

I haven't said home-cooked food is germ-ridden or disgusting, btw, but I am (trying to) stand up for people like me who have been labelled rude, disgusting, selfish, weird, strange and arrogant by other posters on this thread, simply because we've said we wouldn't eat any home-cooked gifts we were given.

Everyone has eating habits that could be considered weird to others, but I don't see why it's necessary to get offended and throw nasty insults out just because someone does things differently.*
You've pretty much implied all the way through the thread that home cooked food is unhygienic, you are now slightly changing tack and making it about food textures, but you are still 'defending' posters that hold that view.

Unless you have evidence to the contrary, then thinking all home cooked food is unhygienic compared to outside sources is odd, which you have pretty much validated, by explaining you have issues with food.
What you eat is your own business, but if you are talking about insults and being rude. I think its quite rude to put perfectly good food in the bin, implying or stating that home cooked food is dirty, disgusting and germ ridden.
I don't bake, but would imagine a few home bakers might be quite offended by that, what about their feeings ?

ChristmasFluff · 19/12/2021 18:16

Damn, I wanted to ge tin and eat the covid fudge before anyone else had a chance!

Please, please, I'll have the covid fudge!! All the fudge!!!

BogRollBOGOF · 19/12/2021 18:08

Covid is not going to survive a week of being cooked into or even touching the quantities of sugar involved in making fudge.

icedcoffees · 19/12/2021 17:48

[quote Pigeoninthehouse]**@Pigeoninthehouse - yes, I'm aware of that, but I suppose I just think people should be allowed to decide what they do and don't want to eat without being labelled weird, rude or selfish for doing so. Everyone has reasons for eating the way they do and most of those reasons won't be rational, but that doesn't mean people should be labelled rude or selfish as a result.
Yes you are entitled to eat as you wish, as long as you accept it's very irrational behaviour and don't try to impose your irrational views on others, by stating home cooked food is germ ridden, disgusting and covered in snot.[/quote]
Why is my way of eating automatically irrational, but yours is totally rational, though?

I haven't said home-cooked food is germ-ridden or disgusting, btw, but I am (trying to) stand up for people like me who have been labelled rude, disgusting, selfish, weird, strange and arrogant by other posters on this thread, simply because we've said we wouldn't eat any home-cooked gifts we were given.

Everyone has eating habits that could be considered weird to others, but I don't see why it's necessary to get offended and throw nasty insults out just because someone does things differently.

Pigeoninthehouse · 19/12/2021 17:41

@Pigeoninthehouse - yes, I'm aware of that, but I suppose I just think people should be allowed to decide what they do and don't want to eat without being labelled weird, rude or selfish for doing so. Everyone has reasons for eating the way they do and most of those reasons won't be rational, but that doesn't mean people should be labelled rude or selfish as a result.
Yes you are entitled to eat as you wish, as long as you accept it's very irrational behaviour and don't try to impose your irrational views on others, by stating home cooked food is germ ridden, disgusting and covered in snot.

RuthW · 19/12/2021 17:39

At the moment I would eat anything made by others whether they had covid or not.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 19/12/2021 17:39

I would eat it and consider it homeopathic.

icedcoffees · 19/12/2021 17:36

@Pigeoninthehouse - yes, I'm aware of that, but I suppose I just think people should be allowed to decide what they do and don't want to eat without being labelled weird, rude or selfish for doing so. Everyone has reasons for eating the way they do and most of those reasons won't be rational, but that doesn't mean people should be labelled rude or selfish as a result.

I do eat out in restaurants but as I said, I don't have a personal relationship with the staff, so if there's an issue, I can speak up and complain, not eat the meal/just pick at the chips or whatever - it's not as easy to do that when the food is made and prepared by someone whose feelings you care about, so it's easier to avoid the situation by not eating that homemade food in the first place.

My personal issue is more with textures than germs anyway - I'm autistic and have serious problems with some textures and I would hate to try something a friend baked me and have to rush off to spit it out or be sick. So I just don't try it in the first place as I find it a lot easier that way.

EssexLioness · 19/12/2021 17:34

Just to clarify my earlier post: I would accept this gift with a smile and nothing but gratitude. I also gladly eat food prepared by adults in their home (with the exception of one person I know who is a hoarder and her house is filthy, but then she wouldn’t ever offer anything anyway).
My only issue is food prepared by children as they do not have the same understanding, generally when younger, that adults should have re hygiene. Young children are disgusting and think nothing of coughing in your face or hugging you with snot dripping from their nose.

Pigeoninthehouse · 19/12/2021 17:32

@icedcoffees

But why would you be concerned about someone coughing or sneezing on it if you didn’t think that transferred live virus?

Because I don't want to eat food that's covered in other peoples' spit and snot particles? Is that really so odd?

Yes, the cooking or baking process would kill any germs present in the mixture (assuming it's cooked properly) but the finished product still needs to be cut, decorated and handled before being given as a gift.

I really don't know why people are so offended at the idea that not everyone wants to eat other people's homemade cakes.

Who do you think is preparing your food in restaurants and takeaways ? Unless you prepare all your own food from scrarch, I can pretty much guarantee that you will at point have had someone sneeze on your food, talk over it (spit particles) touch your food without washing their hands properly and all manner of distingusting things that humans do. You are kidding yourself if you think otherwise.
icedcoffees · 19/12/2021 17:30

@girafferafferaffe

I hope that people who throw away all homemade food tell the giver that they do that, so they don't waste any more time, energy or money on them anymore.
Do you do the same to people who buy you tat you're never going to use? Probably not.

You do the polite thing which is to say "thank you, this is lovely" and then put it away to be re-gifted or donated because it's not nice to say to someone's face that they've given you (what you think is) a shit gift.

santabetterwashhishands · 19/12/2021 17:28

Why don't you make salt dough tree decorations . My daughter really enjoyed us making those and can't wait to hand them out to family tomorrow.

icedcoffees · 19/12/2021 17:28

@Pigeoninthehouse

There's probably more care and attention to hygiene given when cooking for people you care about than the average food worker. Its real people preparing the food your buy in, people that are probably earning minimum wage, working long shifts when feeling ill and tired, because they can't afford not to work. Not sure why that is preferable to someone making something at home.
As has been said though, if you get food poisoning from a restaurant, you can simply not go there again. Or if you dislike the food or it's undercooked, you can complain, send it back, ask for a refund or swap your meal for something else. There's no personal relationship there so it's much easier to speak up and say "this is not nice, can I have X instead please".

But if a friend makes you something, you can't very well say to their face "sorry but that looks horrendous" or ask to swap it for a different gift, so social etiquette requires you to be polite and say thank you, even if you know you won't actually enjoy it or eat it.

And if you do eat it and it makes you sick, or you really dislike it, or it's undercooked, you're unlikely to tell your friend that, and you're then also put in an awkward position if they make it again - you don't want to risk getting sick (again), you can't return it or re-gift it, so there's no other option but to put it in the bin.

GrannytoaUnicorn · 19/12/2021 17:24

@SenseSphere

I once caught hand foot and mouth disease from a cake baked by a 5 year old. So no.
Don't be so utterly ridiculous
girafferafferaffe · 19/12/2021 17:21

I hope that people who throw away all homemade food tell the giver that they do that, so they don't waste any more time, energy or money on them anymore.

Pigeoninthehouse · 19/12/2021 17:19

There's probably more care and attention to hygiene given when cooking for people you care about than the average food worker.
Its real people preparing the food your buy in, people that are probably earning minimum wage, working long shifts when feeling ill and tired, because they can't afford not to work. Not sure why that is preferable to someone making something at home.

icedcoffees · 19/12/2021 17:19

But why would you be concerned about someone coughing or sneezing on it if you didn’t think that transferred live virus?

Because I don't want to eat food that's covered in other peoples' spit and snot particles? Is that really so odd?

Yes, the cooking or baking process would kill any germs present in the mixture (assuming it's cooked properly) but the finished product still needs to be cut, decorated and handled before being given as a gift.

I really don't know why people are so offended at the idea that not everyone wants to eat other people's homemade cakes.

Swipe left for the next trending thread