Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should my fiancé tell his best friend, his ex is dating one of his friends?

39 replies

NorthSouthcatlady · 19/12/2021 00:59

Let’s call fiancé’s best friend Richard, Richard dated a mutual friend of fiancé’s called Katrina. Richard styled it out they were all casual because he thought that’s what Katrina wanted. In reality he was besotted and in love with Katrina. Their relationship imploded a bit after he had a freak out about Katrina -she / is was a bit of a party animal. She thought they were on the same page but errr they weren’t.

Roll forward 10 years or so Richard is still hung up on Katrina. Problem is she’s started dating Matthew who is another friend in the group and they’ve started living together. I’ve said to my fiancé Richard should be told but he doesn’t want to get involved. Richard is a lovely guy and deserves to know. I’m dreading him finding out and then working out other people i.e. us and others know. I like everyone but lm a big fan of honesty is the best policy? I won’t interfere but lm feeling uncomfortable about it all

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
DrManhattan · 19/12/2021 07:00

Yes definitely stir it all up. Just In time for Christmas

invisiblereally · 19/12/2021 06:33

It's a bit worrying that Fiancé is best friends with Richard and hasn't given him that Move On mate tough talk yet. In 10 years ...

I'm slightly concerned at your Fiancé

  • can keep a secret within friends group away from his bff for how long? Years?
  • doesn't say something that needs to be said for 10 years and everyone else is thinking it

Fiancé always honest with you OP? He's not upfront honest with his BFF ...

invisiblereally · 19/12/2021 06:24

If this ever comes up, that Richard finds out Katrina is dating an old friend of his Matthew- the reply surely is "Meh who cares mate? You dated her 10 years ago... move on"

First Matthew clearly isn't a good friend of Richard's- as he would know who he was dating or would have asked, if they were.

Secondly, his friends should spend their effort - not hiding this but - persuading Richard to go on dating app so that he moves on. Sounds like Richard over romanticises a long finished relationship from his teen years and could do with a dose of "Move On mate" tough talk

Aprilx · 19/12/2021 06:10

I read the thread title and was sure my answer would be of course. But then I saw the bit about ten years.

No this is you trying to create unnecessary drama and to be honest I find it difficult to believe he could still be hung up on Katrina ten years later. And I say that as somebody that takes longer than average to move on.

If he is still hung up on her, he needs professional help, not updates on Katrina’s life.

Batinhernightdress · 19/12/2021 05:48

I agree with you op.

It sounds like the friendship group is deliberately keeping it a secret from Richard, and that is shitty. If he found out everyone knows, he will realise everyone has been talking about it/him. Doesn't matter what the secret is really, if a friendship group work against one person that person won't feel part of the group.

Kbish1 · 19/12/2021 05:37

There's great to be more to this.

It wouldn't even occur to me that a person would need the new breaking to them, after 10 years.

I suspect Richard is very good at playing 'I am a nice guy' while having people priorise his feelings and generally feeling bit sorry for him.

If I found out, that some sat my casual ex down to tell him I was dating someone he knew, 10 years after we split up I would not be happy

Longdistance · 19/12/2021 05:33

Richard had his chance ten years ago. That ship has sailed.
I’m with your fiancé on this.

Mummyoflittledragon · 19/12/2021 05:31

There was thread like this a few weeks ago, albeit it was the man, who dated a friend of the op then a long time later is dating a mutual friend. Many people said it was fine. But it was odd how many said it wasn’t ok, right back to a boyfriend at school being off limits. Glad to see posters here are a bit more measured.

19lottie82 · 19/12/2021 05:19

TEN years? No, it’s fine.

AnotherOneWithNoGoodName · 19/12/2021 05:07

Matthew should probably have mentioned to Richard that they were seeing each other, as they are all friends.
Richard needs to get over it and move on.

pompomsgalore · 19/12/2021 05:00

I'm saying this nicely: I'd aim at filling your life with other things to think about.

HappyDays40 · 19/12/2021 04:54

prick

HappyDays40 · 19/12/2021 04:53

Flipping eck he sounds like an entitled price. She is not his possession he doesn't deserve to know anything she sounds well shot.

Hawkins001 · 19/12/2021 04:47

tis a pickle.i can understand both sides.

user1473878824 · 19/12/2021 04:03

Sorry OP but are you her because this weird tip toeing around a man who broke up with a woman TEN YEARS AGO but is apparently so fragile it would split the social group apart is absolutely insane. Is no one worried about the fact that in the last DECADE Richard hasn’t got over her?

Wagamamasforlunch · 19/12/2021 02:45

Well they can't be that close if Richard doesn't know that Katrina has moved in. A lot of unnecessary drama that could be easily solved by Matthew just talking to his friend when he first started seeing Katrina.

Richard sounds like a bit of a potential stalker, but Matthew sounds like a shit friend.

NorthSouthcatlady · 19/12/2021 02:39

@Wagamamasforlunch Richard and Matthew are friends of 20 odd years

OP posts:
Wagamamasforlunch · 19/12/2021 02:31

Richard needs to move on and get a life.

Matthew should have talked to him about if he is actually friends with Richard though. But are they really friends? It's not really your fiancé's place to tell Richard, but intentionally hiding the truth from him isn't very nice.

MrsTerryPratchett · 19/12/2021 02:09

But then again l think dating people in the same friendship group is dodgy…

Over TEN YEARS? Maybe a few months.

My best friend is married to someone I snogged about a thousand years ago. I don't want him back thanks. Yuk.

Aquamarine1029 · 19/12/2021 01:21

Richard may be the nicest bloke in the world, but he doesn't deserve to know a fucking thing about Katrina's life. He needs to get a grip.

madisonbridges · 19/12/2021 01:19

Your partner sounds very sensible. It's 100% unnecessary to say anything.

NorthSouthcatlady · 19/12/2021 01:19

Ok the room reckons it’s tough titty. I had no intention of staging an intervention or “letting slip”. I literally said to my fiancé he needs to know and left it at that. That’s where it will be left!

OP posts:
steff13 · 19/12/2021 01:18

@user1471457751

It's been 10 years. Richard needs to get over it.
This is exactly what I said to myself as I was reading! I think your fiance is right to stay out of it.
NorthSouthcatlady · 19/12/2021 01:17

@NugsNotDrugs she very much is her own woman, that’s one of the reasons why l like her

OP posts:
NugsNotDrugs · 19/12/2021 01:15

Way too dramatic.
‘Katrina’ is her own woman and can do as she pleases!