Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not comply...?

287 replies

Largethighsbadeyes · 18/12/2021 22:42

...if the government imposes restrictions over Christmas, given what we now know happened last Christmas with parties at downing street.

The possibility of this is rumour at the moment and hadn't been confirmed but I'm interested to see how others are feeling.

By restrictions I mean rule of 6 indoors for Christmas day or even no mixing of households for Christmas eve, Christmas day, boxing day.

I will not comply. I cannot do that to my child who is an only child and whose grandad is dying. He wants to be with extended (but very close) family at Christmas, as do I.

If we all test negative the day before we will be carrying on as normal regardless of the rules (all adults triple vaccinated)

YABU - I will follow the restrictions if brought in over Christmas

YANBU - i will not follow restrictions if brought in over Christmas

OP posts:
xxxGirlCrushxxx · 19/12/2021 08:54

Interesting that the only 'not comply' example people can give us, is one which will put many many people at risk....and further the spread...... giving us all, themselves included, a greater chance of a full lockdown

Tiptoearound · 19/12/2021 08:52

I think you have to assess your own situation sensibly, rather than having a childish mindset of f boris f conservative. I think to needlessly put people at risk just to to make a point is utterly selfish

BigYellowHat · 19/12/2021 08:26

Just because other people did it, it surely doesn’t make it the right thing for you to do? Do you want to hasten your granddad’s death by giving him covid?

GabriellaMontez · 19/12/2021 08:20

@ChristmasWithBellsOn

I might not fully comply (I did last time...to the letter). But equally, I won't take the piss.

Eg I might have my parents over if we've all had LFTs, I might have my sister to visit (with LFTs), or visit a friend for a playdate.

I won't be hosting cheese and wine parties. Because I'm not a twat.

I don't care what you do.

But this attitude...has been pervasive at government level and in so many others.

I will continue to prioritise the things that are important to me.

But if other people have other priorities that I dont consider righteous, they're a twat.

x2boys · 19/12/2021 08:06

Comply ,don't comply the virus doesn't care 🙄

MsEmmeline · 19/12/2021 07:52

@Stompythedinosaur

Two wrongs don't make a right.

The best way to express disgust at rules breaking last Christmas is to never vote for those individuals again, not to engage in equally bad behaviour.

This.

I don't understand people saying politicians went to parties, therefore they're going to go to parties and potentially overwhelm the NHS Confused.

DrSbaitso · 19/12/2021 07:44

I can't see how they could attempt to impose restrictions now, which is presumably why whoever had that information leaked it when they did.

I wouldn't refuse to comply purely because the government are hypocritical pigs...the potential damage is too serious to make the decision based on the actions of people who deserve contempt. But I can't judge anyone who would. It is galling.

Beveren · 19/12/2021 07:13

Yes. I have a foretaste of it as I've been called in at short notice for an urgent medical procedure, had to do a PCR test beforehand and have to isolate in between. Of course I'm complying with that, though it it's a bloody nuisance with Christmas preparations, because I don't want the procedure to be postponed.

I wonder how many of the Nos would change their minds if there were clear consequences?

phishy · 19/12/2021 07:10

@sst1234

Sure you were. Perhaps you may try asking the poster who started the thread about breaking self isolation as her mental health is shot to bits. She is absolutely at breaking point.

You’ve literally made all that up, OP never said any of that.

You’ve literally made

SuPerDoPer · 19/12/2021 07:01

We all need to take responsibility for our own actions. I largely stuck to covid rules throughout including lockdowns because I could see it was there to protect the vulnerable and the NHS. There were some rules I didn't comply with and I'm happy with my decisions in that respect. I'm not changing my behaviour now just because others are behaving badly. All those who complied without question previously were deluded and those who now think blanket "non compliance" is some sort of middle finger to BJ are deluded. Make the decisions that are right for you and your family.

AlternativePerspective · 19/12/2021 06:52

So, because someone else had a party last year you won’t comply with restrictions? Nothing to do with not wanting COVID to spread any further or another lockdown? Riiight.

So presumably when your child hits another child and says “well, little Johnny hit someone else,” you don’t discipline them?

Right now we need to look at the facts as they are. Omicron is doubling every 2 days. However, right now the death rate is actually dropping, but we know from experience that the death rate is usually about 2 weeks behind the infection rate, therefore we won’t know for another 2 weeks whether omicron is more lethal or not. If we wait another 2 weeks then the figures will have increased even more, and if the strain is more lethal, the death rate will as well. Whereas if we seek to bring the spread under control we have the ability to limit the death rate as well before we have to bring in longer term restrictions to do so.

As for the antivaxx “what about feeling ill after the vaccine” brigade, did you vaccinate your children? Give them the baby jabs? MMR? Because if so you happily gave your children vaccines which caused them to feel ill for a few days afterwards, given feeling ill after childhood vaccines is almost a certainty, not serious illness, but fever, etc, which is why parents are always advised to give their DC calpol after their vaccines. But we don’t hear people crying for not vaccinating children because of it, because we know that childhood vaccines are for the greater good.

And I’m not talking about the twats who link MMR to autism and the like, I’m talking about every parent who vaccinates their baby in the knowledge their baby will likely be unwell for a few days afterwards. 3 baby vaccines isn’t it? In the space of 2 months? And then MMR a few months later? So if you’re prepared to put your child through feeling unwell after a vaccine, and that needs to happen because the vaccines are necessary, then why should you be different?

I’ve had all my vaccines incidentally without a single side effect. Actually I had a bruised arm after the 1st one but that was likely linked to the fact my INR (blood thickness) was out of range at the time. If I catch cOVID though I will almost certainly die if I haven’t been vaccinated. So a couple of days of feeling ill would be a small price to pay. And even if I were not vulnerable, a couple of days of illness post vaccine would be a small price to pay to avoid having someone else’s death on my conscience when I merrily spread COVID around. And yes, vaccines are proven to reduce transmission, even though they don’t prevent it altogether.

UsernameInTheTown · 19/12/2021 06:51

No comply here. Don't know anyone who still is.

carrythecan · 19/12/2021 06:49

@Tealightsandd

It's time for vaccine passes. Bookings in France (previously one of the world's most vaccine refusing countries) shot up after they were introduced.

Better having mitigations - masks worn properly, ventilation, vaccine passes - than long or repeated lockdowns. It might be too late to prevent a circuit breaker at this point but for the future we need to choose mitigation as first choice over restrictions.

There is light at the end of the tunnel. It's just unfortunately a long one. Longer term thank goodness we'll have wider availability of the antivirals and monolunal antibodies. Plus more of the world vaccinated, and more knowledge.

They did, and now they are having a surge in cases.

www.globalbankingandfinance.com/frances-macron-to-address-the-nation-on-tuesday-as-covid-cases-surge/

We need to stop this madness of thinking that more vaccination is the answer. The vast majority of over 70's and those with high risk factors for Covid are fully vaccinated. We need to let young, healthy people get the virus and build up natural immunity. There are more vaccinated people in hospital with Covid than unvaccinated. It is a complete myth that the unvaccinated are filling all the hospital beds.

AngryApple · 19/12/2021 06:34

Also…we know this thing spreads fast. The unvaccinated could get majorly hit. Imagine a loved one being in a road accident or having a heart attack and being taken to A&E and being told “sorry no beds and staff due to Covid”. Because this is where it’s heading.

But you can’t force people to take the vaccination.

AngryApple · 19/12/2021 06:28

I don’t see what anyone can do if businesses are forced to shut and everything is cancelled. I’ll see people who are comfortable with seeing me as I did that last time also. I didn’t go to parties as I don’t really go to parties anyway, but I certainly met up with people who were struggling and I’d not think twice about doing it again. My dad is also now is now dying after being diagnosed with an extremely aggressive terminal cancer and has just months left. We were cheated of time together first time without realising. Not happening this time.

I wear a mask, I keep my distance, I’m triple vaccinated. This now isn’t about the virus killing those of us who have done our bit. This is now about protecting the 10 million who haven’t been vaccinated who could easily clog the NHS when it’s being run on skeleton staffing because of the isolation rules.

rubydoobydoo · 19/12/2021 02:44

I'll be using my own common sense this year. I was working Christmas day last year and the was the only day families were allowed to meet so missed out on that one (normally go to my parents a few days after and celebrate then instead!)

This year I'm working Christmas day again and planning to visit my parents on 27th whatever happens, won't make any difference if we go a couple of days later whether the bring in the whe banning household mixing or not(and it wouldn't have last year either we just weren't allowed to).

CoffeeMuggins · 19/12/2021 02:22

If we need to lockdown to protect a service that is designed to supposedly protect us, then the problem is the NHS rather than covid itself. The protect the NHS leading to a dystopian future of years of jabs and lockdowns is something I would quite happily sign out of NHS treatment to avoid ( they have always been fucking awful from my experience anyway)

Okay. The NHS is shit. This country has been voting for the tories for a long time and we are now paying the price for that.
We are heading for a crisis right now. What do we do to fix the NHS within the next few weeks so that it can continue operating well enough?

siteofmoronslol · 19/12/2021 01:57

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

siteofmoronslol · 19/12/2021 01:43

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

siteofmoronslol · 19/12/2021 01:41

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

siteofmoronslol · 19/12/2021 01:39

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Donotlie · 19/12/2021 01:39

@Mouseonmychair

Look East for a lesson in basic pandemic infection control that allows a life closer to normal.

Absolutely and this is why I think western democratic rights of the individual over society will mean we will fall well behind the far Eastern countries who amazingly had no issues with wearing a proper mask with virtually no exceptions, or isolating covid patients away from the home and generally thinking more about the rights of the state rather than the rights of the individual. They have quarantined and handled this pandemic well whereas in liberal Europe we have floundered around demanding an end to restrictions.

Coming from a Communist country and your words totally terrify me. North Korea's covid case is zero by the way.
siteofmoronslol · 19/12/2021 01:36

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

KilmordenCastle · 19/12/2021 01:35

I have no desire to slag off Brits though. I'm a Brit myself Criticise British policy, yes

Earlier in this thread you said that the people who are not willing to comply with another lockdown are making this pandemic last longer. That's blaming people isn't it? Not policy?

I don't think that there are many people who think that the government have handled this pandemic well. Everyone that I have spoken to thinks that they have been an utter shambles. That (I think) is something that we all agree on.

But I cannot stand the lack of understanding and empathy that this pandemic has brought out in people. I can understand the point of view of those who would support another lockdown. They are worried about themselves or their loved ones catching covid, worried about not being able to get treatment if the NHS is overwhelmed, worried about essential services being majorly disrupted. I get it, I really do.

But (and this is to everyone that is so angry with those that won't comply with further restrictions) do you not get our point of view? Do you not understand that we are desperately worried about the impact of further restrictions on our children? Worried about our mental health? Worried about putting food on the table? Can you not see why we don't want to put our dc's through not seeing friends and family again? It's not about partying on for the vast majority of us. It's about keeping ourselves and our loved ones sane. How can you not see that?

CoffeeMuggins · 19/12/2021 01:35

Control what? A minor illness for many? We just need to cut the hysteria, stop the scaremongering and live with it

A minor illness for many. Not minor for a big enough amount that the NHS gets overwhelmed unless something changes. When that happens, getting treatment for other things become near impossible unless you are well off enough that you can go private. I don't know about you but I am terrified of needing any type of treatment in hospital right now. They need to choose the most critically ill, which will be covid patients as well as people having strokes, heart attacks and being in accidents etc. Anything else will likely have to be put on the backlog unless we get the numbers down significantly.

Also, just because you may be okay getting this virus, that doesn't mean you get to minimise how dangerous it is for some.