Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not comply...?

287 replies

Largethighsbadeyes · 18/12/2021 22:42

...if the government imposes restrictions over Christmas, given what we now know happened last Christmas with parties at downing street.

The possibility of this is rumour at the moment and hadn't been confirmed but I'm interested to see how others are feeling.

By restrictions I mean rule of 6 indoors for Christmas day or even no mixing of households for Christmas eve, Christmas day, boxing day.

I will not comply. I cannot do that to my child who is an only child and whose grandad is dying. He wants to be with extended (but very close) family at Christmas, as do I.

If we all test negative the day before we will be carrying on as normal regardless of the rules (all adults triple vaccinated)

YABU - I will follow the restrictions if brought in over Christmas

YANBU - i will not follow restrictions if brought in over Christmas

OP posts:
Ceramide · 19/12/2021 15:04

Education is not a high priority, which is why I will continue to see my family if they wish

I disagree. Children have missed so much already and schools are still trying to catch up even now. All schools and children have been significantly affected, but disadvantaged children particularly so.

In secondary schools, attainment dropped by 6 months for the most advantaged children, a year for the least. Primary children's attainment has dropped behind by around a year for more advantaged children, even more so for the less advantaged.

If schools are asked to close again, and parents have to home-educate again instead of working, that will reduce staff levels everywhere, including hospitals, GP surgeries, care homes and visiting carers. You may be able to visit your elderly relative but if they don't get the care they need, it is counterproductive.

Education now is also required to create the doctors, scientists, nurses, teachers, virologists, carers, key workers, too many others to mention, and informed citizens of the near future.

Of course we all want to see our elderly and infirm relatives. I have been unable to see mine anywhere near as much as usual. However, children being cut off from friends and social contact for weeks or months is also not something to take lightly.

Tealightsandd · 19/12/2021 15:00

But yes it's morally wrong that people have been unable to spend time with loved ones, particularly the very ill, because of the lack of mitigation measures. Other countries took proactive infection control, and families there have been able to more safely see each other. CEV and CV family included

Tealightsandd · 19/12/2021 14:57

@SoItWas

Are you really comparing someone wanting to smoke on a train, because they're stressed, to people wanting to make the most of the time they have left with elderly or terminally ill loved ones, support family and friends with mental health issues, who don't want to watch their children become depressed because of social isolation, or who fear financial insolvency, etc?

Really?

Smoking 🚬 is a major stress reliever. And it's well known that people suffering mental health issues make up a disproportionately high number of smokers.

And, the economic link... Backed by studies, smoking is a net national economic gain.

SoItWas · 19/12/2021 14:51

*Children to become, goodness knows what other typos slipped in there.

SoItWas · 19/12/2021 14:49

Are you really comparing someone wanting to smoke on a train, because they're stressed, to people wanting to make the most of the time they have left with elderly or terminally ill loved ones, support family and friends with mental health issues, who don't want to watch their children become depressed because of social isolation, or who fear financial insolvency, etc?

Really?

Tealightsandd · 19/12/2021 14:41

Next time John from No. 8 has to take a long train journey after some bad news, I trust he'll have strong support from those on here - when he does not comply with the smoking ban. He needs a fag for his stress (but he's also aware his smoking helps the economy via smoking taxes).

All the countries that took good proactive infection control mitigation measures have had lower death rates, better access to non Covid healthcare, fewer and/or shorter lockdowns. And healthier economies.

Peppercorn9 · 19/12/2021 14:37

The best way to express disgust at rules breaking last Christmas is to never vote for those individuals again, not to engage in equally bad behaviour.

A thousand times this.

SoItWas · 19/12/2021 14:35

"E.g hospitality workers who have to go to work and serve people who are clearly unwell"

I'm one of those people, was furloughed on 80% pay, and struggled to make ends meet. If there's another lock down, and they close the hospitality sector again, and can't afford furlough this time around, my boss won't be able to pay me. I'll have to go on benefits, which could take weeks to apply for and receive. When I go on benefits, I'll have to sell my car, cancel my broadband, and cut down on food. Electricity and gas prices are through the roof, so central heating would become a luxury. If they close schools, and banned kids from playing I'd, I'd have to watch my son struggle without any contact from his friends again.

Frankly, we're young and healthy, I'd rather we caught covid.

"but others in your place (a few close friends and family members included) do not feel like that they are scared and don't want to 'fuck the rules' and end up with covid"

Then they should comply, and stay away from those of us who no longer wish to?

BitterTits · 19/12/2021 14:30

[quote squidpig]@BitterTits but others in your place (a few close friends and family members included) do not feel like that they are scared and don't want to 'fuck the rules' and end up with covid [/quote]
I don't want to 'fuck the rules' either, but I will see my family. Come January I will again be surrounded by everyone else's. What's the point in shutting myself away now? Obviously I'm not going to force my company on anyone, but my gran will want to see me (she believes she won't be here next year anyway) and my dad was treated like shit by his employer as CEV (not furloughed) and has no interest in rules.

I'm not a clubber. I might go to the pub once or twice and I quite fancy a trip to the cinema. Small freedoms that I will not give up for as long as I'm not protected at work. I'll happily wear a mask and am finally triple vaccinated.

SoItWas · 19/12/2021 14:22

Do the people comparing mmr's and the like, to covid jabs, realise that mmr's etc were tested a lot more thoroughly, before being administered to the general public? Covid vaccinations are fairly new, most were authorised initially on an emergency/temporary basis, bioNtech had to submit an emergency use authorization request in the US, and they had to seek approval from the Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency here in the UK. Other countries approved the use of vaccinations on similar public health emergency grounds.

It's impossible to know yet what long term side effects may occur, it's unprecedented for a vaccine to go so quickly from development to such widespread use.

I'm double jabbed, but I do sometimes wonder what if it causes issues in the future, and I've let myself be damaged for the "greater good". And now they want to give me another jab, and possibly another again, in 6 months.

Scbchl · 19/12/2021 14:17

I won't be complying, today us our last day of isolating after having covid. I'm doing what I like over Xmas..I have just come off antidepressants after having to start them last February after home schooling and working from home got too much. I'm not putting my or my children's mental health at risk, thats my main worry not covid.

squidpig · 19/12/2021 14:15

@BitterTits but others in your place (a few close friends and family members included) do not feel like that they are scared and don't want to 'fuck the rules' and end up with covid

BitterTits · 19/12/2021 14:13

E.g hospitality workers who have to go to work and serve people who are clearly unwell, those medical professionals who have worked their arses off but will be effected by YOUR actions, teachers who have felt with children who have symptoms yet their parents insist their fine just to be met with a positive test just before Christmas.

But I am one of those people. It's become glaringly clear that I do not matter, I'm not even a vaccine priority. That is precisely why I will not be told what to do again.

squidpig · 19/12/2021 14:12

@ToastofLandon

I will be seeing family over Christmas regardless of what measures are put in place.

We've all had our boosters, none of us are clinically vulnerable fortunately, we all test regularly and avoid contact if ill. People should use their judgement and do what's right for their personal circumstances and not judge others who choose differently.

What about those clinically vulnerable people you will then encounter at the shops, if you have kids their teachers etc do they not Mayer?
squidpig · 19/12/2021 14:10

I really don't understand this mindset. Yes it's shit but for one second take a moment to think of those who can't make the 'choice'

E.g hospitality workers who have to go to work and serve people who are clearly unwell, those medical professionals who have worked their arses off but will be effected by YOUR actions, teachers who have felt with children who have symptoms yet their parents insist their fine just to be met with a positive test just before Christmas.

You need to get a grip and look beyond yourself. Your mental health is no more important than those listed above who can't make the decision to avoid your selfish acts

phishy · 19/12/2021 13:59

@sst1234

Read the thread. It was a a reply to another poster who is basically a lockdown enthusiast and laughing at anyone who won’t comply. Despite the well documented difficulties people are having. Like I say, read the thread. It helps.

No, you said the OP said that. She didn’t. Read the OP.

Biker47 · 19/12/2021 13:58

My plans are set, the government can go fuck itself if they think I'm changing plans on their say so.

SoItWas · 19/12/2021 13:58

And yes, we will be sensible, continue to wear face masks out and about, in shops etc, disinfect groceries, keep hands clean, take regular lft's.

SoItWas · 19/12/2021 13:51

**imposed

ToastofLandon · 19/12/2021 13:45

I will be seeing family over Christmas regardless of what measures are put in place.

We've all had our boosters, none of us are clinically vulnerable fortunately, we all test regularly and avoid contact if ill. People should use their judgement and do what's right for their personal circumstances and not judge others who choose differently.

SoItWas · 19/12/2021 13:44

*I also have another relative who I was terrified would become mentally unwell, due to the impossed isolation last time. They aren't clinically vulnerable, so I would rather they broke the rules and caught covid, than killed themselves in despair!

Squirrelblanket · 19/12/2021 13:41

No, but I didn't last year either.

SoItWas · 19/12/2021 13:38

Whoever wrote the sneery post with all the lol's and lmao's, wise up. No, I don't want to wear a party hat and get drunk, I'm no fucking torie!

I have a 100 year old relative, another who's waiting on the results of tests to do with their brain tumour. Both are triple jabbed. These family members may not have long left on this earth, and have already said they would rather die of covid having spent time with their loved ones, than live through another lockdown, lonely and scared. I'll not be avoiding my family again, on government orders, especially not a government that says do as I say, not as I do.

DdraigGoch · 19/12/2021 13:32

@Stompythedinosaur

Two wrongs don't make a right.

The best way to express disgust at rules breaking last Christmas is to never vote for those individuals again, not to engage in equally bad behaviour.

But it's not about 'tit for tat', I will be seeing my family this Christmas whatever rules are in place. I would be saying this even if nothing had gone on in Downing Street. Come to think of it, I said and did it last year (albeit not the extended family), despite what rules Drakeford imposed. Life's too short to stay locked up.

I will however continue wearing masks and avoiding crowded spaces because neither measure is difficult for me to follow. I've had my booster.

thegreenlight · 19/12/2021 13:24

My dad looks like he has aged 20 years over covid - mis-management of his cancer which had been in remission has meant he’s needed radiotherapy and it’s really taken it out of him. He’s writing down all his life stories to share with his grandsons as I have a feeling he thinks this Christmas might be his last. The government can fuck off if they think I won’t see him over Christmas - they were happy for me to keep working in a school with 10 children off with COVID in my class so I don’t trust that they have my best interests at heart.